A year in the WWE can feel like a lifetime. One minute a wrestler is main eventing, a while later and they can't even get on the show. That's partly why it's refreshing to get an annual WWE 2K video game release, it reflects the changes in the WWE programming. The stars who were considered the best rated talent a year ago are in some instances the weakest wrestlers on the show today. There are guys who won all the time in the run-up to WWE 2K14's release, who nowadays lose every week in under three minutes. WWE 2K15 is going to have to reflect these changes, so expect the in-game 'ratings' system to look very different come the October release. 2K14 ranked its wrestlers out of a hundred. The top level talent, the television main eventers, were mainly attributed to be a 90 plus. Some of those same names will struggle for the mid 80's this time around! Some of 2K14's most difficult wrestlers to beat are going to need a serious downgrading... so let's get straight to it!
15. The Rock
WWE 2K14 Rating: 95WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 90 We start off with a big rating to get the feature underway, WWE 2K14 cover star The Rock with a game rating of 95. Did he deserve it? He had main evented WrestleMania in 2013 but hadn't wrestled at all in the six months before 2K14's release. He hasn't competed at all in over fifteen months now. A downgrading is going to be essential based on this lack of activity, sure he's a legend, but he shouldn't be ranking above the likes of Steve Austin (94 in 2K14). In truth, the only reason The Rock was ranked 95 in 2K14 was because he was the cover star. His ranking made him the joint highest ranked player on the game (alongside John Cena). That was clearly not reflective of reality, it was a perk of being the game's franchise star. This year 2K can appoint The Rock a more realistic rating, which would be around the 90 mark.
14. Christian
WWE 2K14 Rating: 86WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 82 Christian has had a miserable last 12 months, mainly due to injury issues and lack of creative push. He slightly got his career going again at the start of 2014, but a March concussion has since sidelined the Attitude Era star. In all likelihood he's near retirement and his best days are firmly behind him. 2K14 had ranked Christian as an upper mid carder, but even last year he was struggling for a firmly relevant role on WWE television. This year he is absolutely on the fringes of the company and 2K15 will reflect this with a relegated ranking. A lowly 82 rating seems fair. His role in the new game should be that of an easier AI, an opponent that new players can tune up against.
13. Damien Sandow
WWE 2K14 Rating: 87WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 80 What a difference a year can make. Twelve months ago we had Damien Sandow riding high as Mr Money In The Bank. Fast forward to present day and his weekly work involves coming to the ring in fancy dress and losing in 3 minute squashes. He is literally getting zero attack in these days, instead being nothing more than a mannequin to absorb other wrestler's blows. WWE 2K15 will have to reflect this with a rating downgrade. Sandow enjoyed the lofty rating of 87 in WWE 2K14, he was a moderate challenge to beat, his move set had impact. For the new release that will have to be diminished. A rating of 80 seems more in line with his television status. His computer AI should be reduced and he should be one of the easiest characters to beat on the game. That's just the way things have gone for Damien Sandow this year.
12. R-Truth
WWE 2K14 Rating: 87WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 82 R Truth has rarely ever been used beyond short jobber matches in the last few years, so how on earth did he achieve an 87 rating for WWE 2K14? That meant he was one of the better characters on the game, even though he was rarely if ever on WWE television. His main reason for having a job in WWE is merely to lose to more important superstars. 2K15 need to reflect this with a major rating change. Instead of being at the top end of the 80's, Truth should be at the low end of the 80's. He's a smaller guy with low-power moves, fodder for gamers who are working their way into the game.
11. Dolph Ziggler
WWE 2K14 Rating: 89WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 83 With a rating of 89 for WWE 2K14, Dolph Ziggler was considered a main eventer by 2K's developers. His character AI and move impact were strong, he was one of the more challenging opponents on the game. You can understand why 2K programmed Ziggler in this way. In their developmental phase over the spring of last year, Ziggler was legitimately a headline star. He was taking part in main events against Alberto Del Rio and challenging for the World Title. Unfortunately, due to outspoken criticism in the media about the way he was booked, Ziggler ended up being put in the WWE dog house. He has spent much of the last 12 months either not appearing on cards or simply being used as a three minute jobber. He's probably the biggest loser on WWE television from the past year. In reflecting this, 2K15 will drop Dolph's rating to around the low eighties. He will become one of the very basic wrestling characters. In all likelihood this could be Ziggler's final game appearance; his contract expires at the end of 2014 and with his current situation he must be considering his options.
