10 Ways Gaming Is Better (And Worse) Than Ever

So much progress... with a few back steps.

By Scott Tailford /

Naughty Dog/Studio MDHR/Bethesda/Sony/Arc System Works

There's no medium on the planet quite like video games. Essentially going from curio fad to pastime, arcade phenomenon to Hollywood-aping money vacuum, the industry has seen unprecedented success, and you need only compare the Mario of 1986 to his 1996 incarnation, to get an idea for how fast things can move along.

Advertisement

Cut to 2018, and all things video game-related are thriving. Thanks in no small part to Nintendo's Wii bringing group play sessions to the living room and Call of Duty ensnaring many a popular celebrity's endorsement during late night talk shows, video game consoles are as regular a feature underneath the TV as a blu-ray player.

And yet... simply because the industry sits between a venn diagram of technology and entertainment, it means all manner of calculations get factored into every major advancement. Objective improvements vs. subjective refinement; business vs. artistry; "the next big thing" calculated through player data, vs. a one-off idea that finds an audience.

Advertisement

If you've been following along for the last 30+ years, there have been some major highs... but just as many lows.

10. Better - Graphical Quality Is Unsurpassed

Naughty Dog

Like primitive man aiming to replicate the human form on cave paintings, games across the 90s were forever chasing real life.

Advertisement

Hollywood and cinematic influence came into play too, as the general notion of "What if you could play a movie?" became the driving force, culminating in Metal Gear Solid skyrocketing into legendary status immediately thereafter.

Now we're seeing companies like Sony and Microsoft push the "Ultra HD/4K" agenda as a way to further those age-old ideas, but the reality is: We hit photo real graphics that are more than enough years ago, and have enjoyed a high bar of quality ever since.

Advertisement

Horizon Zero Dawn, Uncharted 4, Star Wars Battlefront II - all are absolutely, eye-wateringly beautiful, testament to the sheer talent of designers who roll together skills from architecture, physics and hand drawing into one.

9. Worse - Larger Companies Focus More Than Ever On Existing Franchises

Rockstar

I'll get onto the whopping cost of producing the 100 hour-long behemoths we call video games in time, but as an opening salvo, it's imminently clear that the largest developers are primarily interested in the biggest returns.

Advertisement

You see this in everything from Rockstar only making GTA expansions to the majority of Ubisoft's titles being sequels or soft reboots. EA's treatment of the Mass Effect IP was to forgo the star-chasing spark that made the original trilogy so loveable, in favour of boilerplate crafting mechanics and milquetoast humour - so much was made clear by ex-Bioware employee Manveer Heir.

Like Hollywood, gaming's top brass are trying to find a way to crowbar any new pitch into an existing mould. It's why Metal Gear Survive is a lifeless husk of rote zombie horde mechanics, Agents of Mayhem still retains a connection to the Saints Row universe, and why even Assassin's Creed Origins felt the need to retain its franchise name, despite barely tying into the canon until the last 20 minutes.

Advertisement

It's understandable for companies not wanting to take risks, but calculated ones... are kind of what the entire industry is built upon.

8. Better - Constant Internet Connections Mean Games Get Fixed Immediately

Eric Barone

In years gone by - especially back when the Atari 2600 was the "cutting edge" of gaming - there was literally no way for a company to amend any mistake, bug or glitch, once the game had gone to print.

Advertisement

"Great", I hear you say, "It means they had to get it right!"

Very true, but every developer wants to make the the best possible product - it doesn't change how publishers have always approached the business. You can't manufacture time, and sometimes deadlines just come around, no matter what.

Advertisement

It goes without saying that now, if any remote issue is discovered, a developer/publisher can commission a patch that has the thing rectified and working perfectly in days. The likes of Stardew Valley literally had one-man coding powerhouse Eric Barone watching his own Reddit thread for suggestions post-launch, hopping back into the game's guts to touch it up immediately.

That level of symbiotic tinkering and group advice is something that helps many games be the best they can be, and it's also very much unique to the medium overall.

Advertisement

7. Worse - ... This Has Led To MANY Games Shipping Broken/Unfinished

Bethesda

The flip-side to knowing anything "can be fixed later" means way, way more games get shipped or slapped with price tags, before actually being finished.

Advertisement

Many developers of yesteryear would be horrified (or overjoyed, as it means they don't have to work all night) if they got eyes on the states that pass as "retail worthy" today.

Granted, 2014 was the absolute worst of this, with Assassin's Creed Unity releasing in a markedly terrible, unplayable conditions. Since then we've seen companies remember their duty to consumers when taking such large chunks of cash, but things like Mass Effect Andromeda, Ghost Recon: Wildlands and PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds all released in less-than-ideal states, taking months to course-correct or reach a build that generations' past would've mandated.

Advertisement

6. Better - Plateauing Graphics Technology Puts The Emphasis On Gameplay

Nintendo

Back to graphics, and as mentioned earlier, the whole "4K race" has always felt like a bust, because we're already at a point where games look as stunning as they need to be. Film, too, reached a point where the sheer technology of capturing an image was adequate, actively stepping back from the experimental 48fps that was used in The Hobbit. Audiences and production companies alike realised that, actually, there isn't always some nebulous "better quality image" out there, and creators need to work with what's more widely accepted.

Advertisement

In gaming, we're seeing this as games and consoles with a 4K focus fail to catch on. The PS4 Pro and Xbox One X have arrived to very little fanfare, yet taken alongside the Nintendo Switch's runaway sales and its "underpowered games", they prove one thing: Gameplay always trumps graphics.

Nintendo even went one further, generating a huge burst of interest around new gameplay experiences with a few pieces of cardboard, proving the average consumer is hungry for the very thing that lies at the heart of why they play in the first place: New video games.

