WWE 2K17 Early Reviews: 10 Things We Learned
The reviews are coming through: how does WWE 2K17 stack-up?
WWE 2K17 has finally hit the market after months of of hype, and the game has a lot to live-up to. Last year’s incarnation represented a big leap forward from 2K15’s disappointment, and while far from perfect, 2K16 was a step in the right direction for wrestling games in general.
With streamlined gameplay, altered reversal and grappling systems, and a focus on realistic simulation-style gameplay over the arcade trappings of old, 2K16 improved on its predecessor's core gameplay. Though still relatively slow and clunky, the Creation Suite saw a number of new options added, while the unparalleled match choice and giant roster made for endless replayability.
Despite 2K16’s improvements, 2K17 entered development with a number of problems to resolve. The desolate and disjointed My Career mode has long been a bugbear in WWE games, as has the lacklustre commentary, and while 2K16’s Creation Suite was better than 2K15’s, it still wasn’t quite as comprehensive as in previous versions.
Have they pulled it off? It’ll be a few days before the reviews really start flooding through, but the early signs look relatively positive for 2K17. Consensus is that Yuke’s and Visual Concepts have developed another solid wrestling game that’s not a giant leap forward, but presents some notable improvements alongside a handful of regressions.
Here are 10 things we learned from WWE 2K17’s early reviews.
10. If It Ain't Broke...
You know how the old cliché goes.
2K stumbled upon a winning formula with 2K16, and it looks like they’re treading the well-worn EA Sports path with 2K17. For the most part, this year’s game is marked only by a handful of changes to the core gameplay systems, with My Career, Universe, and the matches themselves functioning very similar to 2K16.
There are plenty of new features in 2K17, but none are big enough to make a significant impact on the all-round gameplay. If the early reviews are to be believed, 2K17 will provide a very similar experience to 2K16, so if you had fun with last year’s game, you’ll probably enjoy this one too.
It’s a smart move from the developers. While they won’t want to fall into the habit of releasing the same game with slightly updated rosters and stats every year, there’s no point in messing with a winning formula. It’s unlikely to convince anyone who’s already decided that the 2K games aren’t for them to change their mind, but such familiarity will likely appease the series’ loyal fanbase.
9. The Commentary Stinks
Regardless of the developers and publishers, commentary has always stunk in WWE games. For whatever reason, nobody has ever been able to pair fluid in ring action with with suitable, natural-sounding announcing. The games have always suffered from announcers that sound like they’re reading a series of misplaced soundbites from a script, with their monotone, lifeless voices doing nothing to amplify the action.
This is no different in 2K17. Michael Cole, Jerry Lawler, and JBL are as atrocious as ever, and provide tiresome, repetitive commentary that largely revolves around them delivering the same handful of clichés over and over again. 2K17’s commentary is now stuffed with advertisements for the game itself, but most egregious of all is the use of the term “Divas” to describe WWE’s female wrestlers: a word that hasn’t been used in six months.
You can argue that 2K17’s terrible commentary is an accurate reflection of that found on Raw and SmackDown, and therefore amplifies the game’s realism, but there’s no excuse for this. What’s most surprising is that Yuke’s old UFC Undisputed games had tremendous commentary, and the NBA 2K games feature some of the most dynamic, informative commentary you’ll ever hear in a game. Sadly, the developers show little interest in improving this aspect of their WWE games, and it’s to their detriment.
8. The Sound Needs Work
Sound effects and music are a big part of the WWE 2K experience, but it looks like the developers have flubbed their lines this year. It starts with the soundtrack, and while there’s nothing objectively bad about P. Diddy’s chosen songs, it lacks the energy of previous games, and therefore detracts from the experience. Reviews state that Diddy’s beat-orientated hip-hop is too calm and relaxed to get the pulse racing, particularly compared to the series’ old fast-paced, hard-hitting rock songs.
More worrying than the soundtrack, however, is the poor audio mixing. The issue rears its head all throughout the game, but it’s particularly prominent during wrestler entrances. Any character that talks or yells in their ring entrance finds their delivery either amplified to ear-piercing levels, or muted to a barely audible level. It’s a relatively minor presentation glitch, but a noticeable one.
The mixing issue is something they’ll likely patch at a later date, and the music is entirely subjective, but it sounds like 2K has taken a step backwards in this regard. For a publisher with such a great reputation for outstanding presentation, this is disappointing.
7. A Refined User Interface
WWE 2K16’s user interface was far from ugly, but it was a little clunky at times. The menu system often felt overly blocky and simplistic, resembling Windows 10’s Start menu more than a means of navigating through a videogame. Still, it was functional enough to make working your way through the game’s menu systems an unobtrusive experience.
In WWE 2K17, the developers have tightened the nuts and bolts to present a cleaner all-round UI. The menus have larger been stripped of 2K16’s static photographs, and the game makes greater use of the wrestlers’ character models instead. This is particularly noticeable on the wrestler select screen, where the characters don’t feel static and lifeless, but alive.
WWE 2K17 just feels like a tighter, more professional experience. These changes improve the game’s dynamism tenfold, and the greater emphasis on character models, however flawed they may be, really helps immersion levels. Few things looked worse than one of your engine-generated CAWs standing beside Triple H’s photograph in an old match preview screen, but that’s not a problem any more.
6. Graphical Inconsistencies
Despite positive tweaks on the UI front, WWE 2K17 is a graphically inconsistent game, and as mentioned previously, some of the character models just aren’t up to scratch. Wrestlers like John Cena and Triple H are recreated with an incredible level of precision and look remarkably close to their real-life counterparts. Others? Not so much.
