It's quite the bold statement to make, but video games have the potential to handle plot twists better than any other medium. Whereas in film or literature you're resigned to a passive position, watching events unfold without any interaction, when all is not what it seems in a video game it's you that's being deceived, backstabbed or taken for a ride. The best game developers know how to weaponise this feeling into a knockout punch, too, with things like the original Metal Gear Solid's 'Master Miller is Liquid Snake' reveal hitting far harder considering you'd been conversing with him the entire game. Others though... not so much. Choosing to inject a healthy dose of rug-pulling to your title of choice can be the reason it gets recommended so much in the first place, but when that goes wrong for reasons ranging from being unnecessary to just plainly bad thought-out, it forever remains a blotch on an otherwise fantastic game.
9. 400 Year-Old Ancient Spaniards Are Still Alive - Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
When it comes to high-falutin' archaeological exploits, you're either going to love a bit of the old 'and the ancient thing really did have power' sort of twist, or it's going to be a massive leap from an otherwise literally grounded setup. For all three Uncharted games, Naughty Dog have never managed to do this sort of thing justice, with the first and second games in particular having last minute reveals that were just cringeworthy in the grand scheme of things. Let's focus on the first game though, as at least by the time Among Thieves rolled around, you at least knew this sort of twist could happen. To that end, Drake's Fortune sees Nate investigating the history of Sir Francis Drake, only to discover the ancient sect of Descendants (long-dead Spanish villagers) are not only still capable of movement, but they're rampaging zombies with a taste for human flesh. How to fix it: Avoid the zombie fiction aspect entirely, and have the final showdown be between Nate and Navarro, but for the treasure they've been tracking for days at this point. In the end we get that fight regardless, so the Descendant battle is just tonally out of place, with the real conflict we always wanted being between these two characters. The problem as it stands is in the execution. We went from a massive buildup to whatever reveal was on the horizon, to a "Oh crap, ZOMBIES!" reaction, and then a supremely deflating 'fight for your life' series of encounters were you fought them in close-quarters. Alongside the random blue warrior-men from Uncharted 2, this remains one of the weirdest and most pointless parts of an otherwise stellar trilogy.
8. The Arkham Knight Is... Exactly Who You Thought - Batman: Arkham Knight
You've got to hand it to Rocksteady, they really went with the JJ Abrams/The Prestige-style notion of purposefully telling the fans bald-faced lies, all in service of a twist that should've been one for the ages. Sadly, the problem wasn't that we'd been lied to when it came to the AK very much being an established character and not a new one - it was that the dialogue was terribly written. Anyone with even a passing knowledge of Batman's former-Robin, Jason Todd/Red Hood, knows he's an angsty, shoegazing sort, and so when the very first thing he said was "Time to die, old man", who else was it going to be? Damien Wayne? From then on in, everything he said only furthered this idea, with the game randomly crowbarring-in a scene where Bruce remembers the character out of nowhere, ruining the reveal when the dots were connected in the most obvious way possible. How to fix it: Stick to it being an actual new character, with a final reveal steeped in fake-outs. If you've read Geoff Loeb's Hush, you'll be familiar with how that novel weaved various characters into the villain's true identity, explaining them away but still savouring the impact of each and every one. In an Arkham context we could've had Bruce hallucinate (thanks to Joker's blood still being in his blood from Arkham City) seeing Todd, Hush, Damien... pretty much anyone that would get a heart-stopping "No way!"-style reaction, only to reveal the true culprit in the end. Best of all? Mark Hamill's Joker could've just been a cameo, not the overstayed and overblown appearance he did make, which was just annoying and forced by game's end.
7. Shelby Is The Killer - Heavy Rain
So-close-it-hurts narrative 'genius' David Cage is a man of substantial hits and misses, but one of his most notable positives (besides the voice acting) was 2010's Heavy Rain, seeing four separate protagonists attempt to track down the Origami Killer; a maniac who drowns their victims in natural rainwater by trapping them in small places. It's a horrifying setup, but after you've been following the various characters track down the killer from all angles, you're set for a reveal that's going to thermonuclear detonate your socks into another orbit. Then... you find out one of the main heroes - Private Detective Scott Shelby - is the killer, despite it not making a lick of sense when you factor in how other playable father, Ethan, was experiencing flashbacks and sleepwalking to areas where the bodies were taken. How to fix it: We at least needed something involving Ethan's flashbacks, as having him sleepwalk out his house, lose his son in the process and wake up with an origami figure in his hand (something the killer left on his victims) made no sense in the grand scheme of things. It's clear that his plot was in service of making the character a massive red herring, but the best detective thrillers always have internal consistency. Even if Ethan was the brother of Shelby that we see him lose as a child, that spawns his hatred for... rainwater? Cage could've planted some hints that Ethan had repressed memories from surviving going under and trying to move on and live a normal life, before using that to reveal a totally new character as the real killer.
