The One Feature All Spider-Man Games Get WRONG

How do they keep messing this up?!

By Josh Brown /

Insomniac

Spider-Man is the perfect superhero for a video game adaptation. Everything about him can be game-ified, with the web head coming pre-loaded with a bunch of unique powers and abilities that lend themselves perfectly to satisfying mechanics.

Advertisement

It's why over the decades there have been tons of tie-in titles and adaptations, and why, even in the ones that absolutely suck (looking at you, The Amazing Spider-Man 2) there's always fun to be had indulging in swinging around Manhattan, doing whatever a spider can.

While the art of swinging and web shooting has been perfected over the years, with there being a few legitimate claims to throne (though for me it's a two-way race between Spider-Man 2 and Insomniac's most recent game), there is one area every game based on the Marvel hero falls down on and, ultimately stops you from, as the old overused saying goes, truly feeling like Spider-Man.

Advertisement

The wall crawling. It's the wall crawling.

Despite it being a major part of the character's toolset, and a unique ability that dictates everything from how he moves around environments to methods of attack, it's always felt like an afterthought in the games.

Advertisement

Which is odd, right? Especially considering that if you check the reviews for any Spider-Man game from the past couple of decades (which I have done), there's a good chance a major criticism will be the wall crawling segments.

Swinging around NYC will be lovingly tweaked and tinkered with until every subtle animation and thwip of the web looks like a comic-book panel brought to life, but just attaching yourself to a wall in a Spider-Man game turns into a wrestling match as you make sure you're angled correctly, to press a button, wait a second and then look in disbelief as the camera glitches into Spidey's arse.

Advertisement

Now, overlooking or undercooking this mechanic doesn't mean that Spider-Man PS4 is suddenly a 4/10 disaster. These games are still great in spite of this recurring issue. But that said, they could be even better if they gave some love to such a signature part of this character.

The Camera Issue

Marvel

First off, obviously some of the games have done this better than others, and it's not like the system hasn't changed since Spidey first awkwardly shimmied up a wall on the Atari 2600.

Advertisement

The first 3D game on PS1, for instance, gave a lot of love to this ability, and laid the groundwork for a bunch of Spidey games to come. With platforming being all the rage back in those days, wall crawling was an essential part of the character's arsenal, and with a limited amount of web swings to get around, navigating the world on your hands and feet became a main source of gameplay.

This made for some pretty cool moments, such as the levels that had you moving up a skyscraper, avoiding those machine gun spotlights PS1 titles loved so much. There was also some rudimentary stealth involved as well, with players thwipping up to the ceiling and taking out guards from below without being seen.

Advertisement

It was a pretty good start, but with it came issues that developers still struggle to overcome to this day. For one, anything other than a flat surface would have Spidey awkwardly shuffling and spinning around trying to compute how he could possibly get over a centimetre-large lip on a skyscraper.

However, the camera was the biggest hurdle. After all, there's no point giving you a full view of Spidey on the ceiling if you can't see the criminals shooting you from below. To accommodate this, early games often swung the camera outside the map to a top-down view. While this aided clarity, it became a total immersion breaker, as parts of the environment became transparent, Spidey himself appeared to be crawling on air, and the barriers of the entire level were shown to the player.

Advertisement

The issue of how to control the camera during wall crawling is something all developers working on these games have had to battle with. During the 2000s, even into the 2010s, a bewildering camera was one of the most common criticisms in gaming. Hell, even regular action titles struggled to make one work without it freaking out and giving you a view of inside someone's skull, and those usually followed a character on ground level.

It's probably no surprise keeping this in check for a hero with much more manoeuvrability was a logistical nightmare.

Advertisement

Nobody Gets Wall Crawling Stealth Right

Beenox

Wall crawling being left in the cold suck as well because, for the most part, it and stealth sections should be a match made in heaven. Most action games have stealth sequences these days, but they're often not implemented particularly... organically.

Advertisement

Take the Arkham series for instance: its stealth was industry leading, and yet was let down because Batman needed a convenient set of gargoyles to be in every room for the mechanics to work as intended. You might even say they were the best gadget he ever needed.

Spidey doesn't need this kind of gimmicky level design to open up stealth though, because he can just web to any vantage point and stick to it if he wants. Some games have capitalised on that freedom well: The Amazing Spider-Man had pretty good stealth, and webbing people from a vantage point was as freeform as it should be. Sadly, what let that title down was the execution, with repeated animations, wonky enemy A.I. and a lack of challenge letting the idea down.

Advertisement

There hasn't been a game to properly run with that system and give it AAA production values. Spider-Man PS4 has stealth sequences in the same vein, but they don't base them around the wall crawling. Instead, you're doing the Batman thing, perching yourself on lampposts, ledges, and other pre-determined vantage points, but why?

