8 Video Game Stories That Waited Years To Be Resolved
Imagine waiting 18 years to find out what happens next.
A great ending can really propel a game from a level of mediocrity upwards. Those final moments are the payoff that can make anything worthwhile, rewarding you for your time and showing you that it was all investing in.
We want to be killing the bad guy and rescuing our princess, not seeing a black screen after a big reveal. Ultimately, us players just want a little bit of closure and a warm, satisfying feeling in our belly as the credits roll. Sure, leave the story open-ended if you must, maybe a little teaser after the credits but no one wants a decade long cliffhanger.
We’re looking at you, Valve.
This list will focus on those rare games that did, after all those years, resolve their stories, and they don’t have to be massive cliffhangers, either. A loose thread, a character arc, a suspected death or in some cases, actually giving us the next part of the story you chopped off the end of the last game.
Some sequels may never release but while we wait, we’re here to look at the games that took years to resolve their story.
8. Halo 2 - Finishing The Fight
Halo 2 is a weird one in regards to unresolved endings because ultimately, it wasn't the original plan.
There wasn’t supposed to be a cliffhanger at the end of the game but due to time constraints, it had to happen. Developers of the sequel have stated that its release came down to the wire and that extra few weeks of polish the previous game received just wasn’t there. They had lines recorded, assets ready but they couldn’t implement a final mission or proper send-off which matched the ending and tone of Halo 2.
Players were all ready to head to Earth, to finish the fight and kick some ass. But then, the game just ended.
Fans had to wait three years and leap into the next generation of consoles, from original Xbox to Xbox 360, before they could regroup with Master Chief and the Arbiter.
What’s worse is that wasn’t the last time Halo hit us with a cliffhanger, with Halo 5 leaving a pretty big plot point open between Cortana and her newfound AI.
7. Assassin’s Creed - Who Does Lucy Really Work For?
Like Halo, Assassin’s Creed is no stranger to cliffhangers. Twist endings and confusing characters, from historical fiction to sci-fi settings, all the way to weird alien-like entities - the series is full of complications and reveals. In fact, all of these elements led us through a three-game story arc back in 2010.
This arc focused on Lucy Stillman, a double agent, informant-type who worked alongside Abstergo, Desmond, The Assassins and The Templars.
Throughout the original game we are led to believe that Lucy is held against her will, like Desmond. She claims she was saved by lead scientist, Warren and although held captive, tries to convince Desmond of his sincerity. Leaving hints and clues, eventually gaining Desmond's trust, the game ends on an abrupt note.
Released two years later, Assassin's Creed 2 continues the modern day side of things. Now on the run with The Assassins, we see more hints to Lucy's real motivation. This time, however, they point to Lucy working behind The Assassins' back, as she leaves updates for Warren, the aforementioned scientist, a Templar working under Abstergo. However, not much more is shown, leaving fans to wait for Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood's release.
A year later, taking three years and two games in total, we see the conclusion to Lucy's story. As Desmond grabs the piece of Eden at the end of Brotherhood, he is possessed by Juno, a deity. She reveals Lucy's true identity to Desmond and motivates him to kill her.
After three long years, the sub-plot was concluded.
6. Shenmue 2 - That Damn Cliffhanger
Shenmue is an interesting game, to say the least. The gameplay is weak, held up by combat that has been changed significantly for the latest instalment. Players roam through a calm, plodding world, interacting with citizens in an attempt to find the man who killed the protagonist’s father. Regardless of any shortcomings, the game’s cult following has clung to this narrative, curious of where it will go and how it will conclude.
Well, after 18 years between Shenmue 2 and 3, a rough ride from Kickstarter to a place in the Epic Store, fans got the next part of the story. Chasing chickens, searching cupboards, interacting with wooden, unresponsive characters, it was just like being a kid again. Generally seen as more of the same, the sticking point of Shenmue 3’s release was that, after almost 20 years, it ended on a damn cliffhanger yet again.
This one’s a double-bill, then. Not only did Shenmue fans wait nearly two decades for a sequel, they’ll be waiting once again to get the story’s conclusion. Damn you, Lan Di.
5. Devil May Cry - Nero's Heritage
Just like Metal Gear Solid, Devil May Cry is a long running, complicated series involving numerous complex characters. Starting in 2001, Devil May Cry generally followed the life of Dante, until 2008. With the release of Devil May Cry 4, players also took control of Nero.
Nero brought a new style of play to the game through his augmented arm, the Devil Bringer. In gameplay, this arm offered many different abilities and attacking potential, offering a combat style vastly different to Dante's.
The reason for the Devil Bringer's relevance is because, at the start of Devil May Cry 5, released in 2019, it is ripped from Nero's body. After utterly destroying the arm, the assailant leaves, their identity still unknown.
