Spider-Man PS4 The Heist Review: 4 Ups And 3 Downs

With Black Cat, a brand new Spidey villain and new missions aplenty, is the DLC worth it?

By Ewan Paterson /

Insomniac Games

Spider-Man PS4 is just over a month old, and the first entry in The City That Never Sleeps DLC - entitled The Heist - has just released. Clocking in with just under three hours worth of content, it provides players with a worthy follow-up to the game's story, albeit with not quite the same amount of depth.

Advertisement

Picking up some time after the events of Spider-Man's main story, players are introduced to Felicia Hardy - the femme fatale also known as the Black Cat - as she returns to New York with Hammerhead, who heads up one of the Maggia families in NYC. It soon transpires that all isn't as it seems, and with deception the name of the game, Spidey soon finds himself in the midst of an escalating gang war, all whilst trying to make sure Hardy doesn't get herself killed.

That isn't all though. The Heist comes complete with side-missions involving a newly-released Screwball, more crimes to tackle, and a sub-plot involving an old NYPD detective. It isn't without its flaws though, and while the first entry in The City That Never Sleeps is itself an enjoyable piece of content, players may wish to hold onto their cash for just a little longer.

Advertisement

SPOILERS AHEAD...

Ups...

4. Black Cat Is Fantastic

Insomniac Games

Considering the narrative strength of the base Spider-Man title, it should come as no surprise to hear that the story behind The Heist is really quite exceptional. Central to it is of course Black Cat, voiced by Erica Lindbeck, who returns to New York under the pretence of working for Hammerhead.

Advertisement

All isn't as it seems though. Once Spidey gets involved, and Cat reveals that she has a son, things are taken to a whole other level entirely, with Insomniac's writing team marshalling the unspoken history between Peter and Felicia exceptionally well. There's a real chemistry between the pair, and it makes Black Cat's current-gen debut a thoroughly entertaining one.

First thing's first: Insomniac's redesign of Cat's outfit is long overdue, and provides a modernising uplift to yet another of Spider-Man's female leads. Hardy's characterisation is also handled remarkably well, with the added wrinkle of her having once gone straight before returning to her criminal ways adding some much needed internal conflict to her duplicitous - and flirtatious - personality.

Advertisement

The chemistry between her and Peter is just really fun to see play out on screen, and though the ending did sort of leave her in a precarious predicament, fans can expect the character to return as the DLC progresses - either in Turf Wars, or in Silver Lining.

3. The Beginning Of Miles' New Journey

Insomniac Games

Miles may not actually appear in the DLC (so make due with this delightful shot of Spidey enjoying a double pepperoni), but he does share two important phone calls with Peter at various points in the story. It's clear that he wants to be the next Spider-Man, requesting that Pete "train him" - a request he's understandably reluctant to indulge.

Advertisement

What makes these two conversations so great, really, is that it shows Insomniac have a clear journey in mind for this universe. It would've been relatively easy for them to have just retroactively inserted a Black Cat storyline into the main game's narrative, but instead, we've got a genuine follow up that expands some elements from the story's ending in a genuinely worthwhile manner.

We've already theorised what Spider-Man 2 may include, but with teases for that title coming thick and fast in the first wave of DLC, it could be possible that we see more of these elements sooner than we originally anticipated.

Advertisement

2. Black Cat Gameplay

Insomniac Games

It was known for a while now that Black Cat would be the star of the first piece of downloadable content, but Insomniac had been able to keep it under wraps that she'd feature in gameplay too.

Advertisement

While players never find themselves with the option to play as Felicia Hardy, she does feature in both stealth and combat sections. Players can highlight targets for her to take down, and she'll even intervene in combat sections too by delivering the occasional instant takedown. Sure, it's lightyears away from the dual-play style combat found in Rocksteady's Arkham games, but it made for a nice surprise, and featured in The Heist's most enjoyable gameplay sections.

We can only hope that Insomniac implement this feature with some of Spidey's other allies, but even if they don't, this served as a great tease of things to come. It's only a matter of time before Miles Morales is teaming up with Peter in the field, and with other Marvel characters inevitably set to feature at one point or another, it's great to see the studio experiment in the DLC.

