9 Most Discussed Video Game Plot Holes That Will Never Be Answered
Would you kindly... explain how you're apparently only one year old?
Creating a video game story is hard. Not only are developers given the gargantuan task of coming up with a compelling narrative that needs to last potentially tens of hours, but they also have to make sure that it complements and supports the ideas found in gameplay, too.
Because when these elements don't mesh, you get strange inconsistencies. For instance, almost all zombie games rely on the idea that when people are bitten in cutscenes they become infected, but this becomes a plot hole when the player can take bite after bite during gameplay without it ever being a problem.
Some plot holes are more pressing than inconsistencies between a title's story and gameplay however, and even the most critically acclaimed narratives in games have gaping holes and/or leaps in logic that fans have been discussing for years. Even though developers would like players to get over them, fans continue to attempt to fill in the gaps and explain away the story problems of their favourite games.
Still, with no official explanation ever coming, players are starting to accept that these often-discussed plot holes may never be solved.
9. Makarov Being A Celebrity-Level Terrorist Ruins Modern Warfare 2's 'No Russian' Plan
One of the most controversial levels ever made, at first glance the premise of the 'No Russian' mission in Modern Warfare 2 seems to make sense.
The idea is that you're playing as an undercover American agent working with a gang of international terrorists, about to conduct a mass shooting in a Russian airport. After the massacre it's revealed that the terrorists knew about your cover the whole time, and they leave you for dead at the scene of the crime, sparking a war between Russia and America in the process.
The problem is however, despite the only confirmed culprit being an American agent and the terrorists purposefully not speaking Russian to hide their nationalities ('No Russian', indeed), their identities should have been easy to suss out...
Why? Because the team is led by Makarov, one of the most wanted men in the world in MW2's story. His existence and his appearance is common knowledge - not least to the international units who are dedicated to taking him down.
Even in the unlikely event that nobody caught a glimpse of him (after all, he's not wearing any sort of mask during the mission), then surely someone would check to see if he was involved, rather than immediately jumping straight into an unnecessary war?
8. Jack Marston Growing Into A Badass In Three Years
Red Dead Redemption has one of the most memorable endings ever, with hero John Marston being gunned down on his own land by the Sheriff's posse who hired him at the start of the game.
But that's not technically the end of Rockstar's Wild West tale, as the title continues after this 'final' scene. Picking up later as an older version of John's son, Jack, the real final mission has players tracking down the people responsible for his father's death to enact some sweet, sweet revenge.
The problem is that it's never explained how Jack transformed from a sheltered kid into a revolver-wielding badass in the space of merely three years.
Likewise, although Rockstar obviously didn't want to leave players without the ability to continue exploring their open world, it doesn't make sense to have Jack suddenly follow in his father's footsteps and become a bloodthirsty killer. The entire point of the game was about John getting away from that life, so it doesn't ring true when his son makes the same mistakes.
7.
6. Elena Magically Stumbling Across Drake In Uncharted 4
Elena and Drake's romantic relationship has been the emotional backbone of the entire Uncharted series, so it made sense for Naughty Dog to put the couple through the wringer for Drake's final adventure.
The two seemingly break up halfway through the game when Elena finds out that her husband has been lying about his extra-curricular activities, but inevitably returns to his side later to help nurse a wounded Drake back to health.
It's a great moment in the game's story, but it's probably one of the most implausible parts of a game about Indiana Jones-type heroes searching for hidden pirate treasure.
Because when Elena stumbles across Drake, he's actually lost in the middle of a jungle that hasn't been explored in centuries. Even with help from Sully, there's no way that she could have found him this easily. Even the enemies who were hot on his tail didn't know where he was.
The game attempts to wave this away by saying that Elena followed the sounds of gunfire, but it's a flimsy excuse to justify this huge leap in logic.
5. Why Doesn't Miles Just Leave The Asylum In Outlast?
The original Outlast tells the story of Miles, a journalist investigating shady activities happening at the fictional Mount Massive Asylum. Although he was tipped off by a whistleblower, nothing could have prepared him for the horrific nightmare waiting for him inside the walls of the asylum, and Miles quickly finds himself trapped and surrounded by psychopaths trying to kill him.
It's a solid set up, but the game doesn't do a good enough job of making Miles' situation feel inescapable. While the main doors and the outside gates are locked, there's nothing stopping the reporter from, you know, leaving through a window like the one he used to enter the asylum in the first place.
