15 Video Games You Wrongly Assume Are Terrible

Wait... That 50 Cent game didn't suck!?

By Jack Pooley /

Swordfish Studios

Gamers are a notoriously fickle bunch, and when games cost as much as they do, it's kind of fair enough. One glance at a 65 Metacritic score can be enough for all interest in a game to completely evaporate, though often it's not even reviews that seal the deal: the toxic, excessive negativity of the online echo chamber encourages a hive-mind mentality where consensus is formed without many people actually trying games for themselves.

Advertisement

Now, there are plenty of games that most people proclaim to be terrible without having ever actually played, like E.T. and Big Rigs, that totally live down to the hype, but sometimes a game's bad reputation precedes it when, in reality, it's actually pretty damn good.

Sure, most of these games are not great as such, but they're still a good deal better than the online vitriol would have you believe. They're certainly not the unplayable, insulting messes that so many gamers love to bleat about.

Here are 15 video games you wrongly assume are terrible...

15. Knack

The Game: The PS4's big launch-day platforming beat-em'-up, widely touted as "the next Crash Bandicoot" as it came from that franchise's executive producer, Mark Cerny.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Even Knack's defenders will admit that it's not the Crash Bandicoot follow-up many were hoping for, making it an immediately disappointment to many. Critics also expressed disinterest in the plot and harshly criticised the game for its sparse checkpoint placement.

Why You're Wrong: Knack may not be the most brilliant or memorable PS4 launch title, but it's a perfectly enjoyable platformer all the same, albeit one you'd probably not want to have paid full price for.

What really sets Knack apart from other games isn't so much any of its central mechanics, but rather the surprising level of difficulty for something largely aimed at children. The boss fights are fun and imaginative, and though the checkpoint system does occasionally frustrate, it's simply nice to have a platformer that doesn't handhold the player throughout. The Metacritic score of 54 is thoroughly undeserved.

14. Goat Simulator

The Game: This one really speaks for itself: you play a goat who is tasked with causing as much wanton destruction as possible. There's not much else to it.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Anyone who's taken a quick glance at Goat Simulator will probably assume it's another piece of indie shovelware trash dumped on Steam to try and make a quick buck off its name above all else. People can't really be faulted on that assumption, to be honest, because the game kinda revels in its own perceived awfulness.

Why You're Wrong: Irony can only take a game so far, and while there is something perversely entertaining about playing "so-bad-it's-good" games, Goat Simulator is also a genuinely entertaining title in its own right.

Sure, the graphics are just OK and the physics are utterly disastrous, but personality goes a long way, and this is one charming game. Even with its absurdly janky gameplay mechanics, Goat Simulator is an absolute blast even when you strip away the social media buffoonery and just revel in its sandbox mayhem. Once you fling the goat onto a trampoline, you'll never look back.

13. Assassin's Creed: Unity

The Game: 2014's entry into the popular open-world action adventure franchise, taking place in Paris during the French Revolution and introducing 4-player co-op multiplayer to the franchise.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Because, to be fair, the launch was an utter catastrophe, with a critical embargo set after the game was already in players' hands, and an end-product that was riddled with bugs to the point that Ubisoft had to stop selling season passes and offer free content as an apology.

Why You're Wrong: It may have taken Ubisoft several months to properly fix most of the performance issues, but Unity is now a rock solid Assassin's Creed title rather than the embarrassing effort it started out as.

It may not do much to invigorate the series' formula, but the compelling narrative and innovative multiplayer at least made it stand out a little. Still, everyone loves making fun of the game's early graphical glitches, so it's easy to get swept up and forget that it's actually a pretty good game now.

12. Enter The Matrix

The Game: The video game tie-in for The Matrix Reloaded, telling the movie from the perspectives of supporting characters Ghost and Niobe.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Because it's a video game based on a movie, and how often does that ever work out? Plus, it got heavily mixed reviews with many expressing disappointment, quite rightly, that you didn't get to play as Neo, and the game felt rushed out to meet Reloaded's release date.

Oh, and nobody ever really talks about it at all anymore, which for a game based on one of the most iconic action movie franchises of all time is a major alarm bell.

Why You're Wrong: It's not perfect, but here's a game that any card-carrying Matrix fans owes it to themselves to blast through. The close-quarters combat is ludicrously fun, and it does a decent job deepening the mythology of the movies, even adding in live-action scenes shot specifically for the game (memorably one in which Niobe makes out with Persephone). Flawed, sure, but snazzy fun all the same.

