Super Mario 64: Ranking The 15 Worlds

What's your favourite world from the N64 classic?

By Josh Mills /

The release of Super Mario 3D All-Stars has given Nintendo fans the world over another chance to relive three of the podgy plumber’s finest adventures. And while some may grumble at the price or lack of refinement for the ports (rather than remasters) of Super Marios 64, Sunshine, and Galaxy, the rest of us have relished the opportunity to dive back into these games.

Advertisement

While Super Mario 64 shows its age at points, it’s also undeniably one of the most important games ever made, hurling players into the third dimension. Camera and structure issues are present, but on the flip side the game is full of charm, crisp platforming, and some of the finest levels ever seen in gaming.

Super Mario 64 boasts 15 different worlds, and all of them possess their good points and bad, individual challenges and moments of frustration. Not all worlds are created equally, though, and while some of these levels will generate warm nostalgia in replayers or awe in newbies, others are found lacking, or aren’t worth the grind.

The game on the whole deserves to be celebrated, but as we’ll see, not everything quite hits the mark.

15. Wet-Dry World

It should be said that the water mechanic is neat. Depending on where you dive into the entrance of this world, the water level will accordingly be adjusted higher or lower. The ability to affect the level’s layout is as cool now as it was then.

Advertisement

Beyond that, though, Wet-Dry World doesn’t have an awful lot going for it. It’s the emptiest level in the game, just two large chambers mostly devoid of enemies or features to climb on or jump off. You’re forever tasked with shifting the water level further, which players of contemporaneous Zelda games will know is never a great time.

Then there are the stars, which are not among the game’s finest. Seeking out the red coins in the world’s second chamber, laid out like a little town, is fun, but then there are stars asking you simply to push five blocks, dispersed around the level, which eventually yield you your prize. It’s not especially intuitive, nor is it much fun.

It’s one of the only levels that visually feels undercooked, and that’s reflected in the stale tasks at hand.

14. Dire, Dire Docks

By this point we’ve already played one water level, which is perfectly fine, but not a highlight of the game. Super Mario 64’s second aquatic adventure is a sharp drop from the first, primarily due to its increased reliance on swimming.

Advertisement

For a 24 year old game, 64 handles like a dream for the most part - except when it doesn’t. Swimming is a pain at the best of times, so when you’ve got to do it for the majority of a level, it’s always going to result in a lowlight of the game.

Some of the stars are an exercise in frustration, particularly the one gained by swimming through rings emitted by a manta ray. The camera and shonky controls conspire against you - there seems to be no rhyme or reason as to whether or not the game will register a successful attempt, so the player is judged on fate, rather than skill.

Visually this is also one of the more bland levels, and the coolest star - boarding Bowser’s sub - is the very first one. It’s a good step up in challenge, but takes away some of the momentum from the game’s midpoint.

13. Lethal Lava Land

A mixed bag of a level, Lethal Lava Land contains a couple of cool mechanics. The red coin star is obtained through a shifting blocks puzzle like you might get from a museum gift shop, which is deceptively simple. The final two stars of the world require you to hurl Mario into a volcano, unlocking a couple of nicely challenging pure platform stages.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, though, the world is somewhat repetitive. Two of the stars require you to defeat a number of Bullies, cannonball-like enemies who attempt to shunt you off a platform and into the lava, while you do the same to them. This requires seriously good timing, and is enjoyable to complete once, but not so much the second time.

Repetition is what lets Lethal Lava Land down on the whole, as the colour palette is seriously one note. It’s a fun level to navigate as there are risks everywhere which necessitate crisp jumps, but it’s not the kind of word you really want to spend a lot of time in.

12. Whomp's Fortress

The game’s second world smartly ramps up the difficulty of the first, adding in more vicious foes and a ledge over which Mario can fall to his death. On the whole, though, it’s not one of the more inventive levels, requiring the player to repeat the same climb to the top of the tower repeatedly.

Advertisement

It’s on the small side, meaning you can race through it pretty quickly, and it doesn’t bring a whole lot more to the table following level one. There’s another boss battle which introduces you to further mechanics, but like the scrap on Bob-omb Battlefield this isn’t much to write home about.

There are a couple of irritating stars, too, which demonstrate the game’s limitations. A cannon-based task can result in disaster seemingly at random, and you’re required to navigate some moving platforms that are made far harder than they should be due to the game’s shonky camera.

A solid second level, but lacking the magic of the first - not the most thrilling world, and simultaneously a bit too short.

11. Rainbow Ride

The game’s final world offers Super Mario 64’s greatest challenge by far. The margin for error on this level is practically non-existent. Much of the world is spent leaping from rotating platforms to magic carpets and back, with flamethrowers and floating foes ready to knock Mario into the infinite abyss.

