9 Most Overdone Clichés In Modern Video Games

Yup, it's another skeleton with an audio diary.

By Scott Tailford /

Bethesda

Play enough video games over time, and you'll start to notice the sharing of ideas. Influence taken, inspiration given, design philosophies, bankable mechanics, character archetypes - there's a ton of crossover with other entertainment mediums, but often when something takes off, the competition will directly ape it for a few years after.

Advertisement

Obviously this is how we get trends, but stay too long in that mindset and you've become a cliché; a tired trope the audience has seen way too much of, that simply needs to change or be eliminated altogether.

Gauging the lifespan of these things is incredibly hard, and when the turnaround on your average big budget title is 3-5 years, it's easy for "brand new games" to be full of outdated concepts.

Advertisement

9. The Mysterious Overturned Cart

CD Projekt RED

Witcher 3 definitely set this back in motion in 2015, and was rightfully praised for getting it right.

Advertisement

Since then however, many IPs distil this setup down to its barest steps. "Find overturned cart or vehicle, push button to inspect, track down NPC that didn't want to be found, reveal truth". Assassin's Creed Origins and Odyssey are stuffed full of these, and even Ghost of Tsushima fell prey to it a few times too.

Red Dead Redemption 2, Fallout 76, Kingdom Come: Deliverance - when the content itself isn't very rewarding, an arbitrary overturned cart feels like a dialogue interaction with extra steps.

Advertisement

8. The Two Types Of Climbing Sections

Naughty Dog

Type 1: Everything Collapses

Advertisement

This came directly from the Uncharted book of action adventure, where if you're climbing any section of handholds, let's say one in three will collapse. Cue you falling back down to climb up again, or dangling off what remains as you push a button or complete a quick-time event to regain composure.

Type 2: Follow A Weirdly Neat Sequence Of Handholds

Advertisement

This seems to be a way to add a baseline mechanical variety to what you're doing, but it's in the most plain way possible. Horizon Zero Dawn, Ghost of Tsushima, Far Cry, God of War - all give you specific highlighted paths of perfectly placed handholds to simply pilot your protagonist up or down.

God of War eventually narrativised this in a pretty genius fashion by tying it to Kratos' wife knowing where he'd go the whole time, but many other titles have pathways that feel too "gamey" and immersion-breaking.

Advertisement

The last big game to revolutionise climbing and do it right was Breath of the Wild, before that was Grow Home and before that was the original Assassin's Creed, where buttons were assigned to your head, arms and legs. This latter system went nowhere because we all just held sprint and the "leg" button to auto-climb, but clearly so much more could be done if developers took verticality seriously.

7. Difficulty Through Numbers, Not Skill

Ubisoft

It's hard to pin down precisely when this went mainstream, but every time a game's challenge is predicated on making you grind out some levels and numbers rather than actually get better at timing or combat mechanics, that's the issue.

Advertisement

We're talking areas of an open-world gated by one-hit kill enemies, a boss that flattens you because their "level" is more than five above yours, even though all they're doing is jabbing you with a dagger. Ostensibly, it's the sort of game design MMORPGs focus on balancing out for months or years' worth of play, condensed and crowbarred into a triple-A action title.

Why? Often, it's to alleviate the grind with microtransactions or pre-order stat boosts.

Advertisement

As I write this, Marvel's Avengers is another. A game where you're only as powerful as whatever statistic is on your current piece of loot; only as effective as whatever canned animation you can trigger over and over, and if you can't hit hard enough, the only recourse is to grind until your number is higher.

Contrast this with games where you actually get better as a player - Ghost of Tsushima, Sekiro, Breath of the Wild. Those that hide their numbers altogether feel far more natural and rewarding to play.

Advertisement

6. Following A Character While A Location Is Under Siege

Sucker Punch

As a quick aside, what is it about "tailing sections" in games, that developers are convinced we care about?

Advertisement

Even the mighty, damn-near perfect Ghost of Tsushima gives you a couple of tailing missions across its runtime, though more to the point, it opens with a "village under siege", and you going place to place in the background.

It's this latter setup that is SO overdone. Seriously, how many times have we had to "wait for a patrol to pass", only to crouch-walk over to another piece of cover, wait for a couple of guards having an unrelated conversation to finish, so we can walk forward again. There's always some innocent bystander being killed but you can't help them, often a main villain JUST out of reach because you need to wait until later.

Advertisement

These sections never get held up as memorable (they're easily the worst parts of Tsushima), and I'm yet to meet anybody who actually enjoys them.

5. The Late-Game 5-Step Fetch Quest

Kojima Productions

Seen in Mass Effect 3, Anthem, Death Stranding, Fallout 4, Dead Rising 2 and scores of other titles, this trope is best exemplified by The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker.

