8 Disastrous Failures That Killed The Xbox One

A woeful tale of self-sabotage.

By Joe Pring /

With the Xbox One continuing to suffer from a distinct lack of exclusives and the console itself steadily pushing five years of age, Microsoft has a tough but crucial decision to make.

Advertisement

Does it attempt to make amends for a so-far lacklustre generation by doling out a handful of excellent exclusives as a last hurrah or cut its losses, resign the Xbox One and its numerous iterations to life support and focus all of its efforts on ensuring history doesn't repeat itself for whatever the future holds?

For now, we're to assume that Microsoft's current platform will be the recipient of all its attention going forward, but is there much point? At present, its main competitor is too far ahead with a slew of attractive exclusives and a strong start for there to be any hope of a comeback.

Not that stiff competition has been the only deciding factor in the Xbox One's downfall. Much of its woes stem from a result of Microsoft's poor decision making throughout the console's lifetime, with cancellations and studio closures aplenty.

A fresh start is what the brand desperately needs - just as PlayStation did, following the disastrous PS3 - to get back on track. A blank slate where it won't be constantly reminded of the failures that led to the Xbox One's slow and steady decline.

8. The Cluttered UI

Formed of a mesh of variably-sized panels, the Xbox One's dashboard has always felt less like a simple, accessible front-end serving as a gateway for its user's needs and more like a busy storefront populated with bright colours and attention-grabbing images - all splayed out on one cluttered screen vying for your attention. It's a visual noise that could be better filled with more relevant information.

Advertisement

The PlayStation 4 by no means provides a perfect alternative, by the way, but it's clean, uncluttered and navigable without first having to Google an answer for how to access any particular feature.

Adverts, deals, promotions; these things all exist on Sony's platform too, but they're either tucked away in the segregated storefront or kept hidden from view, ready and waiting to show themselves only to users actively looking for relevant details.

Simplicity, to an extent, is key for a frustration-free experience, something Microsoft seemingly forgot in its quest to make the Xbox One's UI look like a digital catalogue.

7. Microsoft's Overconfidence

Sony had every right to gloat in 2013. The PlayStation 2, then (and still) the best-selling console of all time, had secured its place at the tippy top of the popularity pyramid.

Advertisement

In that climate, the PlayStation 3 was primed to be a guaranteed success, but Sony made the fatal mistake of taking the win for granted. The Xbox 360 arrived out of left field and knocked Sony for six, quickly establishing itself as the de facto multi-platform device due to its easy to handle architecture that didn't give developers nightmares at the prospect of making games for the platform.

Sony took its beating in the following years like a champ, content to retreat and lick its wounds after having the gall to charge $499 for the PS3's entry model, eager to come back fighting in 2013 with an apology in the form of the PlayStation 4.

Inevitably, history repeated itself once more in 2013, only this time it was Microsoft that had taken its past success and customers for granted. It too will need to pull off a similar turnaround if it wishes to win back the dissenters.

6. The Competition

Horizon Zero Dawn, NieR: Automata, Nioh, God of War, Spider-Man, The Last of Us Part II, Uncharted 4: the list of exclusives released and still to come for PS4 continues to accentuate the discrepancy in first-party content between itself and Xbox One, to the extent that Microsoft, at this stage in the game, has no chance of catching up.

Advertisement

Even if the console's proposed 2018 lineup (namely Crackdown 3, State of Decay 2 and maybe Ori's sequel) make it in time for 2018, PS4 will still have it beat, and these are all sequels, i.e. unlikely to expand Xbox's audience.

The One X has helped Microsoft to claw its way back somewhat as the undisputed best platform for non-exclusive content, but the Pro doesn't lag far enough behind to justify the former's price point.

No, what Microsoft needs is to ramp up its first-party output but sadly, it appears to be too little too late. With a new hardware generation creeping ever closer, Microsoft seems, at least from the outside looking in, content to leave the One on life support in order to refocus its efforts on adequately supporting its next console.

The most logical choice - and the saddest.

5. Self-Destructive Decisions

Scalebound, Fable Legends and Lionhead Studios itself: there's no guarantee that, had any one of those assets been propped up by Microsoft that they would have ultimately been successful, but they could have been, and that's the important distinction to remember.

Advertisement

Fable Legends, for example, had every chance of being a surprise hit, but even so, why didn't Microsoft opt to pursue the safe route and commission Fable 4? Former Lionhead employees have revealed since the studio's closure that nobody wanted to make Legends, but Microsoft's desire to tap into the 'games as a service' model meant that the treasured UK-based studio was forced into taking a risk that ultimately led to its demise.

