FIFA 18: 10 Fan Demands EA Sports Must Include
Can we see the back of those unstoppable scripted CPU goals, EA?
EA have announced none other than Cristiano Ronaldo as the cover star for FIFA 18. That's great, but there are one million and one other things the developers must also sort (beyond box art appeal) if 18 is going to be that killer experience every video gaming footy fan hopes it will be.
FIFA has always been a tightly scripted sort of game, the kind that favours dramatic last-minute wonder goals over dull 0-0 draws. The problem with that is football can sometimes be drab, but EA forego realism for writing matches between the likes of Scunthorpe and Hull as akin to Champions League finals.
That just won't do, because EA need to get real and consider the more measured approach to football. Whilst they're at it, having a quick look at referees, player customisation and fleshing out one of the game's most cherished modes wouldn't go amiss either...
10. Greater Attention To Detail Off The Pitch
A quick look at the official trailer for FIFA 18 reveals that those in-stadium crowds are finally getting a much-needed overhaul. At least, that appears to be the case if EA's own 'in game footage' boast from the video is true. If not, then they should seriously consider revamping those fans.
Greater attention to detail away from the pitch in general would be nice. We get that a lot of teams won't have their own stadium fully digitised for our enjoyment, but why not add some splashes of colour relative to the side in question for default grounds. Better, EA could even dot club badges around the place to lend a more authentic feel.
Aside from stadiums, it's time ball boys, police and security staff didn't look like painted-on puppets with around 10 pixels between them. No, this sort of thing isn't top of the priority list, but it would add more immersion into FIFA's world. That's what the game is all about, right?
9. Fresh Commentary Teams (Or At Least A Choice)
How many times can players be expected to hear Alan Smith wax lyrical about the first time he played against Leicester after moving to Arsenal from The Foxes? That insight is deep and meaningful, yet loses any and all impact after the 100th repeat. Commentary overall requires a bit of thought from EA.
Martin Tyler and Smith have been fantastic since taking over the commentary team reins in the series, there's no denying that. As much as that's true though, it would be sweet to see other duos get a shot, if for no other reason than to mix things up a bit. Sky Sports and BT Sports don't have the same set of narrators, y'know.
Clive Tyldesley and Andy Townsend are available for international matches, but that's about it. Change that, EA, because we want to use them across the board and keep our ears listening.
Creating in-exhaustive commentary that doesn't repeat is likely impossible. Things would be a lot less problematic for EA then if players were able to pick from multiple commentary units, with maybe even some Scots or Irish voices to add extra flavour.
8. A Revamped Creation Centre
Older FIFA fans will recall being able to create their own teams and players in bygone titles via the Creation Centre. Like Wayne Rooney's hairline, that's a feature in dire need of a comeback, because such player customisation is key to pretty much any sports title in 2017.
It's slightly understandable (yet totally annoying) why EA don't allow gamers to tweak team strips or player appearances. They didn't spend all that money on licensing only for someone to decide that Man Utd would be better off playing in green, after all. Still, seeing some level of kit design personalisation would feel like a huge step.
Failing that, allow people to build their own clubs from scratch. We're talking stadium editors, strip design, logos, crests and more here. A revamped Creation Centre could be one of FIFA's best additions in years if handled properly.
WhatCulture FC, anyone?
7. The Ability To Switch Clubs At Will In Career Mode
One of FIFA's continuing burdens is the lack of player freedom in Career Mode. Ignore for a second all the other problems with the mode, because winning countless Champions League titles with a minnow only for big teams to shun your manager is tedious at best and insulting at worst.
Back in the old days of FIFA, players were given the chance to switch clubs at will come the end of the season. That has since been scrapped in favour of the dreaded 'Potential Job Openings' suite, a feature that seems totally random at times. One week, Arsene Wenger has left Arsenal and the board are seeking a new gaffer. The next, you're playing against the Gunners and there's old Arsene himself patrolling the technical area.
It's all wildly inconsistent, and becomes worse when in-game bugs make it practically impossible to move clubs. That's when gamers get bored, switch off or start a fresh career. There's no reward for doing well, and that must change in FIFA 18.
6. PlayStation VR Compatibility
It remains to be seen whether or not Sony's latest tech is a short-lived gimmick or not, but the PlayStation VR at least deserves a chance to show what it can do. Rumours are rife that EA will bring some sort of VR compatibility to FIFA 18, and that has to be considered an exciting prospect.