11. Black & White

The Game: Peter Molyneux's enormously-hyped 2001 God game, where the player rules over an island, can answer the prayers (or not) of the tribes who live there, and even get their own pet.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Because it always ends up on "most overrated" lists, and Peter Molyneux's toxic reputation as an over-promiser and under-deliverer has unfortunately retrospectively tainted the consensus of many of his games. Despite the enormous hype and strong reviews (it scored a whopping 90 on Metacritic), nobody really ever talks about the game anymore.

Why You're Wrong: Black and White is one of Molyneux's few post-Bullfrog games that actually mostly delivered on its promises, even if wasn't quite as developed in some areas as expected, and didn't really grab the player long-term. Still, it was hugely ground-breaking at the time of release, and the God mechanics remain ludicrously entertaining.

10. Call Of Duty: Ghosts

The Game: 2013's Infinity Ward-developed CoD title that arrived as the first entry into the franchise on PS4 and Xbox One.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Pretty much everyone agrees that Ghosts is the worst CoD game, and despite receiving broadly positive reviews was criticised for failing to do much to build on previous titles, basically rehashing franchise formula in both its campaign and multiplayer offering. Also, those who hoped the next-gen leap would result in significantly better graphics were more than a little disappointed.

Why You're Wrong: Though gamers may flippantly dismiss the game as a dumpster fire, it's still a perfectly enjoyable FPS outing when taken on its own terms. Sure, it doesn't really measure up to the better games in the series, but it still delivers the usual CoD mayhem, and far from being bad, it merely settles for being decent.

9. Brink

The Game: Splash Damage's innovative, parkour-based FPS that emphasised slick movement alongside the usual shooter thrills.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Because Brink was disappointing: there's no getting around that. The game was well-marketed and looked to be a serious breath of fresh air at a time when the FPS genre had never felt more rote and charmless. The bugs, the minimal content and poor AI do undeniably detract from the overall experience, resulting in the game hurriedly being viewed as a "failure" by a large amount of gamers.

Why You're Wrong: Brink still wasn't the disaster that so many dramatic gamers like to insist it is. Yes, it had a shaky launch and fell shy of expectations, but that didn't stop it being a stylish, fast-paced, entertaining FPS if you were smart enough to keep your expectations tempered (and then lowered them a little once it actually came out).

Sadly, the multiplayer community died off extremely quickly, so nowadays the game exists largely through a small network of hardcore fans. What a sad fate for a solid (if flawed) shooter.

8. Spec Ops: The Line

The Game: Yager Development's 2012 military third-person shooter about the psychological toils of war.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Spec Ops was regrettably marked as a generic, down-the-line shooter with little more to offer beyond that familiarity. As a result, gamers were largely turned off by it and the game was a commercial flop, causing most to write it off and never give it a second thought.

Why You're Wrong: Spec Ops may look like your standard, flag-waving military shooter, but it's actually a surprisingly intelligent, thoughtful game about the nature of war and also of modern game design. Without giving anything away, the game has a few narrative sleights of hand ready to ensure you're left with plenty to think about.

It also features one of the most disturbing and unforgettable scenes in gaming history, where the player launches a white phosphorus attack that accidentally decimates dozens of innocents.

What could've been a fairly familiar shooter is instead reinvented as one of the most cerebral and pleasantly surprising war games ever made. Call of Duty could take a few pointers from here.

7. Viva Pinata

The Game: Rare's singular 2006 garden-tending simulator, with the goal being to collect pinatas and breed them.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: A large portion of gamers wrote this one off from the outset because it looked like a silly, low-effort children's game that should probably have been on the Nintendo Wii instead, right?

Why You're Wrong: Viva Pinata may be colourful and cute, but to be honest, a lot of kids would probably find it too difficult to get through, and there's also a massively unexpected level of depth to the core mechanics.

It's an easy game to mock, but if you actually try the game for yourself, your cynicism will probably crumble away in mere moments.

6. Metroid: Other M

The Game: The continuing adventures of the legendary Samus Aran, this time set between the games Super Metroid and Metroid Fusion.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Fans have been vocally disdainful of the game's unflattering depiction of Samus, transforming her from a strong warrior into a more meek, mild and naive young woman who can actually prove pretty grating and unpleasant on occasion.

Why You're Wrong: To completely write the game off because of this is to ignore the fact that the gameplay and graphics are rock solid: this is a great-looking Wii title and the mechanics are as robust as you'd expect from any "core" entry into the series.

Yes, Samus was a bit of an embarrassment this time, but the game gets a lot more right than most hardcore fans are prepared to admit.

