Five Years Later: 10 Things You Learn Replaying Batman: Arkham Knight

How does Rocksteady's divisive Arkham threequel hold up now that it's half a decade old?

By Alfie Seymour /

In today's culture, it's rare for a game to universally be expected to be excellent. High profile disappointments such as Watch Dogs and Anthem have created a culture where nearly every major game release brings with it some form of trepidation.

Advertisement

That didn't happen with Batman: Arkham Knight.

Having produced two of the best licensed games the medium had even seen with Batman: Arkham Asylum and Batman: Arkham City, gamers and critics alike were fully prepared for Rocksteady Studios to hit another home run with the finale to their Batman trilogy. The mystery surrounding the identity of the Arkham Knight, and the inclusion of a fully playable Batmobile meant anticipation was high.

Upon release however, the reaction was much more mixed. The Arkham Knight's identity was branded a predictable disappointment, and the Batmobile sections were widely derided for being dull and out of character for Batman. These issues, coupled with a disastrous PC port that was plagued with technical faults, resulted in a much more mixed reaction than the previous two games.

These ten observations come having replayed the game nearly five years later, removed from the euphoria surrounding the its original release, which revealed certain elements of the game which may have been overlooked or under-appreciated upon release.

10. The Game's Opening Is Fantastic

Rocksteady had the unenviable task of reintroducing players to a Gotham which had been rocked to its core following the events of 2011's Batman: Arkham City, in which the Joker was killed and a great portion of Gotham's criminal underbelly had been wiped out by Protocol 10.

Advertisement

Unlike previous games, which often threw the player directly into the shoes of Batman, Arkham Knight takes a slow-burn approach. The cremation of Joker's body with Frank Sinatra's I've Got You Under my Skin blaring subverts expectations, and was a clear departure from the beginning of previous games. The surprising jump-scare and mass panic in the diner, followed by the ominous introduction of Scarecrow, immediately establishes him as a looming threat across the city, and showcases this Scarecrow as a changed man from the Asylum.

The swelling score, coupled with the sense of vastness as the camera pans across Gotham, makes the unveiling of Gotham City and the rush of finally controlling Batman feel better than ever.

9. The Core Gameplay Is Flawless

Despite its shortcomings, there is no denying that Arkham Knight plays fantastically well.

Advertisement

Rocksteady were able to take the satisfaction of gliding, grappling and punching to astonishing new heights. Especially once the player has fully upgraded their grapnel gun, gliding around the city feels phenomenal as Batman is launched high into the air with every press of the right bumper. This, coupled with quality of life improvements, such as the ability to chain together grapples as you climb a building, makes traversing Gotham's skyscrapers just as thrilling as tearing through its streets in the seemingly indestructible Batmobile.

Both the hand to hand combat and invisible predator sections build on their already stellar framework to create best in their class experiences. Dropping into a room full of twenty goons and obliterating them with your bare hands is an experience unlike any other. Likewise, the introduction of the Fear Takedowns, as well as the myriad of gadgets on hand, allows the player to feel unstoppable as they terrorise increasingly large numbers of armed guards.

In a way, these combat and movement systems are so complete, that it poses the question of how future games can possibly build on them. Still, five years later, this combat system is among the best in all of gaming, and it is truly a testament to the Rocksteady's dedication to refining it, that a mechanic created in 2009 feels as fresh as ever.

8. The Graphics And Audio Remain Stellar

Despite not quite holding up to games such as Red Dead Redemption 2 and Death Stranding, it's a testament to the care with which Rocksteady crafted their version of Gotham that it has aged remarkably well.

Advertisement

Despite not even using the newest game engine available to them at the time (Rocksteady opted to keep using the third iteration of Unreal Engine rather than the fourth) the character models, lighting, and especially the rain effects are still of the highest quality.

What's more, the game's audio is comfortably the best in the series. The bone-crunching effects that ring out with every punch, kick and slam that Batman delivers makes you feel godlike as you decimate thirty men within seconds. The Batmobile, controversial as it may have been, sounds like a perfect blend between tank, sports-car and monster truck. As another example of Rocksteady's love and dedication for the Batman history, the downloadable Batmobiles have their sound tweaked to replicate those heard in the film, making them feel like authentic recreations rather than a re-skin.

