Video game adaptations of licensed material often dont fair well, with countless tie-ins failing to take advantage of the potential offered by their source, and a general sense of frustration hanging over the genre as a whole, but in 2012 Telltale Games discovered a key secret ingredient; quality writing. Thanks to their outstanding writing, The Walking Dead didnt just tug on our heart strings, it completely tore them out of our body, along with our hearts, and pushed them through a grinder. Its that much of an emotional rollercoaster of a ride thanks to the fantastic voice acting, complex, and multi-dimensional characters - even further in fact, they are more lifelike, sympathetic, and relatable than Rick Grimes and his TV show cohorts. Thats not me knocking me the show or comics either, as I deeply love them too, but when it comes down to it though, the actual video game series has better writing and is simply more engaging than its affiliated stories. Is this partly due to how the morally tough choices presented to the player can determine the fate of certain plot centric characters? Possibly: its easy to scream at your television about how stupid the characters are, considering the consequences arent resting on your shoulders. When you are the one calling the shots though, you cant help but get attached to each and every death. And with Season 2 of the episodic series on the way, it feels topical to reflect on those that are no longer with us, and to prepare for the inevitable emotional devastation of the incoming season.
5. Carley/Doug
Way back in the beginning of the series, Telltale flung one of the most difficult narrative driven choices in gaming on you; choose which of these characters - that are useful for radically different reasons - would die while you save the other. This climactic cap-off to episode one really set the stage for what was to come from this series, and proved Telltales claim that your choices would carry heavy consequences. Naturally, you only grew more attached to the character you saved. I actually played the game multiple times too and have seen various dialogue interactions, so I really got to understand both characters. Nevertheless, episode 3 contains a genuinely shocking moment when Lilly shoots whichever character you saved in cold blood. Its all because the survival group begins eroding from the inside too. Players that saved Carley may have suffered an additional emotional kick however, considering that a strong case can be made that her and Lee were subtle love interests. Losing Doug is a blow too, but realistically hes just the tech savvy survivor and carries slightly less importance.
4. Larry
Larry is a confrontational hard-ass no matter how you slice it, but he only behaved that way because he was overly protective of his daughter Lilly. Its assuredly a natural personality of a father with a young adult daughter amidst a zombie apocalypse. Still, he didnt deserve to die though, despite how rude he responds even when youre kind to him, and the moment comes with a typical emotional punch: You have to remember that Kenny is also a father too and has a wife, and if you die in The Walking Dead, youre getting reanimated as a zombie whether you were bitten or not, so in his position it is understandable why he decided to crush Larrys entire head with a block. You can perhaps argue that Larry wasn't technically dead, but the group wasn't in the strongest of positions at the time to rationally talk everything out. Kenny is justified in murder, but seeing it go down for the first time truly upped the ante on the kind of experience Telltale was delivering - no character was safe and could seemingly be killed at any second.
3. Duck And Katjaa
Continuing along with Kenny as a loving father and husband, fuelled and determined to shelter them from danger, we come to one of the most controversial and gut-wrenchingly depressing sequences of the entire Season. As previously mentioned, no one is exempt from death in this game. Not even children. Admittedly, I had a cold feeling that Duck was screwed the moment writers had him warming up to Lee, acting as the Robin to his Batman-like traitor seeking sleuthing. His naivety and innocence as a child only wanting to help began shining through. Its a segment that changed many peoples original perception of him from Kennys bratty annoying kid, to someone you could care for. And then he gets bitten. You are also left with one of the cruelest decisions in the game; force Kenny to kill his own child or end the misery yourself. Its a twisted world, and the unbearable pain causes Katjaa (Kennys wife) to commit suicide. This is without a doubt that moment in the Season where we all questioned how much more sadness we could take. In the blink of an eye, you can lose everything in the world you live for. Powerful stuff.
2. Kenny
Throughout most of the game Kenny is an alcoholic, questionably murdering people, and generally only looking out for his own family, regardless of how you personally treat him in dialogue choices. He walks a fine line between two-faced and justifiable with his cynical decisions, that usually only benefit those he immediately cares about. Its only natural then that when all is lost, his last act is completely selfless and an attempt to save someone else. We never technically see Kenny die on camera, but I think its a foregone conclusion that he willingly died to not only save another life, but potentially rejoin his family in the afterlife. Whether you found him an irritable jerk or not, theres no denying that there was humanity in him. He was essentially a man conflicted between protecting his family, and risking that ability to do so by sticking his nose out for others.
1. Lee
I think most of us knew the exact direction plot point for plot point - that Telltale was heading towards with the Lee/Clementine bonding: Lee would train her how to survive throughout the apocalypse - and either how to maintain or let go of her morality - before fulfilling his destiny of a tragic death. Whether you were ready for it or not couldnt change a single thing regarding how emotionally crippling the execution would be: all throughout episode 5, from the moment Lee is bitten you know his fate is sealed. In a last ditch effort you could go through with an arm amputation, praying that the comic logic wouldnt apply to the video game adaptation, but its all white noise. Telltale designed their game around a bonding that would never be forgotten, largely thanks to player interaction. These writers eloquently provided us the tools to mold Clementine into whatever we saw practical to survive, and we will take those teachings into Season 2. Are you excited for more riveting Walking Dead drama? Comment below and keep on the look-out for further coverage!