Dead Island was a game that seemed to come out of nowhere, taking the gaming world by storm with an incredibly moving CG trailer that showed the death of a family in reverse. It was heavy stuff, and was likely the key in allowing the game to be as successful as it was. It was so successful in fact, that it has started its own franchise and we are anxiously awaiting the release of Dead Island 2 next year. While Dead Island Riptide was somewhat buggy and lacking polish, it seems like Dead Island 2 is on course to remedy all the issues found within Riptide. Backed by a brand new development team in Yager and a whole new setting in southern California, Dead Island 2 is looking to continue the tradition of zombie killing madness. But before we start booking our flight to Los Angeles and sharpening our machete, let's take a step back and realise that Dead Island had a lot of obvious flaws that prevented it from reaching its highest potential. It's a massively fun time to be had, but there were more than a few lingering issues that Yager is going to have to fix in order to make Dead Island 2 the sequel it needs to be. So slice open that next button with your electrified cleaver, and we'll take a look at 10 things that need to be fixed in Dead Island 2.
10. Headshots Drop Zombies
What is the number one rule in zombie fiction? Headshots kill zombies. So it's a little weird that Dead Island completely ignored this, making zombies nearly immune to them. Even more baffling is that the human characters that you encounter are immediately dropped by a well-placed headshot, an unusual decision that didn't quite work out all that well. Certain tropes are immutable, and shooting a zombie in the skull is one of them. As villains, zombies illicit one of the greatest sense of fear imaginable, as the idea of being torn apart is truly frightening. So the empowerment you get from smoking one with a head shot can't be understated, as it just makes the player feel in control in a situation where they have none. It may seem like a trivial thing, but that rush of power is so important in games like this. Without that feeling of small victories, you lose a lot of impact in the overall structure.
9. Better Weapon Selection
One thing that the Ryder White DLC for Dead Island did was the advent of more interesting guns, and allowed the player access to a much more interesting arsenal than before. Granted, Dead Island has a penchant for melee combat, but there's a lot of validity to ploughing through the game with barrels blazing. And considering how weak the gun selection was in Dead Island, this can only be a good thing. Throw reality out the window; give us an armoury to blow zombies up with. Give us sniper rifles, uzis, sub-machine guns and any other kind of firearm you can think of. In a series that is as off the wall as Dead Island, the time to up the violence capacity is long overdue, and something that Yager has to be thinking about.
8. Better Artificial Intelligence
At a certain point in Dead Island - once the initial terror of being hunted by vicious flesh-eaters wears off - the zombies in Dead Island start to show the chinks in their armor. You begin to see them less as horrific creatures determined to murder you, and rather as silly little children that you are the care taker of. Sometimes, they just do stupid things and you have to give them a gentle nudge in the right direction. One thing that Yager should be focusing on in Dead Island 2 is fixing the readily apparent AI issues and make sure that the zombies never act out of context, for fear of breaking the illusion that we're about to be killed. It's something that would often creep up in the first game, and seeing zombies run into a wall as they tried to get at an enemy that wasn't even there, it greatly takes away from their aura. Please, Yager, stop us from laughing at these poor souls.
7. Survival
A key part of any piece of zombie fiction is the survival aspect, the part where the heroes must hunker down into a less than desirable location in order to stay alive. It's a tried and true way to make sure that your characters get pushed to their limits, forcing them into scenarios that test their mettle. Take the prison from The Walking Dead, a location that almost became a character in itself. It was a breeding ground for insanity, and it allowed the characters to grow into either confident leaders or loyal followers. For Dead Island 2, the concept of zombie survival needs to be addressed in a way that it wasn't in the first game. Part of this was because the main characters were made immune to the zombie virus, which is a good idea on paper but took away from the danger element of being eaten. Dead Island 2 needs to bring back that fear; the notion that you are on the run and need a place to stay and fortify. Riptide was a step in the right direction with the hub defense missions, but now it's time for Yager to take full advantage of it.
6. Character Creation
While it was fun to see these unique characters come together, especially considering how different they all were, the thing that makes the most sense today is character creation. From Mass Effect to the Elder Scrolls, gamers are all about creating their own hero or villain now and being able to define their personality over time. Whether they choose to be a good guy or a bad guy, all of that remains up to the player. And in the zombie apocalypse, that is even more appealing. If you create your own survivor, the potential for greatness is heavily increased. Making your own choices about who to ally with, as well as what side of the fence you sit on, it's all prime zombie apocalypse material. In a world that is all about difficult choices, allowing the player to create their own hero or anti-hero to blast through this brutal new world with is infinitely exciting.
