7 Things Nobody Wants To Admit About Persona 5
When you want to love someone, but they keep pushing you away.
Attempting to voice a negative opinion on something as critically revered as Persona 5 is not an easy task. Right now I guarantee a small army of fans are sharpening their pitchforks and loading their shotguns, one cartridge at a time.
"Let's here what he has to say", thinks one. "No, it's already gone too far!" cries another, lighting a piece of wood and holding it aloft, the flames highlighting the real fire behind their eyes.
And here's the thing: I really love Persona 5. Parts of it. At time of writing I'm 40 hours in (or 38:43, to be precise), and I've got some thoughts - some that contradict the straight 9s and 10s the game has been getting since launch. Some that make me question how much I've possibly put up with in Persona/JRPG games past, and others that highlight the cross-generation development cycle the game went through to emerge on PS4.
For the sake of both placating the fans and establishing exactly where I stand before we go further, Persona 5's presentation, score and overall style is one of a kind; a truly exemplary aesthetic package that rewrites the rulebook on how a game can feel. This translates into the majority of gameplay too (hence close to 40 hours in a few days), but there are a handful of poignant negatives I can only imagine I'm not alone in noticing...
--
Note: Spoilers for the first three main story Palaces.
7. Dialogue Choices Often Mean Nothing
Aside from a handful of specific interactions when you choose to hang out with the main cast, every major story-related decision steams ahead regardless of your choice in the moment. Oftentimes, even if you want to apologise for something, stick up for a character being talked down to or literally state you don't want to go through with a given thing, either someone else will chime in and say "Come on, man!", or it'll be taken as a joke.
This leads to a similar feeling to Mass Effect Andromeda, where in striving to move away from binary dialogue options - something Persona has never had - we're given a story that only offers the illusion of choice. There are many instances of characters asking what you think, only for your options to be variations on the same sentiment, "I don't know", "That's not for me to say", "..." - all of which fail at making you feel as though you have any real agency in the story itself.
One notably bizarre scene occurs when Morgana straight-up offers your place as somewhere for Yusuke to stay, following Madarame's palace. You're not given any room to object, agree or step in whatsoever, the story putting him in your room the next time you arrive. Morgana even assumes the role of your character, doing the "make yourself at home!" routine, when it should really have come from you.
Yes, various character-specific scenes can pivot and modulate through what you've said, but as the main story goes on, it feels as though your 'character' barely has less meaningful presence overall.
6. Corridor Dungeons And Design Gets Repetitive Fast
Assumedly as a way to ensure Persona is a very lengthy game, the various dungeons you visit are made up of a fairly small amount of assets. They're effective gameplay-wise, and I must make the distinction between structural repetition/object repetition and the occasional specific set-piece room - the latter of which are insanely inventive and very memorable.
For example, Junya Kaneshiro's twisted version of Shibuya where every citizen is a walking ATM? Brilliant. Kamoshida's sex-fuelled upper rooms being filled with statues of teenage derrieres that are guarded by a putrid, oversized, literal penis? Also, total genius.
However, having literally one object be the source of loot in each respective Palace (a vase, a piece of art, a money bag etc.), or having all three Palaces (so far) centre on "Go to the security room, find the guard, acquire the key and proceed"? Not so much.
Even the 'stealth mechanics' amount to tapping X to wait in specific spots, before ambushing guards in the same fashion, over and over.
There's a level of artistic inventiveness that's genuinely outstanding in parts of P5's dungeons - and all its enemies, bosses and manifestations of your targets' desires are spot on - but the actual interaction with them outside of visuals, the playability of a given map, falls short of matching such ambitious aesthetics.
5. It Takes 30 Hours To Really Get Going
Perhaps it's down to Persona 5 being the first game to ditch the Shin Megami Tensei branding in the West, but you can tell a ton of effort has been put into making this an entry point for newcomers, holding your hand for a ludicrous amount of time. Even after you've clocked Kamoshida's palace you'll still be getting drip-fed basic game mechanics like combining Personas, grinding stats, making lockpicks, accessing Mementos and keeping up with social appointments.
There is a lot to take in overall, but it's only a rare occasion where P5 lets you take multiple Requests, shows multiple characters asking to hang out or highlights multiple possibilities for how YOU want to spend your time. That is where the core Persona experience is supposed to come to life, and it does at times, but they're very short-lived.
The "overwhelming stress" various critics and commenters have mentioned as a positive way the game pulls you in many different directions at once? I've not experienced it, because everything is spoon-fed, one element at a time - and that's before Morgana actively chastises and berates you for attempting to do something other than go to bed in the evenings.
4. There's No Real Overarching Drive Or Motive
I can only attest to playing a healthy chunk of Persona 4 as comparison, but at least in that game, you're tasked with foiling a murder mystery plot; the dark reality of slain bodies forever interrupting the carefree nature of 'another day at school'.
Here, P5 seems to be an exploration of vigilantism, of being a superhero in a world devoid of justice; highlighting the various ways 'adults' can abuse and ruin the youth. Lofty goals, but ones that lack any throughline focus. For the aforementioned 30 hours you'll mostly be high-fiving each other over how awesome it feels to 'change someone's heart', juxtaposed against the narrative framework of each mission being told through flashback, as we know from the intro that our main character gets caught eventually.
