Every Mass Effect 2 Loyalty Mission - Ranked

Who comes out on top in the original Suicide Squad?

By Stacey Henley /

The Mass Effect 2 loyalty missions are arguably the best side missions in gaming history. These weren't simple fetch quests, or even a case of doing enough nice things for a character so they'd like you. Each and every one of these quests dove into the soul of your squadmates, developing their story, revealing their motivations.

Advertisement

Even the ones featured at the lower end are be some of the best gameplay experiences in modern RPGs. Mass Effect 2 remains the jewel of Bioware's crown, and is a genuine contender for the best game of the Xbox 360/PS3 era.

But which of them are the best? Which are the crem de la crem de la crem?

For this list, we're taking into account gameplay (obviously), but also the story, the effect on Mass Effect lore and the impact it had on the character overall.

Note: Liara's Lair of the Shadow Broker is excellent, but as she's not a permanent squadmate, I'm not counting it.

12. Zaeed - The Price Of Revenge

Mirthless, merciless mercenary Zaeed Massani is kicking us off at number 12. Zaeed was a DLC character, available via a free code if you bought the game new. However, with used games being a booming market (and there being some issues with porting the DLC to Xbox One), some players missed out on this mission, which has to count against it in the rankings.

Advertisement

In truth though, there's more than that counting against The Price Of Revenge. While some missions on this list have enough heart and soul that an entire game could have been built around them, Zaeed's is a by the numbers revenge outing. There's nothing especially wrong with the gameplay, with some sections featuring some great run and gun fun.

Still, it's hardly inspiring. Or particularly indicative of the quality of missions still to explore. For most fans, this was a mission they'd put off on their second playthrough, or perhaps rush through first to get to the good stuff later.

The final scene where Zaeed tosses his burning used clip into a gasoline puddle to create an explosion is cool enough to fit a John Carpenter movie though, so at least there's that.

11. Thane - Sins Of The Father

BioWare deserves praise for so many different mission types, but this is a bit of a swing and a miss. Storywise it's as nuanced as any, but flip-flops a little. Playing as a Renegade is typically thought of as the canon choice, as sticking to pure Paragon forces the soulful Thane to become bad cop in an interrogation scene.

Advertisement

That scene in and of itself is inventive, but Thane's mission feels like different bits stuck together. It does what it's supposed to, but it's a stark contrast between the deep delves of some of the others featured here.

It's also entirely non-combat. While that isn't a deal breaker (with another non-combat mission appearing much higher), it feels like a waste of Thane Krios' reputation as a master assassin. That plus the catwalk sections can be frustratingly fiddly, making you wish you could pull your gun out and start blasting.

While it's certainly heartfelt to see Thane and his son Kolyat work through their differences, we know so little about their species, the Drell. Those two are the only ones you meet outside of DLC, so you'd think BioWare might've done better letting us explore this angle rather than another redemption arc.

10. Mordin - Old Blood

I know it's controversial to have the very model of a scientist Salarian so low down the list, but let me explain. First off, they couldn't all make the top five. We'll all have our favourites, but aside from a few iffy sections in Thane's and a lack of creativity in Zaeed's, there's nothing wrong with any of them.

Advertisement

Obviously, the genophage is a huge part of Mass Effect lore. Some would even say it's the single defining factor in revealing the complexities at the story's heart. But despite its presence in Mordin's loyalty mission, the truly heartbreaking part of this narrative comes in Mass Effect 3. It had to be him. Someone else might have gotten it wrong.

Because of that, the weight of the story counts against it a little. The first time it felt like you were burrowing to the core of this controversial science, but on replays it just feels like a prologue for the really heavy stuff in Mass Effect 3.

Gameplay wise it's solid, but there's nothing to elevate it above tenth. Besides, there's a better mission on Tuchanka anyway, as you'll soon see...

9. Garrus - Eye For An Eye

Eye For An Eye is another mission that's just a little hamstrung by niggling issues. Garrus is an absolutely fantastic squadmate across all three games. Up there with the best, if not the best, ever. But there are bucket loads of missions and interactions that show this off much better than this out of character revenge plot.

Advertisement

Digging deep into the Citadel is definitely a nice touch, and very much in line with what the loyalty missions should be about. Deep exploration. Discovery.

