Oh, how blind we Xeno-fans were back in 2011. Just how exactly could Aliens: Colonial Marines possibly suck? As the craftsmen behind such acclaimed games as Brothers in Arms and Borderlands, Gearbox had our confidence signed and sealed, but couldn't deliver worth a damn. The gaping cavity Colonial Marines left in our chests was a hearty deathblow to our collective faith in a franchise that was already struggling to stay relevant. It put us in a state of deep existential longing for the future existence of a game that understood why the Alien is so iconic and terrifying, and on October 11th, our prayers to the Engineers were answered. Creative Assembly heeds the call of true horror preservationists and fans of Ridley Scott's 1979 masterpiece with Alien: Isolation. Reviews so far have been an above average mixed bag, but Alien nerds will definitely find more to love here than in that Gearbox atrocity we're all busy forgetting. Before we had a chance to play Isolation, the critical reception got us wondering a few things that we now feel confident answering. Is the game really 20-25 hours? Yes. Is it really that scary? By uprooting most preexisting FPS cliches, safety nets, and firepower for the sake of sneaky, powerless horror... yes, it most certainly is. Is it really that hard? Well... Hard Mode definitely is. Consider playing on Medium, and Hell - there's no shame in going for Easy. You'll die regardless. 7 things are certain - Alien: Isolation is a much better game than Aliens: Colonial Marines for these reasons...
7. Respecting The Source Material
Set several months after the nightmare on LV-426, Colonial Marines was pitched as the long awaited, interactive sequel to James Cameron's 1986 film, Aliens - a much better sequel. You may have thought its surprisingly accurate recreations of Hadley's Hope, the Sulaco and a few half-android and audio-log Easter Eggs would do the trick, but without a soul, the recognizable husk of something we love never became anything more. The (literal) execution of Marine's story hinged on a vast oversimplification of what made Aliens' marriage of "action" and "terror" so distinguished. Instead of authentically retrofitting Cameron's best ideas in a creative and organic way that elevated the storytelling advantages of both mediums, Gearbox's half-gestated mess failed hard on both fronts, with level-design that bolstered its recognizable set-pieces to no substantial effect and cameos that not only fudged established cannon, but felt about as natural as a baby Xeno sprouting out of our chest. What good is any one point of source material accuracy if it's built on the foundation of a glaring facade? Alien: Isolation lovingly takes its cues from Ridley Scott's relatively restrained original film, with stylistic legitimacy and thematic integrity that finally does the franchise justice, right down to the (optional) VHS film-grain. Rather than cutting-and-pasting famous sets and doing nothing special with them, Isolation painstakingly borrows core elements of the Alien universe design palette and seamlessly welds them together in a sensibly layered and altogether thrilling fashion. Chunky 80s CRT tech, a deceptively open map-layout and dynamic human, android, and Alien A.I. coalesce to form a believable play space and achieve a sensory experience that truly surpasses the the sum of its parts. We've had plenty of games that look and sound like an Alien movie... and now we finally have one that feels the part.
6. A Smart Script And Understated Acting
The first two Alien films narrowly side-stepped the pitfalls of your average B-movie monster mash by capitalizing on every aspect of their A-movie potential. Arguably, the most important tool in Scott's and Cameron's toolboxes were their world class acting ensembles and largely understated scripts. Tonally, each film found an unforeseen, grounded balance within a fresh sci-fi paradigm that managed to subvert their slasher and action-heavy sentiments with a subdued and industrial approach to character and setting respectively... all of it stuffed in an air-locked pressure cooker. Aliens: Colonial Marines must have missed the memo. Boasting some of the most generic dialogue this side of the bro-shooter handbook, Gearbox's hackneyed scene-work didn't have a natural bone in its narrative body. Marines aped a sloppy understanding of contrived, human interaction in a context we never fully understood as a blatantly transparent means to shuttle us from one shooting gallery to another. Embracing gaming cliches to the point of painfully bursting, Aliens: CM crashed and burned in its efforts to provide players with a relatable point of reference for an already ham-fisted approach to storytelling. Isolation knows enough to steer clear of such tom-foolery, granting fans a nuanced script rooted in realistic, filmic-isms and understandable motivations. If H.R Giger's Alien is our worst psycho-sexual nightmare, Sigourney Weaver is the heart and soul conduit through whom we've grown to fear and love the horrid creature, and Amanda's journey mirrors her mother's experience beautifully. In lesser hands, the direct parable of Ellen Ripley's grown daughter facing the same fate would feel too on-the-nose, but Creative Assembly touches these stark similarities earnestly without smothering your face in them. The justification for just about every single piece of fanfare is handled meticulously and the narrative conceit for Alien as an interactive experience is accessible, deep and thematically pure for the first time. Most importantly, it never gets in the way of the game's razor sharp focus on staying alive... and every desperate measure that entails.
