Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs
"A blast from the past"... with some crippling differences.
We all knew Sony were going to get back around to remastering Crash at some point - the orange marsupial goes hand in hand with PlayStation branding like nothing else.
Single-handedly responsible for selling the PS1 to an entire generation, it goes without saying that those first three games are still held in the highest regard. So for a studio to both advertise the fact they were taking Naughty Dog's old masterpieces and recreating the entire trilogy from the ground up - it was either going to be phenomenal or a complete disaster.
Thankfully, the result is a resoundingly positive one, seeing Vicarious Visions - who were formerly responsible for all the Game Boy Advance iterations of the franchise - step up to bat for a full console release. With their only other triple-A Crash experience being filtered through Skylanders: Imaginators - Crash Edition and the fact they have Naughty Dog's impeccable legacy to live up to, the fact they've pulled anything off is cause for celebration alone.
That said, Crash's 2017 edition isn't perfect, though it does come mighty close...
- Ups -
7. Absolutely Gorgeous Graphics
Almost as though Vicarious Visions were fully aware of just how jaw-droppingly stunning their new engine is, when you first wash up on N. Sanity beach and see Crash flex his muscles, the resultant rush of reworked colour, sound and Crash's own fur textures look incredible.
Not only that, but formerly dark tombs now come with great dynamic lighting, casting arched shadows across walls as distant flame pits light up the way. Occasionally this actually helps you judge the path ahead too, with horizontal platforms being telegraphed thanks to their own shadows.
All in all, whilst early qualms centred on Crash looking a bit too 'cutesy' or rounded compared to his edgy - literally and characteristically - 90s counterpart, the result is a very positive, recommendable upgrade across the board.
6. One Of The Most Faithful Recreations Of A Beloved Classic Ever Made
The debate rages on as to just how a video game remake 'should' be done:
Is it in the vein of Final Fantasy VII where gameplay is completely uprooted and replaced, or here where the original forms the mechanical framework and the majority of time goes into updating textures and graphics?
If you're in the latter camp - which was also mostly the case with Nintendo's excellent Ocarina of Time upgrade on 3DS - Crash is exemplary. There are some qualms that emerge from Vicarious Visions applying Crash 3's physics model to both Crash 1 and 2, but from the moment you begin running, jumping, smashing crates and hoovering up Wumpa fruit, it feels like Crash.
Atop that, you've got completely reworked/redesigned cutscenes, gorgeously rendered and animated perfectly with all the iconic sound effects and score from the originals, re-recorded in HD.
Basically, this looks and plays almost identically to the version of Crash in your head, which is just what's needed.
5. The Cast Return From Various Crash Games
Carrying on from the idea of remastering the soundscape of the originals and redoing all the cutscenes, those original 90s audio files certainly wouldn't have held up. As such, Vicarious Visions recruited a smattering of voice talent from Crash's 20 year history, including everyone from John DiMaggio as Uka-Uka to Jess Harnell as Crash himself.
Sadly, none of this talent was present back when Naughty Dog first recorded everybody, but the returning cast do an exemplary job mimicking the mannerisms and inflections of some of the trilogy's most memorable scenes.
Those moments where the various bosses pop up and berate in between levels in Crash 3, or even the manic high-pitched squeaks of Ripper Roo?
They sound spot.on.
4. Coco Is Newly Playable Throughout All Three Games
One of the few entirely new features, at key points in the games you'll be given the opportunity to switch control over to Coco - something many will remember thinking they could do in Crash 3 anyway, as she's seen standing in the level select centre console.
Playing as Coco is more a cool neat addition than anything game-changing, though these remade Crash levels can get excruciatingly hard (more on that in a bit), so piloting a different character model through some extremely small gaps can help just a tiny bit.
3. The (Unconfirmed) DLC Is Most Likely Unused Naughty Dog Levels
We covered this in our exclusive breakdown of the - still unannounced - DLC for the game, but it looks as though in gaining access to Naughty Dog's vault of levels, Vicarious Visions have also plumbed the depths of two specific ones that never saw the light of day.
Called Stormy Ascent and Sunset Vista (Extended), both look to be part of the 'Lost Treasures' pack listed on the game's various purchase pages, though at time of writing, we're yet to get any official confirmation.
Still, being the icons for each level's trophy mimic characters and iconography from these missing levels - which fans have acquired and posted about for decades - it's truly awesome to see them get the full remaster treatment.
This is the closest we're going to get to actual 'new' Naughty Dog Crash content, so breathe it in.
