20 Reasons 2017's Biggest Video Games Might Suck

Brace for disappointment.

By Jack Pooley /

2017 is an absolutely stacked year for video games and looks set to be one of the biggest ever (assuming most of them don't get delayed into 2018, of course).

Advertisement

Even so, gaming has taught us time and time again that it's best to maintain reasonable expectations wherever possible and approach any potential purchase with a certain critical mind-set.

Specifically, what could a developer be hiding from you in order to make off with your hard-earned cash?

Though many of these games are sure to be critical and commercial smash hits, others will simply fail to live up to their potential due to issues, foreseen or not, which will become abundantly apparent to players when each game is finally out in the wild.

From a combination of gameplay footage, interviews, rumours and good 'ol intuition, here are 20 reasons 2017's biggest games might suck...

20. The Open-World Lacks Meaningful Content - Horizon Zero Dawn

Why It Might Suck: As gorgeous as Guerrilla's new action RPG looks, it could very well struggle against the age-old open-world problem: how do you populate the world in a way that's satisfying and not just full of boring fetch quests?

Advertisement

Though the media push is ramping up as the game nears release, it still remains to be seen whether or not there's mission and activity variety. If not, it may end up feeling like the dull, repetitive open-worlds typically cranked out by Ubisoft.

Why It Might Not: Guerrilla have been refreshingly open about previewing the game to the press, and so far reports are that the game has a solid level of content, even if a 4-5 hour preview event may not be quite long enough to assess how repetitious it could end up later on.

19. Everyone Plays It Once & Forgets About It - 1-2-Switch

Why It Might Suck: 1-2-Switch is a launch title for Nintendo's soon-to-be-released platform, and while Nintendo are quite clearly targeting the casual party market with this game, there's understandable concern among some that it just won't have much to offer after half an hour of play with some buddies.

Advertisement

Ultimately, this looks like a game that should've been bundled for free with the Switch, and then its probably insubstantial nature wouldn't be quite so disheartening. Expect it to quickly collect dust, especially with so many other better-looking Switch titles on the horizon.

Why It Might Not: Maybe I'm wrong. Maybe it goes over a hit with the 20-something crowd, what with its innuendo-laced gameplay, and is something brought to parties for the next few years. Doesn't seem likely, though.

18. Budget Constraints - Shenmue III

Why It Might Suck: The original Shenmue was made for a staggering $47 million back in 1999, making it the 15th most expensive game ever made adjusted for inflation.

Advertisement

Shenmue III, conversely, has been Kickstarted with additional funds reportedly contributed by unknown investors as well as Sony themselves. However, the game's going to struggle to amass a budget matching that of the original game (about $100 million in today's money), and therefore it's possible that the long-awaited threequel will simply feel less than its two predecessors.

Ultimately, fans may have to settle for a rather rough-around-the-edges finale to the classic Dreamcast franchise.

Why It Might Not: In fairness, nobody outside of the game's upper echelons actually knows the full production budget, so perhaps the impressive Kickstarter campaign gave investors a supreme amount of confidence going forward to pour more money into it. Please?

17. Characters Don't Transfer Over - Destiny 2

Why It Might Suck: There's been a lot of mixed signals about whether or not your Destiny characters will transfer over to the sequel due for release later this year.

Advertisement

With the game apparently planned for release on PC alongside consoles, reports stated that Bungie wanted to start fresh and, alongside avoiding the mistakes that plagued the original game, put everyone on a level playing field.

Bungie commented a few months after these rumours that they're favouring the idea of an epic, decade-long journey with your character, but stopped short of actually confirming that characters will transfer over.

If character transfer doesn't happen, it's going to be a huge deal-breaker for a lot of players.

Why It Might Not: Again, this one's still rather up in the air, and it's possible that the utter player disgust to the news last year may have given Bungie enough pause to actually change their minds.

