If theres one thing an older generation can be counted on to leave to young people, its criticism of their music. Even in the 60s, when popular music underwent an unprecedented period of innovation and growth, parents overheard their kids listening to that Led Zeppelin 'noise' and wondered if theyd turn out okay. So when we criticise the pop music of today, it's important to make sure we aren't just being crotchety old-timers, making us ask a reflective question; is there something objectively worse about the pop music of today? The answer, of course, is yes. Just listen to it it's terrible. So much Top 40 material is unmemorable and unsatisfying cheap, two-note hooks surrounded by computer-generated noises and sung with Auto-Tune. Even whats not on the radio seems to be suffering from a dismal lack of ideas, retreading ground already covered with better verve 50 or 60 years ago. Its easy to view music from that era as the pinnacle of pop and rock music, and indeed many people do. While there are plenty of good things happening in music today, the trend if you could somehow chart quality over time for top-selling music has undeniably curved downward. How did things devolve so badly?
10. Too Many Genres
Baskin-Robbins has 31 flavors, and heavy metal has about twice as many subgenres. At the rate metal critics are subdividing their acts, itll get to the point where each band will be the sole representative of its own genre. But metal isnt alone in this similar nitpicking can be found in just about every larger music community, from folk to electronic. Its a bit like looking at a magazine rack there are publications for every interest, hobby and fetish you might imagine, from gun, car and nudie mags to philosophy and astronomy journals. A band does not deserve to be placed in its own genre for playing "doo-doo-da" well the other bands are playing "doo-doo-dee." Catering to fan demand is one thing, but the real problem is labels telling the band what fans want and then making fans want it through advertising. Many of the most commercially successful artists are those who play to their genre-determined specifications to a tee. Imagine the Zac Brown Band attempting a cover of War Pigs, for instance worse than sounding ridiculous, they'd risk losing their fanbase, a chance fewer and fewer artists are willing to take. Depending on the genre, there might be a moratorium on certain instruments, singing in certain registers, using certain chords, or singing about certain subjects. An adventurous artist would never self-impose these kinds of arbitrary restrictions.
9. Tween Pop
This should go without saying, but lets get it out of the way Miley Cyrus and One Direction suck. Its not an edgy or a controversial opinion, but the promotion of teen pop idols is a mystifying perversion of the very word music. Frankly, Justin Bieber CDs should not even be considered musical products they have more in common with trading cards and glow sticks than they do with music. These poor kids are groomed to appeal to our basest consumerism, unveiled to the world once every year or two like an iPhone by proud corporate parents like Disney who parade them around like child pornographers. If you manage to get past the cult of personality and listen to the recording itself, youll quickly learn that the word disposable doesnt begin to do it justice razor blades are disposable but at least they have a function. Until the artists grow up, break down and become unsafe for marketing, they serve kind of the same function that TV does a cheap babysitter to keep kids busy for a while. But as Bill Hicks once asked, When did mediocrity and banality become a good image for your children? Kids who grow up listening to this will one day have to be deprogrammed, like victims of a sinister, smiling cult.
8. Indie Music
Indie used to be short for independent, meaning an artist who is without big-label representation and, at least theoretically, free to record music that comes straight from the heart. At some point, the term came to refer not just to an artistic philosophy but also to a genre of music, which, sadly, tends to be about the least-offensive, middle-of-the-road production in the industry today it can only be described as adult contemporary/soft folk. Its meant to appeal to yuppies, which is why so much of it sounds like an Apple ad rudimentary guitar strumming, lily-white boys and girls singing whimsically and an air of deluded happiness. If you still dont know what its like, take an infectiously charming song like Here Comes the Sun; then, strip it of innovation and melody and replace its musicianship with a rich liberal arts graduate whos played guitar for two weeks. Theres lots of bad music out there, but this too-frequently takes the cake. Its inoffensiveness is by far its most offensive aspect. Bizarrely, its a darling to much of the establishment music press, but its got to be called out for what it is. As the great music critic Butt-head once said of an indie song, This is music for like people who have, like, never had anything bad happen to them.