Video games have always had a problem with artificially creating barriers for the player (just think about how many times you haven't been able to jump over a knee-high bit of rubble), but it becomes a major problem in Outlast where most of the horror relies on this botched logic.
4. Ethan's Convenient Blackouts In Heavy Rain
Like all good crime stories, Heavy Rain keeps the identity of its Origami Killer a secret right until the very end, spending the rest of the game dropping hints and red herrings to make sure players don't figure out the twist too early.
Unfortunately, that means that a lot of the logic surrounding these red herrings doesn't make sense when you actually know who the killer is.
But the most egregious attempt to trick the player is easily the convenient plot device that sees one of the suspects, Ethan, blackout at the same time the Origami Killer strikes. Waking up later with incriminating evidence on his person, these sections set Ethan up as a murderer who isn't in control of his own actions.
Obviously the character isn't revealed as the killer in the end, and while the blackouts themselves are easily explained as being caused by stress, it's never revealed why they always happened around the time of a crime, or why Ethan always woke up covered in incriminating evidence.
4. Resident Evil 4's Saddler Says He Wanted You To Escape... After Repeatedly Trying To Kill You
The entire plot of Resident Evil 4 focuses on Leon Kennedy's attempt to rescue Ashley, the President's daughter, who's been kidnapped by a Las Plagas-worshipping cult.
Players go through hell and back throughout the game to save Ashley, facing off against angry villagers, skewering a giant mutated fish and surviving constant traps laid by the game's main boss, Saddler.
Which makes it all the more ridiculous when you find out that Saddler's master plan the whole time wasn't to kill Leon at all, but to have him actually rescue the infected Ashley and take her back to the USA, where she would pass the infection on to the President and hopefully the entire population.
It's a fine plan, but it's one that would have only made sense if Saddler hadn't been trying to kill Leon for the entire game.
3. Bioshock's Jack Surviving Away From Rapture Despite Only Being A Year Old
The Bioshock series is known for its mind-blowing twists, but the problem with a lot of them is that if you think for more than a few minutes on these otherwise 'mind-blowing' revelations, they tend to fall apart.
As such, the twist that comes in the final moments of the original Bioshock is no different. The title's final act reveals that the character you've been playing as the whole time was actually a test tube baby, 'aged up' artificially to have the body of a healthy grown man, despite only technically being alive for one year.
The thing is though, in between his 'birth' in Rapture and his return a few years later, Jack apparently lived a seemingly normal life above the surface of the water. It makes sense that he wouldn't know about his real home, as the scientists who made him also gave him false memories - but it's hard to imagine that the same people had the time to teach this one year old how to do his taxes or accomplish any of mundane tasks that he'd need to live peacefully outside of Rapture.
2. Mass Effect 3's Backwards Final Choice
There's a lot that's been said about the ending of Mass Effect 3, but it's biggest plot hole was that the final 'good' or 'bad' choice went against the rules the game had previously established.
Throughout the whole trilogy, blue choices signified the good Paragon decisions while red choices were indicators of evil Renegade options. To support this good/evil dynamic the game builds Captain Anderson up as essentially Commander Shepard's Obi-Wan, a wise military veteran who leads him towards the noble choices in the series. On the other hand the Illusive Man acts as the devil on Shepard's shoulder, luring the player over to the dark side.
The third game throws these ideas out the window in its final moments, instead using Anderson to represent the 'bad' red choice of destroying the Reapers, while linking the Illusive Man to the 'good' blue path of controlling them.
It only added to the confusion of the scene, and made gamers wonder whether the choice was actually real or just part of the Reaper's indoctrination.
1. Crysis 2 Forgets What The First Game Established About Nuclear Weapons
As far as video game stories go, the Crysis trilogy isn't exactly rubbing shoulders with the likes of Uncharted or Bioshock.
The franchise as a whole has plenty of plot holes and inconsistencies, but the most head-scratching moment comes in the second game, when the military decides to drop a nuke on New York City in an attempt to stop an alien invasion happening.
It's a solution that's in line with Crysis' '80s action movie inspirations, but it only works on the assumption that the military has forgotten everything it learned over the course of the first game. The original Crysis also saw a nuclear bomb being used to eradicate the alien threat, only back then it was revealed that the energy from the explosion actually made the enemies stronger, rather than doing them any harm.
Why the military would try the same thing again in the second game then, is anyone's guess.