7 Video Games Most Hated By Politicians

By C Dillon /

Video games are evil and they serve no purpose other than to make us super crazy and want to kill everyone. Well, that's what politicians seem to think. For some reason that us gamer's find hard to fully understand, politicians and news media really have a disliking for the medium. They blame many of societies problems on video games that we know are simply there to entertain us and make some money. There's no underhanded plan or deep-rooted evil in video games, but that's what politicians would have you believe. Very specific games often crop up into the mainstream media, usually as a point of interest in a murder trial or a senator using them as an example as to why society is so terrible these days. Games like Grand Theft Auto and Call of Duty are all too often used as a way to highlight the violence our children are subject to. Sadly, games don't get even one quarter of the recognition they deserve as fun, thought-provoking, meaningful narratives and experiences that are quickly surpassing Hollywood in terms if artistic design and spectacle. Rant over. As well all know, politicians do indeed hate video games, or at least use them as scapegoats when there is no other viable excuse. So which games are most hated? Which politicians or news outlets slandered which games? And what kinds of controversy did the games supposedly cause? Read on to find out!

7. China VS Online Gaming

OK, so I'll admit, this isn't so much a video game as a way of playing but it would be foolish not to include this. Now it's no surprise that China are pretty darn serious about censorship. However in the case of online gaming there's a little more to it than simple censoring of messages, in this instance addiction plays a big role. In China online gaming addiction is rife and the country has been attempting to regulate this by implementing time restrictions, the idea behind this is to encourage gamer's to take a break. Back in 2007 the Beijing Reformatory for juvenile delinquents claimed that a third of its prisoners were heavily influenced by online gaming. Of course there's no real way to prove this and I doubt there is any correlation but the claim itself is enough to encourage such precautions as time restrictions. As previously mentioned, we all know that video games are heavily censored in China, like every other entertainment medium too. Causes for censorship include things like 'Divulging State Secrets', 'Disturbing Social Order' and 'Damaging the Nation's Glory', what those entail exactly are up to the Ministry of Culture. However a recent game that was banned gives us an insight as to what is not tolerated. Battlefield 4 was banned in China for "smearing the image of China and endangering national security." Now I don't really know what about the game could be considered a threat to national security but I do understand they don't want their country portrayed as the villains, had they listed that smearing the image as the only reason it would have been more understandable. So China has some serious restrictions, censors and even bans on video games, usually of the western variety. However I put this example at the top of the list as it's hardly surprising.

6. Bully VS Jack Thompson

And with the return of Rockstar we also get the return of Jack Thompson and British MP Keith Vaz - who also participated in the Manhunt debacle - jumping on the train to abuse Bully. The criticisms for Bully came from the way it presented teachers, sexual content and bullying. It was for these reasons the game was renamed as Canis Canem Edit in the UK. Bully received a T-rating and parents, Thompson, Vaz and others argued that it wasn't suited to that age range. In Bully, the protagonist can kiss both boys and girls, which was a subject of dispute but the ESRB said they accounted for the bisexual content when they rated the game. The game was also banned entirely in Brazil for the same reasons that Thompson and Vaz were so outspoken against it. Needless to say Thompson failed to get the game banned in Florida and it was only removed from shelves in very select stores in the UK. For anyone who has played Bully, they know it is like a high school version of Grand Theft Auto but much less violent and more tongue-in-cheek. The game is really not worth any controversy, the violence is minimal, the sexual content is optional and the presentation of teachers and parents is simply a form of humor. Something many politicians and media outlets seem to lack.

5. Mass Effect VS Fox News

In 2008 a controversy arose over the sci-fi epic from EA and Bioware, Mass Effect, when a little known news service, Cybercast, falsely reported that the game's sex scenes were like pornography. No one took much notice of the story because anyone who played the game knew it was untrue; the game does not even feature nudity of any kind. Sadly the story became a much bigger deal when Fox News got word of the story and, without the forethought to actually play the game and find out, began a week long report on the false claims. The game was depicted as one for perverts and yet aimed at children. Author Cooper Lawrence jumped in on the story in a debate with games specialist Geoff Keighley, who asked her if she had played the game and she laughed at the idea. Needless to say gamer's took to their keyboards and began letting Fox and Lawrence know just how wrong they were. Lawrence's book on amazon received hundreds upon hundreds of 1-star reviews from scorned gamers around the world. After the week long abuse EA put a stop to it, sending a stern letter to Fox News, letting them know how wrong they were. This is simply further proof that politicians and media gurus tend to jump the gun and not actually bother to play through these games, or even do a little research, before reporting falsehoods and erroneously slandering video games.

4. The Playable Taliban

Remember how in Goldeneye you could play as the bad guys? Well EA tried to do something similar in Medal of Honor Warfighter in which you could play as the Taliban. Yes in 2010 EA decided you could have the option of playing as the Taliban in the online multiplayer mode. The developers stated that it was a necessary inclusion in the game to make it more realistic and that "if someone is the cop, someone's gotta be the robber". Needless to say controversy was abound. Liam Fox, the UK Defense Secretary, tried to get the game banned because he deemed it "un-British". Fox, having not played or seen the game, claimed that you killed British troops in it, when the British forces didn't even feature in the game. This seems a little extreme when you consider that in every FPS multiplayer mode, one team is the US or British or whoever and the opposing side will be Germany, Russia or Korea. So this was really nothing new. Fox wasn't the only outspoken politician, Canadian Defense Minister Peter MacKay also said he did not approve of the game and the idea of children playing as the Taliban (despite the game having an 18 or M rating). The game was also banned from being sold in many US Military bases, "out of respect for the men and women serving their families." said commander Bruce Casella. In this scenario the politicians marginally got their way, the name of the team in the multiplayer mode was changed from Taliban to opposing forces, thus hushing the outcry. This is yet another tale of politicians complaining about things they have limited to no knowledge of and slandering the image of a game that really didn't do anything wrong.

