Overwatch: Ranking Every Cinematic Short (So Far)

How is there not an Overwatch movie at this point?!

By Motzie Dapul /

The Overwatch cinematic shorts may single-handedly be responsible for half the purchases of the game itself, and even more so their extensive merchandise sales. They unite gamers and non-gamers alike with their above and beyond storytelling prowess, and have people wishing for films and TV series as much as more levels or characters in the game.

Advertisement

Though Overwatch itself may be enjoyable and endlessly playable, it's Blizzard's sense of animation design and storytelling that makes its property so compelling, with nothing emphasising that sense more than their cinematic shorts. At first created to get people excited for the game, Overwatch has since released multiple stories in short film form, often to accompany a new event or map, but largely to expand on their complex story and lore.

With each short showing levels of artistry that rival Pixar, the astounding levels of quality, storytelling and emotional depth shows real mastery of the storytelling and world-building. Here are all of Overwatch's cinematics released so far, ranked from "least great" (because none of them are even remotely bad) to truly amazing.

11. Reunion

A stylish and deeply enjoyable piece, this ranks lowest on the list due to its lack of focus on its lead—fan-favourite hero, McCree. For all that fans were waiting for his animated debut, this cinematic seemed more interested in turning him into a vehicle for introducing other, less interesting characters.

Advertisement

Not to say it doesn't have its merits, however. The slick, stylish opening setting McCree up as the archetypal lone cowboy really sets the mood, along with its excellent soundtrack, and McCree's fight with his former friend Ashe and his former gang, Deadlock, was fun and well executed.

Even without giving McCree, the focus and backstory seen in the Retribution event cut scene, or his comic, Train Hopper, this short still showed what makes his character so compelling to fans, showing off his impressive abilities, cool ruthlessness, good humour, and inherently kindly spirit.

Ashe was a fun villain, though not nearly as threatening as Talon, and B.O.B. (Big Omnic Butler) was an adorable addition, rounding out Ashe's status as a playable character with something more unique than she presented alone.

All in all, while still being good, this short is on the low side of great. Still worth watching, though.

10. Cinematic Trailer

The OG short that introduced everyone to what Overwatch was really all about, this piece is clunky in places (for being the first and earliest of the animated shorts), but it was very effective in getting audiences excited for the game before it came out.

Advertisement

The main characters in the short very strongly resemble the brothers from Jurassic World, more or less filling the archetype of "teen brother who doesn't care that much and little brother who's endlessly enthusiastic and bright-eyed". The setup feels cutesy fun, almost saccharine, but the genuineness and good spirit of this cinematic shines through, especially with Tracer's final words to the boys:

"The world could always use more heroes."

The action in this short also excels, allowing people to get a sense of the characters, their skills, and personalities, and how colourful the world of Overwatch is. It also effectively establishes the lore and history of their world.

This short ranks a bit lower on the list for having more cliches and flatter portrayals of its characters, but that's to be expected in a game that was in its earlier stages, with a story that's being developed to this day.

9. Shooting Star

A fantastic character piece emphasising the difference between a media persona and real life, this short would be higher on the list if not for its tendency to "tell, not show", with more exposition in news reports and Hana and Dae-hyun's conversations than in the actual short itself.

Advertisement

It's strongest in the moments the audience gets to see Hana's flashbacks, short as they were, as well as when she's fighting the Gwishin omnics. These moments clearly communicate that she's a serious, traumatised soldier behind the scenes, while Dae-hyun not-so-subtly emphasising how NOT glamorous and NOT luxurious Hana's life is, just sounds unnatural.

The short still excels, however, in presenting a larger real world reality about how powerful a hero's public image can be in bolstering a country's feeling of safety. Hana's determination to protect her country really fleshes out her character, clearly presenting her celebrity persona as a front, with the only accurate personality trait being her determination to "win"—because winning, for her, means survival.

While a great short for D.Va, showing her off as an incredibly complex character, it's not one of their best. Even if "not their best" is still "amazing" and "better than most".

8. Hero

An exciting, overall hopeful story about old heroes and their effect on the world, this particular cinematic is probably the most reminiscent of a Pixar or Disney film (as most audiences say on first viewing), with an excellent soundtrack and a likeable child protagonist, with gorgeous, colourful visuals that stick in the mind.

