Spike VGX Awards: 5 Reasons It Was An Embarrassing Celebration Of 2013 Games

By Robert Kojder /

Opening up this article bluntly, Spike TV€™s annually televised Video Game Awards have never been a guiding light to anything in the industry. Back during its earlier days when WWE programming was associated with the channel, whoever was running the sham would shamelessly hand out high profile awards to Smackdown games€ with WWE wrestlers actually seated in the audience. Flashing forward to more recent years, the ceremony was at least tolerable and actually distributing nominees and awards in a logical thought process. You€™d be hard-pressed to find a wealth of gamers visibly upset over Uncharted 2 or The Walking Dead winning Game of the Year. Commercially and critically those games are highly lauded and rightfully so. The more recent panel has also done a very admirable job at toning down on kissing the behind of any game trending worldwide for all of the wrong reasons €“ cough Call of Duty €“ and spreading awards out with the thoughts of legitimate gamers in mind. When you turn on the Oscars you don€™t see Twilight nominated for Best Picture, you get a panel that intelligently nominated and voted across a myriad of categories. Quality is rightfully of the upmost importance. The cancerous and overbearingly painful presentation is what we gamers actually hate. There was always an abundance of Hollywood celebrities presenting various awards, which would be understandable if they were legitimately gamers and not grinning their way through a teleprompter loaded with bull****. Marlon Wayans isn€™t there because he loves gaming; he€™s there as a D list celebrity eager to cash a paycheck because most humans would rather have chronic diarrhea than pay him for a ticket/Blu-Ray of A Haunted House. A celebration of gaming should not involve Hollywood celebrities seeking attention. There is no correlation unless aforementioned celebrity deserves to be there, like Ellen Page for her sincere dedication to Beyond. I know she wasn€™t present yesterday €“ and trust me, it€™s obvious why- but if she was, that€™s a legitimate case of Hollywood and gaming crossing over. Gamers want to see their heroes on stage, and those heroes aren€™t a random D list actor. Gamers want the industry leaders and most crucial figureheads present because that€™s who we€™re honoring. It€™s not the time for toilet humor, abysmal sketch comedy, fake personas pandering to an audience that doesn€™t care about them, and musical performances that are completely unrelated to gaming. Spike, Geoff Keighley, and the entire panel seem to have taken the hint too, issuing this statement online.
While its roots lie in the Video Game Awards, VGX will abandon the traditional Hollywood style award show to feature more world premiere game trailers than ever before, plus extended deep dives into the next generation of games, new looks at gaming culture, one-on-one interviews with the industry's most visionary creatives and expert panels digging into what's coming to consoles in 2014 and beyond. The new format features more games, less fame, in an intimate studio setting, and the live stream will be hosted by Joel McHale and Geoff Keighley.
To say that these people didn€™t try with creating an awards show ceremony that better reflects what a passionate gamer realistically wants is an understatement. They took the feedback to heart, but they also churned out an event even more embarrassing, which theoretically should be freaking impossible In other words it seems that the producers and panel still have no idea what true gamers actually want to see at an event of this magnitude, so here are 5 aspects Spike needs to fix.

5. This Is An Awards Show?

This one is admittedly tricky because over time gamers have actually come to like all the World Premiere announcements for mystery games. Even I got chills when the Last of Us was revealed two years ago. So with this in mind, do not interpret it as me saying that all reveals and breaking bombshell news should be stripped from the show. It is very disappointing how little awards actually were allowed acceptance speeches though. An estimated 75% of the awards were quietly handed out before the show even began, which actually sends the message that you€™re placing less emphasis on celebrating a year of developmer blood, sweat, and tears. Getting a first glimpse of upcoming €“ some not even announced- games is cool but it shouldn€™t come across as cramming as many as possible into the timeslot for maximum advertising. Select these World Premiere announcements more carefully and in fewer numbers so we€™re left with actual exciting announcements only. Balance the ratio of awards vs. advertisement so we can see people like Troy Baker give acceptance speeches for their dedication in voice acting. This is an awards ceremony and focus should head that direction first and foremost. Also, who the heck announces Game of the Year at the top of the second hour in a 3 hour broadcast? That illogical thinking completely deflated a majority of the following 2 hours because you€™ve already given away your biggest prize. Start from the bottom with one or two bigger categories, and slowly work your way through the rest finishing with Game of the Year. That should be common sense but apparently it isn€™t.

