8 Cancelled Video Game Movies That Would Have Changed Everything

It's a shame Hollywood pressed reset on this bunch.

By Mark Langshaw /

There will be a lot riding on Alicia Vikander's shoulders when Tomb Raider plunders its way into cinemas next year with decades of bad video game adaptations behind it.

Advertisement

There are good reasons why movies based on console titles come with a stigma attached and Lara Croft is the latest icon of the medium to try and challenge the world's preconceptions about such projects.

The road from home computing to the big screen is paved with cowpats. Regardless of whether the film is question is based on a game as simple as Double Dragon, or as sophisticated as World of Warcraft, they always seem to underwhelm for one reason or another, some more spectacularly than others.

Super Mario Bros became the first mainstream blockbuster based on a video game when it arrived in cinemas in 1993, bearing little resemblance to any of the plumber's platform outings, and it's been mostly downhill from there, the cheap, schlocky thrills of the Resident Evil sequels notwithstanding.

The video game adaptation is waiting for that one film to come along and finally get it right. That could change everything, and it might have already happened if one of these had actually made it in front of the cameras...

8. BioShock

It's easy to see why Universal thought BioShock would make a great movie. With its layered plot, striking visuals and underwater dystopian setting, it would have been quiet the spectacle on the big screen.

Advertisement

The studio enlisted the services of Pirates of the Caribbean director Gore Verbinski to bring the world of Rapture to Hollywood, a feat he aimed to pull off with the help of rich CGI environments and a hard R rating.

Verbinski's BioShock would have challenged several preconceptions about video game adaptations with its mature themes, intellectual subject matter and stylish visuals - providing the CG was up to scratch - but it wasn't to be.

The project stalled when Universal expressed concerns about its budget. The studio's top brass were reluctant to throw big bucks behind an R-rated video game adaptation, believing it was too big of a risk.

Verbinski later dropped out of the director's chair and was replaced by 28 Weeks Later filmmaker Juan Carlos Fresnadillo, with a view to staying on as producer, but it wasn't long before the movie sunk into the depths.

Universal has long since washed its hands of the adaptation, and although this version of the project is dead, Verbinski said during a recent Reddit AmA session that the success of the R-rated Deadpool would have made his original BioShock vision possible to achieve today.

7. Castlevania

Konami's vampire hunt-em-up Castlevania recently found success as an animated TV series, but there were plans to turn it into a movie in the mid-2000s with some big names attached.

Advertisement

Paul W.S. Anderson was keen to adapt the series as horror-action hybrid steeped in Dracula lore that fleshed out the vampire's long-running rivalry with the Belmont clan. Based on his handling of the Resident Evil and Mortal Kombat licenses, this version of the film would probably have been high on adrenaline, but light on substance.

Only when Anderson vacated the director's chair did the project become promising. The Conjuring director James Wan was selected as his replacement, with Anderson staying on as producer, and that sounds a lot more like it.

With Wan at the helm, Castlevania could have been a survival-horror video game adaption that was actually scary. Not only that, if the movie delved into the origins of Dracula's conflict with the Belmont family, it could have had some depth to it too.

Location scouting took place around Hungary and Romania, and a screenplay underwent numerous rewrites, but the last status update came way back in 2009, so it's safe to say Castlevania's coffin is firmly nailed shut.

6. Halo

Microsoft really wanted to make a Halo movie back in 2005, and if it had been successful, the world could have had Avatar four years early, with more guns and explosions and fewer blue things running around.

Advertisement

The Xbox platform holder was deadly serious about bringing Master Chief to the big screen and it was aggressive in its efforts to partner with a studio to make it happen.

After most of the major players dropped out due to the Big M's hefty financial demands, Fox and Universal partnered on the project, Peter Jackson was tapped as producer and Neill Blomkamp signed on to direct.

If ever there was a video game adaptation with the potential to change the medium's fortunes on the big screen, Halo was it. With its cinematic flare, epic set pieces and fleshed-out lore, the Bungie-developed shooter was an epic blockbuster waiting to happen - so what went wrong?

Microsoft is what went wrong. The computing giant was incapable of speaking the Hollywood lingo from day one and financial disagreements with the studios and creative bickering with Blomkamp and Jackson eventually derailed the adaptation.

That was in the mid-2000s, and the closest thing the fans have had to a Halo movie since is the 2012 live-action miniseries Halo 4: Forward Unto Dawn.

5. Metroid

Nintendo's attempts to break into Hollywood with Super Mario Bros was always going to end in disaster. The concept of two plumbers who battle a dragon in a kingdom of mushrooms was never going to lend itself well to cinematic adaptation, especially with a Briton and a Latino playing the two Italian-American leads.