5. Interesting Characters
A big issue in Dead Island was that no matter which character you picked to play as, they all seemed interchangeable. Aside from unique skills and abilities, the characters didn't have much in the way of personality, or if they did it was so cartoony that it still didn't work. With Dead Island 2, Yager should absolutely be focused on creating unique and compelling characters for the player to interact with. This is especially true if Dead Island 2 plans to follow along the same route as its predecessor, where the open-world RPG formula created a game that took almost thirty hours to complete. If Yager is planning to give us a twenty-five to thirty hour experience, then there needs to be some interesting characters to interact with. Allow us the option to form strong bonds with them, and avoid using the invincible NPC trope so that they can be killed if things go bad. Make us love them, then make it hurt.
4. Tighter Combat
While the combat of Dead Island is a lot of fun, there's a certain amount of player feedback that doesn't quite come through in the final product. When you swing that bat to crack a zombie's head open, it sort of feels like you're just hitting the air as opposed to flesh. The impact isn't quite there, and you often feel like you're just kids running around playing make believe instead of a tough zombie slayer. For Dead Island 2, all that impact from the weapons needs to be really felt by the player. Give the combat weight, so that when we swing our machete into a zombie's face, there's friction and contact. The more real the combat feels, the more immersion is afforded to the game, and the power fantasy of slaughtering countless shambling fools is a huge adrenaline rush when it's done right.
3. Location Variety
So much of what made the original Dead Island appealing was the subversive concept of a zombie apocalypse in a bright, tropical island setting. Where most zombie fiction put the protagonist into urban cities and wastelands, Dead Island turned the sunshine up to eleven and let you go to town. It was a fresh take on the zombie apocalypse scenario, something that it sorely needed at the time. But even so, the island began to feel rather monotonous after a while. Even as you made your way to other locations, it was still clearly a tropical island and didn't quite escape that vibe. There were valiant attempts with a sewer location and a visit to a prison in the climax, but it still just felt like Banoi with new paint. With Dead Island 2 being set on the sunny streets of California, you can certainly put that little issue to rest. Tangling with zombies inside shopping malls, schools - even the the Golden Gate Bridge - anything to make the different locations stand out. Heck, imagine the pure thrill of escaping a zombie horde by fleeing to the mountain ranges in the Sierra Nevada. All of it needs to work together to create a vibe of constant evolution.
2. Deadly Choices
In the three years since the original Dead Island released, the industry has seen significant leaps in the idea of player choice and good vs. evil alignment. Dead Island wasn't really much for this idea; you either accepted a side quest or you didn't, and you could always come back to it later. That was about the extent of it, but Dead Island 2 is a great time to engineer the idea into the series. Recently, Telltale Games have been further cementing the concept in their own take on the zombie apocalypse with The Walking Dead, which is a great place to start. Putting the player into the middle of this outbreak, and then asking them to make the tough choices would be an excellent step forward for the series. If Dead Island 2 is looking to be a twenty-five hour experience, the impact of a choice coming back to haunt you all those hours later is a very tantalizing prospect. Consider a scenario where you are presented with the option of saving a family from some vicious looters, with the reward of potential goodies. Well done you old softie, you saved a family and their children. Good for you. Except for the part where those looters come back and kill a member of your group some fifteen hours later. Events like that would help solidify the Dead Island franchise in a world where evolution is so important.
1. Less SyFy, More AMC
Perhaps the biggest criticism that was levelled at Dead Island was what fans perceived as deceptive marketing; the three-minute CG trailer showing a family in their bloody final hours was truly harrowing stuff and gave Dead Island all the hype it would ever need to become a success. It wasn't until players got into the game when they realized that it was less AMC, and more SyFy original movie. The campy characters and storyline weren't exactly endearing to its audience as they lacked empathy, something that is more or less a requirement in zombie fiction. While a bit of levity is certainly welcome in something as dark as the zombie apocalypse, it tends to wear thin fast and results in the narrative suffering. With Dead Island 2, Yager needs to compose a story that has pathos, a real sense of despair. Combining this with compelling characters and interesting choices to be made, it can all work together in beautiful harmony. Let the players make some emotional connections, give some down time where there isn't constant zombie bashing and let the characters just live. Let them breathe and have something worth fighting for, pull on the emotion that is inherently connected to the zombie apocalypse. What changes do you think need to be made in order to make Dead Island 2 surpass the original? Let us know in the comments!