A huge plot device for the Devil May Cry series has always been bloodlines. Whether it was through manga, films or even a play, fans were always asking for more lore.
Now, the 20 long year stage had been set. Nero was a fan favourite, well integrated with the series, particularly alongside Dante. After the removal of Nero's arm, the big reveal is that the mysterious attacker, Vergil, known antagonist and Dante's brother, is none other than Nero's father. This addition to the family tree took nearly two decades.
Truly a shocker to fans considering the resemblance of the three.
4. Metal Gear Solid - Psycho Mantis' Backstory
The Metal Gear Solid franchise is about as confusing as they come. The creative vision of Hideo Kojima spans through numerous decades. To help matters, the games didn't release via in-game historical order, either. For example, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom pain, takes place in 1984, whereas Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots, takes place in 2014.
Regardless of chronology, there are some Metal Gear Solid characters players simply can't get enough of. The one we're interested in is Psycho Mantis. That's right, the same guy who read your save files in Metal Gear Solid, which took place in 2005.
Throughout these games, be it through lore entries or other exposition, Psycho Mantis' history is referred to. It's stated he was born in 1970, as a child soldier who was also taken in and out of different testing facilities.
In The Phantom Pain we finally get to witness a younger Psycho Mantis, looking to be aged around 14. His plane crashes on the way to a lab, with him being the only survivor. He then latches onto The Burning Man's vengeful thoughts, helping him pursue Venom Snake.
It can all be very confusing but the general idea is, Metal Gear Solid is all over the place. But the fact we got to see a Psycho Mantis' origin was well worth the wait.
3. Half-Life 2
Major spoilers for Half-Life: Alyx ahead.
In 2007, Half-Life 2, Episode 2 was released and ended with Gordon Freeman escorting Alyx Vance to the White Forest to meet her father. She spoke of unforeseen consequences which we assumed were the events that proceeded, Eli Vance’s death.
Now, 17 years later, with the release of Half-Life: Alyx, we actually get some kind of closure in relation to Episode 2’s infamous ending. Though, it’s fair to say it doesn’t resolve it entirely. It adds more plot, more questions and more mystery to the G-Man.
After releasing the G-Man from the Combine’s prison, thinking she was rescuing Gordon Freeman, Alyx Vance is confronted with the G-Man's powers. She is shown her father’s eventual death which occurs five years later and given the opportunity to stop it entirely.
In saving the future version of her father she has now unintentionally put herself up for hire by the G-Man in the same way Gordon Freeman did at the end of the original Half-Life. Gordon is free, Eli Vance is alive and in the present timeline of Episode 2, Alyx has been taken and put into stasis. Not exactly a resolution but most definitely a change of events. A development fans have yearned for over 15 years.
2. The Last Of Us - Does Ellie Accept Joel's Lie?
The Last Of Us is our
honourable mention of the list. Its ending, as talked about in my 10 Things You Didn’t Know About The Last Of
Us list, had seen some revisions. First, game director Neil Druckmann
wanted us to square off against Tess. Then he wanted a happy ending for Joel
and Ellie. In the end, though, he settled on an open-ended lie that could leave fans pondering the game's closing moments. As of right now, though, we still don’t have an answer as to where
that lie puts both Joel and Ellie.
There’s been plenty of teaser content released for The Last Of Us Part 2. Cut-scenes and gameplay we don’t particularly know the context or timeline of, as well as characters whose motives are unclear. What fans do want to know is the health of Joel and Ellie’s relationship, and if that will last throughout the course of the game.
Did Ellie truly find out that Joel lied to her, did she know and simply come to terms with it, and has that made her bitter towards Joel as she grew up? It’s not resolved yet but once the game drops, we will finally find out.
1. Red Dead Redemption - John's Scars And Dutch's Gang
The gigantic, blockbuster endeavour that is Red Dead Redemption 2 is littered with plenty of information relating to the previous game. For example, there are awesome little easter eggs referring to the 'Strange Man' that John encounters in the original Red Dead Redemption.
What we're interested in, however, is the loose end that Red Dead Redemption left dangling. Throughout the whole game we gaze at John Marston's face, which features a deep looking scar on his face. So deep that it's actually stopped hair from growing. During the course of the game we get no hint or inkling as to the origin of these scars.
In the very opening of Red Dead Redemption 2, however, we get our answer.
John wanders off into the snow and is found on the edge of a cliff. He's mangled, bloodied, cold and now, scarred. Though, it's revealed that he wasn't mauled by a big old grizzly bear. Instead, he gained his facial scars by fighting off a pack of wolves.
I mean, that sounds pretty cool to me but apparently his friends didn't agree and felt John would need to come up with a more exciting story.