7 Worst Uses Of Video Game Plot Armour
Headless? Just a flesh wound.
Deus Ex Machina, Script Immunity, Character Shield, there’s a few different names for this literary phenomenon, but the most colloquially accepted is that of The Plot Armour.
Appearing in works of fiction through the centuries, it is a trope of the main or narratively relevant characters in a story surviving seemingly insurmountable odds or dangerous situations because, well, the story wouldn’t be able to progress without them.
Creators always try their level best to balance peril with believability, but not all of these attempts come off as skilfully, as the sudden shattering of immersion that such contrivance brings out can often land the trope somewhere between the comically inept and the insultingly lazy
As an art form, video games are no exception. It can be prescribed to the protagonists to give them the edge, antagonists to magnify the challenge to overcome, or even just any old NPC, because the plot wouldn't be the same without them.
Love them or hate them, the games on this list surely are some of the worst when it comes to making their survivors the best.
7. Amanda De Santa - GTA V
A cynical or reactionary person might say that GTA is about killing people. Whilst the games, most notably their recent iterations, offer a whole slew of things to do beyond this, we do have to concede that there is a certain amount of validity in that slightly reductive observation.
With machine guns, flamethrowers, bazookas and tanks on offer, it has to be said that murder is a very easy option in GTA, so the developers naturally had to come up with a way to make sure you can’t accidentally obliterate a key character and soft-lock yourself out of the game.
A notable example of this would be Michael's wife Amanda from GTA 5.
Insulting, gold digging, drinking, stealing and a pretty heavy dose of infidelity are just some of the wonderful things that Amanda brings to her marriage with Michael, so when her character model appeared in front of the player's car it was barely a New York minute before players wanted to test her resilience.
Although dialogue makes it clear that Michael is not on board with this, it is completely possible to run down his infuriating wife and begin life as a bachelor. This single life is short lived however, as immediately after leaving the area you'll receive a furious text from your durable wife and a hospital bill for your trouble.
Whilst it's tempting to say that people survive car crashes all the time, this is a character who will survive car crashes all the time. Like it or not, you're stuck with her, so you'd better make sure your health insurance is all paid up.
6. Balthier - Final Fantasy XII
Plot armour is nothing new in the world of Final Fantasy. After all, we are talking about a franchise where you frequently pick a fight with literal Gods and only get knocked out for your troubles. Final Fantasy XII is no exception to this rule, and its the deliciously suave sky pirate Balthier who dons some narrative chainmail for this game’s final act.
A slight oddity in the Final Fantasy canon, FFXII both eschews the turn based battle system and unfolds the story from the perspective of Vaan, a character who has little bearing on the narrative other than being a member of the party set to save the world.
Charismatically professing his role as the leading man throughout, it’s Balthier who elects to stay behind to save his friend Fran when the Sky Fortress Bahamut plummets to its destruction in the finale.
Sure enough, a letter from the lovable rogue at the coronation of Princess Ashe during the ending cutscene confirms his daring escape from the jaws of death, and his friends fly through the skies to meet him.
Although not the first FF character to get away without a Phoenix Down in sight (more on that later), Balthier’s own proclamation that the main character can’t die seems so on the nose that his fate would surely be sealed. We’ll never know how he survived, but it could very well be out of sheer arrogance.
5. Liquid Snake - Metal Gear Solid
Despite the reverence with which it is held by many, the Metal Gear franchise is one which does occasionally fall victim to narrative tropes such as plot armour in amongst Hideo Kojima's trademark barminess.
With cyborg ninjas returning from the dead and stealth operatives taking down giant nuclear mechs, it’s a franchise which does have to take realistic odds and pop them to one side for a second, first witnessed by many in the seminal Metal Gear Solid.
Antagonist Liquid Snake is a tricky foe to take down. Flanked by super powered lieutenants like the iconic Psycho Mantis and Sniper Wolf, although Liquid himself is not super powered, his devious trickery ensures that he remains a step ahead of Solid Snake for the game’s duration. Throughout the game Liquid crashes his helicopter, takes multiple rockets to the face whilst piloting Metal Gear REX and remains in the cockpit as the giant mech explodes with enough force to launch Solid across the arena.
Not willing to go down just yet, Liquid still has enough pep for a fist fight above REX, and a jeep crash for good measure, before his time is cut short by the narratively important FOXDIE virus.
Plot armour is always a useful tool when you’re in a pinch, helping you brush off the sort of injuries which would rip even your super powered cronies to pieces. Do be careful though. Just because you haven’t died now, doesn’t mean you won’t die later... and come back as somebody's sentient robot arm in the follow up - because Kojima.
4. Wild Dog - Time Crisis
Not exactly known for its rich and deep lore, the Time Crisis light gun games are nevertheless ones with an overarching storyline and one mad as a sack of frogs mercenary causing all kinds of mischief: Wild Dog.