6. You Aren't Big Boss - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
Hideo Kojima was always going to have one hell of a time wrapping up the final Metal Gear Solid in a way that both delivered on fan expectation, netted him enough money to avoid being whipped by Konami's top brass, and left his own mark as a worthwhile entry in the series. As such, the game was meant to be a tribute to the fans in the most meta way possible, revealing that we were never actually playing as Big Boss, but a brainwashed medic who'd survived the former game's helicopter crash alongside him. Suddenly the game wasn't about discovering precisely how Big Boss could've gone from hero to villain, and more about forging his legacy across the Afghani and African wilderness. Personally I'm a huge fan, but general cultural reception has been supremely negative, and that's without mentioning that having this be the 'big reveal' completely side-steps a good three years-worth of marketing. How to fix it: This mainly boils down to making TPP into the game we were shown in the run-up to release, as a humungous amount of content and narrative was left on the cutting room floor. We were supposed to see Big Boss (the real one, in theory) breaking down in an African village as he lamented some event that drove him to near-madness. We saw him smear his fellow soldiers' ashes on his face and eventually 'go nuclear' by not giving a hoot he was soaked in blood - not exactly something that happens without ample reasoning. Kojima mentioned during development that he was working on a very delicate plot line that he would "have to get right". Now, get this; in the full game you can visit an area of Africa that looks like the aforementioned burned out village, complete with charred corpses of dead child soldiers. If you go with the assumption that in a scene that was never finalised, Boss involuntarily brought this about by accident, you've got one hell of a motive for a guy to really struggle living with himself afterwards.
5. Cortana Is... Super Evil Now?! - Halo 5: Guardians
MGS V wasn't the only game to completely drop the ball across 2015. Nope, Halo 5 also built its campaign around a particular event happening, and then shat the bed when it came to delivering on said event. Going in, we were supposed to find out what the Master Chief had done wrong to draw the ire of the UNSC and Commander Jameson Locke, who had vowed - for implied personal reasons - to bring in the Chief at all costs. Then you play through the campaign, and realise this wasn't the story at all. Chief and Locke rather quickly, ahem, 'Batman V Superman' it, which is to say they team up against another threat almost immediately. And that other threat? Why it's Cortana, who's revealed to not have died at all despite Halo 4 saying goodbye to the character, and is now some sort of supreme being that can access entire galaxy's worth of digital code in an instant. As you do. How to fix it: Stay true to the marketing materials. We were promised a showdown between Locke and Chief, and that should've come with a heady mix of expectation and reality. Why not go with the proviso that Chief had abandoned one of Locke's men (after all, you leave random wounded marines on the battlefield all the time), leading to him picking up his rifle and deciding to 'take the fight' to the one guy who's always causing carnage and leaving the rest of them to clean it up. Halo 4 touched on how the real world's media were portraying the Spartans as child experiments who just happened to find a purpose when the Covenant attacked, but as humanity rebuilds itself and looks into how the Chief operates, we could see a media campaign drum up quite the spin on how MC 'must be brought in' for continually reckless conduct. It could've been a massive comment on the effects of the media during war time, along with exploring what it means to 'do the right thing' when those goalposts are constantly shifting. Instead, it was none of the above, and just as its hammered home how much power Cortana has, as we're left with a cliffhanger ending that means you won't get to see more for another three years minimum.
