DOOM Eternal Review: 8 Ups & 1 Down

2020's first must-have game.

By Scott Tailford /

iD Software

DOOM Eternal is one of the best games I’ve ever played.

Advertisement

Hell, it’s one of the best THINGS I’ve ever experienced. A masterful execution on envelope-pushing, synapse-stretching first-person shooting, that doesn’t let up for 20 straight hours.

iD Software already proved they MORE than still had it with 2016’s soft reboot of DOOM, and as veterans of the industry, you can tell they know EXACTLY what had to happen next.

Advertisement

Firing into DOOM Eternal, seeing the DOOM Slayer’s flying space fortress (because why not), cocking the shotgun and hearing another MASTERFUL Mick Gordon soundtrack, it creates a sensation of a rollercoaster banking up that first climb.

You know what you’re in for, and you THINK you can anticipate those adrenaline-charged drops and swerves, but only when they actually kick in, do those extra wide smiles and heart-racing cheers come in.

Advertisement

Because DOOM Eternal revels in its own ridiculousness, in the best.way.possible.

Let's break everything down.

Advertisement

Ups

8. Elevating The Brand & Connecting The Original Games

iD Software

The question before launch was “how”.

Advertisement

How – after getting the 2016’s “return instalment” so right out of nowhere - could iD POSSIBLY top such a glorious, self-aware celebration of a franchise, whilst continuing to raise the bar AND not introduce anything that stymied that momentum?

Well, by bringing Mick Gordon back, for one, but also by fleshing out DOOM’s lore in a way that officially – AND FINALLY – solidifies a backing for the original titles AND what we have now.

Advertisement

I’m not gonna say how because you NEED to experience this ride spoiler-free, but the fact iD "went there" with all these plans, only gives DOOM a sense of future-proofing that'll no doubt pay off.

Also, know that Eternal doesn’t necessarily tell a STORY if you don’t want it to.

Advertisement

If you just want to play the Slayer as this righteous embodiment of demon-slaying justice and cosmic balance, you can. You’ll still get the major scenes I'm referring to, and a literal handful of other third-person cutscenes, but the bulk of the background lore is told through text entries you'll have to pause and read.

Personally, I love this. It lets you get as invested as you want, walking the line between the chaos-loving carnage of the old-school, and the origin story, connected universe fare of the modern day.

Advertisement

7. The Best FPS Combat In Gaming History

iD Software

DOOM Eternal plays like a thrash metal guitar solo. It’s a guttural scream bellowing the opening of a track that’s only followed by the band going hell for leather, and thousands in attendance headbanging their grandchildren into a lifetime of hereditary neck problems.

Advertisement

There’s a PACE to new-age DOOM, and after 2016 set the bar, Eternal innovates and expands in all the right ways.

Your chainsaw now activates with a push of the button, the all-new Flame Belch means on-fire enemies spew armour, letting you stay amongst the fray as you charge SO MANY additional modifiers for what happens next.

Advertisement

The three separate upgrade systems give you grenades that scatter from grenades, enemies have weak spots that disable certain attacks, others respond to a grenade in the mouth or having their head-cannons shot off. The GLORIOUS one-hit kill Blood Punch is a super melee that unleashes a shockwave designed to clear space, should anything get in your way.

6. Genuine Progression As A Player From Start To Finish

Bethesda

Every single part of DOOM Eternal’s design has been masterfully assembled to guarantee complete 100%, signature feel intensity. It doesn't mean you'll be able to pull off kill combos and claret ballets from moment one - the game even warns you of early deaths at the beginning - but every step of this is intentional.

Advertisement

Quickly you'll learn that DOOM wants you to come to it. There aren't any hand-holdy tutorials outside of testing a weapon, and if you keep getting put down, it's ALWAYS because you forgot about one key ability in your sizeable arsenal.

Where so many other titles batter you into a fine paste and leave you in the ground; you screaming "but I pushed the button and he still died", DOOM Eternal actually is "brutally hard, but fair".

Advertisement

You'll know what you did wrong; where you went wrong, and you'll course correct next time.

Even better, you'll start making these realisations in the moment, keeping the Slayer alive and never letting up on all the combo possibilities before you.

Advertisement

5. "Combat Chess"

iD Software

I mentioned that sensation of movement and weapon feel, but there's an intricate system of "rock, paper, scissors" that ebbs and flows underneath every encounter.

Advertisement

Many have come to coin the term "combat chess", and while it was prevalent in the 2016 reboot, here you really need to be thinking on your feet and reacting as fast as possible at all times.

Stay still and you’re dead. You NEED to cleave through enemies to get more ammo, NEED to weaken them for a glory kill to regain health. You’ll need to switch through EVERY weapon, the Super Shotgun’s new grapple hook being just as valuable as the Plasma Rifle’s shockwave.

Advertisement

Speaking of the latter, its energy rounds tear apart the electric shields some demons have, or break down larger barriers surrounding minibosses.

