7 Games You Didn't Realise Were Playing You

Well, that was unexpected.

By Jack Smurthwaite /

Throughout gaming's entire history, there's always been the notion of choice in the experience. From the first playstation titles with secret endings, to the early point-and-click games of the 1980s, right down to kids getting lost in Choose Your Own Adventure books in 1979; it's a truth universally acknowledged that the most immersive experiences are the ones that feel someway personal. Spectacular set pieces are still a huge part of gaming in the modern age though, but now more than ever gamers are given more ways to arrive at and influence them. Moral choices and split paths are features of almost every narrative these days, but in some cases the programming is so clever, so detailed, that the lines of free choice start to blur. The player effectively becomes the played. It's indicative of the way in which the medium of games has evolved and matured, especially in the past decade. New technology has not only allowed new ways of exploring gameplay and story-telling, it's also given developers a myriad of new ways to play with the player themselves. So, here are 7 games that celebrate the art of turning the tables on players. Some are emotional, some are bizarre and some are just horrific, but all of them are guaranteed to stay with you long after you're finished playing them. Warning: This list contains spoilers for most of the games listed. Read on at your peril.

7. Undertale

The most unnerving kind of fourth wall-breaking games are the ones which don't tell you that they're doing it. Undertale is one such game. Undertale knows everything you're doing. Everything. If you've reloaded the game from a save point, the game knows about it and will make references to it, even making it a part of the narrative. You become revered for your godlike powers of saving and loading by other characters. If you restart the game from scratch, Undertale knows about that too. Flowey will berate you for going back on the decisions you made on your earlier playthrough. There's even talk of the game knowing when you're streaming it. This could be a case of reading too deep between the lines of some of the character's dialogue, but when they say things like "I bet someone like that's watching right now, aren't they?" you can't help but wonder. All of this makes you acutely aware of every decision you make. You never know when they could crop up later in the game. It speaks to the love and attention to detail that went into the game's creation. Simply addressing the concept of mechanics like saving and loading as a part of a game's universe adds a layer of meta awareness not found anywhere else.

6. Amnesia: The Dark Descent

Amnesia messes with the player by presenting them with a particularly cruel dilemma. Light is your lifeline in Amnesia. The protagonist Daniel is petrified of the dark; being in the dark causes him to go progressively insane. Staying in the light reduces Daniel's levels of insanity, but there are also monsters everywhere that are tying to kill you. This leaves with a decision: You can stay in the darkness and gradually lose your mind. Or you can stay in the light and risk facing death at the hands of a variety of ravenous, bloodthirsty creatures. To complicate things even further, if Daniel so much as looks at the monsters he'll go crazy even faster. It's an impossibly difficult decision and hugely adds to the emersion of the game. Daniel's terror becomes yours, whether you're in the light or dark.

5. The Walking Dead

The Telltale Walking Dead games love to force you into making tough decisions in tense, life or death situations and giving you about 20 seconds to make them. At several points The Walking Dead asks you whether some lives are worth more than others. You forge relationships with other characters through a series of dialogue choices and genuinely feel like you've bonded with the other people in your group of survivors. Then, all of a sudden, the game throws you into a situation in which you have decide whether to let them die in order to save the rest of your group. Ultimately, The Walking Dead confronts and confounds you with your own moral compass. If all of that wasn't difficult enough, at the end of each chapter you're shown statistics of how other players responded to the same decisions. There's never been an easier to compare how much of a terrible person you are to the rest of the world.

4. Catherine

Catherine doesn't employ any technical wizardry to screw with your head, it simply asks you a series of short questions. These questions include "Does life begin or end with marriage?", "Who would be responsible if you cheated, you or the person you cheated with?" and the ever-challenging "Could you have sex with an attractive ghost?" During the course of the game you're asked dozens of questions like this. Some are silly, others are very, very serious and introspective. It becomes especially awkward if you happen to be playing the game with your significant other. There's a good chance that relationships have been strained by some of the questions asked in Catherine, that's how personal it gets. This is a level of introspection that's very rarely explored in games. Through a relatively simple mechanic, Catherine legitimately forces you to question and reevaluate aspects of your own personality.

3. Papers, Please

Speaking of questioning yourself, Papers, Please will make you question why you're such a terrible human being. You're given the role of immigration officer at the border of the fictional land of Arstotzka in 1982. At the end of each day on the job you're given money based on how many people's applications you've processed and how many bribes you've collected. The problem is that you have a family to feed but processing applications doesn't pay well enough. Taking bribes from potentially murderous criminals is where the real money is. The game forces you into situations where you have to decide between feeding your starving family and not letting violent criminals into the country. To quote Spock in The Wrath of Khan, "The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few, or the one" and Papers, Please makes you wonder whether there's actually any truth in that saying at all. It makes you question whether the wellbeing of those close to you is more important than the lives of innocent civilians. If you give Papers, Please a try be prepared to have your personal politics, your compassion and your empathy for other human beings torn apart.

2. Eternal Darkness

Eternal Darkness is really messed up. It's notorious for using (at the time) realistic visual trickery to fool the player into thinking they were going crazy. The player has a sanity meter. When a monster spots the player, their sanity meter depletes. The lower the meter, the more likely it is that the game will screw with you. The tricks it pulls on you get old pretty fast, but the first time they get you, they're pretty harrowing. The shear terror when the game tells you for the first time that your memory card has been wiped has stayed with players for years. Perhaps the most well-known sanity effects are the ones that pretend to alter settings on your TV and change the channel. It's a relatively simple effect, but it was unprecedented at the time and has never been successfully replicated since. It's creative, meta and terrifying. When you're suffering from sanity effects, there's nothing you can do about it. You just have to let it play out and accept the suffering. The only issue with Eternal Darkness is that, like a lot of games released in the same era, its visuals haven't aged too well. In a world full of HD remakes and sequels, it would be great to see Eternal Darkness updated for modern consoles. There are so many ways an updated version of Eternal Darkness could deeply, deeply, disturb the minds of a whole new generation.

1. Bioshock

Bioshock plays you in a way that isn't clear throughout the majority of the game. That's what makes it so cruel. A common criticism of many linear games is that they force you through a series of events without allowing you much control. Typically, there's some kind of narrative voice telling you exactly what you're supposed to do. To an extent, Bioshock also follows this trope. Its execution is a little more interesting than most other linear games, though. Early in the game you get a sense that the narrator, Atlas, is your ally as well as your instructor as you explore Rapture. That is until a certain, notorious, plot twist. You may have heard of the "Would you kindly?" moment. In which, it becomes clear that the protagonist Jack has been brainwashed. Whenever he hears the phrase it triggers him to obey every command that follows those three words. The person behind all this? Atlas; who reveals that his true identity is Frank Fontaine, a criminal mastermind who has been indoctrinating Jack since he was a child. It's a narrative curve ball that most players didn't see coming and there's a sense of betrayal when it's revealed that has arguably never been matched in games before or since. Bioshock toys with your preconceived notions of what it is to have free will in a linear game, and it does so with devastating effect.