Originally seen kidnapping the President’s daughter in the original game, Wild Dog has been a consistent antagonist across the whole franchise. Appearing in every game, this sunglass and trench coat model is determined to see his plans through despite being shot in the chest and blown up, crashing his helicopter and initiating a self destruct device on THREE SEPARATE OCCASIONS.
Whilst his first apparent death did indeed rob him of his left arm, being replaced with an increasingly souped up mechanical version, there really does seem to be nothing keeping this dog down. The lore itself has even started to indicate that this formerly straight laced franchise has taken on a theistic route, and that Wild Dog is escaping from the gates of Hell itself.
Whichever way you cut it, science has thus far been unable to explain this manic merc’s uncanny ability to cheat death at every turn. Whether its a deal with the devil or just a running gag, you can be sure that he’ll keep coming back as long as the plot demands it.
3. Ada Wong - Resident Evil 2
A recurring mystery in the Resident Evil franchise, across her numerous appearance in the games secret agent/corporate spy/love interest/grapple gun wielding badass Ada Wong has made a name for herself through both her self serving determination and near omniscient ability to be in the wrong place at the right time.
Fans were first introduced to Ada in Resident Evil 2, where she forms a partnership with Leon S. Kennedy by posing as an FBI agent investigating the Umbrella Corporation. As the game progresses this backstory is proven to be a ruse, and Ada reveals she is actually working for a rival organisation looking to steal Umbrella's G-Virus. Depending on which character the player chooses first, Leon's storyline plays out in two different ways, with Ada either getting shot and falling to her 'death' or being crushed against a wall by hulking fedora enthusiast Mr X and bleeding to 'death' in Leon's arms.
We present both those mortal options with a heavy pinch of salt however, as later in the game, during Leon's encounter with the aforementioned Mr X, Ava reappears from the shadows and gifts Leon the rocket launcher he needs to put down his pale-faced stalker for good.
Characters often like to make a re-appearance across the Resident Evil franchise, owing to their virus imbued regenerative abilities, but this anti-heroine manages to return to the party plenty of times without such luxuries. Maybe it is plot armour keeping her going, but then again, she is doing everything these other characters are doing whilst wearing high heels, so maybe she is just that damn good.
2. William 'BJ' Blazkowicz - Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus
Cool guys walk away from explosions, that's a given, but how many do you know that can walk away from being beheaded?
Set in an alternate timeline which saw The Nazis as the victors in World War II, Wolfenstein and its sequels tell the story of William 'BJ Blazkowicz, an American spy waging a one man war against the totalitarian forces which threaten to rule the world.
After the finale of the previous game, where Blaskowicz is caught in an explosion after killing recurring antagonist Wilhelm "Deathshead" Strasse, The New Colossus sees the protagonist wake from a five month coma and begin the task of liberating Nazi occupied America. Naturally a task of this magnitude is going to come with some setbacks, but I don't think anybody was expecting this hard as nails main man to have his head chopped off halfway through the game.
Not wanting their hero to die, Blaskowicz's team of rebels manage to recover his head and surgically attach it to a bio-engineered Nazi super soldier body. The phrase 'bio-engineered Nazi super soldier body' is mad enough, before you even consider the scientific side-stepping it takes to present this as a viable option. For all his weapons, skills and mountains of muscles, Blaskowicz is ultimately human, and decapitation for even the most resilient of specimens usually has a strong ring of finality to it.
Does this conform to any laws of biology in the real world? Absolutely not. Are we inclined to care when the mayhem gets to continue? Not even slightly.
1. Squall Leonhart - Final Fantasy VIII
Here it is, the plot armour so thick its lead to an entire section of the gaming community swearing blind that it can’t be true. Squall Leonheart, protagonist of Final Fantasy VIII, is dead.
Let’s rewind a little bit. The moody middle child of the PS1's Final Fantasy output, FFVIII holds a special place in many fans’ hearts for its rich character development and challenging yet rewarding Junction system. Following Squall and his fellow SeeD cadets, members of an elite military force for hire, the game sees the party squaring off against the time bending sorceress Ultimecia. Following a failed attempt to assassinate their foe, the young protagonist is stabbed with a high speed shard of ice, the force knocking him back to fall to his apparent doom.
Then he’s…fine.
The cinematic really hammers home that this magical assault on Squall is a big deal, with love interest Rinoa looking on tearfully as he plummets, the ice shard still embedded in his chest.
Squall’s progress from mortal wound to irksome imprisonment is so convenient that fans speculate he did not in fact survive, and that the fantastical back half of the game, combined with perceived hints in dream sequences, are evidence of a dying fever dream.
Alas, Square Enix confirmed that the shard did actually pierce Squall's shoulder, and the rest of the game is in fact real. Whilst it's tempting to believe the hype, we do all just have to sigh in bitter disappointment, as it turns out this shoulder was indeed wearing plot armour several inches thick.