The Usos and Revival suffer from bland, blurry character models that look nothing like they should, while Becky Lynch and Alexa Bliss would be barely recognisable if not for their attire. The women are particularly problematic in fact. In 2K17, long hair looks like a sodden mop, and the textures are basic at best.
The graphical inconsistencies extend far beyond the character models, though. The arena’s lighting and smoke effects look much improved from 2K17, but the pyro and fire still lag behind. Such shoddy effects have been a regular problem in WWE game for years, and 2K17 does nothing to improve them.
There are countless other examples spread throughout the game, and while these changes are purely cosmetic, they do see 2K17 lose a couple of points on the presentation side.
5. Matches Have Been Streamlined
While the developers have moved away from the WWE games’ old arcade-centric style, 2K17 brings through a number of minor changes that only partially succeed in streamlining the gameplay.
First is the new “roll-out” function in multi-man matches. What it essentially does is force a wrestler who has taken a certain amount of damage to leave the ring and catch a breather, rather than hobble around and extend the beatdown. Players determine the time taken to get back inside, but while it forces more effective stamina management, it’ll frustrate fans who just want to get on with it.
Ladder matches have been greatly simplified. The roll-out system comes into play here too, but you can’t just set up ladders in any old place any more. Ladders must now be “locked” into a certain point in and outside the ring, and while those does make placing them easier, it diminishes the match’s chaotic nature, and makes them feel like a more linear experience.
The result of these changes are matches that look and feel a lot smoother, but have a reduced propensity to descend into the kind of all-out mayhem that often makes these games so enjoyable.
4. The Gameplay Is Deeper Than Ever
WWE games used to be arcadey, quickfire affairs that favoured urgency and quick thinking over careful planning, but not any more. The days of straightforward reversals and simplistic controls and long gone, and 2K17 continues the move towards slower, simulation-based gameplay that kicked off in 2K16.
Some were turned off by 2K16’s slower pace, and they’re not going to come running back for 2K17. Timing and coordination are more important than ever, and if you don’t spend time learning from your mistakes, you’re not going to go very far in 2K17. Just like last year, this game rewards patience and repeat plays, and players can’t just go all-out from the first bell. It may work on occasion, but destroying your stamina early on will most likely lead to a quick defeat.
2K17 might be the series’ truest representation of professional wrestling yet. It might feel sludgy to start with, but 2K17 will slowly reveal its depth as you become familiar with the mechanics. After a while, your dedication will be rewarded, and subtle changes to 2K17’s physics and grappling systems make it a game worth mastering.
3. The Promo Engine Is A Flop
2K17’s new Promo Engine was marketed as a means of letting wrestlers “express themselves to the WWE Universe and call out or respond to other WWE Superstars” during the game’s development. It sounded like a welcome addition: promos and interviews have been a vitally important aspect of professional wrestling since the sport’s rise to popularity, and they’ve never been accurately recreated in the games.
Unfortunately, 2K17’s Promo Engine fails to deliver on its promise of a more interactive experience. Promos come in six different forms (self promotion, call out, turn face/heel, form/break-up tag team). The player selects one of four dialogue choices, the character delivers a text-based rant, and if it involves a rival, the promo’s subject responds. It sounds straightforward, but it’s mired with problems.
The lack of voicing makes it a flat affair, and the whole experience is marred by some cringe-worthy dialogue. Early reviews mention John Cena cutting AJ Styles to his very core by calling him a “rooster,” and countless occasions of opponents calling the player-controlled character a “malodorous mouthpiece.” All in all, the system is a flop, the dialogue is distractingly awful at times, and there’s much room for improvement.
2. A Mixed Bag Beyond The Ring
One of WWE 2K17’s biggest selling points was the renewed ability to fight in new areas outside the ring. Though this feature was constant throughout early WWE games, it had been stripped away in recent incarnations, but while WWE’s current PG trappings have largely removed this from the real-life product, crowd and backstage brawls have been restored in 2K17.
The execution is a mixed bag. According to reviews, fighting at ringside feels better than ever thanks to the implementation of new, TV-style camera angles. Ringside battles were often viewed through a single hard camera in previous games, but the new angles really make you feel like part of the action, and brawling in the crowd works incredibly well. There’s an area near the announce table jam-packed with weapons, and you can bludgeon your opponent until your heart’s content.
Backstage fighting isn’t as successful, however. While it’s nice to have the option of throwing wrestlers around the corridors again, it’s limited to one on one affairs, and let down by a lack of variety. The old SmackDown games featured a wide number of backstage environments, but 2K17 only includes a handful. A wasted opportunity.
1. My Career Still Sucks
My Career is a great concept. Take your rookie wrestler from learning his craft at the Performance Center through working his or her way through NXT, finding a place on the main roster, competing for titles, and becoming a legend.
It’s a nice idea, but the developers never seem to get it just right, and 2K17 is no different. This year’s version is incredibly similar to 2K16’s: you put your character through matches with the intention of winning, earning experience, increasing your attributes and skills, and getting involved in the odd rivalry. The formula is fine, but the execution is off.
As mentioned earlier, the Promo Engine doesn’t really work. It’s a fun diversion for a while, but it quickly falls into the same repetitive trappings that have plagued Career mode for years. Working with Paul Heyman is another distraction, but it takes at least five or six hours to get to that point, by which you’ll have already wrestled your seventh consecutive singles match with Wesley Blake.
By all accounts, My Career remains a draining, grindy experience with little reward to compensate your efforts. The RPG elements still give a sense of progression, but WWE 2K17’s nonsensical booking and lacklustre stories detract from any satisfaction gained.