As with all the Arkham games, the voice acting is stellar, with Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill as ever providing definitive versions of Batman and the Joker. The additions of Jonathan Banks as a worn-down Commissioner Gordon and John Noble as the menacing Scarecrow, coupled with Nick Arundel's haunting score, helps add to the feeling of playing a grown up version of the animated show

7. The Lack Of Quality Boss Battles Really Hurts The Game

The one area where Arkham Knight's gameplay disappoints is in the boss battles, with what few there are being ranging from fine to outright terrible.

Advertisement

Compare the battles with Deathstroke in Arkham Origins and Arkham Knight. Whereas Origins presents a battle between two masters of their craft in a constant game of one-upmanship, Arkham Knight's battle consists of the player doing their very best to avoid Deathstroke's tank while they take out the same tiresome Cobra drones they have fought the entire game.

Furthermore, rather than fighting the Arkham Knight, who is supposedly a physical equal to the Dark Knight, Rocksteady forces the player into uninteresting games of cat and mouse, and what amounts to little more than a standard predator encounter.

Rocksteady produced one of the best battles in recent memory in the fight with Mr Freeze in Arkham City, where the same attack would never work twice, yet Arkham Knight's boss battles feel like the antithesis of that philosophy, with most fights boiling down to beating up standard enemies before performing one special attack on the boss.

This lack of variety when fighting these key enemies robs the game of some of its best set pieces, and makes finally defeating these iconic foes feel underwhelming compared to previous games.

6. The Tank Sections Can Actually Be Enjoyable (In Small Doses)

One of the most widely derided aspects of the game upon launch, the Batmobile was what everyone knew they wanted until they got it. The combat sections were lambasted by fans for being out of character for Batman and the Cobra tank battles were singled out in particular for the boring, hit-and-run style they forced players into.

Advertisement

Somehow the concept of 'stealth' didn't translate very well to a giant rocket-firing tank.

However, what was overlooked was that the more standard battles featuring the unmanned drones were actually surprisingly enjoyable. Rocksteady did a good job of creating enough different enemy types to force the player to continuously change their tactics, and once fully upgraded, players were given a strong arsenal of weapons to use. The final battle outside the GCPD is one of the few moments in the game where it genuinely feels like you're taking part in the "war" Batman refers to at the start of the game. Taking out 10 enemies at once with your fully upgraded missile barrage truly does make you feel like you can take on the entire world.

Just the less said about those Cobra battles the better...

5. The Side Missions Are The Worst In The Series

Side missions were something the Arkham series always struggled with, as both Rocksteady and WB Montreal struggled to create missions which didn't just descend into repetitiveness.

Advertisement

Arkham Knight has the same issue, with interesting mechanics, such as the deep-tissue scanner from the Professor Pyg missions, being repeated until they simply feel tedious. What's worse is that classic villains such as Penguin and Two-Face are reduced to missions that have little in the way of character development or story, and instead force the player to repeat mundane tasks such as following Penguin's vans through the streets, only to lead to a simple combat encounter. Furthermore, defeating the various strongholds of the Arkham Knight's militia around Gotham results in a laborious grind in which every battle feels the same.

The most egregious of these is the mission featuring Hush, which took one of Arkham City's best lingering plot threads and reduced it to little more than a five minute quick time event. This is especially disappointing since Rocksteady showed a commitment fleshed out side missions in the events featuring Man-Bat and the Season of Infamy DLC, but decided to throw away one of its fanbase's most anticipated stories for the sake of a cheap surprise.

In the end, completing the side missions comes less from a desire to actually defeat the enemies, but more just to slog through them in order to unlock the game's final ending.

4. The DLC Picked Quantity Over Quality

Arkham Knight released before micro-transactions dominated gaming, where publishers would strap season passes to their game instead, itself a controversial practice as many questioned why this content wasn't on the disk to begin with.

