FIFA 13 vs PES 2013: 4 Reasons Why PES 2013 Will Win The War

WhatCulture runs down four reasons that PES 13 will win the war against FIFA 13, and one reason it just might not.

By Michael Atkinson /

Advertisement
In the next couple of weeks, the biggest footballing feud since Joey Barton took to his Twitter to wage a war on Mike Ashley will kick off for real when the twin football gaming behemoths of FIFA 13 and Pro Evolution Soccer 2013 (or PES 13) are released within just a week of each other. In the past couple of months that feud has been very openly fueled by PES Team Leader Jon Murphy taking to the press to criticise the work and practices of his major developer rivals, with EA Sports remaining typically tight-lipped on the matter. Both gaming companies have been promising that this year's additions to the franchises will be big developments on last year, with gameplay changes for both titles as well as aesthetic and presentation ones thrown in for the usual visual shake-ups, and that can surely only spell positives for football gaming fans. So, which game do we buy? The decision to release both games at almost the same time actively encourages the development of a direct rivalry, as if both Konami and EA Sports are keen to split fans, when they could both potentially enjoy increased sales by purposefully avoiding one another on the open market. But then, the football game market has been a duopoly for some time now, and it's unlikely those fans who shout either way for their favourite football game would ever go over to the dark-side. A lot of bad blood had passed between those fans, and a lot of damaging words have been said. Whilst it has been a number of years since Pro Evo has outshone FIFA in all aspects except an official licence, and (cough) sales, the arrivals of the demos this year have made me question myself once again. Do I go with FIFA, with which I have spent so much time these last three to four years? Or do I go with Pro Evo, my old friend who appears to be on the road to recovery after his stint in rehab? Put those knives down, but I think I'm going home to Konami. And here follows my 4 reasons why PES 2013 will be better than FIFA 13.

4. It's New

Advertisement
For the first time in years it feels like I'm playing a new football game. FIFA has been excellent through these last three versions, and the tweaking throughout the series resulted in the best version yet last year, particularly with the defensive improvements that added a certain intelligence to the game. However, the leap in quality with Pro Evo (please remember I'm using only the demos as a basis) this year is huge. Whilst FIFA feels very similar with only the apparent introduction of increased speed and new player animations, the brains at Konami have taken improvements from the work in progress that is PES2012, and made something that is both exciting and functional. That's not a negative - there are so many ideas involved here that to get them working together is a great thing. By the end of last season I'd almost stopped playing FIFA entirely, I find the single player mode a slog thanks to regimented defensive lines and poor attacking AI, much like in this demo - despite what others are saying about the newly revamped features. And online play had become as much about repetition as it had about Napoli. In short, it felt a lot like the game had gone as far as it could as players found the ways to exploit the game's programming. This year, it's not that much different.

3. Player Movement

Advertisement
This was it, the clincher in my argument for years when discussing Pro Evo's superiority. Bold claims about official licenses mean nothing when your full-back has no concept of over-lapping, I said. And I always knew I'd be proved right. FIFA has greatly improved over the years but when the two games are compared side by side, there really is no competition. The genius of Pro Evo is that the players seem to make mistakes and find themselves out of position (albeit too often in defence), and it's this irregularity that keeps the game exciting, the player always thinking, trying to create and exploit weaknesses, and if that goes wrong you can always blame the player, and not yourself. This blame-tactic made the Pro Evo career modes that little bit more enjoyable as players were encouraged to form an attachment to the players and their various foibles. FIFA's tedium is partly due to a system based on speed and whether the player is stupid or not. It lacks nuances that vary a striker's movement, or whether the centre midfielder should drift out wide to allow the full-back to cut inside. It does feel like I'm embellishing the differences somewhat, but it stems from an overall feel. One of fluid football, and one of Stoke. And again, there can only be one winner in those stakes as well.

2. Ball Physics

Advertisement
Welcome to part two of my €œPro Evo debate winners€. The issue of ball movement. The ball movement in Pro Evo allows for a randomness that I've already touched upon. Misplaced passes are more frequent here and perhaps this is the key to out of position players, caused by a willingness to attack they leave themselves exposed when the move breaks down. The variation in long to short balls is greater with PES too: sometimes catching defenders flat-footed as the ball sails over their heads or simply running out for a throw in as the winger misjudges the bounce. It adds a sense of unknowing and that in turn creates greater excitement. Both games however do suffer from a tendency for the player to be able to pass-pass-pass-pass to the forwards without much problem, but I just feel the erratic ball movements - particularly when in flight - adds that extra dimension for PES. The predictability factor is clearly something that EA Sports have worked on this year, but still, based on the demos, PES still has that edge.

1. Graphics

Advertisement
Now, the graphics argument is all dependent on taste when comparing the two titles. Pro Evo has a much sharper edge when comparing players and this makes them stand out, particularly in the beautiful designed replays (of which there are actually too many) and with close-ups considering the crowd look flat and frightened. FIFA on the other hand has a more rounded feel and the generated world they play seems to all fit together - nothing jarring here. There is one comparative issue though - and it's the one that hands victory to PES here - and I think it stems from EA's idea that dynamic lighting is a good thing. It happened in Madden 13, and it's happening here: the bright is too bright and the shadows are too dark. Sure, it makes everything more vibrant, but compared to Pro Evo's more reserved tones, it makes FIFA less realistic. The sun is not located somewhere behind the Etihad stadium in Manchester, so please, tone it down. Click next to reveal the one reasons FIFA 13 might emerge triumphant in the battle of the football games this year...

But... I Might Be Wrong

Advertisement
There is one aspect of the demos that might make FIFA the more enjoyable of the two footballing games however. And that is the art of scoring goals. FIFA feels like it has a weight to it: goals feel like they hit the back of the net and the feeling that gives is greater than scoring in Pro Evo, so much so that I imagine Arsene Wenger prefers Pro Evo. After all, why would you ruin a good move with a goal when the result is so understated? All joking aside, that is actually a major flaw: the entire point of the sport is the one thing that Pro Evo fails to deliver on. It might even be the lack of commentary on the demo that manages to dilute the reaction as the goal goes in, but I doubt it. It could also be a result of the ball physics I'd praised earlier and the weightlessness that provides, but there's certainly something not quite right. Also, the manipulation of shots is poorer than FIFA's more controlled approach. That might not be a major issue for some gamers, but to me, in the end it all feels very The Tortoise and The Hare. So, what do you think football game fans? Will PES 2013 or FIFA 13 emerge as the better of the two games? What are your thoughts based on the demos already released? Share your thoughts below.