We were all pretty disheartened when Rocksteadys final instalment in their critically-acclaimed Arkham trilogy got pushed back to next year - it just cant come soon enough, as Warner Bros Batman: Arkham Origins was a colossal disappointment when it released last year. In fact, Batman fans are still trying to wash the dirty taste it left in their mouths, and theres no better cure for that than a slice of awesome, next-gen Metroid-vania goodness courtesy of Rocksteady. Batman: Arkham Asylum wowed the gaming world with its incredible gameplay that made us all genuinely feel like we were the omniscient caped crusader... with abandonment issues. It was an amazing game, but its easy to impress when your audience has little to no expectations. Consequently when its sequel Arkham City released it was hyped by just about everyone and inevitably some people ended up disappointed. It was certainly a bigger game than its predecessor, but it felt bloated and unfocused at times. Lets face it - Rocksteady basically had us when they revealed that the Batmobile is in Arkham Knight, but as awesome as that will undoubtedly be, it wont be enough to sustain the lengthy campaign alone. Were hoping that Rocksteady tweak the formula from the last part of their trilogy to fix some of the issues that ruined Arkham City for some people.
8. The Empty Open-World
When people hear the name Arkham City without playing the game they will probably picture the tropes that come with an open-world game: pedestrians roaming the streets and going about their lives, traffic going by, planes flying overhead and trains taking legions of commuters to their presumably miserable, mind-numbing jobs. But what was actually in the game was a city that had been evacuated. As a result Batman only had a few cops and a seemingly endless number of generic thugs for company. The city felt barren, lifeless and didn't seem like a place that was worth saving. Rocksteady's confirmed that pedestrians will be conspicuously absent from Arkham Knight as well. It may end up being a smart design choice, as speeding around in a Batmobile in a populated city will make it damn difficult not to break Batman's no killing rule. What they can do however, is add depth to the NPCs that have been left behind. There were a few that were present in Arkham City, but they were mostly people in need of getting saved from a group of slap-happy goons. If Rocksteady added variety to the NPCs troubles and gave them personalities of their own it could do a lot to sell Gotham as a real place.
7. The Fetch Quests
The barren nature of Arkham City was exacerbated by its mission design that usually forced you to travel to multiple locations. In an early mission of the game The Penguin sets up three jammers around the city that prevent Batman from using his trusty cryptographic sequencer. You have to follow the signal, fight the enemies guarding the jammers, destroy them and then go back to where you originally were. If that sounds boring, it's because it is. Sadly The Penguin mission is far from the only fetch quest in the game. What's worse is that they usually make you do exactly the same thing three times because for some reason that's the law in video game land. In Arkham Knight we'd like to see more creative mission objectives. This is Batman, after all. He's capable of much more than going to a place, beating up some enemies, picking up or breaking something just so he can go to a new area and do the exact same thing.
6. The Rubbish DLC
It was bad enough that the Catwoman DLC only consisted of a few missions that barely added anything to the story, but it was even worse that the content was restricted to those that bought a new copy of the game. If you bought it second-hand then you'd have to pay extra to play this slice of wonderful mediocrity. The whole thing seemed solely designed to drive completists insane, as some Riddler trophies could only be collected by everyone's favourite scantily clad Kitty. Rocksteady released a fair amount of DLC but it's safe to say that it never reached its full potential. Even Harley Quinn's Revenge story DLC that took place after the closing events of the game ended up being a missed opportunity. There were also the usual challenge maps to complete with a few new characters like Robin, but they weren't really anything special. Seeing as publishers have collectively decided to take a break from screwing over pre-owned game buyers with silly restrictions, it's safe to say that Arkham Knight won't come with its own DLC fiasco. Let's just hope Rocksteady pull their finger out and deliver some DLC worth buying a season pass for this time.
5. The Repetitive Goon Chatter
Even though Arkham City was empty, it was at least nice to look at and could have had a very immersive atmosphere if it wasn't for the endless goon chatter that Batman constantly picked up wherever he went. It really started to grate after a few hours of hearing the same few voices violate your eardrums with their inane chit-chat that never went anywhere. We can only pray to the gods of video game design that this issue is rectified in Arkham Knight. It would be a shame to have such a beautiful game once again ruined by some muscle-bound criminal bragging about how they're going to be "The one that'll kill Batman" - despite similar muscle-bound criminals with strangely similar voices always failing to do so - about five seconds before we fly in and kick them in the mush.
