FIFA 14: 9 Ratings EA Have Got Horribly Wrong

By Joseph Dempsey /

a new trailer was released for the popular football simulation game, as we enter the last furlong before its release. And, in a little over two days, EA are set to release the official demo (Tuesday 10) giving fans a first taste of the action. As if that wasn't enough, EA have ramped up anticipation for FIFA 14 even further by unveiling a list of the highest-rated players in-game. A list of the top 50 players has appeared online and it's fair to say there are a few surprises here and there. One thing that won't surprise you is that the list consists predominantly of Real Madrid, Barcelona and Bayern Munich players, while Lionel Messi is No.1 with a rating of 94. But how do the Premier League teams fare? Chelsea have four players in the top 50, Arsenal have two players making up the elite shortlist, and Manchester City have five stars rubbing shoulders with the greats. As always, these ratings will become a bone of contention among fans, and here, we take a look at 9 ratings we feel EA got horribly wrong.

Advertisement

9. Luka Modric Rated 85?

Real Madrid enjoyed a reasonably successful season last term, finishing as runners up to Barcelona in La Liga and reaching the semi-finals of the Champions League. It won't surprise you then that Los Blancos have eight players making up the top 50, with a certain Cristiano Ronaldo being voted the second best player on the game just behind Lionel Messi. One thing that might alarm you however is the decision to award Luka Modric a rating of 85. The Croatian had a dreadful campaign last season, scoring just three league goals in 33 appearances and subsequently being voted by Spanish media as one of the worst signings of the season following his arrival from Tottenham. Yet somehow, EA figured he's just as good as Karim Benzema and Thomas Müller. Inexplicable.

8. Nemanja Vidic Rated 87

Another rating that raised our eyebrows was Nemanja Vidic being afforded an 87. The big Serbian has been a loyal servant to Manchester United down the years and has won five Premier League titles and the Champions League. However, a spate of injuries has limited the 31-year-old to just 28 league appearances since the start of the 2011-12 season, and there's no way he's an 87. That rating, astonishingly, puts him on a par with the likes of Edinson Cavani and Gareth Bale (a little more on him later) and sees him given a higher rating than Vincent Kompany. EA got this one badly wrong. There may have been a time where an 87 for Vidic would have been met with acceptance, but those days are long gone.

7. Wayne Rooney Rated 87

Another rating which makes that afforded to Nemanja Vidic seem all the more laughable is the decision to hand his teammate Wayne Rooney an 87. Unless we're expected to believe they're both as good as each other. In actuality, neither of them deserve such a lofty evaluation in FIFA 14, for both have been off the boil for quite some time now. Rooney especially, after the England international endured such a miserable campaign last season that he almost walked out on the club for domestic rivals Chelsea. "Wazza" was forced to play in midfield with now-retired manager Sir Alex Ferguson preferring Robin van Persie up front, while he was also dumped to the bench for a key Champions League game. There are many who believe we've already seen the best from the 27-year-old - Not EA, apparently, who rate him just as good as Juan Mata, Gareth Bale, Mesut Ozil and Edinson Cavani.

6. Luis Suarez Rated Only 33rd In Top 50

It can also be argued that Liverpool's Luis Suarez received something of a raw deal in this year's player ratings. The 26-year-old is considered only the 33rd best player in the game, that's despite the fact he was the Premier League's second-highest goalscorer last season - more than Gareth Bale, who is considered one point better off. The decision to hand Suarez an 86 makes a little sense when you take into account the fact he can't play until later this month due to his suspension for biting Chelsea defender Branislav Ivanovic, but even then the decision to underrate him seems a little ridiculous. Off-the-field antics shouldn't be accounted for and his mantle as a world class player cannot be diminished. Suarez was behind only Robin van Persie in the Premier League goalscoring charts last season, yet the Dutchman is considered a whole 27 places better off.

5. Iker Casillas Being Rated As Good As Neuer

Another rating that had us scratching our heads was the decision to rate Real Madrid's Iker Casillas at the same value as Bayern Munich's Manuel Neuer on 86. This decision really doesn't stand up in the face of logic, particularly when you consider Casillas isn't even getting in the Madrid team right now. The Spain No.1 has been displaced at the Bernabeu by Diego Lopez and has yet to play a single La Liga game for the Spanish giants this season. He was also dropped last season by former Madrid boss Jose Mourinho in favour of Lopez, and only made 19 league appearances. Meanwhile, Neuer won the Bundesliga, DFB-Pokal, DFL-Supercup, UEFA Champions League and UEFA Super Cup with Bayern, yet still isn't worthy of edging out Casillas in the rankings, apparently. That's despite the fact Casillas won nothing with Madrid last season.