Then again, if they'd pulled a 180, wouldn't they let it be known ASAP, in order to cut down on all those negative vibes within the fanbase?

16. Bad Single-Player & Not Enough Content - For Honor

Why It Might Suck: As anyone who's played the game's beta will know, For Honor is a surprisingly skill-orientated online fighting game, but the beta has also done little to stem many players' worries that the end product just won't tout enough content to be worth a AAA asking price.

Advertisement

The online combat is fun to a point but probably not substantial enough for most to warrant a day-one purchase, and if Ubisoft have been keeping that single-player mode in the dark because there's not much to it, that'll be hugely disappointing.

Why It Might Not: There's much more money in a sustained, curated multiplayer experience than single-player, so perhaps Ubisoft are simply betting all their chips on that, even though the campaign could still be a total blast regardless.

And content-wise, Ubisoft have already confirmed that all DLC maps and modes will be free in order to prevent splitting the player-base, so that's pretty encouraging, right?

15. Boring New Characters & A Lifeless Open World - Mass Effect: Andromeda

Why It Might Suck: Despite releasing at the end of March, the marketing campaing for the fourth Mass Effect has been curiously quiet, which to many is proof enough that the game's going to release as a rushed mess.

Advertisement

While the little we've seen is interesting and promising to a degree, many are naturally concerned that the shift to more open-world exploration could invite a feeling of listlessness in players, and that the new cast of characters won't be as charming as those from the original trilogy. Very justifiable worries, really.

Why It Might Not: Bioware have clearly spent a long time honing this game, which is itself fairly encouraging after Mass Effect 3 was rushed out and the end product clearly suffered for it.

Time spent is no sure indicator of quality, but if the end product feels shoddy or incomplete, Bioware will rightly get absolutely massacred for it (and they sure as Hell know it).

14. It Tries To Be Too Different - Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy

Why It Might Suck: With original developers Naughty Dog having moved on from the Crash Bandicoot franchise, it's up to Vicarious Visions to tag in and try and deliver a nostalgic reprise of the classic platforming trilogy.

Advertisement

There's the understandable worry that Vicarious may attempt to impart their own creative stamp on the games rather than bring them to gamers largely untouched, apart from the necessary graphical and mechanical upgrades.

Moreover, Crash doesn't need to level up, and the game doesn't need microtransactions for more apples and Aku Aku masks.

Why It Might Not: The gameplay shown off to date is definitely hitting the right notes, and the best evidence we have that this is just a shinier version of the Crash we know and love.

13. No Original Cast Members - Guardians Of The Galaxy: The Telltale Series

Why It Might Suck: Telltale haven't confirmed yet whether they've roped in the principal movie cast to provide voices for their Guardians of the Galaxy episodic game. The silence is a bit depressing, especially considering the rather mediocre job Telltale did nailing down voice talent for the Game of Thrones adventure.

Advertisement

Considering how animated and distinctive some of the Guardians' actors and characters are, pale imitations just won't suffice.

Why It Might Not: Firstly, there's no casting confirmed yet, and it's possible that contracts and scheduling are still being worked out. Plus, some impersonators can be really, really good (though we're loath to admit it), and if the script's awesome enough, it'll probably succeed regardless.

12. Character Switching, Just Because - Red Dead Redemption 2

Why It Might Suck: Grand Theft Auto V's superb character-switching mechanic blew pretty much everyone away, and it would be easy for even a developer as meticulous as Rockstar to milk that gimmick for all it's worth by injecting it into their western sequel, regardless of whether the story really calls for it or not.

Advertisement

Why It Might Not: Rockstar rarely puts a foot wrong, and while character switching probably will be a part of the new RDR game, they're likely to make it feel like an organic part of the game's fabric.

Come to think of it, why the Hell are we even doubting these guys anyway?

11. Cloud-Based Gameplay Is A Total Failure - Crackdown 3

Why It Might Suck: Crackdown 3's big selling point has been the fact that online play will be powered by cloud technology, allowing an insane amount of persistent destruction to take place that a single Xbox One could never pull off.