5. A Meaningful Challenge
Cheating virtual death has been a staple in video games for as far back as we can remember, but the essence of imminent death and narrow escape only becomes a tangible dynamic if the stakes are equally palpable. Dying only matters if the consequences are successfully communicated in a way that doesn't trivialize victory over defeat. Gearbox's game provides no such experience. Aliens: Colonial Marines did its damnedest to pass off a barrel full of bullets and a ton of Aliens as mortal tension. The entirely misguided logic of this execution was made all the less effective by abysmal AI, dog-paddling through swathes of scenic clutter while aimlessly assaulting anything within claws reach. Weyland's goons weren't much better, not even taking care to focus fire on Xenos in a three-way combat scenario. With Aliens as underpowered as these, we can hardly blame the Mercenaries for not taking them seriously. When a higher difficulty means Aliens can simply take a few more bullets, we reach the capacity of Colonial Marines' ability to deliver a poignant challenge. There will always be hard games, but we're thrilled to see the resurgence of playful punishment that has taken root in hardcore survival-horror games. Isolation is right up there with Amnesia, Slender and Outlast. Death is a way of life, or more accurately... the way of more death. But this kind of death doesn't run full speed at your face in the form of endless, mindless hordes. It comes at the crux of a few desperate strangers fighting for survival. It comes as a punctuation to the otherwise slow burn of stalking along an ominous hallway. It comes suddenly and without warning. If it does come screaming towards you, it's with wild and ferocious purpose, and by then, it's far too late... Death is brutally real and unpredictable. You'll use every faculty of perception available to you. You will devise quick and dirty plans on the fly, crafting invaluable gadgets to distract and disable threatening lifeforms and unhinged automatons. Sometimes you'll find yourself cursing that insufferable beast for seemingly singling you out, but it all serves to add authenticity to the random chaos of this uncanny survival simulation.
4. Environmental Effects And Visual Fidelity
One the most glaring controversies regarding Gearbox's 2011 train-wreck was the game's generously target-rendered gameplay debut, the final product's noticeable dip in graphical quality and the reasons it all went wrong. Textures were five-years-too-blurry, even if you played on PC, but the console-quality gap wasn't a mere matter of low resolution and poor lighting. Console optimization was outsourced, and boy did it show. Screen tearing. Pop-in. Rampant clipping and hit detection issues. You name it. Players would straight-up fall through certain maps that lacked polish, soul and some essential debugging, which clearly never happened. Holding the actual game up next to its original demo showing laid bare blatant evidence of massive technical compromises, from drastically less impressive lighting to particle effects that weren't even in the same league. As horrifying as its interstellar hell may be, Alien: Isolation is simply stunning to look at. Dynamic light sources dole out dim scraps of visibility that fully exploit the natural claustrophobia of our limited senses, capturing a classic, deep space sterility in earlier levels and the dank, metal, emergency-flashing sweat-fest the hunt inevitably becomes. As silly as it may sound, ambient fog and steam serve a practical purpose of visually impairing you and lend an additional layer of realism that cannot be understated. Random garbage, people clutter and general debris make the Sevastapol's metal hallways feel lived in. In-game flames are some of the absolute best we've ever seen, flickering vibrantly and vividly spewing from broken pipes and punctured gas canisters - useful distractions in a pinch. A small army of androids on fire - stoically marching in your direction - isn't as hopeless as it sounds. Unless they want to "help you." That's code for murder.
3. Death Won't Save You
If you died in Colonial Marines, it was your own fault for letting go of the trigger, and of course, like most video games today, you'd respawn at a nearby checkpoint. Failure meant nothing. For the most part, we're glad that save systems have evolved to keep us in the action, but as much as this has allowed developers to more deliberately guide the pace of their narratives, generous progress markers have all but sucked the gravity out of more modern, in-game life-or-death situations. Thankfully, not every modern game is willing to compromise the meaning of mortality, something Dark Souls, Day Z and XCOM have used to legendary affect. Following their deadly footsteps, being mauled and murdered in Alien: Isolation is no saving grace. You will die... a lot. You won't always know why and it will almost never be a good time. In order to save your progress, you'll have to manually punch your film-accurate, security card replica into one of the few, sparsely-placed, automated work-stations strewn about the Sevastopol. Remember, each save happens in real-time, so you're not actually safe and clear until you've pulled the card from its slot. We never died this way, but just knowing it's possible makes the save box's signature beep a massive sigh of painful joy and a tense reminder of your mortality all at once. Running the emotional gambit of draining terror followed by defeat to dizzying relief and survival by the skin of your teeth isn't for every gamer, but if you get-off on hardcore fear in a controlled-setting, Isolation is definitely for you. The uncertainty of what dynamically fatal circumstance you'll find yourself in next, teamed with the very real risk of losing progress with every last breath, lets Isolation soaks you in unrelenting tension, operating on a spectrum of tonal extremes we're proud to see again in mainstream horror games.
