FIFA 14: 10 Over-Rated Players Who Need Downgrading In January Updates

By Sam Heard /

To err is human.

Alexander Pope

Advertisement
No one can always be right. We are all human and we all make mistakes; even the egg-heads at EA Sports who year-in-year-out bring us the best football simulation game on the market. In a sport that inspires so much passionate support worldwide, it's inevitable that one of the most vehemently debated areas in each year's instalment of Fifa is what the developers choose to give the players for their rating. Each year Ronaldo's devout supporters will belly-ache about how he should be Messi's equal (or more,) Neymar nuts will moan about why he isn't faster than Theo Walcott and trolls will argue that Emile Heskey should have a rating of 93. Some people can't be right at all. Every year a contingent of players on FIFA will stand out as having been given an unfair rating - whether it is overly generous or under-stated, and this year is no different. This is the reason EA release a patch in January to amend these questionable player ratings based on recent form, though EA do seem to only update players positively as a general rule. Here we take a look at the 10 Overrated Players Desperately Deserving of a Downgrade...

10. Stevan Joveti‡ (Man City) - 84

At this halfway point in the season it's fair to say that the Montenegrin international is having a tough time of it at Manchester City. Since his big money move to the Premier League, he has racked up only 3 league appearances and has failed to score a single league goal in a team which has the highest scoring record in the Premiership. Having only picked up the 24-year-old last summer in a deal worth more than £20m, the once promising prospect has turned out to be a fair sized flop, following in the unfortunate trend set by other over-priced City players. But then, they can probably afford a few. With fellow City newcomer lvaro 'Beast' Negredo having already racked up 18 goals but being rated a meagre 83, there can be no question that Joveti‡'s rating needs to be re-evaluated.

9. David Villa (Atletico Madrid) - 83

Advertisement
I'm sure we all remember the days of Fifa 12 when David Villa was rated 89 and was one of the most dynamic players in the game. Two years and a broken tibia later and David Villa isn't the same world beater he was back then, explaining his release from Barcelona at the end of last season. In the past Villa was famed for his ability to strike impeccably with both feet as well as his brilliant attacking positioning. Though this season he has returned to form somewhat having scored 10 goals for Atlético Madrid, his rating of 83 puts him level with Brazillian team mate Diego Costa who has scored an amazing 23 goals in 23 appearances. It seems clear that the powers-that-be at EA cannot unforget his incredible years at Barca and give him a more realistic rating, especially in line with a boost for Diego Costa.

8. Iker Casillas (Real Madrid) - 86

Advertisement
Not so long ago, Casillas was not only the final line of defence to what was one of the best club teams and the best international side but was also considered to be the world's best goal keeper. Cut to 2014 and Real Madrid have been superseded by Bayern Munich, the Spanish national team are well on the decline and Casillas has been dropped to the bench. Casillas' fall from grace started last season when then-manager Jose Mourinho dropped him to the bench to be replaced by in-form Diego Lopez but this wasn't to be the end of Caillas' ill-fate. This season he hasn't picked up any league starts for his club and has only played 9 times in European and Cup contests, which is a telling indication of his status at the club now. The lofty rating of 86 puts him on par with Bayern Munich's Manuel Neuer, and feels like it's based more on past glories than current ability. After all, it's not a tough decision which you'd want on your fantasy team...

7. Mario Gomez (Fiorentina) - 85

If Mario Gomez was truly an 85-calibre striker why on earth would Bayern €“ who have a scarce selection of forwards as it is €“ release him to Serie A side Fiorentina? That's not to say that Gomez is not a quality striker: he has appeared just three times in the league for Fiorentina due to a persisting injury and has scored in two of these games. However, a rating of 85 ranks him as one of the best strikers in the world, level with the likes of Karim Benzema, Marco Reus and Ezequiel Lavezzi. In his heyday a few years ago at Bayern his name would belong among these current superstars but as it stands Gomez ability does not warrant 85. Thankfully for Fiorentina, Italian-American forward Giuseppe Rossi is making up for Gomez's absence and then some.