3. Hilary Clinton VS Grand Theft Auto

I can't think of many games that come under more media scrutiny than the uber-popular Grand Theft Auto. The series is often brought up in any video game violence debate because it's incredibly well-known and was indeed one of the first real open-world games in which you could kill civilians as you please. The thing that separates GTA from the usual video game is that it is simply way too popular for any slanderous comments or media negativity to have even a tiny dent on the game's image or sales figures. Indeed every iteration of GTA to date as received negativity from politicians or media in some fashion, it's all but expected. Possibly the most criticized version however, has been GTA: San Andreas. Back when the game was released in 2005 Hilary Clinton went on a tirade, complaining about why the game should have a more mature rating. She advocated that the game was terrible for children, "There is no doubting the fact that the widespread availability of sexually explicit and graphically violent video games makes the challenge of parenting much harder". Now as someone who played his brothers copy of the game at the age of 12, I can safely say I've never caused any problems for my parents nor anyone else I've known. She even said that the game encourages you to "have sex with prostitutes and then murder them." Once again, apart from the removed mini-game (Hot Coffee) that allowed users to have sex, I can't recall a time in the game when I was ever encouraged to do that. And once again, it was a mature game for adults, children shouldn't be playing it. Hypocrisy I know, but we all played games when we were too young and the vast vast majority of us are completely fine. Needless to say Clinton's claims did nothing to hinder the sales, popularity or critical reception of San Andreas, it sold massive numbers and the franchise has went from strength to strength. Yes GTA's Hot Coffee sex simulator was stupid and had no place in the game, which is why Rockstar removed it, but to claim children had access to it and that the game encouraged you to have sex, was an outright lie. The reality is, if a parent was that concerned about what their child plays they wouldn't buy them the game, or at least take a look at their collection from time to time. But to attempt to ban it for all the people who are of age and can make decisions for themselves is simply censorship of the highest and stupidest level.

Advertisement

2. No Russian

'No Russian'. The level that sparked controversy worldwide; in which you play as a deep-cover CIA agent Joseph Allen, as you join a group of Russian terrorists and proceed to massacre civilians at an airport. This is significantly different from any other such controversy because you are killing civilians that simply run away and scream; they don't fight back. However, it is worth noting that you do not have to kill anyone to pass the level. Infinity Ward even gave players full warning and options to skip the mission before it even begins. The player receives no penalty for skipping the level and there is no "score" calculated - as there usually is - for killing civilians or airport security; also, there are no achievements or trophies earned during this mission. As controversial as this mission is, the developers did just about everything they could to warn players about the content and to not glorify it or even force you to kill, while still keeping their integrity and the story intact. For that much we should respect their choice. Regardless, the game received much criticism and abuse in countries like the UK, US, Germany, Japan and Australia. Once again British MP Keith Vaz was at the forefront, he very outspoken against the video game and did so during a House of Commons debate. He was, however, suggested to be in collaboration with the Daily Mail (a less than reputable newspaper) for attempting to make moral panics of video games. A member of the British Muslim Forum even came forth and likened the game to the work of Joseph Goebbels. The criticism thrown at this game came from a vast number of sources and was immense. Even though this is indeed an incredibly controversial level to put into a game I can't help but think that the game is for 18 year ol's and up, who should understand the medium and that the game is like any movie, book or TV show with controversial content. A game is simply a story created by others in which we play a small role of interactivity and in the case of the 'No Russian' level the interactivity was optional. I do understand the outcry toward this game but with people like Keith Vaz who need only a tiny push to start a mass criticism of the medium as a whole, it becomes hard to sympathize with the claims.

1. Manhunt Murder

Back in 2003 Rockstar Games released Manhunt, a super-gory action game that caused huge amounts of controversy worldwide and is my number 1 most hated game by politicians and or the media. In Leicestershire, England a teenager named Stefan Pakeerah was murdered by his friend,Warren LeBlanc, and because LeBlanc owned the game, Manhunt became the primary cause for this young man to turn on his friend. Pakeerah's parents were adamant that Manhunt was a major influence in their sons murder and continuously linked the game to the tragedy. Officials from both the BBFC and ELSPA emerged and said the game had absolutely no effect on LeBlanc and being only 17 at the time he shouldn't even have been in possession of the game. Despite this the game was pulled from shelves throughout the UK and Europe. US Attorney Jack Thompson was hired by Pakeerah's family to attempt to sue Sony and Rockstar. Thompson, who is outspoken about video game violence, claimed he had wrote Rockstar a letter at the time of the games release and told them to take it off shelves as it would only encourage copycat murders. Eventually it was revealed that the copy of Manhunt in question was found in Pakeerah's possession and not that of LeBlanc. Leicestershire Police confirmed that there had been no connection between the game and murder. As Manhunt 2 was announced 3 years later the controversy started again and both the Pakeerah family and Thompson stated the game had played a role in Stefan's murder and that they would attempt to get the game banned; they failed to do so. To this day Manhunt and the murder case is used by politicians to try and lay claim to the negative effects of video games. This is easily one of the most controversial and spotlighted video game debacles of all time. Despite officials from the BBFC, ELSPA and Police reports proving no correlation between the game and the murder, Jack Thompson refused to admit it and fought the case for quite some time. As tragic as the entire ordeal was there was no sense in blaming a video game that obviously played no role. In turn it created more hype for Manhunt that it would have generated on its own. Manhunt was a very controversial game that, to this day, is still a topic of debate and never managed to separate itself from the controversy, which is why it gets the number 1 spot. What other games have politicians and the media singled out? Do you think the claims they throw at the games are justified? Or erroneous? Let us know what you think in the comments below!