The Most Underrated Video Game You Should Play RIGHT NOW

Don't let this horror game slip under the radar.

By Josh Brown /

Puppet Combo

2023 was a frankly ridiculous year for games.

Advertisement

Fans were bombarded with massive releases seemingly every other week, and as a result you've probably still got plenty of games from last year to get through in 2024.

Well get that backlog ready because I've got yet another title to add to your pile. One that just so happens to be the best horror game of 2023.

Advertisement

Called Stay out of the House, this first-person horror from indie darlings Puppet Combo has actually been a long time in the making. Initially teased via a prologue entitled Night Shift back in 2018 (which we'll get to later on), PC players have seen versions of the game in early access over the past few years, before it released proper in 2022.

Advertisement

Me, being a Big Dumb Console Idiot, had no idea this thing even existed before randomly scrolling the recently added games tab on the PlayStation Store when it dropped on consoles in June 2023. I'm pleased I did though, because many months later, I still have the desire to play every game Puppet Combo has ever made.

Now, the plot of Stay Out of the House is simple: You're the latest victim of the Night Shift Abductor, who has taken you back to his horrible old home. Think tea-time at the Texas Chainsaw Massacre house. You wake up trapped in a cage, and have three in-game days to figure out how to escape this building. Every time you're caught by the Abductor who patrols the hallways, you wake up the next day, in a new cage, the clock ticking.

Advertisement

It's up to you to figure out why this menace is doing this in the first place, and maybe even rescue some other victims, if you're lucky...

[Continued]

Advertisement

A Retro Horror Masterpiece

Puppet Combo

Gameplay wise, Stay Out of the House is an old-school survival horror experience. I mean "old-school" in all of its meanings, as not only are we dealing with the sub-genre's classic set of mechanics - those being limited inventory space, puzzles revolving around keys and items that open new areas of the level, limited offensive options and punishing manual saving checkpoints - but it also applies to the presentation. Stay Out of the House doesn't look like a game that came out in 2023. Its rudimentary polygonal design is intentionally evocative of PS1-era horror games. Not content to stop there, there's also a VHS and CRT filter intended to create the illusion that you're watching a grimy old horror video tape you found in your uncle's attic.

Advertisement

It's more than just a gimmick as well, as the limitations of older technology are used here not just to create a sense of nostalgia, but to contribute to the fear factor. Old horror games had extremely limited draw distances so the environment and enemies would load in as you moved around - see the original Silent Hill for an example of that - and as such Stay Out of the House also has limited draw distances that serve to obfuscate the player's view.

Puppet Combo

Not only does it brilliantly put the player in the shoes of someone fumbling around a dark house they're unfamiliar with - itself a terrifying prospect as your tormentor knows every inch of their hunting ground - but it invites the player to imagine horrors unable to be conjured by the low poly textures and janky animations. The effect is similar to the film Skinamarink, which also used the obscurity of its image and the whirring grain of a VHS filter to draw you in, imagining shapes in the film where there were none in reality. Great stuff.

Advertisement

Back to how it actually effects gameplay though. See, puzzles here usually amount to finding items and using those items on certain interactable elements in the world. It's a simple loop really, but one made truly nerve wracking because of how difficult the game makes navigating and seeing what's right in front of you.

Hell, in the opening scene, where you're just trapped in a cage and need to figure out how to escape, I was fumbling around for ages trying to figure out what to do. I spent so long in there my character literally died by staring too long at the TV.

Advertisement

Which, by the way, is how I plan on dying in real life too. In reality, my escape was just a 180 spin and a click on a bent bit of wire away, but finding that in the visual haze was easier said than done. Somehow, this never becomes truly frustrating either, probably because if you are having serious trouble progressing, you can just turn the filters off to see clearly and get your bearings.

That lack of power over your senses makes the game's enemies that more terrifying as well. Though there are indicators to where the killer may be, you can never truly trust that he won't emerge from the darkness in front of you and come at you screaming with a butcher knife.

Advertisement

[Continued]

Sound And Vision

Puppet Combo

The sound design of course elevates this tension, helping accentuate the intent of the graphics and animations. What's remarkable is the game's use of silence. You'll go long stretches with truly unbearable quiet, listening to only the thumps of your character and the stamps of the killer.

Advertisement

Like the visual haze though, this draws you in further, making you second guess yourself, thinking "Was that noise I just made too loud? "Is a musical stinger gonna break the silence with a jump scare?" "Are those footsteps getting louder, or is my brain playing tricks on me?"

And when the music and sound effects do come in, they're more than worth the wait. The squelch of metal hitting bones, the barks of dogs, screams from victims all hit in their grainy, distorted clarity. Likewise, every time the killer is alerted to you - which will happen a lot - you're informed via his inhuman squeal and the quickening of footsteps as he makes his way to slice you up. And genuinely, while so many game monsters become too familiar once they begin to catch you, this guy always remained scary thanks to that terrifying scream piercing the silence.