Advertisement

Arkham Knight's season pass cost $40 when it was first released and promised players six months worth of content. While dressing up as Michael Keaton's Batman may invoke a brief period of nostalgia, the skins for everyone outside of Batman were fairly limited, and provide little other than a a brief visual novelty. What's more, the racetracks and challenge maps are enjoyable enough, but offer little to keep you engaged once you've acquired all three stars beyond climbing leaderboards.

The much-hyped story packs were the biggest disappointment, as they were barely thirty minutes long and featured little other than a few standard combat and predator encounters stitched together with a few lines of dialogue. Even the Batgirl storyline, which featured its own open world and self contained story, had things restored exactly to how they were by its conclusion. The desire to keep the game's ending ambiguous meant Rocksteady weren't willing to show players a proper glimpse into the impact of the game's events on its world and characters, resulting in limited storytelling capabilities.

The saving grace was the Season of Infamy expansion, which added four side missions which did everything the base game's couldn't. Mad Hatter's featured a nostalgic look back at the Rocksteady's Arkham trilogy, while Mr Freeze's character arc concluded in heartwarming fashion.

3. The Joker’s Presence Enhanced The Story

When Arkham Knight was released, players were looking forward to a game without the Joker as the lead villain. Having dominated the first three games in the series, fans were ready to move on from the Clown Prince of Crime, especially following his impeccable death at the end of Arkham City.

Advertisement

Therefore, when Arkham Knight was released, and players realised that the Joker was once again one of the key villains in the game, Rocksteady were criticised for falling back on a character many felt had run its course.

Removed from this sentiment however, one can see that the Joker's presence in the story serves as a twisted commentary on the consequences of Batman. Acting as Batman's own devil's advocate, Joker provides horrifying alternatives to everything the Dark Knight does, while also playing on Batman's guilt over his death.

Furthermore, Arkham Knight is able to provide the true showdown between Batman and the Joker which the Arkham series hadn't been able to provide up to this point (that terrible battle at the end of Asylum doesn't count), through a battle of wits between the two within Batman's mind. In this, Rocksteady expose the fear in the Joker that he was never able to overcome, a fear which Bruce exploits to finally put his greatest foe to rest.

No other version of the Joker was quite so fundamental to the character of their Batman as this one, and therefore he needed to have some part to play in the caped crusader's final stand.

2. The Arkham Knight Was Doomed From The Start

The Arkham Knight was destined to be a failure the moment Rocksteady decided that his identity would be a pre-existing character.

Advertisement

The identity of the Arkham Knight was the biggest mystery heading in the months before release. Fans came up with a host of names for the titular character's identity, from Damian Wayne to a robot controlled by Quincy Sharp. Unfortunately, Rocksteady went for the Jason Todd, the safest and most obvious choice to anyone who knew a thing about Batman. The flashbacks to Jason's torture at the hands of the Joker meant that his reveal towards the games conclusion comes as a shock to nobody except Batman himself.

Upon reflection however, the retelling of Jason Todd's story is well executed in isolation, and he was really the only character that made sense for the role within the boundaries of plausibility Rocksteady had set within their Arkham Universe.

The character could have been so much more though had Rocksteady been willing to actually make the Arkham Knight a wholly original character, something they were adamant it was in the build up to the game's release. By making the Knight a pre-existing character, Rocksteady worked themselves into a corner as the reveal could never have lived up to the impossible expectations they set.

1. The Ending Should Be Left Alone

To be clear, Arkham Knight is an excellent game.

Advertisement

Despite its flaws, anybody who has even a passing interest in the Dark Knight will find an enjoyable experience with an engaging story, a beautiful world and perfectly refined gameplay.

With that said however, it is clear that Rocksteady intended for this game to be the end of this Batman's story. Despite its ambiguity, there is still a sense of closure in the games ending - it is made clear that this Gotham no longer needs a Batman.

Across four games, this Batman has shown himself to be less interested in self-preservation and more with doing the best thing for Gotham. The loss of his identity was the last thing he had to give to Gotham, and now that it is gone, there is nothing else he can do for it, marking an appropriate end to his crusade. The game's emotional climax would be made redundant if the story were to continue, and it is clear from the ending that Rocksteady feel the same way.

Superman, anyone?

Advertisement