5. Conker's Bad Fur Day

The Game: Rare's unforgettable 2001 action platformer about a crude, boozy squirrel looking to make it home to his sexy squirrel girlfriend.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Because it sold horribly for one, and a ton of gamers will take one look at Conker fighting a poo monster and decide the game is too childish for them.

Why You're Wrong: Conker received strong reviews despite poor sales, and is an absolute must-play for pop-culture hounds, because the references to classic movies in particular are both plentiful and brilliant throughout. Plus, with the game now being part of the Xbox One's Rare Replay collection, you have no excuse not to.

Yes, the camera could use some work and not every gag lands, but it's ferociously imaginative and easily one of the N64's best games overall.

4. WWE All Stars

The Game: THQ's WWE game that takes the larger-than-life world of professional wrestling and makes it even bigger, with wildly exaggerated character models and physics-defying finishing moves.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: This one came and went really quickly, and though it received solidly positive reviews, it's still sniffed at by a lot of wrestling game enthusiasts for its lack of realism and moving far away from the simulation aspect of the mainline WWE games. Also, the small move-set and lack of features were widely lambasted.

Why You're Wrong: All Stars is an undeserving black sheep in the wrestling game canon, if at least held to be miles ahead of proper turkeys like WCW Backstage Assault. Still, the criticism is largely unwarranted, because while All Stars probably wasn't a value-filled purchase at full retail price, it is a fun, frothy, gleefully over-the-top brawler that's a pleasant return to the aradey wrestling games of yesteryear.

Sure, it's not bursting with features and the gameplay is very simple, but sometimes that's all you want. The graphics are pretty damn awesome, too, and in what other wrestling game can you have CM Punk take on Andre the freaking Giant?

3. Silent Hill: Downpour

The Game: The final core entry into the Silent Hill series to date, following yet another poor sap trapped in the nightmarish titular town as he attempts to make his escape.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Even reliable fans of the franchise didn't show much interest in this one, and the reviews were extremely mixed with many expressing a distaste for the emphasis on combat and wide-open exploration.

Developer Vatra Games folded mere month after Downpour came out, which pretty much tells you how well it did (or rather, didn't) sell. Of the core SH games, it's generally accepted to be the worst.

Why You're Wrong: Silent Hill: Downpour is admittedly a far cry from the heights of the series, but to completely dismiss it based on that notion is totally absurd. The combat is certainly no less clumsy than it was in the earlier games, and the emphasis still remains on atmosphere and suspense above all else.

Plus, the Otherworld sections of the game are arguably some of the most surreal, visually striking and intense sequences in the entire series. It's plenty flawed, sure, but it dares to try something a little different, and hell, the story's better than Homecoming's, so that's something.

2. 50 Cent: Blood On The Sand

The Game: A sequel to 2005's widely-maligned shooter 50 Cent: Bulletproof, Blood on the Sand once again puts the player in the shoes of 50 Cent as he pursues a high-value artifact stolen from him by Middle-Eastern terrorists (yes, really).

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Because to be honest, it sounds pretty terrible, and Bulletproof was an utter trainwreck, so why expect anything more than a lame cash-grab this time around? Nobody has any expectations whatsoever for a video game revolving entirely around Fiddy's ego-trip, and it's pretty hard to blame them. Most people hated it without even checking out reviews, because it seemed like a foregone conclusion.

Why You're Wrong: In part a sure testament to the benefit of low expectations, Blood on the Sand is a totally rock solid shooter that, while hardly reinventing the wheel, is a good deal better than anyone could've imagined. It's action-packed, high-octane and delivers the basic goods, and if Fiddy wasn't such an egomaniac we'd probably want him to know it, too.

1. Spore

The Game: Maxis' hugely-anticipated God sim which allowed players to cultivate a species from its inception all the way to becoming a highly advanced space-faring civilisation.

Advertisement

Why You Assume It's Terrible: Almost anytime Spore is brought up in discussions online, it's inevitably followed by the proclamation that it was a crushing disappointment and its mere existence an affront to humanity. Criticisms are primarily directed at the simple mini-games and features removed from the final version of the game that were previously demoed, as well as a general consensus that it didn't live up to the astronomical hype.

Why You're Wrong: Spore may not be the masterpiece we were all hoping for, but to call it anything less than resoundingly average is totally absurd. The space level is obviously the crowning achievement here and the other four mini-games don't really live up to that level of excellence, but it's still an enjoyable outing on the whole when stripped away from the gaming industry's hype machine.

Which "terrible" video games do you feel compelled to defend? Disagree with any of these picks? Shout it out in the comments!

Advertisement