10 Bands We Miss More Than Some Of Our Own Relatives

Catch them while you can, and as for the rest it's over to pristine archive footage and the power of your imagination.

By Ted Meyer /

What would you give to see Led Zeppelin live? We're not talking about a reunion show. No, this is Zeppelin in the mid-1970s, with John Bonham still kicking and the band at the height of their considerable powers. What would you give? A year's wages? Your dog? Your first-born child? Whatever you say, someone else can almost certainly best you. These hyperbolic assertions don't do much to mask a sad truth; in music - as with everything - time marches on and we lose some of our favourites. There are some things that we will never be able to do again, and the prospects of seeing any of these bands ever again are at best remote and at worst completely impossible. The losses of these and many other legends can be crushing. Generations of young music listeners grow up knowing that they will never be able to see their favourite band. Every great has a litany of imitators and followers, but this is little solace in the face of the crushing grief we feel at never being able to see our personal favourites in the flesh. Thousands of bands have come and gone over the course of rock's history, but which 10 bands do we miss the most fiercely?

10. Rage Against The Machine

Nobody worked the metal-anarchy shtick as successfully or maniacally as Rage Against the Machine. After nine years, three astonishing original albums and thousands of concert arrests, Zack de la Rocha departed the group, leaving Tom Morello and company to regroup as Audioslave alongside Chris Cornell. Audioslave captured some of the sonic overload of Rage but none of the wit or politically charged fury. La Rocha was angrier and more devoted to his anarchy than any other like-minded frontman; he wasn't seeking attention for his music unless it would have brought tangible change. His brutally honest devotion to anarchy and societal deconstruction is one of the things that gave Rage its unstoppable force. That, and the unbelievable guitar work of Tom Morello. Rage is most commonly characterised as a rap-metal band, but Morello brought both the funk and the noise, concocting that high-pitched slide guitar effect that is perhaps the band's most distinctive sound. Morello's post-Rage work has disseminated much more popularly than De la Rocha's. His Nightwatchman project reveals him to be just as political as his former creative partner, and his on/off work with Bruce Springsteen (particularly his funk-ifying efforts on Springsteen's latest, High Hopes, and the hell-raising take on "The Ghost of Tom Joad" that Rage pioneered on covers album Renegades) has been one of the more fruitful love affairs in recent rock music. But even these fine endeavours don't fill the massive chasm in our collective hearts where Rage Against the Machine used to be. Metal is such an outsized, ridiculous genre that it has become nearly impossible to take seriously, but these guys really bought into it - all the fury, the technical prowess and the noise. Angrier, louder, funkier and smarter than their numerous punk/metal contemporaries and followers, their unique sound and style will never be replicated. But hey, at least we got a couple of reunion tours.

9. Sublime

The best of the Third Wave American ska bands, Sublime's loss can also act as a stand-in for the broader loss of popular ska. Noting what makes this genre so great reveals much of what is lacking in rock these days. Why doesn't anybody play that uptempo anymore? Why have horns disappeared; are there no more trumpet and trombone players in the world? Does nobody know how to have fun anymore? Sublime's enduring legacy masks just how flash-in-the-pan their popularity was. After two lively but raw albums, they finally hit it big with their self-titled third effort, a terrific record featuring most of their biggest hits. Unfortunately, just as they were hitting their stride, frontman Bradley Nowell died of a heroin overdose, missing membership in the 27 Club by just a few months. Sublime was just as punk as some of their contemporaries, but their biggest hits - "What I Got" and "Santeria" especially - reflect the general irreverence and relaxed tone that the Long Beach-beached based band nevertheless achieved. Sublime lived as much of a rock'n'roll lifestyle as anybody, but their songs about sex and drugs were always among their chillest. Talented songwriters, Sublime's ska perfectly straddled the line between the thrash of punk and the diverting leisure of reggae, and they are deeply missed.

8. The Band

The Band's sonically unique blend of southern folk and early rock music resulted in an incredibly vibrant catalogue. They fulfilled many roles over their varied career, backing Bob Dylan's tours in the 1960s and continuing to collaborate with him throughout a fruitful studio career of their own. Robbie Robertson was a terrific, distinctive songwriter. Songs like "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down", "Up On Cripple Creek" and "The Weight" carry a kind of rustic permanence that really couches The Band in the folk traditions they were reared on with Dylan and their earlier collaborator Ronnie Hawkins. Robertson urged the group to orchestrate their own farewell in the epic final concert The Last Waltz, which was accompanied by a Martin Scorsese concert film of the same name. An even cooler "dry run" of sorts for this spectacular show can be found on Rock of Ages. Post-Waltz tours didn't include Robertson, and The Band didn't put out much more original material. This kind of telegraphed exit is almost unexampled in rock history. With a distinct crossover style and some truly monumental credits to their name, The Band and the few groups comparable to them are sorely missed in today's music scene.

7. The Doors

The Doors did so many things better than anyone else. Arguably, they had the best keyboardist and most distinctive lead singer in rock history. Jim Morrison - perhaps music's most mythical single figure - glided over all of their best songs with his slinky, ethereal voice, and Ray Manzarek (who usually played bass at shows) couched their brand of rock more closely with the blues than any other band (except maybe one group that appears later). Their style varied widely, ranging from slow, old-blues jams (Back Door Man) to bizarre, quasi-occult epics (The End). It's impossible to separate The Doors' legend from that of Morrison. His on and off-stage antics gave the band a lecherous reputation, but his sophisticated, philosophical lyrics and devoted energetic performances give the band their most memorable qualities. His grave in Paris is perennially littered with flowers and loving notes, even more than 40 years after his death. The attempts of remaining band members to continue without him were honorable but sadly doomed. The Doors died with Morrison, and this remains one of music's greatest losses.