Advertisement

There, as the game was drawing to a close, Nintendo had you embark on a fetch quest that repeated eight times. Asking you to chase down separate Tri-Force shards, each required an interaction with character Tingle, and a price tag to reveal their location. You'd then have to journey out to a spot in the ocean and retrieve the shard, before repeating the process through to completion.

It ground the game to a halt, and was so hated by the fandom that Nintendo - very much known for doing their own thing at all times - dropped this requirement down to three Shards for the Wii U re-release.

Advertisement

Regardless, there's nothing worse than what is essentially a playable roadblock gating access to a finale you've been working towards, and it breaks all sense of pacing in the process.

4. The "Skeleton With The Audio Diary"

Private Division

First done as "skeleton with a diary" in the Elder Scrolls games, once Bioshock injected narrative by way of audio diaries, that has become THE way to do "environmental storytelling".

Advertisement

Audio diaries are a great way to highlight a wider character pool for any title, but having it so every character spills out the relevant information to your quest as their final words? That's the trope we're seeing left, right and centre.

The Last of Us 2, Assassin's Creed, Fallout 76, The Surge 2, Prey - even DOOM Eternal. What's worse is making you stand there, waiting for dialogue to finish, as chances are if you move forward some element of gameplay or a cutscene trigger will interrupt what's being said.

Advertisement

Obviously there are so many other ways to bolster your game's narrative or world, than forcing us to stop and take it in. Give us abandoned homesteads, clashes between NPCs, signature parts of the world itself or remnants of ancient battles. So many teams fall back on the "skeleton/audio diary" combo, rather than come up with anything original.

3. Need To Hide? Use The Tall Grass

Sony

I mentioned how much climbing as a game mechanic has been reduced to a set of handholds, but stealth? We now have an entire genre minimised to "hide in the tall grass".

Advertisement

Honestly, try and think of dedicated stealth games from the last few years.

You've got Hitman, A Plague Tale: Innocence, Mike Bithell's Volume... and that's about it. The vast majority of titles that used to champion this as a signature genre trait have minimised it entirely. Assassin's Creed and Metal Gear introduced more action to your characters' movesets, and the former in particular has gone all-out OTT carnage, with Odyssey and Valhalla seeing your "assassin" butcher entire armies of people with supernatural powers.

Advertisement

Stealth as a genre definitely had a boom across the 2000s following Metal Gear Solid, Splinter Cell and Hitman, but if you're going to include it in a game, don't just make it the most boilerplate version possible.

2. "A Huge Open World!" With Nothing To Do

Bioware

Anthem, Mass Effect Andromeda, Just Cause 3, Days Gone - all championed the idea of humungous, immersive or otherwise worthwhile open worlds... but forgot to give you anything memorable inside.

Advertisement

Anthem was every bit the product of its troubled development; a world raised and lowered to accommodate a flight mechanic the devs simply couldn't decide on until months before launch. Mass Effect Andromeda was the same - taking Dragon Age: Inquisition's "Hinterlands problem" and multiplying it across every planet.

Just Cause's notion of destruction itself being "the thing you do" worked best for the first couple of entries when Havok physics alone were noteworthy, but the franchise has struggled massively to offer anything else.

Advertisement

Games shouldn't just be open world for the sake of it. Titles like The Witcher 3, Breath of the Wild and Ghost of Tsushima fundamentally tie their character and story progressions to that of the world itself. Anything less, and we're verging on something included for the back of a box or advert, rather than necessity.

Here's the test of an open-world game:

Advertisement

If, once you've unlocked the ability to fast travel, it comes as a relief - something you do to get to "the real game" and bypass the world - then that game has failed as an open-world experience.

1. Moving Slowly Through Crevices To Hide Load Times

Crystal Dynamics

Hopefully, if we all gather in a praying circle and will this into being real hard, the next generation should solve this trope.

Advertisement

Done out of the need to mask load times, over the years we've seen different studios tackle the issue in different ways. Gears of War giving you those slow-moving conversation sections? Kinda genius, because they became iconic, and you had no idea the game was frantically queueing up another set of enemies.

Horizon Zero Dawn only loads whatever your camera is pointed at, and God of War - besides one part where you awkwardly crouch-walk through a portion of Hel - hides its loads by locking you in a spiralling pathway until the next area is ready.

Advertisement

The majority of titles though, fall back on crevices and slow-moving "tight space" sections.

These things are EVERYWHERE, from Final Fantasy VII Remake to Gears 5, Star Wars: Jedi Fallen Order to Shadow of the Tomb Raider. They even popped up during Epic's Unreal Engine 5 tech demo, angering those who thought SSD technology might solve the issue.

Advertisement

Epic have since noted this was a way to show off next-gen texture work, but the fact that so many large games forgo load screens for something less potentially informative - and all-round more tedious - needs to be addressed.

Sure, something like a GTA or an Uncharted has one huge load at the start, but that's drastically more preferable than awkwardly shuffling forward every 20 minutes.

Advertisement