2. Vehicle-Based Controls Have Been Touched Up In Crash 3
I'll get onto the fundamental difference in how Crash controls as one of the negatives, but when Vicarious Visions updated the likes of riding motorcycles or biplanes in Crash 3, they've drastically improved the overall feel.
Mostly down to these modes being experimental inclusions back in 1998, the benefit of a developer who've made all sorts of games over the years means they can touch up these sections perfectly. There's no more being knocked halfway across the road on the motorbike levels, and pirouetting through the sky to blast apart enemy fighter planes feels responsive and incredibly fun.
A small addition on paper as those older sections were serviceable enough, but one that makes Crash 3 all the more incredible.
1. Certain Frustrating Levels Have Been Refined
Praise jebus, for the Hog Wild level need not stymy your enjoyment anymore!
Yes, in remaking all of these more momentum-based levels i.e. the ones where Crash leaps on either a warthog or polar bear in Crash 1 and 2, Vicarious Visions have amended the collision detection, meaning you don't get snagged anywhere near as much on random pieces of world geometry.
In Hog Wild it was those damned spiked columns or shield-baring natives, and in Crash 2 is was nigh-on impossible to hit all the levels' crates without getting your path just right.
Thankfully, no more. Now the warthog can survive going that little bit closer to the spikes in those quick left-right-left slaloms, and Polar (the polar bear) gives a wider birth, meaning you need only brush past said crates to break them open.
If you're coming in fresh you'll probably not notice, but for all those who remember how annoying these levels could be in the originals, it's a welcome change.
- Downs -
3. The First Game Is Far Harder Than You Remember
Onto downs, and mostly as a hangover from just how platformers were designed across the late 90s, there is a lot of precise movement and jumping required to proceed, especially in the first Crash.
If you're picking up the collection and hoping to rekindle a casual love for the series - one which mostly likely came from Crash 2 and 3 overall - you'll be completely unaware of just how brutally unforgiving many of the first game's level layouts can be.
Partly down to how Vicarious Visions have changed the feel of Crash's jumping and overall momentum, you also have a life counter that once it hits zero, you're back to the beginning.
It's a fine line asking for something like the instant-restart of Trials or Super Meat Boy to be implemented, but if you were wanting to indulge in playful childish platforming with a smile on your face, it'll turn to rage after you're forced to restart the same sequences over and over (and over) again.
Crash 2 and 3 though? They're a delight.
2. It Can Feel Borderline Broken In Spots
The reality of releasing three games that have demonstrable leaps and bounds between them has meant Vicarious Visions need a way for all to essentially play the same.
As such, whilst the first game's levels weren't built for the larger, more momentum-heavy platforming Crash would refine himself into, it's Crash 3: Warped's physics model that gets retroactively used across the trilogy.
Sadly, because of this you'll find yourself over or undershooting a TON of gaps, mainly because the new physics model and Crash's greater jumping arcs don't 'fit' these older levels. Native Fortress and Road to Nowhere/High Road are particularly egregious examples of where you'll feel completely ill-equipped to get by. There is absolutely a way to get used to this over time, but it actively works against those players returning to the game, hoping to reapply the way they once played to the new engine.
In addition, when Vicarious Visions rebuilt all of the various games' levels, the 'hitboxes' (the term used for when a game recognises you landing on something) have been tightened to the point of matching the EXACT shape of the in-game item. Rather than allowing for some 'free air' like before and giving you the benefit of the doubt, either you land right in the perfect spot with the perfect run-up or Crash will awkwardly slip off into the dark below.
You could argue they've changed this to give veteran players a new way to play, but when Crash is such an accessible franchise otherwise - one geared to all ages and that skews towards a younger audience - making the platforming SO meticulous can be straight-up off-putting.
1. Trial & Error Gameplay + Bad Load Times = Sheer Brutality
The final annoyance that actively works against this notion of 'trial n' error gaming' is the load times.
From the opening titles to the main menu - and especially if you want to retry a level that isn't a time trial without losing all your lives (say for a no-death gem run) - you're forced back to the level select screen, then back into the game itself. That means two load screens at around 15-20+ seconds a piece per restart, which just isn't on.
Chances are this'll get patched over time, but as it stands - for a game predicated on trying over and over to surmount some incredibly obstacle-heavy levels, a bad set of load screens can more than contribute to a negative user experience.
--
How have you found Crash, or are you waiting to pick up a copy? Let us know in the comments!