Advertisement

1. New J. Jonah Jameson Dialogue

Insomniac Games

Insomniac Games' version of J. Jonah Jameson was already a fantastic satire of online, InfoWars-esque personalities, but the studio may have saved his best rants for the DLC.

Advertisement

Among JJ's most hilarious monologues in the new story include him venting his absurd frustrations with "female-led reboots" and "shipping" - a trend in online fandom where people 'ship' two characters together. Surly old JJ decries the practice entirely, especially when people begin to ship Spider-Man and Black Cat, offering one piece of advice to those who do: "JOIN THE NAVY!"

It's frankly hilarious, and the idea of JJ embodying toxic fandom is even cleverer. Bravo, Insomniac. Bravo.

Advertisement

Downs...

3. The Predictable Side-Mission Twist

Insomniac Games

Unfortunately, not everything in The Heist manages to stick the landing. Screwball's side-missions are entertaining enough, and the Maggia crimes provide a neat enough distraction, but the collectible quest which sees Pete retrieve art stolen by the original Black Cat is ridiculously predictable.

Advertisement

The mission in question sees Spidey meet up with an NYPD officer called Detective Mackey (pictured above). Mackey is a cop who worked the original Black Cat case 20 years ago, and now - out of nowhere - he needs Spidey to retrieve all the art the criminal stole. There are 10 pieces for the wall-crawler to collect in total, and well... isn't it all a bit obvious where this is heading?

Eventually, it transpires that Mackey is none other than the original Black Cat himself, Walter Hardy, and that he'd been using Spidey to retrieve his loot in order to retire happily. Why is this so predictable? Well, for starters the design is lifted straight from the look seen in the nineties Spider-Man cartoon, and if the white moustache-combo doesn't scream "CAT BURGLAR" to begin with, then well, what does?

Advertisement

Ultimately, Mackey's introduction in the DLC is a dead giveaway that he's really Hardy, and though it does end on an interesting note, it may have made more sense to introduce the character in the base game and develop him over time that way, rather than to have him suddenly appear in a Black Cat-themed piece of content right off the bat.

2. New Enemy Types Don't Shake Things Up Enough

Insomniac Games

One of the few genuinely major criticisms for Spider-Man PS4 was that gameplay could get repetitive in certain sections. With the DLC, that issue appears to have been exacerbated by the lack of new gadgets. Of course, there are only so many things you can stick on a weapon wheel, but Spidey could've really benefited from another piece of tech in this add-on.

Advertisement

It's an issue Insomniac are clearly aware of though. The first batch of downloadable content introduces a new enemy type altogether - the minigun thug. They're definitely the most frustrating enemy type yet, beating out Silver Sable's jetpack-wearing enforcers in terms of sheer annoyance, but they don't really add any depth to encounters so much as they do prolong them. The new weapon certainly provides a challenge, but players need only web the criminal carrying it if they wish to do damage.

Insomniac will no doubt incorporate different kinds of thugs as The City That Never Sleeps continues, but currently, it feels as though combat is wearing a little thin.

Advertisement

1. Hammerhead Only Has A Cameo

Insomniac Games

Making his debut to Earth-1048 is Hammerhead, a Spider-Man villain with an exceptionally robust cranium. He looks set to become a key figure in the next two pieces of downloadable content, but he only appears in one scene during The Heist - a brief two second cameo in its closing moments.

Advertisement

First and foremost, it's obvious that The Heist is all about Black Cat and Spider-Man, and - narratively speaking - it works; we get to see Insomniac really flesh out Peter and Felicia's relationship, and it's great. Unfortunately, the story that we do see lacks the physical presence of a proper antagonist, and subsequently suffers because of it.

Ultimately, it's understandable why The City That Never Sleeps has been released episodically and just mere weeks after the main game's launch. Fans are desperate to come back to this universe, and while The Heist does deliver a neat fix for those particularly enamoured with Insomniac's take on Spider-Man, one can't help but think releasing the entire content in one sole episode - rather than several - would have worked to its benefit.

Advertisement

Watch Next...