7. The Death Of Radio
Heres a dare: spend an afternoon tuning your radio dial and see how many actual DJs there are and how many truly great songs you hear. Unless youre lucky, youre more likely to hear commercials, talk radio, Top 40 and three classic rock stations playing Slow Ride at the same time. FM radio is pretty well dead, and the internet killed it. Like so many aspects of the evolving industry, this is good and bad. People now have unlimited access to the worlds music, and an up-and-coming band has more avenues for self-promotion than ever before. On the big scale, its fantastic at no other time in history could a do-it-yourself musician show something she made in her bedroom in Stockholm to someone in Albuquerque on the same day she made it. But what radio did was provide a community for music. It kept things organised; your local punk station advertised all the upcoming punk shows and a good DJ introduced new artists you needed to hear. With the internet, theres exponentially more material, and sure there are plenty of fan pages; but a diverse and lively radio scene ensured an ongoing local conversation, a satisfying experience that a lucky Pandora discovery made while doing the dishes just cant compete with.
6. Inauthenticity
That quaint, charming fella you've been listening to strum the mandolin and sing about growing up on the farm? Don't let the cowboy boots fool you he's from Albany and drove a Ford Focus in high school. The folk "revival" is roughly the musical equivalent of a Civil War reenactment, starring guys who work for a telecommunications concern by day entertaining uncritical audiences by night by pretending to be rural. The folk revival could be an entry on this list unto itself, but there's a great deal of inauthentic music floating around today. White rappers with college educations come out of the suburbs to tell us all how rough things are on the streets. Boy bands sing about purity rings and abstaining from drugs while they're on the road getting away with we-only-wish-we-knew what. Musicians used to sing about what they knew. Now they sing about what they think they know from movies and TV. Of course, a suburban life in the 80s or 90s is hardly worth singing about, so that explains some of the branching out but some examples of this are pathetic. "Give the people what they want", that's what they say. It doesn't matter if you've never even seen a car in your neighbourhood older than a 2005 if you can convince enough people you've got the blues, you can play it all you want.
5. No New Innovation
Nothing is ever totally new. Even when the Beatles exploded as risk-taking, experimental artists, traces of influences from the Byrds, Bob Dylan, the Beach Boys and others could easily be spotted in their music. This isnt a bad thing, and no one holds it against them: the greatest artists of the world always have a creative way of spinning something old into something new. Unfortunately, over the last several decades, the innovative spirit of the 60s has given way to increasingly computerised instrumentation, preposterous stage shows or louder and dumber guitars. As in many mediums, musical shock value has increased while its quality has cheapened. The last truly groundbreaking bands might have been The Talking Heads or The Police 35 years ago, but the basic way of structuring and presenting a pop song has remained practically unchanged in six decades. There's a reason classic music is still so popular: it's better. Rock music is dead, its principle bands playing undistinguished chords with ridiculously overdriven guitars and sexually explicit lyrics that make ZZ Top's Tube Snake Boogie seem like a sly, coy wink. Even Madonna sounds sophisticated next to her musical descendants, whose songs are awash in tuneless sound effects. Faster, heavier, louder, weirder these are not, in and of themselves, innovations worth celebrating.
4. Music Technology
Want to break into the music industry, but dont have any actual talent? No problem! Auto-Tune will keep you in key, and a whole bevy of programs will write and then practically perform the song for you. There is, perhaps, no better example of this than the 2011 song Friday by Rebecca Black. It was invented as a vanity project for a well-off young girl, features heavily computerised instrumentation and Auto-Tuned vocals, and made its rounds through social media, propelling Black to nearly overnight stardom. And it stank. Pop and R&B songs use technology excessively to mask poor singing, weak writing or simple instrumental incompetence. In the process, it strips music of all its humanity which is really about the only thing that ought to matter. Its a way to create and market people who arent actually musically compelling, but have the right personality to sell tabloids and be a major cash cow to a record label. What else could explain the mystifying presumption so many people have that Miley Cyrus is actually talented? In live performances, the situation has gotten even more out of control. Lip-syncing is common; so is guitar-syncing. Modern musicians are actors first and foremost; the music is a secondary characteristic, almost an afterthought and entirely forgettable of the show. The true star is just the personality that's on stage.