4. Youtube Phenomenons Are Not Welcome

The only thing more insulting than having Marlon Wayans lie through his teeth about his gaming credentials is having a bandwagon of unfunny jokesters present some terrible sketch comedy. Everyone from Smosh to Pewdiepie were simply embarrassing and had no place amongst a celebration of the industry. It€™s like having Carrot Top present Best Picture at the Oscars. I€™ll admit that I enjoy watching my fair share of Let€™s Play€™s on Youtube and perusing the internet for varying opinions on all things related to gaming, but that doesn€™t mean they€™re shining beacons of intelligence that should show up and steal the spotlight. Are we celebrating the industry or Youtube here?

3. Why Are There STILL Celebrities?

Let me get something critical out of the way; I am not referring to Camilla Luddington or the creators of South Park (Trey Parker and Matt Stone). As mentioned in my introduction, if a celebrity has a legitimate reason to appear €“ whether it€™s because they have contributed to a game or are a true gamer - then everyone should be fine with it. This point is referring to a group of clowns that kept getting screen time to promote the Grand Theft Auto V mini-concert that would be airing after the show. Some internet research tells me that they are known as the Loiter Squad and have a sketch comedy show on Adult Swim, but their presence at the Spike VGX tells me that any attempt made at comedy should result in a stoning. Forget the fact that they couldn€™t get anyone to let out a chuckle or go along with their antics, half of the time it appeared as if they couldn€™t read the teleprompter. Every line they juggled back and forth between each other was hilariously stilted with multiple pauses mid-sentence. The icing on the cake was that they didn€™t know a darn thing about gaming. Seriously, we don€™t need these people wasting valuable time.

2. Clueless Hosts

Spike has the habit of signing on some of the most unfit figures to host a ceremony celebrating video games, with the exception of Samuel L. Jackson one year. He was awesome and expressed interest in hosting the show. This year is not another exception to the rule unfortunately. Joel McHale is a comedian/ actor tasked with co-hosting alongside key industry figure Geoff Keighley. It€™s easy to understand where Spike was going with this decision; they wanted some jokes to liven up the mood somewhat. Even the most prestigious of award shows inject some laughter into the timeslot. There€™s only one problem though; those hosts usually have a broader knowledge range of the industry they€™re hosting an awards show for, and thus have a much larger catalog of material to derive jokes from. Joel McHale doesn€™t have that vast industry knowledge, resulting in many of his jokes coming across as your cliché and generic game deprecating humor. When his jokes were being inspired elsewhere, he was genuinely funny at times. The easiest way to describe Joel is as that obnoxious casual gamer friend most of us have, that wants to prove his knowledge. He doesn€™t mean any harm, but is just a puzzle piece that doesn€™t quite fit into the picture. It€™s also highly probable that executive producers running the show behind the scenes actually told him to calm himself at one point, as there were definitely some jokes made that came across rude to developers. He is a comedian though, so realistically I cannot blame Joel too much. The real issue is that whoever is hiring these people seem to be completely out of touch with how video game humor should be presented. Instead of going after comedic hosts that claim to be gamers, why not go after people that we know are passionate about gaming along with being funny? Imagine if Trey Parker and Matt Stone were hired to host the whole affair? Now that would be interesting and please the majority.

1. Horrible Presentation

It seems that with Spike€™s focus on less Hollywood fluff and more gaming content, the budget took quite a hit. In addition to not being televised, it feels like these awards were presented on a ridiculously low budget late night talk show. What awards ceremony hands out awards and conducts interviews over a couch? Even their hosting space (pictured above) looks ridiculously cheap. I could accept this but the ceremony was already granted with a fairly large stage for the closing Grand Theft Auto V musical performances, so why not use that stage for everything? From that positioning you could also hear the audience much more clearly which would have greatly benefited the production value. In its current state, about 5 people clapping were audible as Grand Theft Auto V took home the richest prize in the industry, and honestly the industry deserves something classier. It€™s admirable of the panel to take this humongous budget cut so they could focus more on what gamers want, but the current format completely emasculated this event in feeling special or noteworthy. It was nothing more than Geoff Keighley interviewing some developers with a clueless host occasionally chiming in, and this went on for 3 hours! An awards show still need a stage and other essentials. No wonder nobody bothered to even televise it this year. The awards were fine though and went to deserving picks, so that€™s something positive. Otherwise, this already bad show was rebranded into a train-wreck. Agree or disagree? Comment below!