But it fails to truly make the most of it, especially when it's competing with a few other Citadel missions to stand out. Especially as there's a glitch where dying at one of the tougher battle sections lets you immediately skip past it on respawn.

There's also the issue that this feels a little off for Garrus. Even if he has been busy as Archangel while Shepard lay dying. The solution to this, of course, is to use your Paragon prompts at the mission's climax to convince him to change his mind. But then that just makes the whole mission a waste of time. You get Garrus' loyalty, I suppose, but that's about it. Lovely.

8. Jack - Subject Zero

Jack is another character with a truly fascinating backstory. Experimented on by Cerberus since birth, raised in a place more akin to a prison slash fighting pit than a shelter. Returning to the scene of this horror is obviously emotional for her.

Advertisement

The only emotion Jack usually displays willingly is blood boiling rage, but we see deep seated aguish run through her veins here too. Revisiting her past is like salting old wounds, and the setting itself has some tense, gothic vibes.

We’re at the stage now where eight missions feel worthy of the top five, and Jack misses out for a few reasons. Her recruitment mission is a bit meatier, and simply taking time to talk to her on the Normandy uncovers more of her backstory anyway. While the mission is enjoyable, if you take away the personal connection to Jack, the gameplay isn’t all that different from several other exploration missions across the franchise.

There’s also the fact that compared to her return in Mass Effect 3 (and her recruitment mission earlier), this is probably her worst outing. This mission also throws a spanner in the works when it and a certain other mission are completed...

7. Miranda - The Prodigal

That other mission is Miranda’s The Prodigal. While Miranda can feel smug at beating her psychotic biotic rival, she also just misses the top five.

Advertisement

Once again, outside factors come into play. Miranda is one of the crew there from the very start. In fact, she’s the first thing you see when you wake up from your accident. As a result, her mission can lack urgency. Yes, you might want to help her (and this might be a bigger pull of your BroShep wants to get into her catsuit), but you don’t need her trust like you need the rest.

The story is intriguing, but like Jack you learn more through simple interactions. The clone potential is a little wasted though as it turns into a series of battle arenas where you pop out from cover over and over again.

Also, completing both this mission and Jack’s will lead to the two arguing. Not only does this fuel fanfic everywhere, it forces you to take sides. High Renegade or Paragon keeps everyone happy but without it you need to pick. The one you don’t choose turns disloyal again, and if you’re a male your chance of romance with them is shattered.

6. Samara - The Ardat-Yakshi

Though Mass Effect has always had choices, this one is on another level. You can choose to kill Samara and add her daughter Morinth - a sex vampire - to your team. This is a strictly non-combat mission, but in a way it's the most violent of the lot.

Advertisement

The key here, unbelievably, is douchebaggery. Once you've made enough of a scene, Morinth invites you back to her swinging bachelorette pad. Here, we see Shepard weaker and more vulnerable than usual. Morinth takes control. She flatters us, goading us to merge minds. It won't kill us; we're too strong.

Samara bursts in then to kill Morinth and finally end her daughter's reign of terror. Siding with Samara ends the mission then and there: back to the Normandy you go. Siding with Morinth though will see her kill her mother, then assume Samara's place on the crew, with nobody but you any the wiser. But it essentially means murdering a Jedi because you have the hots for a serial killer. Oh, if you try it on with her again, you get a Game Over. Because she's a sex vampire, idiot.

Bonus; Shepard’s dancing can feature in this mission, which definitely helps its ranking.

5. Legion - A House Divided

As we enter the top five, the nit-picking stops. Most of the missions below would have been highlights in any other game, but Mass Effect 2 spoiled us. Like a glove slapping Texan though, these missions demand satisfaction.

Advertisement

After making the Geth cannon fodder baddies in the first game, Legion - and this mission in particular - humanised them with wonderful subtlety. Like Miranda and Jack, it can start a fight with Tali but that happens so late in the game; most players are well equipped to either Paragon or Renegade their way out of that mess.

The lore here is touching. Legion’s name is from a Biblical quote to signify strength in numbers and his plating is made from Shep’s old armour. We also learn of the factions of in-fighting, and hear Legion paint the Geth as terrified slaves, fearing a strike from the Quarians, their creators.

The level itself is enjoyable and challenging too. Ditching traditional duck and cover gauntlets, one of the final stages is a battle arena where you must take out four increasingly difficult waves.