10. The Miz
WWE 2K14 Rating: 89WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 85 The last year has been a bit stop / start for The Miz on WWE television. Luckily for him, he's getting a bit of television presence back as Intercontinental champion right now. That should help him retain some of his WWE 2K14 status as one of the superior talents. However, Mizanin really does need some sort of downgrading for the new game. His previous rating of 89 meant he was just one point removed from the same status as Batista. How does that add up? Batista is a giant of a man with a powerful attack. Miz in contrast is a smaller and less aggressive worker. As for main event stature, WWE TV gave up on Miz in those spots long ago. Quite why 2K14 gave him a main event rating that was just two points lower than Brock Lesnar is a mystery. A downgrading is necessary for 2K14. A rating of 85 is more in line with the midcard spot Miz will feature on for the rest of the year.
9. Mark Henry
WWE 2K14 Rating: 89WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 84 Mark Henry is another star who 2K assigned with an 89 rating. You can partly understand why Henry got such a high rating last year; as an upper mid carder he was challenging John Cena for the WWE title around the time of 2K14's production. He's also helped by the fact he's a big guy. Size matters and large guys are harder to beat, so giants usually do get a big rating in video games. For WWE 2K15 though, the developers are going to have to downgrade Henry's status. He's still a big man, so they won't downgrade it too much, but his inactivity this past six months means he can't be ranked alongside WWE's finest. A moderate 85 seems a realistic valuation. He'll still be a challenging opponent on 2K14 because of his weight advantage, but no way should he be the level of toughness from last year. Age and injury have seriously marginalised the 43 year old's effectiveness.
8. The Big Show
WWE 2K14 Rating: 90WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 87 Big Show isn't going to be downgraded massively, he's a giant, from a video gaming perspective that demands he be a challenge for the player. However, Show does need to be dropped down a couple of pegs for WWE 2K15. His rating in the last game made him one of the very elite wrestlers. That simply isn't the reality on WWE television. He was destroyed at the hands of Brock Lesnar at January's Royal Rumble and lost in the Andre Battle Royal at WrestleMania 30. Other than that the Giant has been out of the spotlight - although he is due to return to television imminently. A lower rating will reflect that Big Show is no longer a main event player. He's a reliable upper mid card act, who at the age of 42 is winding his career down.
7. Rey Mysterio
WWE 2K14 Rating: 90WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 83 Rey Mysterio has been ineffective in WWE for a few years now. He barely features on WWE television and when he does he's a shadow of his former self. The sad reality is that two decades of wrestling a dangerous style have ruined Mysterio's body. He has serious knee injuries and physically hasn't been able to compete for some time. He's still on the current WWE roster, but in all likelihood, he probably won't be seen in a WWE ring again. The game in 2013 had Rey ranked as a mighty 90. That was more reflective of his main event stature from over half a decade ago. With barely any action in the past year, the rating needs lowering. It might even be the case that WWE use the game to take a shot at Mysterio, turning him into the video game equivalent of a jobber. That's because backstage in WWE, the management aren't happy with how much ring time Mysterio has missed. The dispute has furthered after Rey's contract was extended beyond his will, due to all the ring time he owed the company. A lower rating in 2K15 could be a typical WWE way to take a shot at the star.
6. Ryback
WWE 2K14 Rating: 90WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 83 Ryback is the perfect example of a flash in the pan wrestler. He got over huge in the latter half of 2012, helped greatly by an undefeated streak and feud with CM Punk. Chants of 'FEED ME MORE' filled arenas and Ryback was main eventing consecutive pay per views. If it hadn't been for CM Punk's long planned WWE title match with The Rock, then WWE would almost certainly have made Ryback champion in that period. Instead, Punk prevailed in the feud, which sent Ryback's momentum crashing to a halt. The 2K developers put 2K14 together with Ryback in mind as the guy who nearly dethroned Punk, but over the course of 2013 it became increasingly obvious that the wrestler was far from a main event product. He's now a non-persona in the Rybaxel tag team. With this tumbling fall in television status, expect a serious demotion in 2K15 too. The makers thought Ryback was a big star a year ago, they now know he's not. The ludicrous rating of 90 in 2K14 will be replaced with a still generous value of around 83 in 2K15.