Advertisement

Outside of gameplay utility, it's just an oddly beautiful game to look at and live in. From the stunning titles to the character designs, there's an artistic cohesion to the retro design that brings it to life and makes it more than a gimmick.

[Continued]

Advertisement

Enter The Survival Horror

Puppet Combo

Now, that's a lot of words on how the game looks, but how does it actually play? Really well, thanks for asking.

Advertisement

Ostensibly, it's a stealthy game of cat and mouse. You hide from the killer as he moves around the home, as you attempt to solve puzzles and unlock new areas. While the format is familiar - with a lot of hiding in closets - the execution strikes a strong balance between challenge and tension. As I mentioned, you'll get caught a lot, but that's part of the fun, and thankfully doesn't result in an Alien Isolation situation where you become numb to the chase and meet every death with a deflated sigh.

That's partly down to the potency of the killer himself, but also down to the game's Escape Room-style structure. You're encouraged to experiment, try different ideas and work with the mechanics to progress. It means every death is a learning experience, even if it sets you back.

Advertisement

Even better, you do have options at your disposal to fight back or flee the scene, including a revolver that has a small amount of ammo littered around the environment. Now, the gun is as much a tool as it is a weapon, being able to shoot security cameras or even locks off doors, so it's always a choice as to how you want to expend your limited ammo. For instance there's this rotten old lady who stares at you from a chair and kind of acts like a watchdog. Now, you could sneak around her every time she's in the way, or you could take the risk and take her out with one loud bang.

The gun is also cumbersome to use, forcing you into a lengthy reload animation where you need to slowly chamber each bullet individually and make sure it's in the right place so when you pull the trigger, it actually fires. It's a cliche, but it means every shot counts. It also rewards exploration, as bullets and other resources can give you the edge as you progress.

Advertisement

Stay Out of the House rewards smart planning, but also on-the-fly improvisation, making for a horror experience that demands you pay attention no matter what's happening. It also rewards your patience with great puzzles and twists, whether that's having to find a bunch of body parts to correctly weigh down a machine, or introducing new roaming enemies to stop you ever feeling too secure.

All this is occurring as you piece together the overall plot as well, which is suitably macabre. Told through environmental storytelling and scrawled notes you can find, it's surprisingly engrossing, descending further into the realm of the supernatural the deeper into the house you get.

Advertisement

[Continued]

Night Shift

Puppet Combo

Now, as you can probably tell, I love this game.

Advertisement

At £15 on the PlayStation store at least, I think it's an absolute steal. I've tried to remain as vague as possible in the hope you'll go out and play it yourself, but I don't want to end this video without talking about the part of Stay out of the House that truly hooked me in detail so, if you're sold, head off now, experience it for yourself, and come back later. If you've played it or don't care, let me talk to you about the title's incredible prologue, Night Shift.

Earlier I referred to the killer as the Night Shift Abductor, and the reason for that name is, naturally, explained in this prologue. What's fascinating is that this intro plays nothing like the game to come, being a far more scripted, story-driven, I guess you could say "walking simulator"-style experience.

Advertisement

It puts you in the shoes of Debra as she begins her night shift at an isolated gas station. And for pretty much the entire length of the prologue, nothing happens. You're given a list of chores you can do if you want, including sweeping the floor and putting items on display in the shop. It's tedious; intentionally so because working a graveyard shift like this always is, but that's actually why it's so scary.

Despite the graphics, the game does a good job of mimicking real life. Playing out this shift feels as mundane as it would in real life, but that also makes it as low key scary as a job like that can be. I mean, who among us hasn't been somewhere alone at night and had our mind wander about what could be lurking in the darkness?

Advertisement

The longer the prologue goes and nothing happens, the more anxious you become about every detail. You know something has to arrive eventually - this is still a game after all - and so every customer who comes through the door has you suspicious, thinking: "Is this it? Is this one going to be the killer?".

Every car that pulls into the gas pump attracts your attention, alert for any dangerous red flags. Again, the silence of this sequence draws you in and leaves you with your own anxious thoughts: "Why did that van drive around the gas pumps and not stop? Was it staking the place out, or is this simply a red herring?"; "Have I seen that car before? Why is it here again?" "Oh s**t... did I just hear the back door open?"

Advertisement

Of course, all of this builds to a jump scare, where Debra is attacked and abducted, but the genius is in this build up. The way it puts you in an eerily realistic situation, taps into real life fears and gets you anxious about the details - some of which you might miss completely as you can freely roam around the store at any time - makes the payoff so damn effective.

And that's just the prologue!

Advertisement

This game rules.