2. Thematically Rich FPS Mechanics
Obviously, video games have traditionally let us do more and watch less, but when the doing is as hollow and monotonous as it was in Gearbox's 6-hour slog, we'd rather just watch an Aliens movie. If you measure the actual proportion of time Ellen Ripley and friends spent pulse-rifling Aliens in James Cameron's epic compared to the bullet-hosing majority of Colonial Marines, you'd probably start to think all video games had to offer were the re-skinned contexts of shooting things forever. Marines' derivative gameplay tropes desperately borrowed from every trick in the FPS bag, and unfortunately, every one of its sci-fi ideas had a much better showing in other games, long ago... Alien: Isolation gives you guns too, but guess what? Amanda Ripley can't shoot to save your life. Even more so than The Last of Us, guns are rare, shooting is shakey and players are generally powerless to push the odds in their favor. If a stranger doesn't like you, and you take one bullet to the face, it's game over. Guns also make noise... and noise is very bad in Alien: Isolation. Mr. Alien hates noise. Creative Assembly's survival simulation mechanics show remarkable restraint, all in the spirit of scaring us. Things we take for granted, like being able to focus our eyes on every plane of depth at once... Nope. There's a button that swaps Amanda's focus back and forth between her broader surroundings and the chunky, motion tracker she desperately holds in front of her face. Because the Alien's prowess is taken more seriously, you'll spend most of your time ducking, hiding and peeking your way through the Sevastopol's sinister retro maze. Mind you... you're never actually safe. That tangible threat of impending doom is fully supported by every aspect of gameplay. Literal noise-makers, IEDs and the formidable flamethrower will prove invaluable, but all of them carry their own risks and should only be used as a last resort. We love little touches like hiding in lockers and manually leaning back, actively holding our breath and praying, even if we've only survived that particular scenario a few times. Also, there is no pray button, but manually praying never hurts.
1. Recreating A Horror Icon
The great terror of H.R. Giger's original Alien was no fluke. Spawned from the pages of his personal renderings, the titular freak we know and love was inspired by Giger's artistic affinity for the surreal, mechanical, and sexually grotesque. Someone actually passed Ridley Scott a copy of H.R.'s Necronomicon - published in 1977, two years before Alien released - and the rest is history. To the point of parody, Marines' misguided answer to just about every scenario in-game was, "...and then a sh*t-ton of Aliens happen!" Swarm after swarm of Xeno-slaughter rapidly devolved into arbitrary action with no real tension. The Alien's didn't fair much better individually, constantly catching on errant objects in the environment and generally collapsing in repetitive heaps. If they weren't screaming and scattering like mindless insects, they were inexplicably vanishing or dead on the ground, sporting acid-blood splatters that laughably resembled neon pants. Cameron's sequel still managed to capture the foreign horror of the beast, even with so many creatures onscreen, but Colonial Marines nose-dived into the exact pit that Aliens deftly avoided in 1986 - diminishing the stature of Ridley Scott's singular threat. You'll face more than Giger's imagination, but Isolation brings us back to square one with an Alien you simply do not stand a chance against. Just like the original beast, Creative Assembly's monster is both cunning and indiscriminately murderous. With AI based on functional animal senses, Giger's classic creature actively hunts you via sight, scent and sound. Stay sharp. If you're flying on blind luck, you'll fare about as well as Dallas did in those vents. Wrong way, Dallas! All of these elements that preserve the look, tone and feel of Ridley Scott's first film would fall flat without a believable Alien on the prowl and if this isn't the most realistic and dynamic NPC behavior you've ever seen in a video game, you'll certainly be fooled more than a few times that it is... and be promptly murder-tackled. How did you receive the newest Alien game... or have you? What are the freakiest situations you've gotten yourself into on the Sevastopol? Did Colonial Marines have any other redeeming values? Sound off in the comments below!