Advertisement

This cinematic in particular captures the post-fall of Overwatch world, with gangs in the streets inflicting violence on others and trading heavy weaponry, and the anxieties of raising a child in that kind of an environment.

It also, despite keeping him shrouded in mystery, presents Soldier 76's bitter, vicious, mission-oriented violence, and his ultimate decision to still do what's good, self-sacrificial, and heroic in the end, despite his apparent abandonment of old principles, and his clear determination to complete his mission.

The action here is heart-pounding, with a visually interesting and colourful gang in Los Muertos being taken down with excessive force, and music that punctuates every moment with real weight and emotion, all the way to the Spanish guitar solo at the end.

It's a hopeful, fantastic short centred on how heroism can inspire a new generation, with main character Alejandra providing real heart to the piece.

7. Rise And Shine

A painful yet hopeful piece that focuses on the resilience of its protagonist, Rise and Shine was a gutpunch of a short, especially for a character so undeniably pleasant and sunny.

Advertisement

Mei was always known as Overwatch's sweetest character, with her genuine insistence that "the world is worth fighting for". Some who have read her backstory know of her tragic origins, but this cinematic presented it in full, with Mei and her environmental research team hibernating during a massive ice storm and with Mei waking up nine years later, Overwatch having fallen while they were trapped in Antarctica.

The only surviving member of the team, and having designed the cryo-chambers in the first place, Mei is weighed down by her team's deaths and her own loneliness and loss.

The fact that she's able to get up and work for a better future, despite all odds against her, encapsulates what makes Mei's character so lovable, with excellent voice work by Elise Zhang, who, despite having a hard time speaking English, delivers Mei's fully English dialogue with genuine sweetness and gravitas.

It's the longest cinematic at 10 minutes, and while it shines, there are still others who do just a little better.

6. Infiltration

An action-packed, exciting, and intriguing piece with a fantastic ensemble cast, this short is reminiscent of the best-written superhero cartoons of the 90s and early 2000s. It builds the world of Overwatch effectively, both in terms of politics, and in terms of how Overwatch's greatest enemy, Talon, operates.

Advertisement

Sombra's personality and motivations shine through in this short without compromising the equally interesting motivation of Katya Volskaya, Russia's leader in their ongoing Omnic Crisis, nor the team dynamic of Reaper and Widow alongside their resident hacker.

The action flows cleverly well, with visual gags that don't undercut the real threat Talon presents. People are killed quite ruthlessly onscreen in this short, something that Blizzard certainly hasn't shied away from, and political machinations and intrigue strengthen the depth and adult nuance of a game that's as brightly coloured as a children's cartoon.

Sombra's betrayal gives the audience the kind of exciting twist that has them coming back for more, even if it's later revealed in the Masquerade comic that Reaper knew the truth the whole time.

This short is what everyone's looking to when they ask, "When will Blizzard make this a TV series?" Talon alone could make for an amazing show.

5. Alive

This was the short that showed audiences that Overwatch was NOT messing around, presenting unflinching murder and uncomfortable real world parallels with surprising nuance for a colourful, cartoonish game.

Advertisement

Opening with a monologue about Widowmaker's childhood fear of spiders, the short quickly descends into an uncomfortable yet surprisingly effective allegory about racial and anti-immigrant tensions in Western countries, building up the complex world of a post-Omnic Crisis Overwatch. The omnic religious figure Mondatta, Zenyatta's brother as a monk, makes a speech preaching equality in light of extreme anti-Omnic sentiment in London, with Tracer just so happening to listen in when she realises Widowmaker's setting up to assassinate him.

An action-packed, heart-stopping, and ultimately tragic short, it unflinchingly shows the failure of its hero and the triumph of its villain, the shadowy politics behind the act subtle but undeniable.

Like other shorts, it also shows Tracer and Widowmaker's in-game abilities effectively, with a rooftop battle that's as graceful as it is full of unexpected turns. The climactic shot Widow takes is fantastically precise and brutal, showing off her almost impossible prowess as a sniper. And just like the short, it's painfully unexpected, and all the more memorable for it.