Then there was Scalebound. Microsoft canned the project due to Platinum Games' unsatisfactory progress at a time when exclusives on Xbox One were (and continue to be) lacking. Microsoft promised a slew of great titles to come as a means of softening the blow and yet, here we are, one year later, still waiting on Crackdown 3 and State of Decay 2 to arrive.

Please, Microsoft, think before you leap.

4. The Disastrous Reveal

What did you expect when Phil Spencer's predecessor enthusiastically bounded on stage at E3 in 2013 to announce Microsoft's newest addition to the family? The ultimate media device? A thoroughbred games console that elevated the power of the 360 to a whole new level? Free Xbox Ones for the masses?

Advertisement

Okay, so that last one would have been a bit of a stretch even for lifelong optimists, but nobody could have foreseen what Don Mattrick had in store for audiences on that fateful day.

Once the glitz and glamour of its sleek announcement trailer had abated, all it took for excitement to take a long walk off a short cliff was Mattrick's long-winded explanation of how the Xbox One wasn't just a games console, but a self-policing plastic box. One with the inbuilt power to punish users who didn't adhere to its creator's self-prescribed rulebook on used games and DRM.

Just like that, the hype declined rapidly and even after a total U-turn, the stigma never truly went away. Turns out consumers don't particularly enjoy being roadblocked by anti-consumer policies. Shocker.

3. Kinect's 'Integral' Nature

An easy to overlook segment of Microsoft's initial Xbox One reveal for obvious reasons, Kinect was originally trumpeted as an essential peripheral for the 360's successor, so much so that all launch stock of the console would come bundled with the voice and motion-activated camera and a hefty price tag to boot.

Advertisement

PR talk that we'd later discover to be utter tripe.

By the middle of 2014, Microsoft, still desperately trying to recover from the original, anti-consumer vision it had for the Xbox One, announced that the Kinect would be decoupled from the Xbox One as a mandatory inclusion. You could still use the Kinect for navigation and for games that supported its use, of course, but the announcement put an end to any potential future Kinect may have had.

That reality was set in stone earlier this year when Microsoft confirmed that its Kinect adapter, the only way to connect the ill-fated peripheral to the Xbox One S and X, was being discontinued for good.

Next time a gimmick gains traction, don't lie through your teeth and tell us to invest in short-lived, expensive hardware, okay, Microsoft? Cheers.

2. The Slow Turnover Of First-Party Exclusives...

Halo and Gears of War: Microsoft's two biggest franchises were nowhere to be seen at the dawn of the eighth console generation. It took 343 Industries and The Coalition two and three years respectively to get sequels for both series' in a retail-ready state for Xbox One, not the best result for a console that was, at that point, struggling to provide a reason for its existence.

Advertisement

Good quality, triple-A games take time to make, of course, and we'd all rather wait a little longer if it means a better end product, but why didn't Microsoft have the foresight to get the ball rolling before rushing the One to retail?

Sony similarly struggled to launch the PS4 with any meaningful exclusives (remember Knack?), but its situation has gone from strength to strength ever since.

Since 2017, the only exclusives worth mentioning that have made it to launch are Forza 7, Halo Wars 2, Cuphead and Sea of Thieves and even then, in the latter's case, its final form has left much to be desired...

1. ...And The Undercooked Results

Having been put to task on churning out Kinect games for several years on the trot, Microsoft finally gave Rare the chance to remind us why its name has been held in such high regard since the '90s.

Advertisement

Sea of Thieves, following numerous delays and uncertainty, finally made its maiden voyage just last week, granting fans access to a gorgeous, very Rareesque adventure and, most importantly, a brand new, exclusive IP for Xbox One.

The swashbuckling adventure looks fantastic, feels great to play and earns top honours as the perfect party game for a group of friends to devour, but is there enough here to satisfy the three-year wait from announcement to release? Sadly, that's a no.

For all its quirks and aforementioned positive qualities, Sea of Thieves can't possibly expect to be deemed anything other than an undercooked, highly-stylized pirate sim brimming with untapped potential. A couple years from now, with several content updates under its belt, sure, it could evolve to become a positive footnote for an otherwise lacklustre platform, but as of right now, a few free sessions courtesy of Xbox Game Pass is all it's really worth.

Sea of Thieves needed more time in the oven. It's just a shame that, given its current situation, Microsoft can't afford that luxury.

Advertisement