Once you figure out it's possible to unlock a health-boost that comes from frozen enemies, then douse them in fire for additional armour, get the boost from killing a staggered foe AND chainsaw them for more HP, it's a eureka moment like no other.

Advertisement

4. Letting Your Brain Adjust Through Sheer Muscle Memory

iD Software

Now, you are dropped into all this in a way that can feel pretty overwhelming. Thankfully, iD Software know EXACTLY what they’re doing, and even this initial “HOLY CRAP, this is a LOT of game coming at me” is intentional (the game’s difficulty screen tells you so).

Advertisement

One of the most subtle cards DOOM Eternal plays is subconsciously. You NEED time for all this game’s systems to embed into your brain. Your muscle memory needs to develop, and you need to invest hours in this to get the most in return.

What could once be a fight you scraped through then CLICKS on replay as you fly through the level in a blur of blades and blood. The game never stops introducing new enemies, new combinations of weapons or power-ups – new reasons to rip, tear, and feel absolutely phenomenal doing it.

Advertisement

3. That Boundary-Breaking, Immaculate Score

Never let it be said that music does not matter to a video game.

Advertisement

Composer Mick Gordon's work on DOOM doesn't just obliterate that sentiment, but he fundamentally contributes to the art of immersion in ways you can't put into words - you can only hear and feel.

Sure, that sounds cheesy, but we're talking about a game with an audible footprint just as stonkingly brazen, heavy and identifiable as its mechanics. DOOM Eternal knows when to back off and play to the atmosphere, it knows when to build and deliver a hugely infectious riff, and it knows when to fall back into repeating, galloping patterns while you search for that one remaining foe in a room.

Advertisement

The industrial-meets-groove metal riffs and beats Gordon put together in 2016 were unlike anything even the most ardent heavy metal fan had heard, and here he's only expanding on lessons learned.

The above piece of music is essentially the "main theme" for DOOM Eternal like Rip & Tear was before, only this time it's repeatedly backing every bullet, right in the heart of combat.

Advertisement

2. 60FPS, Even On Base Consoles

iD Software

This is a quicker point as no doubt there'll be so many in-depth platform comparisons to come, but DOOM Eternal - at least on Xbox One - runs like a dream.

Advertisement

Besides maintaining 60fps across the board, it actively invites you to try and overwhelm its intricate web of combat systems.

At any given time you're setting fire to things, cutting them in half, letting fly volleys of missiles, freezing things, exploding things and staying on the move. The only time I got the game to hitch was in one of the many "Slayer Challenges", where the game throws every enemy at you at once, and your task is just stay alive.

Advertisement

Across the board, you can tell iD Software are masters of their craft; some of the most talented coders in the business, and it shows.

1. Id's Best Game & Setting The Bar For Sequels

iD Software

I’ve not had this much consistent fun or ‘gripping the pad til I’m sore’ engagement with a game… ever. The sheer ear to ear, maniacal laughter-fueled euphoria I felt when lock-stepping with everything DOOM Eternal had to offer was unlike any other FPS, including DOOM 2016.

Advertisement

Creative Director – and absolute G – Hugo Martin was spot on about this eclipsing what went before, and it’s not until you see and FEEL what the team have built, that you’ll know why.

The end result is a resounding, sky-punching five star product. I knew it in my bones after my first 10 hour play session, and as the credits rolled and I basked in the dark synthetic beats of that badass score, I felt nothing but pure, sheer jubilation.

Advertisement

I immediately dove back in to experience everything all over again, hovering up missing tokens, attempting challenge arenas now with full loadouts, and punking those motherF’ing Marauders that are so hard the first time round.

You’ll see.

Advertisement

Without getting into specifics because the ride here is so exquisite, DOOM Eternal is one of the best games of the generation, the best game I’ve ever played from iD, 2020s first must-have, and everything you could ever want from a follow-up to that 2016 release.

And now... time for the tiniest negative ever.

Advertisement

Downs

1. Not Having A Better Solution To Weapon Switching On Console

iD Software

Yup, this really is the only negative I can think of. It's super minor, but if you want something approximating a "down", no it's not the climbing - that stuff is super snappy and fun - it's this.

Advertisement

See, DOOM Eternal now requires you to use the Slayer's full arsenal.

Whether through ammo scarcity or literal application (some weapons are better against some foes), you'll be constantly hopping between every last one of your guns, all the time.

Advertisement

On console this resigns you to "hold button, bring up the weapon wheel, point at segment with analogue stick, and let go", and for the vast majority of time, it works as intended.

There are those times though - in the heat of battle, your mind doing multiple calculations about who to shoot next, where and at what angle - where the wrong selection puts you in an infinitely worse place.

Advertisement

On PC this won't be a thing. There you've got the Slayer's entire arsenal available on hotkeys, and you can swap to exactly you want, whenever you want.

On console though, where iD have innovated and improved in every other area, it's a shame they couldn't think of something more immediate during the chaos of combat, than another slow motion weapon wheel.

Advertisement