Gears Of War 4 Review: 7 Ups & 7 Downs

An entertaining but safe sequel.

By Jack Pooley /

The Coalition

After years and years of waiting, the first Gears of War game under a new developmental team, The Coalition, is finally here. It's also the first GoW title on the Xbox One, and while not without its myriad flaws, is at least another entertaining riff on the series' brutally violent, ultra-intense gameplay.

Advertisement

Hardcore fans in particular will find plenty to lap-up here, while casual players may be a little more measured in their praise, because after all, the ambition that one would expect from a generation-leaping Gears of War game really isn't here.

It is a difficult transition from old to new, and while one can see why this game shows awkward growing pains throughout, it at least promises that GoW5 will probably be a more confident and adventurous effort. If not, then rake them over the coals for their lack of effort.

Advertisement

Here are 7 ups and 7 downs from Gears of War 4...

Downs

7. JD Is An Incredibly Boring Protagonist

Microsoft

JD Fenix is, of course, the new protagonist of the Gears of War franchise, basically signalling something of a soft reboot for the series, taking place 25 years after the third game.

Advertisement

This is all well and good on principle, except for the fact that JD is one of the dullest player characters from any AAA video game in recent memory. His teammates Del and Kait are much more lively and memorable (not that they're exactly great either), while JD is a bland block of wood, and there's a giant chasm of charisma between himself and his father (made that much more glaring when Marcus himself shows up).

In short, he'll have you wishing you were just playing as Marcus instead, which feels extra awkward as he's clearly positioned here as the new protagonist for at least two more games. Buyer beware.

Advertisement

6. It's Too Familiar & Repetitive

The Coalition

Likely for fear of alienating the fanbase, The Coalition decided to play their first game as the gatekeepers of the Gears franchise incredibly safe, opting for an extremely simple rescue-shoot-rescue core objective, while largely just dining out on a Greatest Hits collection of the series' finest moments.

Advertisement

The campaign is a lazy, often uninspired slog that repeats the same formulaic set-pieces again and again: split your four-person team into two groups who take alternate routes, fend off two or three waves of enemies in a very Horde Mode-esque fashion, and basically take on the same recycled bullet sponge enemies again and again.

While multiplayer shows a little more innovation, it again feels like it doesn't go far enough, for though the eSports-baiting Escalation mode is a lot of fun, Arms Race is basically just Call of Duty's Gun Game rehashed, and Dodgeball isn't nearly as interesting as it sounds.

Advertisement

Though it seems likely that The Coalition's next game will probably take a few more risks now that they've laid a comfortable foundation, that's no reason to applaud such a blatantly low-effort overall product.

5. All The Cringe-Worthy Dialogue

The Coalition

This has been apparent ever since gameplay was first shown off, so at least fans had plenty of time to prepare themselves for it. While the move towards a greater incidence of humour this time around is certainly welcome, unfortunately the comedy often falls flat and is straight-up embarrassing to listen to.

Advertisement

The banter is full of bad puns and lame jokes, with Del proving the most unfortunate joker of the pack. What's more, there's an obnoxious attempt to lampshade the ropey writing by having the characters frequently draw attention to how silly the dialogue is, but self-awareness can only acquit you so far. It's still awful for the most part.

4. Yes, There Are Microtransactions

The Coalition

Prior to Gears 4's release, there was a lot of concern about the game introducing microtransactions by way of "Gears Packs", essentially randomly-generated loot boxes that contain new skins, characters, emblems and other cosmetic flourishes.

Advertisement

While, to Microsoft's slight credit, they did release a patch to lower the cost of these packs and increase the amount of credits earned, the whole tacky system is still thinly-veiled gambling, as people are encouraged to spend real-world money to maybe, just maybe, get the cosmetic items they want.

Sure, the market dictates demand and this model is clearly serving an audience, but it's still an incredibly gaudy monetisation model, and is weighed heavily in favour of encouraging people to spend real money (even with this patch fix), which given the already considerable RRP for the game itself, is aggressively anti-consumer.

Advertisement

3. All Those Glitches

The Coalition

Yes, glitches are par for the course when it comes to video games, but when a game releases with an 11GB day-one patch, you sure as hell expect that they're going to be mostly cleared up, right?

Advertisement

Well, playing GoW4's campaign on release day, it was clear just how unpolished the patched end product really is, with clipping being ludicrously abundant, especially whenever another character is carrying the fabricator (you can simply walk right through what is supposed to be a solid object).

Getting stuck in the environment or the camera jerking around violently also occurred occasionally, and for a series that prides itself on being slick and well-engineered, really makes this one feel surprisingly sloppy.

Advertisement

2. Act 3 Is Pure Filler

The Coalition

Don't worry: there won't be anything in the way of major spoilers here, but rest assured that Act 3 of GoW4 is one hell of a slog. It's the flabby mid-portion of the game as JD and co. are on a retrieval mission of sorts, but it just drags on...and on...and on, outstaying its welcome by a good 30-40 minutes, by which time you'll likely just feel exhausted.

Advertisement

The only real motivation to keep going is that the end goal is actually fairly interesting, but the overlong, repetitive frag-fest that gets you there is pretty much a distillation of everything lazy and unoriginal that this game has to offer.

Thankfully, once you get past Act 3, things pick up significantly ahead of the finale.