Advertisement

However, the game was announced almost three years ago, has been continually delayed and now word has gone incredibly quiet. Assuming the game actually makes its planned late-2017 window, there's no guarantee all that cloud tech is going to hold up given how failure-prone servers can be during a big game launch.

Plus, maybe the destruction just isn't as impressive as Microsoft thinks it is.

Why It Might Not: Perhaps Microsoft will come running out of the gate at E3 with a near-finished, polished game that looks amazing, and will blow us all away upon release.

Maybe they are just aware that they announced the game too early and don't want to reveal anymore until they're in a position to give a release date. It happens.

10. Gouging Players For Paid Content (Again) - Star Wars: Battlefront 2

Why It Might Suck: As ludicrously addictive as Battlefront's core gameplay was, fans rightly complained about the lack of content and EA's shameless removal of content only to sell it back to the player in a season pass.

Advertisement

Considering that the season pass certainly sold like hot cakes, what's stopping EA doing the exact same thing again with this year's sequel? If it works and people are suckers enough to keep vomiting their cash into EA's coffers, why stop?

Why It Might Not: Considering that EA have promised the game will have a fleshed-out single-player campaign and content from multiple Star Wars movies, it would be unlikely for the game to offer the same or even less than the last Battlefront.

It may not be a huge content upgrade, but after the immense backlash last time, EA will hopefully rein their greed in a little bit.

9. David Cage's Usual Excesses - Detroit: Become Human

Why It Might Suck: David Cage is a one-of-a-kind visionary, but his games largely share one common element: they go wildly off-the-rails late in the day. It happened in the otherwise great Fahrenheit and Heavy Rain, while Beyond: Two Souls was honestly a bit of a mess from start to finish.

Advertisement

As gorgeous and intriguing as his latest effort looks, it'd be foolish to expect a game that doesn't totally crap itself in the final stretch.

Why It Might Not: It's entirely possible Cage will learn from his past mistakes, especially as the game took him two years to write, and hopefully that time was well spent chiseling away his less-savory eccentricities.

8. It Isn't A Forza Horizon Clone - Need For Speed 2017

Why It Might Suck: The Need for Speed series has been on the skids (sorry) for a while, evident no clearer than by the franchise taking an unexpected break last year after the critical mauling of 2015's dubious reboot, simply titled Need for Speed.

Advertisement

Honestly, the incredible Forza Horizon series has such a foothold on the racing genre right now, which is clearly desperate for more games like itself and Burnout Paradise, that Need for Speed may as well just reinvent itself as a Forza Horizon clone.

If it's just more of the same dull wheel-spinning (sorry, again) that the series has seen lately, it's tough to be much interested.

Why It Might Not: It's entirely possible for Ghost Games to conjure up their own fresh idea for a new NFS game, or screw it, they'll just remake Underground, considering how much nostalgia is "in" at the moment, and how awesome that game was. No lie: it would probably work.

7. It Feels More Like A Port Than A Sequel - Splatoon 2

Why It Might Suck: One of the more common murmurs following the Splatoon 2 announcement was that it basically looks exactly like the first game, and considering how few people actually own a Wii U, the game could very well be a stealth port of the original game with a few different colours and a couple of new weapons.

Advertisement

While that's great for those who never played it, it's more than a little lazy, especially as there are so many ways to build on the original game's concept.

Why It Might Not: Remember that the first Splatoon released an absolute avalanche of free DLC content, so hopefully this sequel won't rest on its laurels either, but that's all we've got, really. Gameplay looks business as usual for the most part.

6. It's Hugely Overpriced - Uncharted: The Lost Legacy

Why It Might Suck: Naughty Dog have already claimed that this Uncharted DLC release will be longer than The Last of Us' 2-ish-hour Left Behind DLC, but does that really mean much?