This presumably is the 'main thread', the "How they gonna get outta this one?!", but the game handles these cuts back to the future in a weirdly sporadic nature, usually after you've recruited somebody in the present. You'll acquire a team member, then get a minute-long scene where interrogator Sae Niijima says something like, "You must have had somebody working in [insert X industry] all this time". Well, yes, we just got them.
Overall it feels like if you made an entire game out of Mass Effect-style loyalty missions (which was the issue with Andromeda). There is a 'main villain' lurking in the background (that our main character seems unable to connect some obvious dots with), but the occasionally tone-deaf script aims for this rebellious "All adults are corrupt, man!" ideology, allowing its characters to aim at everybody and nobody simultaneously.
Ultimately, for these 40 hours at least, it has failed to provide any will to see the game through, other than how much fun it is to play and look at.
3. Its Core Message Is Delivered Very Poorly (The Problem With Morgana)
As mentioned, the driving motive character-wise is to "Stop those damn adults!", as Ryuji keeps mentioning. There's definitely a charm buried somewhere in a youthful, teenage view of the world - one that targets the assumption that once you get past the ripe old age of, say 20, all your passions wilt and you devolve into a being of pure, sexless, mortgage-paying ineptitude.
Such an assumption has been the bedrock for escapist fiction for decades (hence the 'need' to reboot everything from your childhood for maximum nostalgia-bucks), but Persona goes one step further and really hammers home the idea that these kids just want to bring justice to a world ruined by right-wing politics and self-serving rule-makers.
But... Morgana is himself the worst example of this.
A boisterous feline with a penchant for denying he's a cat, Morgana actively berates you for trying to do anything other than what he wants to do. He admits to using the teenagers as 'pawns' for his own gain, withholds information as to what the Palaces and Mementos are, and goes so far as to - as mentioned earlier - let other people crash at your place, without your say-so.
Ostensibly, he's the stand-in for the 'voice of God' in Persona 4, or what in any other game would just be the character talking to themselves, yet in restricting your actions and literally being a brick wall to freedom, he ends up embodying everything the Phantom Thieves are supposed to be against.
Want to return a DVD so you don't miss the late fee? You can't, Morgana says you need to sleep. Want to make a lockpick for your next journey? Nope, you "Can't do that now". Watch TV, make coffee or leave the damn café? Nope, nope and hell no.
Get to bed, child, the adults have spoken.
2. Portrayals Of Ann's Femininity And Sexuality Border On Offensive
Speaking of messages being delivered poorly, Japan and various other eastern territories have more than an association with romanticising or sexualising the form of young girls (see PlayStation VR's 'Summer Lesson', Nintendo's latest Direct using the Switch's HD Rumble to 'simulate' groping boobs, or the vast majority of Japanese anime).
Persona 5 attempts to bring this to light by having various main villains discuss just how "disposable", "weak" and "pathetic" women are through their eyes, leading to the likes of Ann and Motoko fighting back against such assumptions, proving them wrong through actions alone.
However, the script itself is just as presumptive as to the appropriate 'uses' of women, shown through the treatment of Ann.
Two key scenes really made me sit back and question whether Atlus are truly aware of their country's cultural issues or not, as in one instance it's fully assumed that Ann will strip nude to seduce/distract Yusuke - a moment you can't intervene with, stop or otherwise voice your disapproval of. Ann herself in this scene does protest, but the suggestion is clearly played off as a "Oh you, you know what needs to be done!", rather than the idea being respectful of her privacy, and allowing for a way to flat-out stop it from happening.
Second is far more subtle, but again highlights this way of viewing women as less than human, and more as sexual objects. Upon completing Madarame's palace, the Phantom Thieves all gather round your protagonist's place for food, to which Ann then falls asleep. As she lies down - with no comment, dialogue or anything to suggest this is a little bit creepy - both Morgana and Ryuji attempt to look up her skirt, before she hand-waves them away and falls asleep.
Much is made of Ann's stunning looks belying the substance and personality - the human - beneath, but it's clear from interactions like these (and Yusuke's assumption he can stay at her place for no reason, not to mention continuing to want to draw her nude) that addressing the issue head-on in dialogue hasn't translated into the mentalities of the writers themselves.
1. Over-Levelling Is Way Too Easy
It was around 35 hours in before I died, and that was thanks to a boss exploiting my character's weakness for a '1 More!', resulting in a swift kill. That said, I'd appreciate more challenge, as once the game lets you delve into the Mementos, you're free to explore, battle and level to your heart's content.
It's here where you'll start taking Requests for other targets that aren't specifically story-related, but it almost feels as though the game doesn't account for how much you can wander off the beaten path, being that doing so for even half an hour will over-level you for the coming main thread. This sort of thing could easily be chalked up to my own fault for indulging in combat, but for such a little time invested, affecting the overall challenge of the whole game is a marked negative.
Why there isn't anything in place to make a check of the player's level and abilities, before then tailoring enemy damage, is beyond me, as even if we go with the assumption that random fights shouldn't always be a challenge, I've completely steamrolled all the bosses so far, too.
--
Let me know in the comments how you're going to kill m- what you think, and for a completely different opinion on Persona 5, check out this article!