Advertisement

Now we have the best graphics tech ever made and they're accessible to more developers than ever, the future is sure to be routed in innovative mechanics, not extra shiny faces.

Still, that's the future. For now...

Advertisement

5. Worse - We're Seeing VERY Little Innovation In Terms Of Genres Or New Mechanics

Bethesda

When was the last time you played a genuinely new genre or idea?

Advertisement

I'll wait.

Even PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds' popularising of the battle royale genre isn't fundamentally "new" - its roots come from other mods also made by creator Brendan Greene.

Advertisement

Indeed, the 2010s and this generation in particular are a far cry from the hotbed of risks and innovations that represented the late 80s, 90s and 2000s. Those decades had everything from new genres left and right (2D and 3D platformers, third-person action, shooters), overhauls of key mechanics (Resident Evil 4's over-shoulder camera, Gears of War's stop n' pop cover system) - even explorations of what it means to control another person in a story (Bioshock's almighty twist, Shadow of the Colossus' final betrayal).

Contrast to where we're at now, and sure, you can say that Hollywood have also ran out of any larger, genre-focused ideas too, but the industry almost feels like its stagnating. Outside of VR - which is yet to have a single "You must play this" game - there's very little in the way of brand new ways to play, with nothing that connotes the wide-eyed, experimental feel of yesteryear.

Advertisement

4. Better - The Sheer Feel Of Gameplay Is The Best Its Ever Been

Nintendo

Of course, the fact that gaming has matured into having its ways set in stone, means innovation is replaced with perfection. Look to Super Mario Odyssey, and you have the best, most exquisite 3D platforming on the market.

Advertisement

FPS' like Titanfall, Call of Duty or Battlefield are hands-down the most responsive and objective best they've ever been. Sports titles, fighting games - just the act of controlling someone in, say, Dragon Ball FighterZ is unequivocally better than ever before.

It's an element we tend to overlook, but where many other mediums unanimously fail to recapture past glories, gaming tends to end each year with a slate of titles that do everything you already loved, in a far more worthwhile capacity.

Advertisement

Compare the sequels or reboots/remakes of games to those of films or the written word, and it's not even close. Games play better today than ever before, simple as.

3. Better & Worse - Where Are The Heroes?

Sony/Microsoft/CORE

Weirdly, although the industry is of course, thousands of people contributing to one entity over time, its fads do replicate the whims of an average western human.

Advertisement

Take the mid 80s as the "birth" of modern gaming (yes, it existed many years prior, but that's when Tetris, Mario and Zelda hit the scene, with the NES launching in North America). Those early years were dominated by cutesy characters and mascots like Mario, Crash and Sonic.

Then, in the "teenage years", gaming's faces became those of Solid Snake, Tekken's Jin Kazama, a more mature Link from Ocarina of Time. We even had the "angry hormonal phase" of God of War, Gears of War, Manhunt and Grand Theft Auto.

Advertisement

Now gaming is - vaguely - in its thirties. Its outgrown cutesy mascots and has no need for one batch of characters to exemplify a given company. Like many of us who grow out of such identifying factors, we're into more relatable, human stories and interactions.

There's a reason Joel & Ellie get slapped on every PlayStation highlight reel alongside Horizon Zero Dawn's Aloy. The industry and its patrons have grown up... though you can't help but miss the age of heroes.

Advertisement

2. Worse - A Notable Lack Of Quality Control On Each Consoles' Storefront

Nintendo

Onto one of two really egregious issues for newcomers to the industry - the overwhelming amount of games that prop up all three of the major systems' storefronts. Where in the last generation, both Sony and Microsoft in particular policed their stores quite well (Microsoft in particular didn't let any game onto Xbox Live Arcade without a free demo), now it feels like the floodgates have been opened.

Advertisement

Nintendo in particular aren't against letting phone ports clog up their search results, and it only serves to bury the more worthwhile experiences. Now obviously, it's hard discerning what's "worthwhile" when everyone's tastes are different, but simply on a mechanical/playable level, something like Vroom in the Night Sky or Troll & I should never have made it to consumer's hands.

We're seeing the first signs of console storefronts transforming into how Steam's million-strong catalogue operates, or a video streaming service hosts every last creation that gets sent their way.

Advertisement

There are plenty of benefits to infinite shelf space, but unlike with film, base quality for video games can come down to objective measures such as controller responsiveness, bug-testing and sheer playability.

1. Better & Worse - Product Pricing, Monetisation Methods & Development Cost

Monolith

For the consumer, the price of a game hasn't changed. Cartridges back in 1990 were $50, just as a full price game circles around that figure today. You're getting way, WAY more value for that money by comparison - like literally, Super Mario Bros. half hour playthrough cost you the same at retail as 600 hours worth of The Witcher 3.

Advertisement

Inflation puts those older prices at closer to $90-$100 through inflation too, so really, we're getting a stupid amount of bang for our buck.

HOWEVER, game development costs have mutated far out of proportion. Mainly because of all the aforementioned factors involving wanting to build the biggest games for the most players with the most accessible, quality-tested mechanics, the average cost of development is around of $80 million. It was $10 million back on the PS3 and Xbox 360, yet the whole time, that street price hasn't changed.

Advertisement

Developers and publishers certainly feel the need to deliver on some lofty expectations put on them from years of consumers wanting to see the best-looking games and most powerful software, leading to everybody's favourite: DLC and microtransactions.

On the one hand, budgets needs to be reigned in with consumer interest and hype mandated alongside, yet on the other, the biggest experiences possible should be made... yet they require a source of income outside of just one-off purchases.

Advertisement

We can't have it both ways, and simultaneously, it makes the industry better and worse than yesteryear simultaneously.