Advertisement

At its best, this is a stern test of the player’s platforming skills accumulated over the course of the game, and when you pull it off it’s great - taking the magic carpet ride through the entirety of the level, or boarding the pirate ship, is very satisfying indeed.

That’s all well and good when the game is tough but fair, but as often as not an error will be made due to the camera rather than player incompetence. For those looking to 100% the game, this is particularly irritating, as gaining the 100 coins star on Rainbow Ride is an extremely tense undertaking, one false move undoing all your hard work.

Still, Rainbow Ride gains points for its visuals, which are among the game’s strongest, full of detail and disparate sections.

10. Hazy Maze Cave

The underground caverns of Hazy Maze Cave make for one of the more sprawling levels in the game. As the name suggests this is a labyrinthine world, so much so that the developers felt it necessary to place a map at the start.

Advertisement

It features some of the cooler game mechanics, requiring the player to ride atop the head of a Loch Ness Monster-type creature, and also houses the metal cap switch, the closest Super Mario 64 has to an invincibility star. The area in general has a vibe and an aesthetic that isn’t replicated anywhere else in the game.

The size of the world, though, can be its downfall, as it never feels cohesive as a location. Rather than exploring Hazy Maze Cave as a whole, you’re simply going somewhere, completing a task there, then re-entering the world and repeating.

It also has some kind of boring stars along with the cool ones, namely the red coins task, which requires Mario to pilot an awfully slow moving platform. As a rule any time the game doesn’t let the player move at their own pace, it’s to the detriment of fun.

9. Jolly Roger Bay

Super Mario 64’s first water level is a lot more enjoyable than the first, not least because of the ways the player can alter their surroundings. Your first task is to explore a sunken ship, which you can only access after coaxing an eel out. Once you’ve done this, the galleon rises to the surface for further investigation, and the eel retreats elsewhere for another star of its own.

Advertisement

This kind of cause and effect was pioneered by Super Mario 64, and the game cleverly teaches the players to remember what they’ve done and to return to earlier locations later on to see what might have changed.

The stars are a bit of a mixed bag, with two involving opening treasure chests in the correct order and one requiring the player to chase the aforementioned eel, who has the gold stuck to its tail, which can be a pain thanks to the swimming controls.

That aside, this is a neat, early level that continues to illustrate just how many different elements and mechanics this incredible game is able to encompass.

8. Tiny, Huge Island

The design of this level isn’t anything too exciting. It’s a return to the green grass of the first few worlds, and in the main features the usual cadre of enemies - goombahs, piranha plants. The strength of Tiny, Huge Island, though, is found in the title. Depending on which painting you use to gain entrance, you’ll control either a tiny Mario on a massive island, or a gigantic plumber on a teensy playing field.

Advertisement

Switching between the two modes is the key to progressing through the world. Giant Mario is used to navigate the world, whereupon small Mario has to overcome some foes in a David and Goliath battle, or the big guy’s heft can be employed to open up paths for further exploration by his smaller self.

The boss battle against perennial foe Wiggler might be the game’s best, and it requires the player to navigate the full island and control both sizes of the protagonist. There’s also another race with Koopa the Quick, this time far more tricky.

Its success does hinge entirely on the size shifting, but that gimmick remains cool to this day.

7. Shifting Sand Land

Likely one of the first levels the player comes to after beating Bowser’s initial form, Shifting Sands Land poses an ideal ramp up in difficulty after the easing in of worlds one through five. While things don’t look to have changed too much on the surface, this is a level full of peril, with crushing blocks, a bird that steals your hat, and instant death quicksand abounding.

Advertisement

It’s another of the bigger levels, but this one all hangs together nicely, a well laid out and varied level complete with a winged cap and koopa shell to allow for easier navigation. Some of the stars can be a little frustrating and unintuitive - standing atop the four pillars, for example, or using the cap to collect airborne coins - but there’s a lot of variety.

The pyramid is where things get real for the player. A stern platforming challenge (unfortunately displaying the camera issues at their very worst), a cool, distinct boss fight against a pair of disembodied hands, and a star based on finding secret coins that’s just on the right side of being too obtuse. Testing, but never unfair.

6. Cool, Cool Mountain

The first snowbound level is another early jump up in difficulty for the player. It resides in the castle lobby and can be accessed with just three stars, but this is likely the first time the player will find themselves repeatedly falling to their deaths after a false move.

Advertisement

It can boast some of the game’s most distinctive, memorable, and best power stars. While the developers pad things out by awarding two stars for going down the secret slide, once alone, once racing a penguin, it’s so fun that you’re unlikely to complain.

The task of reuniting the mother penguin with her baby is another unforgettable one, especially for those who embraced their dark side by chucking the chick off the cliff after gaining their spoils.

