8 Video Games Where The True Ending Is The Bad Ending

All that extra time for nothing?

By Jules Gill /

As with movies and other popular media, the ending of a project is just about the most important piece of the puzzle.

Advertisement

Without a solid closer, you'll leave audiences with a negative perception of the product which will likely cascade into other problems they found along the way. Stick the landing and send the fans home happy and you'll likely receive positive word of mouth, but if you stink up the place then even a 90% decent run could end in a skip fire.

And part of keeping the audience happy is most definitely by ending things on a positive note, to make them feel emotionally satisfied and look onwards to a brighter tomorrow. Therefore it's rather strange to find examples of devs who, for some reason or another, absolutely love making their downer or "bad" endings canon parts of the story. Characters remain dead, hope remains on the brink of being extinguished and ruined picnics seem to be the order of the day.

Cheery stuff right? Well at least for many examples on this list they lead to wild and wonderful sequels and successor franchises so maybe these were happy days in disguise!

8. Castlevania : Dawn Of Sorrow

So we start this list with a bit of a strange example, as technically both the "Bad" and the "Ultra Good" endings of Castlevania: Dawn Of Sorrow allows the player to unlock a brand new mode that carries on the story of our ill-fated protagonist Soma, however the fact that both points converge on this canon post-credits scene does strangely qualify for this list.

Advertisement

And if you don't like that justification just ask yourself this "are you really going to stop me from bringing more attention to this often overlooked area of the Castlevania franchise?"

Thought not.

So let's pick things up at the end of the game where, UH OH looks like you done made a whoopsie and forgot to equip a special amulet before fighting the final boss and now you're Dracula! Gosh, dangit! However, fret not my fanged friends because Julius Belmont is here to help with your situation in the brand new "Julius Mode" which sees you play through the entire game again with different a moveset and enemy placements with the goal of tearing your spirit from this mortal form.

Delicate he is not it seems.

Still what you do get is a rather heartfelt conclusion to the story, a wonderful new challenge, and an ending in which it's both good AND bad, which is just the sort of batshit experience you expect from a Castlevania game.

7. Drakenguard AND Neir

To call the Drakenguard and Neir franchises "a bit odd" would be like saying that morphine is a "bit stronger than a kiss on your boo-boo" aka a monstrous understatement, as both series were helmed by Yoko Taro, a director so utterly off the wall that I bet he eats his soup with a printed paper image of a fork.

Advertisement

Yet nothing is as downright insane as the bizarre connection between the two games, which was established through the original Drakengards "Ending E". To try and explain what's going on up to this point would likely see my brain unravel like toilet paper and then attempt to s**t itself, but in the most basic terms, a giant evil has been summoned and our heroes are having none of it. However, in a manner that can only be termed "oh ok then" the battle between Good and Evil sees all parties transported through time and space to Tokyo in the year 2003.

As the group battle it finally seems that Good has come out on top, yet before any celebrations and libations can take place, the heroes are shot out of the sky by a fighter jet and killed.

Hold your head shakes as it's about to double. For you see as the giant evil collapses and turns to ash, the inhalation of which allows people to use actual magic, but at the cost of nearly everyone dying or turning evil, which is the exact world we find ourselves in when the original Nier title took to the stage.

That's right, the worst ending of one game leads to an entire starting point for another franchise. Yoko Taro you've done it again, and by "it" I mean "broken my brain into a million pieces and then snorted the resulting dust up your nose".

6. Far Cry 5

While at present the Far Cry series might be in a state of diminishing critical returns, there once was a time when the franchise was pulling flips over an open-mouthed volcano and having the time of its life.

Advertisement

And alongside each main entry came a spin-off title that usually looked to add siracha to the vanilla experience. For Far Cry 5 that spin-off was Far Cry New Dawn, a game that set itself as a follow-up to the worst possible ending you could achieve in the prior game.

Here the player explores a world wracked by nuclear ruin, the cause of which was the player's previous inaction to stop cult leader Joseph Seed. By allowing Seed to walk free by ignoring certain prompts early in Far Cry 5 we allow the cult to launch nuclear devices in their effort to "restart" the world.

Far Cry New Dawn even follows up with our previous character The Deputy as here he's known as The Judge a follower of Seed's teachings, making it not just an entire game based on a bad ending, but also an insight into the fall from grace our action, or inaction lead to.

5. XCOM: Enemy Unknown

I know I've said it a thousand times before, but here's another shout-out for those in the back:

Advertisement

I LOVE THE XCOM FRANCHISE.

And one thing I adore even more than the brutally challenging gameplay and rewarding strategic micro-management is that the devs aren't shy when it comes to messing with fans in the best ways possible.

Take for example, how the team decided on the narrative threads for smash hit sequel XCOM 2, as here instead of telling the tale of humanity on the brink of survival, this time around humanity had already fallen. Hard.

This decision was made thanks to game data gathered from XCOM: Enemy Unknown, which showcased a pitiful amount of players had actually won the war against the aliens.