4. The Bloated Villain Roster
Arkham Asylum featured a carefully selected cast of antagonists led by The Joker. None of the villains were there just for the sake of it and every boss fight seemed to occur organically as part of the game's narrative. The same can't be said for its sequel which was a bloated mess by comparison. There was just too much going on; Dr Strange's ominous Protocol 10 countdown, The Joker's and Batman's illness', The Penguin's merry band of goons doing their thing - each time you encountered a new threat, it kind of made you forget about the last one. There wasn't that sense of urgency that was so prevalent in Arkham Asylum and the whole thing lacked cohesion, which was made worse by the amount of unnecessary villain cameos in the game. What was the point in Harvey Two-Face and Poison Ivy being in the game for about ten minutes? Rocksteady don't have to do anything new to fix this. All they have to do take the same approach as with Arkham Asylum because it worked brilliantly. The Arkham Knight is a mysterious and intriguing antagonist and it would be a shame for him to get lost in the shuffle of copious villains.
3. The Combat
Critics praised Arkham Asylum for its engaging, simple free-flowing combat that made you feel like you were the love child of Batman and Bruce Lee. Chaining together counter-attacks, punches and takedowns was deeply satisfying. It looked badass and felt badass. Asylum's combat system has been copied by many games since, including Sleeping Dogs and more recently Shadow of Mordor. There's no problem with that in itself, but Rocksteady created one when they assumed that bigger means better. There were way more enemies in Arkham City, a stupidly large number of gadgets to use and special moves that could be acquired by gaining experience. It sounds good in theory, but for a lot of people the sheer number of options was overwhelming. The ever-looming threat of being rudely interrupted half-way through a killer takedown by an idiot armed with a baseball bat meant that just punching and occasionally countering was usually the best strategy. We know little about Arkham Knight's combat, but what we do know points to it being an evolution of the current formula. There will be more options for environmental takedowns and the Batmobile can even get in on the action. We just hope it remains to be fun throughout the game's entire campaign and doesn't become the chore it was in City.
2. The Boss Fights
The encounters Batman had with Scarecrow in Asylum are undoubtedly some of the finest, mind-melting boss fights in recent memory. They messed with your head, tested your reflexes and left you feeling satisfied, albeit with a tinge of incredulous confusion. The others are almost as good (apart from the somewhat disappointing finale with The Joker) but its sequel didn't raise the bar - it tripped over it. The vast majority of the boss fights in Arkham City (and boy, there's a lot of them) are forgettable and anti-climatic. You spend a good while chasing down The Penguin at the beginning of the game, yet in both times you face him he's disposed off with a quick punch. What's worse is that there are moments of brilliance scattered throughout the forgettable stuff. The fight against Mr. Freeze is mechanically brilliant, forcing you to actually think about ways you can use the environment against him. It's also tense as hell because Batman is easily killed here, forcing you to take a stealthy approach to move around the environment and meticulously plan your next attack. Mr. Freeze and the finale against Clayface are the highlights of City as far as boss fights are concerned. They make the other average bosses even more disappointing because they prove what Rocksteady are capable of when they put the effort in, so let's hope that they strive for quality over quantity with the bosses in Arkham Knight by giving us more like Freeze and less like Penguin.
1. The Pacing
There was a profound lack of cohesion to Arkham City. The whole game buckled under the weight of its own ambition. It had side-quests to complete, riddler trophies to collect, enemies to punch in the face and bosses to take down, but it all felt superfluous. It doesn't help that for most of us at the start of the game you're Catwoman, then suddenly you're Batman, who is just mildly concerned that Hugo Strange knows his identity and is threatening to reveal it to the world. Then The Joker and The Penguin show up because there's a super-villain reunion party going on or something, and before you know it you're on a mission with only a vague notion of why you're doing what you're doing. Having his parents killed is usually all the motivation the Dark Knight needs in theory, but we needed more drive and placement in this narrative. Once again, all Rocksteady has to do is hit the reset button and use what worked in Asylum. One main antagonist, one playable character and only include bosses that contribute to the plot in some way. If they do that, then Arkham Knight will be nothing short of 2015's Game of the Year. What improvements do you think Rocksteady should make in Arkham Knight? Let us know in the comments.