If anyone were to ask me what my favorite video game series of all time is, I wouldn't think twice about my answer. Metal Gear Solid, to me, encompasses everything that is great about the video game industry. Hideo Kojima turned everything on its head when the original Metal Gear Solid was released for the PS1 back in 1998. Never before had anyone used the medium to tell a story in the way that Kojima did, and in my opinion no one has been able to top him in this area since. With Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain hopefully not too far off in the distance, I thought this would be a great time to look back at the main entries in the series and rank them. For this post, I will only be looking at the "Hideo Kojima Game" entries, meaning Portable Ops will not be here. I will also not consider the Twin Snakes remake of the original, as so much was changed from the original that it hardly resembles Kojima's original masterpiece. Also, you will notice that I did not say I would be ranking them from "Worst to Best", or anything like that, as I don't think any of these should ever be considered "Worst" on any list. Of course, there will also be major SPOILERS throughout, so be forewarned. And now, onto the rankings...
5. Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty
Ah Raiden, what fond memories we all have of the first time we met you. Or not. Metal Gear Solid 2 started out so great. I still remember the first time I saw the opening video of the stealth jump onto the tanker; the amazing effects of the rain falling onto Snake and the rest of the environment, the amazing animations, and the new gameplay mechanics we were given. I fought my way down into the bowels of the tanker, only to bear witness to a possessed Revolver Ocelot stealing the new Metal Gear Ray model, and seemingly drowning our beloved Solid Snake in the process. As the second act opens, we were greeted by the familiar voice of good old Colonel Campbell over the CODEC. However, the voice of our protagonist sure didn't sound like the Snake that we had grown accustomed to. The full reveal of Raiden wasn't made until he ascended up the supply elevator and removed his mask, but when it happened I think all MGS fans received a punch right to the gut. We just couldn't process what we were seeing on screen. For me, the sting lessened as the game went on, as we ended up working side-by-side with Snake, but it still wasn't the same. MGS2 is easily the most divisive of the entire series. From the protagonist switch, to the whining of Raiden throughout the many CODEC calls, as well as the incredibly intricate and sometimes very confusing plot, this game usually either tops someone's list when it comes to MGS, or falls to the bottom. There really is no in-between, it seems. I have found that MGS2 got more enjoyable with each play-through, and I really do appreciate what Kojima was doing with his engrossing story, but for me this comes in at #5 on my list.
4. Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
This may end up a little further down than some would agree with, but that's what is great about lists. Don't get me wrong, I thoroughly enjoyed Peace Walker; I absolutely loved the story as it gave us more of a glimpse into the eventual turn of Big Boss into the villain we would come to know in the original Metal Gear games. I do not own a PSP, so I was ecstatic when the MGS HD Collection was announced, as it finally gave me the opportunity to play this title that so many people raved about. As stated above, the story was really near-perfect and gave us more insight into the mind of the greatest soldier that ever lived. It was very emotional, as most MGS games are, as long as you can suspend disbelief enough to buy that an AI-controlled Metal Gear would drown itself to save Mother Base from being wiped out, to symbolically prove The Boss's innocence, as it was her "will" that was controlling the AI. Yes, that last sentence is quite ridiculous when taken at face value, but this is a Metal Gear Solid game after all. This did, however, give us the subsequent powerful exchange between Naked Snake and Kaz, where the title of Big Boss was finally accepted. Big Boss' betrayal, that he felt due to The Boss laying down her gun, really set in motion the path toward darkness we will bear witness to when MGSV is released. Because I don't own a PSP, the mission-based nature of the game was not something I saw as a positive. Missions that can sometimes take less than 5 minutes to complete don't really transition that well to a home system, and is in stark contrast to every other game on this list. Granted, I understand why the game was designed this way as it was originally a PSP game, but it is just not something that I personally prefer. While the introduction of co-op was a nice addition to the franchise, it sometimes seemed a necessity in order to actually beat the game. Admittedly, I could not get past ZEKE until someone jumped online to help me tag team it. The base building, team building, and assembly of ZEKE also was a letdown, as there were so many prerequisites you had to hit before you could actually get to the end of the game. To me, this really slowed down the pace of the game and caused it to actually drag a bit, which is not something I normally think of related to a Metal Gear Solid game. Had Peace Walker been designed for the PS3 instead of PSP, I think the gameplay style could have possibly bumped this all the way up to the top of my list. Alas, for me it sits at #4.
3. Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots
Cut-scenes, on top of cut-scenes, on top of cut-scenes. That's what people who hate on this game will complain about. My response to the complaint is simply this: what did you expect!? Did you really think that Kojima, master storyteller and cut-scene aficionado, would tie up the story of Solid Snake without an insane amount of them? There was just so much ground to cover and stories to tell that there was really no other way for MGS4 to turn out. This is definitely a game that seems to have soured in people's eyes over the years, which is evidenced by IGN not even including it in its latest Top 25 PS3 Games post. Not to mention that IGN is the same website that rated MGS4 a perfect 10/10 when it was released 5 years ago. I love IGN, and the work that they do, but to leave MGS4 off of a list of the best PS3 games is just asinine if you ask me. Another complaint was that the game was nothing but fan service, with so many loose ends being tied up, and so many nostalgic moments peppered throughout. How is this a bad thing? Kojima brought back essentially every character from the series that was still alive, turned Raiden from an effeminate whiny pawn into the new Cyborg Ninja, and gave us what is quite possibly my favorite moment in the history of gaming; the return to Shadow Moses in Act 4. By the time I finally got my hands on the game (I had been visiting my parents out of state the week it came out), I had gotten wind of the surprise that awaited me after the carnage on the Volta river. Even knowing what was in store, it didn't take away any luster from the actual reveal of Shadow Moses. I will never forget the feeling I had when I had evaded the Gekko, and fought through the snow storm to finally see an HD representation of Shadow Moses. With as big a fan as I am of the series, it quite literally took my breath away. When the flashback dialog started to play over certain sections of the map, it just took it to another level. The ending, which does last well over an hour, also serves as a point of controversy for many people. I, for one, was happy that Kojima changed his mind and allowed Snake to come out of the series alive. The ending sequence of forgiveness between he and Big Boss, as well as the revelation that FOXDIE was no longer turning him into a walking nuclear weapon was as perfect an ending to Snake's story as I could have hoped for. Obviously Snake is not a real person, but to know may favorite video game character is able to live out the rest of his life in peace makes me happy. Ending his life with a .45 in his mouth was not something befitting a legendary hero in my book. As much as I love this game, I couldn't place it any higher on my list than #3...