Advertisement

Players are clearly hoping for a 4-6 hour experience here to supplement the original game, but don't be surprised if, after all this hype, it clocks in at around 2-3 hours, and won't necessarily be appropriately priced to boot.

Why It Might Not: Remember that Uncharted 4's Digital Deluxe owners get the DLC for free, and they paid $79.99 for the package.

Minus $60 for the core game and you're left with $20. Assuming Naughty Dog aren't simply rewarding DD owners with cheaper DLC, a $20 launch price for a 3-hour game doesn't sound atrocious.

Not an amazing deal, but hardly a gouge either.

5. Server Issues & Repetitive Gameplay - Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Wildlands

Why It Might Suck: Ubisoft's open-world multiplayer shooter sure looks like a blast, which is exactly why we're worried, considering Ubisoft's penchant for failing to live up to promises and the rather underwhelming launch of The Division last year.

Advertisement

If the servers fall under the strain or, more likely, the gameplay loop is just too samey mission-wise, then this could be a game you enthusiastically play for 10 hours...before realising it's actually pretty dull.

Why It Might Not: Reports coming in from closed betas are surprisingly positive with this one, so it's easy to be optimistic, even with Ubisoft being Ubisoft.

4. It's Too Short - Farpoint

Why It Might Suck: Resident Evil 7 just proved that a full-length AAA experience is possible on PSVR: there are no more excuses.

Advertisement

The next distinct AAA release will be FPS Farpoint, and while it certainly looks intriguing, one wouldn't be stunned if the title ended up playing in the 2-4 hour range, as the developers hinted at 3-5 hours in interviews.

Given that the game is selling itself on a pricey gun peripheral to boot, this potential short length and the infuriating lack of multiplayer could make it the PSVR's first AAA bust.

Why It Might Not: Perhaps there will be some sort of replay value we're missing here, or some free DLC in the future...maybe?

3. It Doesn't Actually Come Out In 2017 - Star Citizen

Why It Might Suck: Star Citizen has been in development in 2011, and in fairness, Cloud Imperium Games have been far more transparent with backers and the general gaming audience than about 99% of developers would ever dare to be.

Advertisement

Still, it's hard to believe this game's ever going to actually be finished, let alone be in a complete form by the end of this year. That'll be the real suck here, short of the game releasing and actually being terrible, which seems incredibly unlikely.

Why It Might Not: Well, there is a possibility it might actually release within the next 12 months...

2. Too Much Reliance On "Emergent Gameplay" - Sea Of Thieves

Why It Might Suck: Rare's new multiplayer pirate adventure led to some of the most cringe-worthy interviews at last year's E3, as the development team offered up "no comment" to so many compelling journalist questions, making it clear that a lot was being held back.

Advertisement

There's just no concrete indication yet that the game is actually going to deliver more than a piecemeal experience, especially as it seems built on the idea of creating stories with your friends rather than actually getting engrossed in a proper narrative. That could easily kill the game for a big chunk of its potential player-base.

Why It Might Not: Emergent gameplay can work, and if Sea of Thieves becomes a streamer's favourite, it could easily catch on as a cult phenomenon. Also, Rare are taking their time refining the game in closed betas, so hopefully the end result will be worth it.

1. Wii U Performance Issues - The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild

Why It Might Suck: Many players complained about the footage of the Wii U version of Zelda: Breath of the Wild at December's The Game Awards touting an alarmingly low, erratic frame-rate of around the 20FPS mark.

Advertisement

Though the game should be expected to play better on the Switch, if this is at the expense of those Wii U owners who may have even bought a Wii U to play this freaking game, some heads are going to roll for sure.

Why It Might Not: This footage was shown off three months before Zelda's release date, which means there's three months for Nintendo to further optimise the game for Wii U and get it looking a lot tighter. Then again, why would they show off such ropey footage in the first place?

What are your concerns for 2017's biggest games? Shout them out in the comments!

Advertisement