While not quite number one, there is no mission in Mass Effect that changes our perception of a race quite so much.

4. Kasumi - Stealing Memory

It might be a little hypocritical to have Kasumi so high when DLC counted against Zaeed, but Stealing Memory deserves it. Without the DLC baggage, it might have been even higher.

Advertisement

This mission takes Shep out of their comfort zone and out of their battle armour, forcing them to rub shoulders at a fancy shindig. Here, you must skulk around a mansion, creating distractions so you can snoop in peace. Little by little you find clues, eventually breaking into the host’s vault. There, you find the greybox of Kasumi’s former lover, Keiji.

It makes perfect sense that someone as secretive as Kasumi would only give her loyalty to Shepard if they can handle this extremely personal task. The mission was also clearly proof of concept for the amazing casino heist portion of the Citadel DLC in Mass Effect 3. Considering many fans rank the Citadel DLC as one of the best packages in any game, Kasumi scores some points for setting it in motion.

The mission blends story and gunplay well too, with the heist theme being dropped once you’re inside the vault. From there on out, it’s good old fashioned Mass Effect as you take on swathes of deadly mechs.

3. Jacob - The Gift Of Greatness

There is no other metric which sees Jacob in a Mass Effect top 3, except perhaps a ranking of how dull they are compared to dishwater. Even then, Jacob faces stiff competition from Kaidan and Liam to win the crown.

Advertisement

This mission though is a career highlight for his characterisation, even if it’s a lowlight on a personal level. Though assassins and sex vampires feature previously, Jacob’s mission is by far the most warped.

It starts out well suited to Jacob’s boring sensiblities. He thought his father died in a crash a few years ago, but he’s just received a distress signal. Cookie cutter.

Once you land on the planet though, it’s anything but. Most of the supplies had spoiled, infected with a brain rotting toxin. Only senior crew like Jacob’s dad got the untainted food. And once the toxin turns the non-essential crew’s minds to mush, they become pets. The game lets you use your information here, but still. Ew.

BioWare tried hard to make Jacob an interesting military archetype, something they later got right with Vega. But this mission gives his no-nonsense personality the spotlight perfectly. Just a shame it set the bar too high.

2. Grunt - Rite Of Passage

The motivations for the Mass Effect 2 squadmates run deep. Redemption, revenge, absolution, atonement... not so Grunt. The motivation here is that he wants to kill something really f@&#ing big.

Advertisement

The Krogan could've easily become the typical big angry orcs in the hands of many other developers, but BioWare nurtured them into a complex, tragic race, without losing that ruthless edge. So it makes sense that while Grunt's mission is literally just 'murder this', there's a lot of thought behind it. Grunt's a test tube baby, engineered to be a great warrior. But warriors are not engineered, and his race rejects him. He's 'tank bred'. There is, however, a way to win them over...

Grunt, assisted by you and one other squadmate (don't take Mordin just because his mission's on Tuchanka too, he's useless here), must fight a Thresher Maw. Similar to ceremonies held by Vikings and other civilisations forged by blood and steel, taking on a maw is a ritual to become a man of the tribe. Completing it not only makes Grunt loyal, it finally makes him a real Krogan.

This mission made you feel like you really were Krogan. Which will have to do until they add playable races.

1. Tali - Treason

There is no mission that quite typifies what Mass Effect loyalty missions are about like Treason. It’s the polar opposite of Grunt’s battle with the Thresher Maw, but that variety is what makes the game great.

Advertisement

Beginning with a court proceeding (which is still the best use of the Renegade/Paragon mechanic to date), the mission soon turns into a close examination of Quarian customs. Even aside from the cult of Talimancers, the Quarians are often considered BioWare’s most fascinating race.

Finding out more about them in such a tightly wound scenario is riveting, especially as we truly see Tali’s evolution here. Meek and shy in the original game, it’s clear from the moment we meet her on our first Cerberus mission that she’s a changed woman. This mission digs into the why, managing to be both micro and macro at once. Yes, the mission is about the machinations of the Quarian people in its widest sense, but at its heart it’s about Tali defending the honour of her late father.

It’s this contrast that makes the mission stand above the others. Of any side mission in any game, Treason stakes a credible claim at being the best ever.

Advertisement