Assassin's Creed Syndicate has arrived like a fart in the night, thanks to some godawful PR from Ubisoft keeping it under wraps until the very last second. Critically it's proving to be one of the most divisive entries in the series, pulling Assassin's Creed back from the brink just like Black Flag did after the disaster that was AC III. Many reviewers are heaping praise its way for simply being playable again, whilst others call it for what it is; a last-gen experience given a lick of paint, a couple of new animations and nothing more. Even before release, 2015 marked the first year where people were actively saying "Eff this" to the series' terrible gameplay and increasingly lacklustre instalments, and it's not enough to make an already decade-old formula simply 'work'. Fans shouldn't be remotely content with the fact that Syndicate merely ticks over. Unlike when Rockstar rolled out GTA III, Vice City and San Andreas within a few years across 2001-2004, modern day development costs and schedules just don't allow for already stilted and tired game engines to be trotted out so frequently. Can the series be saved? Have Ubisoft bled their cash cow so dry that even though it's currently walking again, we're barely going to see a stagger until it falls to the ground? Perhaps. Here are eight big overhauls that would actually make Assassin's Creed phenomenal again - although whether Ubisoft take them on board is another matter entirely.
8. Steal Shadow Of Mordor's Nemesis System
Why haven't more developers 'stolen' Shadow of Mordor's incredibly unique selling point? Monolith's 2014-saving release was an incredible little title that proved the 'Assassin's Creed formula' didn't just have legs, but it could use them to propel us through a good 40-plus hours of gameplay. On top of traversal and fighting mechanics that felt immediate and brutally effective (what AC used to be), we had the 'Nemesis System', a way of turning any random enemy who killed you into a mini-boss that could be researched, fought again and eventually taken out. It meant you always had something to do, and as you took various enemy Orcs out, their ranks would reshuffle and re-appropriate themselves. Today's pawn could be tomorrow's king, providing you opened up the right slot. Throw in the fact you eventually learned how to 'Brand' (mind control) Orcs to filter into the ranks, and you had your own little behind-enemy-lines army, ready to act on your behalf at the touch of a button. Apply this to Assassin's Creed and yes, you'd have to lose the focus on melee combat a tad, but just have peoples' ancestors or whoever become dynamic enemies instead. All the interweaving power structure stuff would be fantastic, and you could create targets that shuffle around the world in terms of influence on a constant basis, affecting their respective areas and the guards within. The innovations in gameplay would write themselves.
7. For The Love Of God, Scrap The Current Game Engine
It's laughable when you think back on Unity's pre-release gameplay footage - straight away from the first frame of gameplay we could see exactly how everything was going to play, look and feel. Fancy new character models and uber-shiny rooftops can only sell a game so much, and so do you remember what Ubi's big 'revolution in game design' was? What they were going to hang the leap to next-gen on? A dedicated button to descend down buildings - they didn't even try anything other than a new item with Syndicate. If there was any more damning indictment on just how money-focussed and utterly incapable of forward-movement the devs are right now, it's the barest notion that gamers are hankering for a single button to descend from atop any surface. Even in-game it was barely usable, seeing the camera swing randomly into all sorts of unhelpful angles as you attempted to pilot Arno towards a specific goal. One of the biggest problems Ubisoft don't want to admit, is they're gonna need to take a hit on financials to revamp the game engine from the ground up across a few years of development. Just look at how much better Fallout 4 will play, now that Bethesda have fully iterated on their Skyrim engine from 2011. We need a gameplay demo of a stealth-focussed experience, where we only realise it's an AC game when the logo pops at the end. Then, and only then, will enough of a change have been made.
6. Do The Open-World Arkham-Style (Small Detailed Areas In A Large Environment)
Arkham City was a pretty brave game, all things considered. Rocksteady took their already fairly open-ended structure for Arkham Asylum and branched it out, splitting linear mission segments and bosses across a far larger game world, whilst tying in the occasional sub objective to complete along the way. It was the beginnings of a formula that would work wonders for AC - ditching an open-world that revolves around a few hundred icons on-screen at once (like Unity, Syndicate or this year's Mad Max) and instead focus on having these really cool, detailed, otherwise-linear experiences dotted around the map instead. It'd allow for replayability of signature or special kills, let Ubisoft take on Hitman at their own game when it came to planning various ways to take your targets out, and ultimately would let the art design and level layouts shine above all else - still the one area where Assassin's Creed is far ahead of the competition. Think about it, Assassin's Creed and its gameplay systems don't need to be in an open-world. Researching targets and gaining info can be done in this way, but let's also have larger stretches of Prince of Persia-style platforming interspersed with Hitman-esque kill opportunities, revolving entirely around a gameplay system that encourages and rewards you to check out every corner of the respective playing field along the way.