4. You Must Kill Yourself To Save The Wasteland - Fallout 3
Everyone points to Mass Effect 3 as the 'one game' that really let down legions upon legions of fans, but like the wealth of bugs also present in Fallout 4 rarely being fully accounted for, Bethesda's past transgressions got swept under the carpet pretty fast too. Looking back, you'll note they actually tried to remove this rather substantial blotch on their record by patching in an alternate ending through paid-for DLC (how'd they get their good reputation again?), allowing the setup of "The radiation will kill you" to be passed over to a number of followers that could always survive such conditions regardless. How to fix it: Bethesda eventually did most of the work themselves, albeit in the most money-grubbing way possible. However, as the entirety of Fallout 3's gameplay is built around player progression and procedural unlocks/abilities, we should've had the ability to extend something like Rad Absorption to the point of withstanding the effects of the area for long enough to get the job done. A similar beat appears again near the close of Fallout 4, where - without delving into spoilers too much - you're tasked with hitting a button in amongst another area that'll kill you in seconds. You somehow pull through thanks to chewing on RadAway and other various meds as your life depends on it - alongside your own abilities - but the option was nowhere to be seen in the original Fallout 3.
3. The Internet Is A Person, Wants To Take Over The World - Fahrenheit/Indigo Prophecy
Oh boy, David Cage really can't stick his landings, as was evident in this inaugural title that started out as one man committing a murder whilst sleepwalking, and spiralled into some sort of world-saving, "You're the one" cavalcade of barmy dialogue and aerial kung fu. Yes, really. The stupidest part - and that's saying a lot - came near the close of the game, when it was revealed the Internet (like, the actual internet) had become so powerful, it had spawned a slew of sentient life forms that were threatening to take over the world, leaving you to defend it... or something. How to fix it: Lock David Cage in a cupboard until he finishes a script without being baked off his face. There's absolutely no way the entire team over at Quantic Dream were behind this idea, and literally anything would've been preferable to this hokum. In seriousness, the plot went out the window as soon as we saw Lucas dodging bullets and leaping entire bridges in a single bound, but it could have been salvaged if they pulled a "It was all in his head" reveal, keeping their ancient Mayan cults and whatnot, laying out the rest of the tale as some new-age revivalist order trying to fulfil the titular Indigo prophecy. But no... the internet is real, guys. Time to punch it in the face to save your girlfriend, because video games.
Coming off the back of AC II, Assassin's Creed could do no wrong. The pacing of the game's sci-fi twist on real-world history was impeccable back then, and the second game had even ended on a supremely brilliant twist, breaking the fourth wall to address Desmond (and in turn, the player) by having the Goddess Minerva talk to him directly. For Brotherhood, we were expecting an expansion of this ideology, as both past and future were now intertwined - surely, the next step would be to set an AC game in the modern day, or at least address the fact that genuine Gods were now convening with us? Nope, Ubisoft decided to interject some sort of rivalry between these higher powers, making one of them really evil before forcing Desmond to kill Lucy through mind-control. How to fix it: Lose the 'argumentative Gods' stuff and actually go with the plan initially envisioned for the franchise, transporting it to the present day and framing Desmond as the time-taught Assassin he was always supposed to be. It's telling that AC creator Patrice Desilets left Ubisoft after this game, as this is presumably where Ubi's higher-ups stepped in and went "Oh... you were thinking of wrapping this up? We'll see about that." Brotherhood marked the high-point for gameplay and general quality of the experience for Assassin's Creed, but it would also be the first to really lose the purpose of the modern day story altogether.
1. The Crucible Is A Child A.I. With A 'Reset Universe' Button - Mass Effect 3
"It's just an A.I." might be the video game equivalent of "It was all a dream", especially after Mass Effect 3 sadly wrote itself into the history books underneath the header, 'Most Disappointing Thing Ever'. Besides its graphical downgrade and weirdly-paced plot though, the real knockout, Fatality-style kicker came from the realisation that an ancient weapon the entire galaxy was gambling on to stop the Reapers... was an A.I. program with a child's voice. It was like approaching the end of all things, and realising a young Anakin Skywalker held all the cards. Truly, truly awful. How to fix it: Bioware would release retroactive DLC to pad this out, but that's still missing the point. Mass Effect was all about the journey, not the destination. We'd forged a few handfuls of friendships over hundreds of hours, and in ME 3 particularly, had united the galaxy under one cause; "Put aside your prejudices and unite to beat this larger threat." Everything was building up to seeing armies of Krogans storming sky-high Reapers, Turians manning their custom cannons and the Quarian's Migrant Fleet showing they could get stuck in and play to win. The end of Mass Effect 3 simply needed to see the entire galaxy unite to blast the Reapers to Kingdom Come with a planet-sized gun, as the groundwork behind any emotional resonance was already in place through your past actions. What naff plot twists would you fix, and how? Let us know in the comments, and join the Facebook for regular content updates!