4. Recall

Encapsulating the entirety of what Overwatch stands for, Recall presents Winston as the heart and soul of the story, and the truly heroic optimism he has to contrast with the tired, beaten down spirit of the other members of the organisation.

Advertisement

Recall kicks off the call to bring Overwatch back years after its fall, with super-intelligent moon gorilla Winston wishing to help the world in response to the anarchy and suffering it's experiencing. The short cuts between his current lonely existence with his past as a baby gorilla on the moon, raised by a kindly and hopeful scientist named Harold Winston.

These two tie together as Winston's home in the Gibraltar base is invaded by Reaper and a slew of Talon soldiers, Reaper trying to extract the identities of Overwatch agents. Though Winston is able to neutralise this particular attack, he's convinced to recall all Overwatch agents still out in the world, kicking off the organisation's second incarnation.

This recall features in almost every other cinematic, and is the centre-point for Overwatch's developing plot. Other agents are coming to respond to the call, from Genji to McCree to Mei. It's just the right story to get people excited for Overwatch's future.

3. The Last Bastion

A masterclass in animated storytelling, this short provides a dramatic and deeply moving piece with a character who doesn't speak and has no emoting face—an admirable feat of visual storytelling.

Advertisement

It tells the story of a Bastion unit that is activated years after it's dropped into a German forest, making friends with a curious yellow bird and exploring the beauty of nature. With backdrops straight out of the painted, colourful world of Disney's Bambi, the story starts off with Bastion making its way to an unknown location, the only "memory" still active in its programming.

Midway through, the gentle robot experiences symptoms reminiscent of PTSD, accidentally reverting to its more violent past programming (similar to the Iron Giant of 90s fame) and scaring its friend away.

It's soon revealed, when Bastion leaves the forest and crosses a large field, that it's one of thousands dropped in a past war against humanity. Unlike its fallen brethren, however, Bastion is able to choose peace over its programmed destructive objective.

The raw, emotional stakes this story presents over an expressionless machine, as well as its stunning visuals, ranks this as one of Overwatch's best works. It's no wonder it won a writing award.

2. Honor And Glory

A perfect blend of epic music, emotional storytelling, and top-tier voice performances, this short never fails to make a viewer cry, and is one of the best-written and most devastating of all the Overwatch shorts.

Advertisement

Opening with Reinhardt, an old Overwatch agent and even older soldier in the battle against the omnics—sentient robots who went to war against humanity decades ago, under the control of "God AIs"—choosing to answer Winston's recall, despite Overwatch having pushed him out before its fall.

It then goes on to Reinhardt's memories as a crusader under the leadership of Col. Balderich, who was the original soldier called to serve with Overwatch's first strike team. Back then, Reinhardt was a flippant, vainglorious soldier, and his over-confidence was partly why his friend and leader died in battle.

In a heartrending scene, Balderich, mortally wounded, hands over his responsibility to Overwatch to Reinhardt, and fights the last of the omnics as Reinhardt returns to protect his team.

It gives painful context to Reinhardt's devotion to Overwatch, and his final words, mirroring Balderich's, encapsulate that:

"I have been called. I must answer."

It's one of Overwatch's greatest shorts, and its most emotional, well-scored, and well-acted, with tears shed for every viewing.

1. Dragons

Truthfully, the top 3 entries on this list could all vie for first place for the sheer quality of storytelling, but the cinematic Dragons scrapes by just by a hair, for mixing two equally gorgeous mediums together to tell two fantastic stories, the majesty and tragedy of the old children's story mirroring that of the main plot.

Advertisement

This particular story encapsulates everything that makes Overwatch so enthralling. The old, epic tales mixed with a dazzling futuristic setting, with interesting and nuanced characters with complex relationships and backstories. The fights are exciting, the emotions are high, and there's something almost Shakespearean about the whole affair.

This isn't even mentioning the breathtaking animation and grandiose score, Genji's reveal delivering one of the greatest climactic highs to any unsuspecting viewer.

Like Recall, Dragons has its characters looking to the future of the world with hope and uncertainty. Unlike Recall, saving the world isn't a foregone conclusion, and Hanzo, who was the focal point of this short, still has a choice he needs to make.

This short is the reason multitudes of people bought the game, and holds up as one of the greatest, if not THE greatest, of Overwatch's truly stunning filmography.

Advertisement