5. Make Climbing Skilful, Rewarding & Integral To Gameplay
Even back in the first Assassin's Creed, Ubisoft received all manner of complaints for over-simplifying the climbing to literally being "Hold forward with right trigger and push A", letting the animation system take over and make you an instant-badass. Syndicate doesn't change this whatsoever, literally nothing's changed in terms of how climbing feels - if anything it's become even more simplified with the advent of the grappling hook and the auto-descend button. Thing is - part of fulfilling this whole 'master assassin' thing should revolve around being the master of your environment too, an ideology that should encompass specific controls for climbing. Factor in weight and momentum to how easy it is to mantle from one point to the next and it'd give you a reason to spec your character in certain ways, item-wise. Pre-release demos of the very first AC had each face button assigned to a specific limb - lending weight to the idea that this idea was on the table at some point. It was since scrapped, the nearest remaining factor being that you could unlock the ability to grab ledges. Thing is, even that made controlling Altair's traversal more involving and tactile, so let's see that built on, not ignored.
4. Pick A Protagonist And Stick With Them
Like new-kids Jacob and Evie Frye? Well say goodbye to them, because they'll most likely be gone next year, just like Connor, Edward Kenway, Adewale, Shay Cormac and Arno Dorian. Thing is, the average person on the street could probably name Desmond, Altair and Ezio (even the latter's full 'Auditore da Firenze' title, too), but as for the protagonists of AC III, Black Flag, Unity and now Syndicate - there's no chance. I'll get into the modern day stuff as a plot line in a moment, but just remember how awesome Ezio's trilogy of games were. If you're going to insist on doing a yearly model for this sort of thing, there's something utterly forgettable about first ditching the aforementioned modern stuff and removing the main thread that binds them together. We've not felt attached about any of the AC heroes since Ezio, and although Black Flag's Edward Kenway (or AC III's Haytham) were memorable, they weren't followed up or capitalised on whatsoever. Many of these guys would've benefitted from multiple instalments to really flesh their stories and motivations out, and when you think about how well Black Flag was received in the first place - it just makes that sharp left turn to ditch everything and branch into Unity all the more glaring.
3. Make The Grappling Hook A Finite Resource
Like the rut Call of Duty now finds itself in - being it's specced the experience towards being all future tech-focussed - they can't go backwards to anything less, considering things like the boost-jump have changed the core flow and feel of gameplay. As such, now we have a grappling hook in AC, essentially rendering the climbing useless - but also meaning Ubisoft have to factor in how it's used across the future of the series (if there's going to be one). The nearest comparison is Batman: Arkham Knight's grapple hook (which looks almost entirely like what Syndicate has ripped off), and although that item's use is infinite, Batman's gameplay never needed to revolve around climbing in the first place. The only way to restore a balance is to make the grappling hook something you'd have to save up and deploy at just the right time, or - again - factor it into a new climbing system and have it be a timed button-press that propels you up certain segments of the game world. At this stage, Ubisoft are butchering what's left of their own gameplay loop, and that could prove to be the final nail in AC's coffin.
2. Wait And PERFECT Glitches & Bugs
Determined to shake their reputation as harbingers of glitch-filled (yet incredibly fun) games, Bethesda look to have finally 'fixed' Fallout with their fourth instalment - something that although I mentioned the act of how this impacts gameplay, also applies to aesthetics and the presentation of your product. Assassin's Creed these days is less an immaculate triple-A system-seller and more a hodgepodge of half-baked ideas strung across 27 separate studios worldwide (yes, really), the resulting puppet-strings on show slowly strangling something that's already struggling to breathe as it is. Floating NPCs, protagonists falling through the floor, character models loading in with their arms out wide, faces melting off, avatars not realising when there's something to be interacted with, other NPCs wandering into cutscenes - I could go on. Syndicate for the most part manages to hold together, but then you look at the likes of Metal Gear Solid V, The Witcher 3 and upcoming Fallout 4 - and it's just ridiculous they're all releasing on the same hardware.
1. A New Multi-Game Modern Day Protagonist
As you might have gathered from the heap of reviews surrounding Syndicate, any mention of the modern day element is quickly scuttled under the rug in favour of pointing at the shiny new city you'll get to play around in. However, that completely ruins the thrust of the series, which until Desmond was killed off at the close of AC III seemed to be geared towards not only delivering a solid world, but also to see what was going to happen in the future. Without delving into the specifics of Syndicate's modern day scenes, they feel more like a checkbox inclusion to 'please the fans' on Ubi's part, rather than them truly knowing where the future of the series lies. It'll take yet another Assassin's Creed to see if Ubi do know what they're doing, but we desperately need something to strive for in each instalment other than "Here's another world". Let's have someone in the present who has a vested reason to delve into their ancestral history; be it some integral information to a murder, conspiracy or whatever else - as at least then we can start giving the modern day element a reason to exist in the first place. Syndicate might be keeping things ticking over, but what would you revamp to keep things fresh?