4. Robert Lewandowski Rated Only 35th In Top 50

Another player who drew the short stick in this year's player ratings is Borussia Dortmund striker Robert Lewandowski. Despite the Polish international enjoying a tremendous season that saw him become the first player in history to score four goals in one game against Real Madrid, subsequently firing his side into the Champions League final, Lewandowski is considered only the 35th best player in FIFA 14. There are an incredible 31 places between him and Radamel Falcao, despite the fact the latter scored two fewer goals and didn't make any impact on European football. It's perplexing that EA rate Lewandowski a worse player than Carlos Tevez and fractionally better than Ashley Cole.

3. Gareth Bale Rated Only 17th In Top 50

Gareth Bale, double PFA Player of the Year winner, third-highest goalscorer in the Premier League last season, Tottenham's top scorer, and, recently, world's most expensive player. His rating on FIFA 14? 87. That makes the Wales international only the 17th best player in the list of 50 greats unveiled by EA, which comes as something of a surprise. Particularly when you compare him with fellow 87'er Juan Mata - whom Bale saw off at the PFA Player of the Year Awards - as well as the aforementioned Wayne Rooney. Perhaps more galling of all is that Nemanja Vidic also shares a rating of 87, and, when you look a little higher up the list, you see that David Silva and Arjen Robben are considered better players.

2. Neymar NOT In The Top 50

There are, typically, some high-profile strikers making up EA's Top 50 list, with the likes of Robin van Persie, Lionel Messi, Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Falcao cracking the top 10. But there is one notable omission in Neymar, scorer of 43 goals in 47 appearances last season and Barcelona's latest top signing. The prodigious 21-year-old goal-machine has been tearing South American football apart over the past four years, thumping in 136 career goals to date, and is widely tipped to shine for Barca this season and Brazil at next summer's World Cup. And so EA's decision to completely overlook him is staggering - Thomas Müller, Sergio Busquets, Pedro and Marco Reus are not more worthy of a spot on the fringes of the top 50 than Neymar. It's also incomprehensible that EA consider Luka Modric a better player, all things considered, and Neymar's omission from the top 50 really is shocking.

1. The Valuation Of Ronaldo & Messi

Naturally, the two players widely accepted as the greatest footballers on the planet make up first and second place on EA's Top 50 list for yet another year. There's no disputing that either of them are worthy of their place having scored an eye-watering 115 goals between them last season alone. They also helped their respective teams reach the semi-finals of the Champions League and finished 1st and second in La Liga. But that's not to say there aren't any bones to pick here. Messi is rated 94 and Ronaldo 92 - meanwhile, back in third place, Franck Ribery is at 90 - are we really expected to believe the difference between Messi and Ronaldo is the same as the difference between Ronaldo and Ribery? There's no way Ribery can be considered only marginally worse-off than Messi, either. If you're going to make Messi and Ronaldo stand out as the two best players in the game, surely it would make sense to afford them ratings of, say, 97 and 95 and leave the likes of Ribery on 90? There simply cannot be that dearth of difference between first, second and third place. FIFA 14 player ranking €“ Top 50: 50. Thomas Müller 85 49. Sergio Busquets 85 48. Pedro 85 47. Marco Reus 85 46. Eden Hazard 85 45. Arturo Vidal 85 44. Mats Hummels 85 43. Luka Modri‡ 85 42. Karim Benzema 85 41. Ezequiel Lavezzi 85 40. Santi Cazorla 85 39. Jesús Navas 85 38. Petr Œech 85 37. Xabi Alonso 85 36. Ashley Cole 85 35. Robert Lewandowski 86 34. ngel Di María 86 33. Luis Suárez 86 32. Manuel Neuer 86 31. Cesc Fàbregas 86 30. Sergio Ramos 86 29. Gerard Piqué 86 28. Mario Gomez 86 27. Carlos Tévez 86 26. Vincent Kompany 86 25. Giorgio Chiellini 86 24. Yaya Touré 86 23. Andrea Pirlo 86 22. Iker Casillas 86 21. Gianluigi Buffon 86 20. Edinson Cavani 87 19. Juan Mata 87 18. Mesut –zil 87 17. Gareth Bale 87 16. Thiago Silva 87 15. Nemanja Vidi‡ 87 14. Philipp Lahm 87 13. Wayne Rooney 87 12. David Silva 88 11. Sergio Agüero 88 10. Bastian Schweinsteiger 88 9. Arjen Robben 88 8. Zlatan Ibrahimovi‡ 89 7. Xavi 89 6. Robin van Persie 89 5. Andres Iniesta 89 4. Falcao 90 3. Franck Ribéry 90 2. Cristiano Ronaldo 92 1. Lionel Messi 94 What did you make of EA's Top 50 Player Ratings? Did they get it right or were you left scratching your head at their choices? Let us know in the comment section, below.