Advertisement

1. The Terrible, Abrupt Ending

The Coalition

Probably the most vocal complaint about GoW4's campaign so far is its ending, which comes incredibly suddenly, provides little in terms of internal resolution and simply throws up a dozen more questions largely in pursuit of selling Gears of War 5 to you.

Advertisement

A cliffhanger was definitely expected, but too was the hope that this game would conclude with a self-contained arc that felt complete and well-developed. Instead, once the final battle is done with, things close out with so much left hanging, when something more fleshed-out would've benefited everyone involved.

Sure, most people who bought this will probably buy Gears 5, but plenty more convincing ways to promote that game could pretty much be plucked out of thin air.

Advertisement

And now that we've got the criticism out of our system, here are 7 ups from the game...

Ups

7. It's The Best Looking Xbox One Game Yet

Microsoft

Gears of War 4 may feel like it's coasting gameplay-wise, but visually, it sure as hell isn't resting on its laurels, providing a substantial graphical upgrade from previous titles and truly making the most of what's under the Xbox One's hood (while if you've got a beefy enough PC, it looks even better).

Advertisement

Sure, there are a few low-res moments (the writing on doors looks rather muddy), and it's not quite up to the high standard of, say, Uncharted 4, but especially if you're lucky enough to own an Xbox One S and can take advantage of HDR, this is quite the eye-watering experience indeed.

6. Old Marcus Is Awesome

Microsoft

Surprise, surprise, but one of the best things about GoW4 is the re-appearance of Marcus Fenix. We won't spoil in what exact capacity he shows up, but it's safe to say that he has a solid role in proceedings, and gets more than merely a cursory cameo for the sake of fan service.

Advertisement

Seeing him aged 25 years is quite a sight indeed, but he's lost none of the spunk that made him so popular in the first place, and unexpectedly becomes the game's greatest source of riotous comic relief. Once you hear the guy raging about his tomatoes getting ruined by an impending enemy attack, it's hard not to be won over.

As for whether he could return for future games? Play the game yourself and find out.

Advertisement

5. Horde 3.0 Is Ridiculously Addictive

The Coalition

The one area of the game that feels the most innovated is Horde Mode, which introduces a clever class system that enhances strategy, while the appearance of a machine called a fabricator allows players to essentially print weapons and fortifications to fend off enemies.

Advertisement

If each player pulls off their class duties well, your five-man team will be a well-oiled machine and make it far before inevitably being cut down. At once Horde 3.0 gives the player the most control but also feels the most frantic and lightning-paced of the lot.

Don't be surprised if you find yourself devoting tens of hours to Horde Mode while basically playing the campaign once and never looking back.

Advertisement

4. The Bada** New Weapons

The Coalition

Demented weaponry has always been a major winner for the Gears franchise, and GoW4 is no exception. The most memorable new weapons are without question the Dropshot, which fires bombs towards enemies that detonate downward on top of them, and the Buzzkill, a saw blade-launcher which gives the player devastating and hilarious possibilities to rack up some sick deflection-based kills.

Advertisement

They're also potent weapons in the hands of your enemies, but if there's one disappointment here, it's that these two weapons in particular appear rather infrequently throughout the game, so make the most of them whenever you in fact see them.

3. Co-Op Is A Total Blast (Of Course)

The Coalition

Gears is one of those games that's just so much better played co-op, and having beasted through GoW4's campaign with a pal, it makes the sometimes ennui-inducing nature of the gameplay so much easier to tolerate.

Advertisement

The increasingly rare allure of couch co-op is alive here, even with co-op being scaled back to just two players, and even if the game clearly buckles a little under the technical requirements that co-op lays out (the frame-rate in particular takes a hammering during intense fire-fights), you'll be having so much fun you probably won't much care.

Yes, playing with a mate does make the game significantly easier than going in with AI buddies, but the sheer enjoyment factor is amplified many times over, which really makes it the effortlessly superior way to play.

Advertisement

2. The Original Set-Pieces Are Excellent

The Coalition

While so much of the campaign indeed leans back on the tried and tested shoot 'em up sequences of previous titles, there are a few extremely entertaining, original set-pieces that tease The Coalition's potential to seriously shake up the series.

Advertisement

While a motorcycle chase sequence is fun but basically on-rails, other scenes really elevate the cinematic feel, especially one named "The Great Escape" which won't soon be forgotten by any fan of the series.

When the scale and freneticism ramps up, this truly is a marvel of a game, even somewhat evoking the same jaw-dropping feel of something like Uncharted 4.

Advertisement

These moments are gems in the rough ultimately, but when they show up, they can rouse player interest significantly. More of this next time please, guys.

1. Fan Service Is Fun But Restrained

The Coalition

And finally, it would have been so easy for Gears 4 to be a relentless fan service-fest in order to ease the transition from Marcus to JD, but to The Coalition's credit, they actually take a much more restrained approach.

Advertisement

Yes, Marcus figures heavily in the game, but he's not overdone, and any references to other characters from the series mostly maintain their integrity rather than throwing it away in pursuit of a cheap moment of uproarious joy.

There's no medium more prone to overzealous fan-bait than video games, but titles like this opting for the more dignified approach provide some hope for the future.

Advertisement

What did you think of Gears of War 4? Shout it out in the comments!