8 Video Game Rip-Offs Better Than The Original

Often imitated, occasionally duplicated.

By Benjamin Richardson /

The video game clone wars have been going on as long as the industry has existed. No sooner was Pong gobbling quarters in bars across America than Atari was batting back a whole slew of suspiciously similar television tennis sims, the inevitable money-chasing volleys to their lucrative serve. Eventually, the market became so over-saturated with home Pong-likes that the bottom fell out entirely, resulting in the lesser known crash of 1977.

Advertisement

Every manufacturer wanted a piece of the disgusting sounding Pong pie, but consumers weren't prepared to pay for the same game over and over again. It wasn't until Space Invaders - the first truly fresh idea in six years - that the video game industry kickstarted back into life.

On the whole then, and with apologies to Dolly the sheep, clones are a bad thing - but not always. Did you know, for example, that Pong itself was a clone? And by clone, we mean outright rip-off. Who knows where the game industry would be without it though? Maybe Magnavox would have been the Atari of their day, before Ralph Baer let success get to his head, tanked the company, and opened a chain of (literally) cheesy theme restaurants.

Even before VHS recorders were a thing, Pong broke the rule that copies are inferior. Its highly successful form of flattery has been imitated repeatedly throughout gaming history - and occasionally, duplicated.

8. Angry Birds (Crush The Castle)

Angry Birds, Finland's greatest export since Jean Sibelius, Nokia, and the sauna, had at least one Flash developer steaming, so suspiciously similar was it to one of their browser games.

Advertisement

In Armor's trebuchet-em-up Crush the Castle, the player launches projectiles from a ballista on the left of the screen at a ramshackle tower on the right, with the aim of squashing the knights stationed within. If that sounds a lot like Angry Birds, albeit with a medieval spin, it's because it's the same. Released just eight months later, Rovio's fowl-flinging mobile hit recreated Crush the Castle's gameplay almost one-for-one - up to and including the projectile variants - only swapping incendiaries for incensed chickens, and soldiers for egg-swindling swine. Thieving pigs!

It's as blatant a knock-off as they come, but Angry Birds' infinitely more appealing characters and accessible mobile format made it a superior - and incredibly successful - one. No doubt Armor had some angry words about Angry Birds.

7. Golden Axe Warrior (The Legend Of Zelda)

Golden Axe, ordinarily a side-scrolling hack'n'slash, basically a tunic-clad, sword-swinging version of Streets of Rage (with little imps you can boot up the arse), went in something of a dramatic new direction in 1991 with the release of Golden Axe Warrior.

Advertisement

The top-down action-RPG, released only for the Master System, sees a teensy hero with a sword and cross-emblazoned shield conquer nine labyrinths across a tiled map, before ridding the land - let's call it, er, 'Fyrule' - of the evil Death Adder. Along the way, he picks up various items that allow him to slowly unpick the secrets of the world.

No, we didn't just badly describe The Legend of Zelda. Right down to the hearts and currency stabbed out of little slimes and evil pigmen, this is a pixelated parrot of Shigeru Miyamoto's Famicom classic. It's hard to copy Nintendo's homework and not earn top marks though, and even if Golden Axe Warrior is wholly unoriginal, the estimable technical prowess of Sega's hardware means it's arguably less gruelling to play than the Famicom forebear. The Bootlegend of Zelda's music is also, dare we say it, better.

6. The Great Giana Sisters (Super Mario Bros.)

Time Warp Productions' obvious Super Mario Bros. pastiche, The Great Giana Sisters, promoted equality in more ways than just its gender-swapped protagonists; though 'better than' perhaps stretches it a bit, the German platformer was just about as good as its Nintendo influence.

Advertisement

At least, it was for European computer owners of the late '80s aching to adventure in the Mushroom Kingdom. With a port of the console-shifting Mario Bros. to the likes of the Commodore 64 and Atari ST entirely off the cards, The Great Giana Sisters aimed to give joystick wagglers the next best thing. As its impudent boxart made clear ("The brothers are history!"), this was more parody than plagiarism - even if the similarities are a little on the nose.

Too on the nose, in fact, for Nintendo, who impelled Time Warp to withdraw copies from the shops lest they pursue legal action. They certainly had a case to answer: though the title deviates from its influence as it goes on, its opening stage is a tongue-in-cheek reproduction of Mario Bros.' 1-1. The Great Giana Sisters' production was promptly halted before it turned into a more expensive sequel: The Great Giana Cease and Desisters.

5. Pong (Table Tennis)

In the broadest sense, Pong, the game which launched the commercial coin-op video game industry, is a superior version of the actual game of ping-pong, in that it's neither extremely exhausting nor does it necessitate running across a sports hall/working men's club to retrieve an errant ball. Curiously though, the Atari megahit isn't actually a rip-off of this table-bound sport (the game's name comes from the signature sound of hitting the ball). Rather, the concept was 'inspired' - that is to say, stolen - from a pioneering video game it just about beat to the market: Ralph Baer's Table Tennis.

Advertisement

Baer, a German engineer whose family had escaped to America at the outset of the Holocaust, first began exploring the possibility of a television game when working for Loral Electronics in 1951. The company weren't interested, but over the next decade he persisted, until one prototype caught the eye of electronics manufacturer Magnavox. The company joined forces with Baer to produce the world's first video game console: the Magnavox Odyssey.