Imagine being able to see the pitch from new camera angles; sitting in the stands or taking pride of place in the director's box, your manager would be able to watch from afar. The whole thing just sounds enticing, although it would be a challenge to incorporate actual gameplay mechanics into VR.
Perhaps the best way to do this would be by gifting players control over the goalkeeper. Those old Move controllers could take the place of gloves (crudely, but they could) and allow gamers to dive around living rooms like Buffon in his prime.
It'd be a start, if nothing else, and remember how long EA took to develop the 'Be A Pro' feature.
5. The Old Set Piece System
Sorry, EA, but that new free kick mechanic is just awful. Whomever had the bright idea of taking control away from players and leaving set pieces in the hands of fate deserves a slap. In FIFA 17, curling a kick into the top right hand corner is clumsy and nigh-on impossible to achieve consistently even with the game's best dead ball specialists.
Penalties suffer too, albeit not as much as free kicks. There's promise in the directional/power arrow concept, but it'll require some work before the idea becomes one of FIFA's brightest. Those wobbly animations in the run up need to go as well, because they make footy's top stars look like they've never seen a ball before.
Bringing back the old set piece system would ironically feel like a step forwards. The old adage, 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it' is often overused, yet this is one example of the phrase's relevance. There was no need to change anything in the first place, EA, you were just looking for something to tamper with.
4. Actual Interaction With Real Managers In Career Mode
Seeing the likes of Pep Guardiola and Jürgen Klopp on the sidelines added to the sense of authenticity in FIFA 17. At the same time, diving into Career Mode made it clear that real-life managers were something of a missed opportunity for the game. Aside from looking the part, those fleshed-out tactical geniuses offered nothing.
Wouldn't it be cool to see some sort of realism in FIFA 18 when it comes to managers? For example, catching wind of Arsene Wenger finally handing in his notice at Arsenal and taking the hot seat at PSG or for the French national side sounds plausible, and it'd add so much more depth to the game.
If EA aren't comfortable tinkering around with management positions, then why not allow player-created gaffers to have more interaction with the likes of Jose Mourinho and Mauricio Pochettino? Building friendships or setting the scene for slow-burning rivalries like Mourinho vs. Wenger is what this should be all about.
3. More Human Feel To The Officials
This is a controversial one, but why should FIFA's referee and linesman teams be faultless robots who have 20/20 vision? Human error is a bigger talking point in the real game than ever before, so it's about time FIFA's officials got it wrong from time to time.
As much as it'd cause players to tear their hair out if their star striker definitely wasn't offside, the excitement levels would skyrocket should refs offer up contentious decisions aplenty. Ok, so this shouldn't happen all the time, because overkill would be bad, but once or twice here and there wouldn't hurt too much.
Officials in FIFA feel stripped of humanity, and that has to be revised. A general upgrade of differences between each referee and linesman set overall should do the trick, thus instantly capturing more of a real-world feel.
We want to shout at referees because they're wrong, not because in-game replays prove them to be right 100% of the time.
2. Gameplay That Relies Less On Scripting
Every FIFA devotee knows the drill: it's the last minute, you're 1-0 up at home to Stoke and under no pressure. Suddenly, Mark Hughes makes some sort of tactical switch that somehow baffles Jose Mourinho, and Marko Arnautović beats 8 of your players to slot home a screamer for the equaliser.
There was no stopping that one, and it's an altogether too familiar feeling. Cut down on this level of scripting, EA, because it doesn't happen during every single match. Sometimes teams are just crap and that's that.
Seeing less scripting to FIFA's action would be nice in 18. Those unstoppable goals that even the tightest of defences can't prevent shouldn't be popping up all over the place like it's 2012 and "Aguerroooooooo" has pounced on a hapless QPR backline to win the title.
Konami have the perfect balance in PES, so EA need to start taking notes on how it's done before FIFA becomes too much like a Hollywood script.
1. A Lengthier Tale In The Journey
The Journey showed so much promise last year, and there's clear potential for the story mode to be a winner for years to come. Alex Hunter's rags to riches story was the digital Roy Of The Rovers tale fans have wanted for ages, so it makes sense that EA will develop the feature further.
Hunter's story needs greater length though, because things felt just a little too brief in FIFA 17. If this is a continuation of The Journey, then international football, European glory and more await. E3's festivities even hinted that Alex could be leaving the Premier League completely and moving to MLS. Now that's interesting.
Whatever EA do decide makes sense for the story, length is key. If The Journey 2 is another short experience, then the mode may find it has more detractors than supporters. The development team really have to make sure that doesn't happen.
What else do you demand EA put in FIFA 18? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!