So the team figuratively must have looked at each other, shrugged, and then said "Fine then, here's the world you couldn't be bothered to save. ENJOY!" and forged ahead by setting XCOM 2 in the worst ending timeline.

Here humanity were bootlickers to the alien races who'd claimed our planet as their own and in a way, Firaxis were pointing and nudging this scenario while saying "See that, XCOM players? That's you, that is."

4. Max Payne 2

Poor old Max Payne. The guy really can't catch a break, can he?

Advertisement

His family is murdered by drug addicts, his life is broken apart by crime families, and he can't even get to enjoy his "power look" aka tropical shirt and bald dome without some cheeky whippets trying to photobomb his holiday snaps by shooting him in the gut every five minutes.

Adding to the pile of misery that is his life is the death of Mona Sax, another soul on a quest for revenge that ends, as most things do when in the company of Max in a world of Payne. Her final moments see her unable to kill Max thanks to the growing chemistry between the pair, and she's shot for her inability to get the job done, as she bleeds out Max kisses her and the audience wept at the death of this rather brilliantly written character.

However, hope remained, as complete Max Payne 2 on the hardest setting "Dead on Arrival", and you unlock an ending in which Mona lived, after likely hours of perseverance.

Unfortunately, the ending wasn't the truth as it turned out this much more upbeat ending wasn't canon, meaning players were forced back into the bleak reality of her death once Max Payne 3 fired up years later.

3. Metro 2033

If you ever cast an irradiated eye over the likes of Fallout and felt that its more comedic tones and over-the-top characters and weapons were a little too silly, then fret not my picky friend because the Metro games are most definitely for you.

Advertisement

Where Fallout embraced an idealized version of the American dream gone very wrong, Metro clung on to enough grit and grime as to make you want a shower shortly after each play session, and let me tell you it didn't mess around with the choices it presented to players across Metro 2033's runtime.

At the very end of the game, the player is evaluated based on how good or bad their karma was and presented with different endings, either showing you sparing or destroying the race of Dark Ones entirely.

Now you'd think that the ending where you spare this misunderstood race and enter into an uneasy alliance would be the canon ending right? As while it moves the narrative endgame towards a corner it still allows wiggle room for conflicts and misunderstandings in a potential sequel, but unfortunately Last Light decided to go in completely the opposite direction by having the game set a year after you chose to blow the Dark Ones to kingdom come.

The devs even went so far as to make numerous references to how terrible a decision it was, and the protagonist also makes reference to how he's not sure it was the right idea.

Buddy, listen for a second, we DIDN'T TELL YOU TO DO THAT. You've made a whole "whoops" situation all on your own pal, we're not picking up this cheque!

2. Mass Effect 3

Now you might be looking at this entry and thinking to yourselves, "pretty sure that the Mass Effect canon definitely reads 'And the crew had a lovely time and shared space biscuits over some galactic hot chocolate' so stop talking out of your ass-teroid belt pal"

Advertisement

And you'd be entirely right, the franchise does accept the canon good ending of "human saves everyone and feels very smug about it", HOWEVER you have to bear in mind that when Mass Effect 3 came out the ending pissed everyone off.

Around the world voices cried out over unresolved plot points; of how the destruction of the relays basically doomed everyone to live in isolation, and how food sources for entire species would be unobtainable - so much so that the developers had to rectify this with a monstrous Extended Cut add-on, which fleshed out missing story elements.

They had in (mass) effect given us the bad ending, and until that DLC was released, it was most definitely the only true one. Thankfully the Legendary Edition kept these fixes and newcomers will never experience the salty rage we early adopters had to suffer through.

1. Koudelka

Koudelka is one of those games that's so brilliantly weird that I'm astounded it didn't get more interest in the years following its release.

Advertisement

While it might not have set the survival horror world on fire with obvious cribbing from the likes of Resident Evil, its battle system, off-the-rails storyline, and of course its "hey do you like discount voice acting because I've got a SALE ON BROTHER!" make it a curio well worth exploring.

It's also bizarrely connected to another cult classic RPG series in the form of Shadow Hearts! And how are the titles connected I hear you ask? Well they are linked by the player sucking and failing at their one task in Koudelka of course!

To better explain, across Koudelka you'll come to know the tale of Partrick and Elaine, lovers who were torn apart when Elaine was murdered after thieves broke into their home.

Now I can't even begin to imagine the pain Patrick felt after losing his partner, but his decision to try and resurrect her using forbidden magic "Pet Cemetary" style was questionable at best. This allowed monsters to infect the mansion which the game is set in and ultimately tasks the player with putting Elaine to rest permanantly.

Yet if you manage to get the "bad" ending of the game, you'll see the heroes defeated while Elaine ascends to the heavens above in a new form, which Shadow Hearts picks up from and uses to establish why magic and monsters are now more prevalent in their world.

It's a neat setup if nothing else, and arguably we got a better game out of a canon "bad" ending than Koudelka ever was!

Advertisement