To sell this new technology to hesitant stockists, Baer and his team demonstrated it at trade shows across America. Of the attendees was one Nolan Bushnell, the founder of Atari, who just so happened to trial the Odyssey's Table Tennis game. Within a month, Pong was born, and so too was the commercial video game business. It was no coincidence.

4. Arkanoid (Breakout)

Shortly after the plagiarised Pong's release - and apparently failing to see the irony - Atari began developing a series of games expanding upon its basic premise in a bid to bat back the slew of clones it had spawned. The man at the helm of the Ralph Baer heist, Nolan Bushnell, was determined to refocus Pong as a single-player game, on the assumption that halving the player requirements could double the cabinet profits. The block-hitting result, Breakout, turned out to be a blockbuster hit.

Advertisement

Inevitably, its own derivatives soon followed, but it'd take some twelve years for one to surpass it, rather than merely simulate it. In many ways, Taito's Arkanoid, released 1986, was gaming's first 'HD remaster'. Sure, the basic concept was practically identical to Breakout - smashing bricks with a ball - but it was presented with hypnotic speed and colour, and now featured power-ups, multiple stages, and - yes! - even lasers! In fact, so definitive was the game, that all block-breakers would henceforth be known as Arkanoid clones.

3. Streets Of Rage (Final Fight)

Gamers separated from 2020's streets of plague have instead been nostalgically wallowing in 2020's Streets of Rage, a long-overdue fourth installment of the series just as good - better, even - than the early-'90s urban brawlers it lovingly recreates. The modern homage is somewhat meta, considering SEGA's original Streets of Rage was in itself a back-alley knock-off of another inner-city puncher, Final Fight.

Advertisement

After SEGA's hardware got the jump on Nintendo, the technically superior Mega Drive quickly earned a reputation as the home of near-perfect arcade conversions. All that changed when, shortly following the 1990 launch of the Super Famicom, Nintendo announced they'd secured the rights to bring Capcom's coin-up smash Final Fight to their system.

Mega Drive owners were crestfallen - but not for long. Rather than submit, SEGA entered a street fight with Nintendo, developing their own version of the game. Released 1991, Bare Knuckle - known as Streets of Rage in the west - was basically Final Fight in a very flimsy disguise; even the protagonist Axel wore the same outfit as rival Cody.

But beyond the immediate similarities, it was so much more than a copy. Streets of Rage couldn't boast the oversized sprites of Capcom's beat-em up, but it made up for them with a super-cool neo-Tokyo aesthetic, underpinned by Yuzo Koshiro's legendary house-trance soundtrack. Attacks were more varied thanks to the slightly ridiculous vault attack, though that was not half as ridiculous as the fantastic, screen-busting special moves that'd see a hail of fire engulf your enemies.

By the time Final Fight was finally ported to SEGA's MegaCD, nobody cared; the sequel to its clone, Streets of Rage 2, had already beat it out the park. Heck, out the city.

2. Minecraft (Infiniminer)

The roaring, almost inexplicable success of Minecraft over the past decade has spawned dozens of inferior derivatives, each looking to tap the popularity vein of Notch's industry-altering classic. It's somewhat ironic then, particularly for a game whose core premise is unearthing the player's imagination, that Minecraft is a wholly original concept.

Advertisement

In 2009, an incrementally released open-source sandbox game, in which the player gathered resources from a procedurally-generated, voxel-styled world, began to earn something of an internet following. No, not Minecraft, but Zach Barth's Infiniminer. Amongst the message board fans of the game was Swedish coder Markus Persson, who began designing his own version shortly after designer Barth discontinued the project.

The result of this mimecraft was Minecraft. Though you have to feel a little sorry for Barth, forever relegated to an intriguing footnote in video game history, it's hard to argue that Notch's continuation isn't vastly superior to its inspiration. Minecraft effectively completed the abandoned foundation Infiniminer had built, and across ten years has been refined into material of much higher quality.

1. Guitar Hero (GuitarFreaks)

2005's Guitar Hero made bedroom Mark Knopflers of us all, allowing even the most untalented and tuneless to become a rock and roll god. Its deceptively simple rhythm action gameplay and novelty guitar-shaped controller invited practically everybody to give it a jam, making Harmonix' melody maker an instant hit. A slew of sequels, expanding into all manner of instruments and ensembles, soon followed.

Advertisement

This was old news in Japan, where arcade-goers had already been thrashing fake guitars for six years. Konami's 1999 title GuitarFreaks isn't just spookily similar to Guitar Hero, featuring both a scrolling fretboard and plastic axe, but was the direct inspiration for Harmonix' hit. The echoes were such that the two companies ended up in court together in 2010, only for the case to be dismissed.

As anyone with a wider appreciation of the music biz knows, many chart-toppers are unbeknownst cover versions. Like Girls Just Wanna Have Fun and Natalie Imbruglia's Torn, Guitar Hero was no different; it might have played from Konami's tab sheet, but it did so with the sort of mainstream appeal that made it an overnight sensation.

Advertisement