3. Music-On-The-Go
Theres something not a lot of people seem to know about music: it wasnt meant to be listened to through a one-inch cell phone speaker. No wonder so much modern music is commercialised and disposable: that's exactly how so many of the people who consume it treat it. Even though its easier now to make a hi-fi recording than its ever been, theres the distinct possibility of an immaculately produced song being compressed so it comfortably fits on an iPhone, where it will be docked for convenient listening on the go while working out, shopping, hanging out by the pool, or even at a party. The time of music being an activity unto itself, with the listener completely absorbed and free from distraction, has largely passed. Everyone has the right to experience music in their own way. But theres something sorely wrong with a person never experiencing live music or the full breadth of an important recording on a nice sound system. Albums like Dark Side of the Moon ought to be played in schools, with kids who talk during it receiving a detention, rather than everyone passively looking it up on YouTube where there's a scroll bar to skip the slow parts. Going from big records and booming speakers to MP3s and a laptop is like going from a wedding cake to a Pop-Tart.
2. Lack Of Identity
Think back to classic bands of the 60s and 70s. Almost as soon as a song begins, it can be identified as belonging to Led Zeppelin, Jimi Hendrix, Jethro Tull, The Beach Boys, Queen, Santana hell, even ABBA. Whoever it is, theres a particular guitar tone, vocal giveaway, or some other cue that reveals the artist, even if youve never heard the song. Its called having an identity, and its something sorely lacking in modern pop music. Just try telling the difference between Nickelback and Three Doors Down. Production values have become so homogenised that just about everybodys distorted electric guitar sounds exactly the same. Theres a flatness to the sound, where every instrument is either being pushed through with pathetic overdrive or, in the case of so many indie bands, suffering from a kind of quiet lethargy either way, hardly anything really distinguishes itself. The identity crisis is so bad that numerous artists simply take to sampling older songs, adding their own obnoxious dubstep beat underneath it and hoping they don't get sued. Lyrically, things dont get any better. Its hard not to become nostalgic for 60s rock when you consider the political potency of that decade. From the Beatles to CCR, songs reflected the times and frequently served as a call to action. Now, even as the worlds many problems have become more transparent and unavoidable, very few artists seem interested in making a statement on it at all.
1. Commercialisation
Just about all the problems listed before can be spun back to this rampant commercialisation has destroyed music. Labels have always been in business to make money, but money is officially the only thing that talks in music today. Its because of commercialisation that all bands within a genre sound the same. Commercialisation brings us Auto-Tune, suburban blues musicians, One Direction notebooks and Miley Cyrus grinding the son of TVs Alan Thicke. It kills the radio and promotes online streaming where the advertising can't be skipped some programs go so far as to pause the ad if any rebels dare mute their computer during them. Part of the problem is the modern makeup of major labels. One might think that the younger, hipper executives of today would produce better music. Instead, the opposite is true: As Frank Zappa recalls below, in the 60s the older, cigar-chomping executives said, "I dont know. Who knows what it is? Record it, stick it out, if it sells alright." Hip scouts and producers by contrast are far more conservative, paid specifically because theyre supposed to know ahead of time what will and what wont work, minimising labels financial risk but dramatically watering down the product.There are easier ways than ever for musicians to go around the corporate influence and get their names out there, but to reach the truly titanic heights enjoyed by the artists dominating the industry today requires corporate backing. Unfortunately, corporations have determined that the lowest common denominator is the easiest way to sell music. If that seems sad, don't worry too much: the 60s and 70s produced more great music than most people will have a chance to get to in their lifetime, and there are great bands out there working today - you've just got to ignore what the big labels, 'hip' people and advertisers are trying to sell you. What other problems do you think are destroying the core of the artistry behind music? Let us know in the comments!