A fun, well sized level with no dud power stars, this falls down only because there’s not a great deal of scope for smart platforming on the icy, vertical course. It’s a world made for its individual moments, rather than free running exploration, which is a big part of the magic of Mario.

5. Tall, Tall Mountain

Perhaps the best pure platforming experience in the game, this world will put to the test Mario’s full arsenal of jumps, flips, leaps, and dives. Admittedly Tall, Tall Mountain does suffer from the familiar issue of having to retrace your steps quite a bit to gain stars - four out of the seven are found essentially at the level’s peak - but this world is so much fun to navigate that you won’t mind.

Advertisement

It’s a primarily vertical level but with neat detailing throughout, like the red coin challenge requiring Mario to hop between airborne mushrooms and alcoves in the cliff face, and a mischievous monkey that will steal his signature red hat.

Then there’s the slide, another great hidden challenge buried in a wall. This one is more challenging than the slides that precede it, with forking paths that will send the player to their death, but even so, there’s little more fun than a slide in a Mario game.

The repeated climb to the summit won’t be to everyone’s taste, but for platforming fans this is one of the finest stages Nintendo have come up with to date.

4. Bob-omb Battlefield

Super Mario 64’s inaugural level gets the game off to a great start. Bob-omb Battlefield somehow still looks great more than two decades down the line, a lush green arena with so much to explore.

Advertisement

Its genius lies in how it teaches the player the game’s mechanics. There are gaps to traverse with your new 3D jumps; a boss to best with Mario’s grab; later you’ll be taught to ground pound, and to utilise the flying cap once unlocked. More advanced techniques like koopa shell riding and hidden teleports are there to be found by keen eyed players.

Nintendo were sure to keep things varied at the top to grab players, as no two stars are exactly alike. You need to reach the summit of the mountain twice, but first there’s a boss battle, the second time a race. The red coin challenge takes you around the entire world, allowing the player to notice things they may have missed.

The difficulty is spot on, too. For new players it may be daunting to have to battle a big king Bob-omb right out the gate, but once you’ve got your head around that, you’re away.

3. Tick Tock Clock

The penultimate world is seriously difficult, a step up from everything that precedes it. There are simply so many chances to die in Tick Tock Clock. The enemies are few, but almost everything you do will involve navigating moving platforms with a bottomless pit awaiting your mistakes below.

Advertisement

Unlike Rainbow Road, though, this world rarely becomes frustrating. There are patterns to learn, techniques to master, and once you’ve got your route worked out, the feeling of traversing the perilous clock is brilliant.

The interactivity is ingenious, too: depending on the time at which you enter the clock, the platforms will move faster, slower, or stop altogether. Your tactics will need to vary depending on the star you’re after - there’s a depth of thought here missing from other worlds.

It’s also just a cool looking level, full of obstacles but drained of colour to indicate to the player that it’s time to get serious. It’s a major challenge, coming so late in the game, but it’s one of the most rewarding levels to become good at navigating.

2. Big Boo's Haunt

A precursor to Luigi’s Mansion, the game’s fifth world sees Mario boldly exploring a haunted manor, as well as a creepy subterranean fairground beneath it. This world is built majorly around Mario’s battles with the next world, as many of the stars are gained from besting phantoms in combat. It never grows samey, though, because your quest to bust ghosts takes you all around the level, including a climactic scrap on the balcony.

Advertisement

Aesthetically, it’s probably the best designed level. You’re deposited in front of an imposing mansion, filled with trick floorboards and malevolent, toothed pianos. The world itself is set in a merry go round, which Mario is sucked into by some spooky force.

The flow of the level is well thought out - the mansion feels like a real location to be explored, and in lieu of bottomless pits, the player can tumble to the underground cavern, forced then to work their way back up.

There are also some stars that escalate the difficulty, like the madcap run to the roof with the vanishing cap, requiring pinpoint long jumps and wall kicks.

1. Snowman's Land

The second snow-based level has everything a gamer could possibly want. An ice block-based puzzle with a star at its centre? Check. A battle with a horned creature on a slippery platform above some ice lava? Yep. An igloo to creep into, a climb up a giant snowman who can blow your cap off, some nimble platforming across freezing water, a breakneck ride on a koopa shell for eight red coins - it’s the total package.

Advertisement

Snowman’s Land features the most diverse selection of stars in Super Mario 64, with the need to rehash old ground kept to an absolute minimum. You’ve only got to scale the snowman centrepiece once, visit the igloo once. There are also numerous ways to go about achieving your goals - you might battle the big bully with smarts, or utilise the shell to barge him to his death.

The world offers the perfect mixture of puzzling, enemy combat, tight platforming, and open world exploration to create an unforgettable blend. And really, that’s what Super Mario 64 is all about.

Advertisement