5. Kane
WWE 2K14 Rating: 91WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 85 Kane featured twice in 2K14, you could play as the modern day persona or the retro Kane. In both instances his rating was 91. Let's put that into context here: Brock Lesnar is also rated 91. Multi-time World Champion Edge is rated 91. Is the current Kane really on a par with Lesnar? Is the retro Kane really equal to Edge's career? You have to say that 2K over-rated the big red machine. He's a reliable and solid talent, but he shouldn't be ranked alongside the same challenge of a Brock Lesnar. It wasn't even as if Kane was a major star when 2K were making last year's game. He was then the comedic partner of Daniel Bryan in the mid card's Team Hell No. Since then his career declined into a period of inactivity before a slight resurgence in recent months. Indeed, he's actually challenged for the Title as recently as Battleground. However, we fully expect Kane to return to the lower rungs of the roster very soon. A continued rating of 91 in 2K15 would be wholly misleading. The developers would be much better advised to rate Kane an 85, allowing space for newer 90 rated wrestlers such as Roman Reigns.
4. Randy Orton
WWE 2K14 Rating: 92WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 89 With a rating of 92, Randy Orton was considered one of the very elite wrestlers on WWE 2K14. Only John Cena was rated higher out of the full time wrestlers. Is 2K's high rating a fair reflection of Orton's talent? He was a WWE Champion as of SummerSlam 2013 and remained at the top of WWE's cards all the way up until WrestleMania 30. The thing is, Orton just isn't very exciting. His action is based on being a heel rather than being the best. You certainly wouldn't say he was a tougher opponent than Brock Lesnar. Neither would you say he's a better wrestler than a Cesaro (rated 88 last year). Taking these factors into account, 2K should consider a demotion for Orton in 2K15. The 92 rating makes him one of the very best in 2K14, regardless of era. It just doesn't ring true. He's good but he shouldn't be getting put in the same brackets as the likes of Austin, Hart of Flair. For WWE 2K15 a rating of 89, just below the magical 90 level, seems far fairer.
3. Triple H
WWE 2K14 Rating: 93WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 90 Triple H is a 93 in WWE 2K14. That makes him the elite of the elite, one of the game's best characters to play as, one of the toughest AI's to defeat. Is he worthy of the lofty rating? He barely wrestled in 2013, save for a win over Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 29 and a loss the next month to Lesnar at Extreme Rules. Did that really warrant him being rated two points above Lesnar and just two points below franchise star John Cena? Of course not. Hunter got a high rating in 2K14 for much the same reason he gets the spotlight on television - because he wields backstage power. He's been slightly more active in 2014 and had first rate matches with Daniel Bryan and The Shield. Still, that doesn't justify Hunter being ranked head and shoulders above everybody else. A rating of 90 in 2K15 would better reflect the fact that he's one of WWE's older part time stars. The high 90's should be going to the likes of Reigns, Wyatt, Rollins and the young headliners who really are lighting WWE's product up.
2. The Undertaker
WWE 2K14 Rating: 93WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 90 This might be a bit unfair, it might be a bit controversial, but The Undertaker in 2014 is not the same Deadman of yesteryear. If 2K15 is looking to stay true to the WWE television product, then it must downgrade The Undertaker accordingly. He infamously lost to Brock Lesnar this year at WrestleMania 30. It was a terrible match and Taker legitimately looked weak. He's clearly a declining force. 2K15 can mirror real life by downgrading Undertaker from a 93 rating to a 90. That's realistic because he's always going to be a 90 region player, he's always going to be booked as one of the toughest forces. The change merely reflects that he's at the imminent retirement stage of his career.
1. Hulk Hogan
WWE 2K14 Rating: 94WWE 2K15 Expected Rating: 90 With the 30 Years Of WrestleMania mode, 2K had to program Hulk Hogan as a force to be reckoned with. The Hulkster was a key part for the first nine Mania shows and beyond. This year, there's a less of a reason to make Hogan so strong. A rating of 94 in 2K14 made Hogan one of the toughest characters to face, in addition to making him one of the easiest characters to win as. In the entire game, only The Rock, Shawn Michaels and John Cena are ranked higher with 95. We've already said that Rocky should be downgraded. As for Cena, he's the top star of the era, it's right that he should be rated as such. In the case of Michaels, he's the best pro wrestler ever. A rating of 95 is fine. Hogan however isn't deserving of his elite level rating. He was a poor technical wrestler and shouldn't be so vastly superior to WWE's current crop of stars. A 90 rating in 2K15 is a fair appraisal of Hogan's legend status, a demotion that opens up the top ratings in 2K15 for WWE's new generation of stars.