GTA V: 5 Ways It Could Fail

It might be one of the biggest upcoming games, but what might Rockstar get wrong?

By Ryan Musker /

Advertisement
The hype behind GTA V is only growing, with screenshots, wishlists and "leaks" spreading like wild fire across the internet, and showing no signs of stopping. The game looks set to be the most anticipated of 2013 (or the end of 2012, depending on who you believe at this stage), and based on what we've seen so far, there's good reason for the excitement. But that doesn't mean the success of the game is a given - massive games like Modern Warfare 3 and even GTA IV ended up being comparative disappointments thanks to some problematic but completely avoidable issues, and we have to be wary of GTA V going the same way and failing to live up to the hype. So, what might GTA V get wrong? It is perfectly possible, and likely for even the most highly revered or well crafted game to have flaws, and no doubt GTA V will be close to, but not, perfect. So what are 5 ways it might totally screw up, and how could Rockstar avoid this crippling issues?

5. Driving

A common fan complaint about GTA IV was the driving mechanics. While I personally enjoyed it for the most part, some of the cars wanted to spin out and crash at the slightest bump. Even more annoying was how every vehicle felt heavy and even the most agile of sports cars handled like piles of bricks. How to fix it? Basically, lighten up a bit. It's that simple. GTA V could use GTA IV's next-gen physics in conjunction with a newer handling model that makes cars a bit more zippy and agile. And for the love of God, Rockstar, keep the camera on target, and not turning around erratically to distract the driver. Similarly, please lock the camera to the centre of the car, not to driver position, because that was really annoying.

4. The Writing

This is a less of a common complaint, and one that only popped up majorly when the DLC's launched. The writing of GTA IV featured insane levels of swearing, and while coarseness doesn't offend me personally, hearing F bombs so many times just gets boring and shows a lack of imagination. It also gives the impression that a 13 year old wrote the game, as there is simply no need to fill the script up with wasted words. If Rockstar go that way again, populating their underworld of criminals with limited and colourful vocabularies, it will be a huge shame. How to fix it? Simply, don't go that way. Max Payne 3 had a great script that still managed to have lots of swearing, yet remained mature and somewhat sophisticated. Not a single line was corny or out of place, and we really got a chance to see a deeper Max than we were used to. GTA V needs to be build a character story, not one about the various uses of the F word, despite how versatile it is.

3. The Story

Advertisement
This is likely the most important issue here. The story of GTA is always "guy moves into town, rises up, takes it over." GTA IV had a great story driven by character rather than plot, but I hope GTA V brings something a bit fresher and more creative to the table. The possibility of a protagonist having kids is a great one, as it is something that could give them a personal motivation and a reason to stop killing and stealing. That sort of complexity is something we haven't really seen before, and it's certainly something that might lead to a deeper and more engaging experience. How to fix it? Try to avoid using stereotypical characters, plot points and themes. Russians and Mafia mobsters? No, no, it's just not necessary to be so one dimensional. Cult groups and family stories? Yes, please. Rockstar needs to really give us something different to make the plot feel worthwhile rather than a reason for the game to progress, and while it wasn't a problem in GTA IV, it is possible that GTA V could suffer the same fate as some other more limited games of this year. And that would be bad.

2. Multiplayer

GTA IV had a fun but flawed online mode, and you've probably already read my ideas and wish list for GTA V's multiplayer. That game suffered crippling lag and online matchmaking issues, and getting kicked from lobbies back to the single player was just too frustrating. A problem in Max Payne 3's multiplayer, and a lot of third person shooters out there, comes when the developer try to throw too much depth in. Sadly, having mountains of customisation is pointless and overwhelming, and while having full player model customisation in GTA V would rock, we don't need perks and classes and similar flourishes. How to fix it? First, deal with the netcode. No more random cars spawing into air and matches suddenly disconnecting. Do not add more depth than necessary, and try to make it easy to understand. Adding a lobby, as seen in like every multiplayer game ever, would help to deal with the single player booting issue. And I would love to see the game kick out players who try to kick others by constantly spamming the button. Just get rid of the both of them, and be done with it.

Advertisement

1. Combat

Advertisement
A hot point of complaint about GTA IV was its cover and shooting mechanics: the aiming, even on the high setting, was slow and didn't give us fast enough response time and cover selection was often random and had us rolling halfway across Libery City when we just wanted to duck behind a car. Another gripe came with the hand-to-hand combat, but this has been discussed extensively already. The lock-on system often tried to target people behind us when an enemy directly in front of Niko was clearly shooting him. Not exactly very helpful. How to fix it? Try having more precision and control. More sensitivity settings, more precise cover actions and having the player move between cover points more. As for the hand-to-hand, I have no real solution other make the player move faster and don't make it suck, basically. The issue where you put your phone away when getting shot was frustrating as well, and a few stealth options wouldn't hurt. Give us more lock on options, like soft and hard lock, or just free aim, from Max Payne 3. And finally, make the characters move faster in combat, that awkward jog when leaving cover left us exposed for way too long. So there's just a few things GTA V might get wrong based on past and recurring issues. None of these would break the game fatally, but if they were dodged it would certainly help the overall quality and reception of the class. Either way, I'm frothing at the mouth for what Rockstar has in store for us in the coming months, and have faith in their abilities to craft a fantastic game. Let us know what you think. Should annoying friend activities be on the list?