2. Metal Gear Solid
The one that started it all. There is so much to love about this game that it is impossible to cover everything. Metal Gear Solid actually rekindled my love for video games when I finally played it, for PC actually and not PS1. I remembered the original Metal Gear on NES, but I was never a big fan of it as a 9 year old. Sneaking around and trying to avoid combat never really piqued my interest, when I could pop Contra in and just start blasting aliens without abandon. MGS was different though, from the first time I laid eyes on it as my roommate in college had it for his PS1. When the PC version came out, I snatched it up, and immediately fell back in love with video games. Cinematic gaming didn't exist before Hideo Kojima brought us this masterpiece. Voice acting was normally barely passable in video games (see the original Resident Evil), and I can't think of any games that used the in-game graphics engine to portray cut-scenes in the way that Kojima did. There were so many little things that stood out and took the presentation to new heights. The snow falling when you stepped off the elevator was amazing at the time. Snake's breath was visible when he was outside, helping to portray the frigid Alaskan weather you were faced with. Not only would you leave footprints in the snow, as well as the sound of your footsteps changing in the snow, but if the guards spotted your footprints, they knew an unwelcome guest was in their midst. While I didn't know a great deal about the back story of Metal Gear, I was able to glean so much of it from the CODEC conversations with different characters. Then there were all the shocking reveals, along with the double and triple crosses; Liquid Snake and Solid were revealed to be brothers and clones of Big Boss, Master Miller was murdered by Liquid before the operation even took place, Liquid had been impersonating him the entire time, and instead of deactivating Metal Gear, Snake had actually activated it using the PAL cards. The best of them all, though, was the post-credits conversation between Ocelot and The President of the United States, who was actually a 3rd clone of Big Boss, and it set a precedent for the rest of the games in the series. Some think it is impossible to top what was done with the very first Metal Gear Solid, but to me there is one game that did it better.
1. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
I don't really know how to begin this, other than to call Snake Eater what I believe it to be. Gaming perfection. From the moment that Kojima first revealed the world of MGS3, it was clear that we were in for an all new Metal Gear experience. The era had changed to that of the Cold War, and the small confined spaces of Shadow Moses, as well as the Tanker and the Plant from MGS2, were being replaced with jungles full of flora and fauna. Kojima was going to get every ounce of power that he possibly could out of the PS2, before moving on to the PS3. The framerate wasn't as fluid as MGS2, but that was the only possible complaint one could have about the graphics and the presentation. The stealth mechanics had also been completely overhauled. With the game taking place in 1964, the gadgets at the disposal of Naked Snake would have to reflect the times. Our best friend, the soliton radar, was no more, and had been replaced by anti-personnel sensors, sonar, and motion detectors. The player now had to be much more aware of their surroundings, instead of simply relying on a vision cone on the map. You also now had camouflage at your disposal for the first time, and this was essential in order for you to sneak around the jungle and other environments. The other major additions were the "Food" and "Cure" options that would allow Snake to recover from injuries, as well as recovering his stamina by hunting and eating wildlife throughout his journey. The story here was the main reason that I think so highly of this game. Snake Eater struck the perfect balance between gameplay and cut-scenes and kept the game moving at a better pace than any of the other games in the series. We were introduced to a young and inexperienced Ocelot, whose character was in stark contrast to the mastermind we would end up seeing later in the chronology. The double and triple crosses from the original MGS were also on full display here, but the most important part of the story was clearly the evolution of Naked Snake into Big Boss. Big Boss was never thought of as anything other than a despicable human being, and a villain to end all villains before MGS3 came along. Kojima decided to tackle his origin story to show that this evil human being was once the ultimate soldier, who was loyal to his country no matter what the mission was that he was tasked with. We were able to live vicariously through Big Boss, and experience the betrayal and heartache that started him down a path that would lead him toward the darkness I explained back in my Peace Walker section. No matter how many times I play through Snake Eater, it is always so hard to press the fire button one last time, ending the life of The Boss at the close of their climatic final battle. I got chills the first time I watched the ending when Naked Snake was actually given the title of Big Boss, and still do to this day. I could go on and on about how much I love Metal Gear Solid 3, and why it is the best of the Metal Gear Solid series, but that is for another time. In a series filled with critically acclaimed games that will always stand the test of time, Snake Eater is the one that stands ever so slightly above the rest. So what do you think? Do you agree with my rankings? Please leave your comments and let me know what your favorite MGS is.