6. Hulk (Zenit St Petersburg) - 85 (Inform)

A few seasons ago no one was singing the praises of Hulk louder than me. I would ramble on about his ridiculously explosive pace, ox-like strength and howitzer of a left boot. In 2013/2014 I am forced to retract these statements: Hulk's decision to follow the more lucrative contract rather than seeking to play at the highest level has definitely damaged his stock. Despite scoring a reasonable amount for Zenit, with all due respect the standard of football in the Russian Premier league isn't as high as other European leagues. In the Champions League games where they faced harder competition Zenit had some embarrassing results including a 4-1 loss to Austria Vienna. Hulk has also had personal issues with the management which has even lead to arguments erupting on the pitch. Whilst it would be silly to say Hulk's career is done at this stage, giving him an 84-rating (and 85 inform) to put him level with his countryman Neymar is ridiculous.

5. Nemanja Vidic (Man Utd) - 86

Though this season he has actually been getting some regular football for the first time in 3 seasons following an on-going knee injury, it is impossible to say that the Serb is worthy of his 86-rating, which puts him level with Vincent Kompany as the best centre back in the Premier League. When Kompany is on the field for City there is a palpable sense of security at the back €“ indeed their clean sheet percentage with the big Belgium on the field is vastly higher compared to when he is not; in contrast, Manchester United in recent times have looked disorganised and lacking confidence defending, and with Vidic at the helm of this defence it is impossible to say he should be rated this highly. Man Utd's fall from grace this season (in comparative terms) has been based on defensive frailties, and it seems only fair that that should be reflected in the game.

4. Gerard Pique (Barcelona) - 86

EA are often criticised by fans for overvaluing Barcelona as a squad in recent years. Of the Catalan team, no player stands out as being more overrated than centre back Gerard Pique who is a far-cry from the player he once was. As a team, Barcelona don't do well defending - their strategy is to dominate the possession so that the opposition don't ever have the chance to organise a fluid attack. On the few occasions when they are caught on the back-foot, Barcelona do not look great and Pique is at the heart of this shaky defence. In the last significant international game he was involved in at the Confederations Cup final back in August Pique was embarrassed by the boys from Brazil leading to the once internationally dominant Spain taking a 3-0 pounding. Putting him level with Vincent Kompany is laughable.

3. Ashley Young (Man Utd) - 80

Ashley Young seems to be adored by the FIFA developers. Perhaps he has relatives in high places, perhaps the £130,000 he makes every week means he has the expendable income to grease a few palms for his own pride. In any case, there can be no denying that since joining United Young has been one of the most consistently overrated players in the FIFA franchise. Even though his rating has already been reduced to 80 this is still overly generous. Despite finally scoring his first league goal since 2012 this season, Young is still unrecognisable from the prodigy who used to tear it up at Aston Villa. Nowadays he has built up a reputation for being a speciality diver, capable of tricking a penalty from even the stingiest of referees. Unfortunately diving and/or acting skills are not categories which contribute to a player's rating so there can be no denying that even 80 is too high.

2. Erik Lamela (Tottenham Hotspur) - 81

Of the numerous signings Spurs made off the back of their record breaking sale of Gareth Bale, none generated more excitement than Erik Lamela, on whom Spurs set a new transfer fee record of £30m. Lamela had built up a reputation for himself in Serie A-club Roma for being a creative attacking midfielder with exceptional dribbling skills; he was even thought to be the man who would fill the big gap left by Bale. Perhaps with all this expectation it was inevitable that Lamela would disappoint; however no one anticipated quite how underwhelming he'd be. He has scored only one goal all season and even this was against Europa League whipping-boys FC Sheriff. What's worse, he can be chronically inactive. His rating would suggest he's superior to dependable Spurs players like Lenon (79), Holtby (79) and the criminally underrated Townsend (76) which clearly he isn't.

1. Samuel Eto'o (Chelsea) - 83

There was once a time when there would've been uproar about this rating of Eto'o being far too low. Sadly, this would've been back in the days when Liverpool were capable of winning a Champions League title, when you could still light up a cigarette in a bar without fear of incarceration and when Crazy Frog had its mind-numbing run in the UK charts. Though it would be an insult to insinuate that Eto'o isn't one of the greatest strikers ever and perhaps the greatest African player to have kicked a ball, I'm sure even Eto'o wouldn't deny that he's well past his prime. Eto'o used to be a player defined by his blinding pace and killer instinct. This season at Chelsea Eto'o has seemed extremely hesitant (2012/13 Torres-esque) and has lost the speed which once allowed him to embarrass even top-level defenders. It is very difficult to rate a player at 83 who Martin Tyler recently accused of looking "amateurish". Which players do you think deserve a downgrade in FIFA Ultimate Team's january update? Share your own thoughts below.