Obviously, the reason is that it's a lot of work to make a compelling and challenging stealth section when the player has such freedom of movement, but that doesn't mean it's impossible or not worth the effort. It's kind of the equivalent of when cover shooters used to design their environments around chest-high barriers. If there were lots of these conveniently scattered around, you knew you were in for a firefight. You can spot the artifice.

Advertisement

Again, not capitalising on the freedom of wall crawling during stealth doesn't mean these sections kill their respective games, only that there's untapped potential there.

Wall Running Has Replaced Wall Crawling

Sony

It's general inelegance that's often been the real destroyer of this mechanic though. The web head might look lifelike moving along a flat surface, each pop of the shoulder blade realistically detailed, the contortions of his fingers painstakingly animated, but it's all for naught if a small pipe sends the camera flying into the floor or brings the character himself to a halt as the game glitches out while figuring out the best way to move him around the obstacle.

Advertisement

This is an issue that frustrated some fans with Insomniac's latest game. Everything else in that release is so smooth, making for a proper next-gen superhero experience, yet wall crawling felt like it was stuck in the past. It was implemented to be entirely separate from the character's other movement abilities. And, hell, a good chunk of surfaces couldn't simply be stuck to, which is part of the appeal for a lot of fans.

Likewise, attaching to a wall took a second to register, and couldn't easily be combo'd with other moves. Sticking to a surface during swinging was treated as the player wanting to stop dead in their tracks, losing all momentum in the process.

Advertisement

This could explain why Spidey's key movement system has been all but replaced by wall-running in his games. If you're not web swinging in these releases, there's a good chance you're going to be wall running. This is all well and good, but there's no reason a slightly slower wall crawl couldn't act as a complimentary middle ground between swinging and sprinting on the side of a building.

Spider-Man Is A Xenomorph

Insomniac

Not factoring these animations into the flow of gameplay stings doubly because some other releases do wall crawling better than Spider-Man games have done wall crawling.

Advertisement

Look, 2010's Aliens vs. Predator is not an amazing game. It's far worse than the best Spidey releases. And yet, it absolutely nails being able to cling onto any surface while stalking prey from below. Going from wall to ceiling is pretty seamless, and the sense of speed and fluidity isn't hampered by a dodgy camera. Sure, it's not perfect and there are issues, but nothing that couldn't be ironed out ten years on with the budget of a Sony console exclusive.

I'm not using this comparison to say that all wall crawling sequences should be first-person and have Spider-Man cracking open the heads of enemies with a second mouth (though I think I've just had an amazing idea for a Man Spider video game), just that it's a bad look if Aliens vs. Predator is beating the hero at his own game. Also, there's no shame in cribbing what works, no matter how unlikely the inspiration may be.

Advertisement

Also, there's another game that perfectly highlights how the current systems are failing to live up their potential...

Breath Of The Wild Does Climbing Better

Nintendo

The latest Zelda, in an attempt to give the player as much freedom as possible, lets you climb literally anything in the environment. There's challenge and a sense of progression in climbing being limited by a stamina meter (that you can upgrade) and being impacted by different weather (rain makes you slip), but that makes it so satisfying to indulge in your curiosity and climb to anywhere that catches your eye. Even better, it's smooth and fluid to actually engage with and use, as Link moves around obstacles with grace and speed.

Advertisement

Put simply, in this way, Zelda is actually more like Spider-Man than Spider-Man is in his own games.

While you can similarly climb anywhere you want in most games based on the web head, it's never incentivised in the same way. There are few places in the open world you can't get to faster by swinging or wall running. It's a shame though, as this is a whole plane of exploration that's being ignored, and would promote actually looking at the environment rather than quickly swinging past it.

Advertisement

With NYC set to be reused for most Spidey games, having these nooks and crannies that can only be found by careful wall crawling could give the city more depth and detail, setting it apart from versions of it that players have swung through so many times before.

Is It A Big Deal?

Insomniac

I realise that talking about Spider-Man's totally not terrible wall crawling in his video games for 2000 words now might seem a bit like overkill, but it's a fair criticism considering it's been completely ignored and botched for decades now.

Advertisement

Every time a new trailer comes out for a new game with the hero at the helm, the Internet explodes with discussion over the minutiae of the web swinging mechanics. Everything from the speed to the animations to how physics-heavy it is is scrutinised, often in a way that makes the eventual game better, as developers respond to feedback.

And yet, arguably an ability just as integral to the Spider-Man character as that gets a fraction of the same attention. With so many Spidey titles building on and refining web-swinging systems and ideas introduced in previous games, wall crawling deserves the same love.

Advertisement

If you want players to really, truly, feel like Spider-Man (there it is again), you can't keep ignoring one of his most unique strengths.