Advertisement

The property the Big N should have used to enter the movie industry was Metroid, which has always been as ripe for adaptation as Halo, and it almost saw the logic in this in 2004.

Face/Off director John Woo acquired the screen rights to Metroid that year and began plotting how to bring Samus Aran to the big screen with the folks at Nintendo.

But the gaming giant was cautious after Super Mario Bros Bob-ombed at the box office, and didn't want to see another of its properties suffer the same fate. Creative differences between Woo and Nintendo were reported at the time, with the two parties unable to agree on how Samus should be portrayed outside of the action scenes.

With a director of Woo's pedigree at the helm, Metroid would have delivered hard-hitting action sequences and a strong female protagonist who doesn't rely on cheap titillation to turn a profit at the box office.

There were few official updates after Woo was reported to have landed the rights and Samus's Hollywood career quietly died a slow death behind the scenes.

4. Gears Of War

New Line Cinema saw the potential in an adaptation of Epic Games' bombastic shooter Gears of War in 2007, so the studio secured the services of Underworld director Len Wiseman to turn it into a $150 million movie.

Advertisement

Wiseman's Gears of War was billed as a prequel to the original game and it would have revealed how protagonist Marcus Fenix earned his trademark scar.

The filmmaker's wife Kate Beckinsale was rumoured to be on board in a prominent role, which would have added some girl power to the mix, a refreshing change from the testosterone-soaked carnage of the games.

With that hefty budget and star power behind it, Gears of War could have served as a fantastic companion piece to the series, with suitably explosive action set pieces and an R rating, but it started burning up on entry when New Line cut the budget.

The studio whittled development costs down to $100 million and now a had a more intimate story in the vein of Cloverfield in mind. The new direction and slashed funds clearly didn't sit well with Wiseman, who exited the project shortly after that.

3. The Last Of Us

The Last of Us has all the makings of a successful blockbuster movie: love, family, survival in the face of a zombie-like apocalypse and a gritty, near future backdrop that would have looked fantastic on the big screen.

Advertisement

At one point, Naughty Dog's mooted cinematic adaptation sounded like a dead cert, with a table reading of the script having taken place, but the latest status update suggests it's undead in the water.

From the sound of things, no progress has been made in more than two and a half years. The Last of Us game director Neil Druckmann told IGN back in 2016...

"I know I said in an interview a while back we had a table read, got the script to a good place and it kind of entered development hell like these things tend to do. There hasn’t been any work done on it in over a year and a half."

It's a shame The Last of Us doesn't sound like it will make it to cinema anytime soon. Anything with even a passing resemblance to a zombie epidemic is always a winner on the big screen, but the game has heart, soul and substance too.

At least its upcoming sequel, The Last of Us: Part 2, is shaping up to be as cinematic as any blockbuster movie.

2. God Of War

A movie based on Sony's ultra-bloody God of War series came close to happening in 2009 when Brett Ratner signed up to direct and a screenplay based on the first game landed on Universal's doorstep.

Advertisement

Kratos's adventures in Ancient Greece would lend themselves perfectly to the big screen, playing out like a gritty, unrelenting version of Clash of the Titans, except with more decapitations and disembowelling.

At Universal, it was all quiet on the God of War front for a while, but the project gained momentum a few years later when Marcus Dunstan and Patrick Melton were hired to rework the script.

The duo's revised script was said to be a prequel to the first game, following the adventures of a more human Kratos in the days before he became enthralled to Ares. This was the last official status update on the project and Ratner quietly made for the exit shortly afterwards.

Interestingly, subsequent games have explored some of the elements that were touted for the movie. God of War: Ascension served as a prequel to the mainline series and the upcoming PS4 instalment will introduce players to a more human Kratos.

Looks like the world doesn't need that movie after all.

1. Monkey Island

The Secret of Monkey Island is the point-and-click masterpiece that convinced the world video games can be funny, feature fleshed-out protagonists and storylines to rival any book, film or radio drama.

Advertisement

Reliable sources - one being voice actor Dominic Armato - have confirmed that a movie based on Guybrush Threepwood's swashbuckling adventures was proposed at one point during the series' heyday.

Information about what form the Monkey Island movie might have taken has trickled through over the years, with some reports suggesting it would have been animated, and more outlandish ones linking Steven Spielberg to it.

Word has it that Pirates of the Caribbean writer Ted Elliott was tapped to pen a screenplay for the film, which would explain why there are so many similarities between The Curse of the Black Pearl and the original game.

With the series' developer LucasArts having been shuttered, the Monkey Island series' future in the gaming sector is uncertain, but the movie is deader than the Ghost Pirate LeChuck, which is a shame because it had at least as much potential on the big screen as Pirates of the Caribbean.

Advertisement