6. Nirvana

One of the main progenitors of the 90s grunge movement, Nirvana was - if nothing else - loud enough. But they also knew how to accentuate and emphasise their volume. Kurt Cobain said that Smells Like Teen Spirit, one of the most influential songs in recent memory, was his attempt to achieve the loud/soft dynamic of the Pixies (another much-missed band). This consideration reflects their intelligent song construction, and it can be found on In Bloom and lots of their other best songs. Listening to their catalogue can seem contradictory. On the one hand, they have a song called Rape Me, but on the other you have the more contemplative All Apologies. One thing their songs all have in common is a tortured self-loathing, coupled with sardonic attacks on society's myriad of faults. Unfortunately, Kurt Cobain may have bought too much into the doom and gloom, killing himself at the age of 27 in 1994. Cobain and Nirvana were gone far too soon, but the brevity of their career has only served to heighten their already substantial legacy.

5. The Police

The Police stand out in rock history for their tight playing style and their general stability, which stands in sharp contrast to a number of other entries on this list. They had a unique, evolving sound - listening to their records is to hear them go from raw punk-reggae grooves to polished pop songs with dub and jazz sensibilities. What they retained through their style changes was really tight songwriting and a knack for a killer chorus. Their songs often speak of forbidden and failed love, and in this romantically dystopian worldview they look forward to British bands like The Cure and Joy Division in the 1980s. Though they were "The biggest band in the world" by the time of their final album, Synchronicity, the band's quality began to slowly slip after their awesome third album, Zenyatta Mondatta. Sting must have agreed, splitting with the group in 1986, then going on to have a terrifically successful solo career. The Police stand out in rock history for their early blending of reggae, jazz and punk. They've had their stylistic followers (one of them, Sublime, appeared earlier), but none of them were as polished or professional in their delivery as The Police were.

4. Beastie Boys

Rest in peace, MCA. The surviving Beastie Boys have been relatively quiet and inactive since Adam Yauch's tragic death in 2012. While the landmark hip-hop band has not technically broken up, it seems safe to assume that, at the very least the band will be unable to continue as they once were. We can hope for more work from Ad-Rock and Mike-D, but the Beastie Boys we knew will never be the same. Beastie Boys have the sound of a thrashing, furious rap band, but the rage in their vocal deliveries masked intelligence and irreverent wit. This was a group with staying power; they evolved and maintained relevance throughout their career. There are great Beastie Boys records scattered through four decades, right up until Hot Sauce Committee Part 2 from 2011. Beastie Boys aren't the only funky rap group to rise from the 80s, but they were definitely the most prolific and long-lasting.

3. Talking Heads

Talking Heads stand in stark contrast to the ridiculous dream-pop of the 1980s. Their music is a unique concoction of punk, jazz and world music, distilled into a distinct and incredibly catchy catalogue. They contributed an unorthodox songwriting style and a use of unusual sounds that has opened the door for hundreds of alternative bands to follow. There is, unfortunately, no love lost between frontman David Byrne and the rest of the band members. As the 1980s wore on, the band increasingly came under the creative control of Byrne, who has since been accused by other band members of being an unloving egomaniac. Their quality does slip a bit after 1983's awesome Speaking in Tongues. Byrne and long-time producer Brian Eno have had prolific careers since Talking Heads' acrimonious 1991 breakup, but their work with the full band was catchier and more accessible. Unfortunately, it seems that some musicians just aren't meant to play with others.

2. James Brown

Saying that there will never be anybody like James Brown is as close to an undisputed statement as anyone can make about music. The arrangement style of a James Brown song is extremely distinctive - very tight and deeply funky. His use of horns can sound spare, but that's just because Brown's own histrionics were already so wild and unfettered. He's one of the distinct superstars - an iconic singer, dancer and stylist. There's no equivalent to him today. There are some extremely funky bands out there, like Parliament or Lettuce, but nobody's distilling anything into such an authoritative, regal persona like James Brown could do. Another fairly recent loss, James Brown is one of the few inclusions on this list who didn't die or suffer some sort of irreparable creative breakdown. He had the dignity to record and perform until his death in 2006. Though his popularity waxed and waned over the years, his prolific recording career produced literally hundreds of great tracks. So much material exists that it's hard to take full stock of his career. Listening to - or better, watching - his live shows gives a much better sense of his real affect. He flails and dances crazily, yelling at his band, calling out for the bridge or a solo. It's all in the best of fun. There have been plenty of great soul men since James Brown, but he's the purest, best performer soul or funk will probably ever see.

1. Led Zeppelin

No band will engender the worshipful reverence that has been bequeathed upon Led Zeppelin. It seems that their titanic stature has almost grown since their 1980 breakup immediately following the death of John Bonham. Zeppelin practically invented every trope and cliché in metal and rock n' roll, with their booze-and-sex-fuelled tours, occult references, thunderous guitar riffs, and hyper-masculine lyrics and affect. As large as Zeppelin mythology looms, the four members of Led Zeppelin were such insanely talented musicians and performers that their music is still much more legendary than their debauchery. It is nearly impossible to imagine the band without the unique contributions of each member - the alternating elegance and unabashed insanity of Jimmy Page's guitar, the ecstatic, sexual howls of Robert Plant, the precision and versatility of John Paul Jones and the sheer power of John Bonham, perhaps the greatest rock drummer of his or any era. Small wonder that upon the death of Bonham, the remaining members felt they "Could not continue as they were". As deeply individual as each member's style was, the band's blues-rooted brand of rock represented a unique watershed between the blues and roots music of the first half of the century and the screaming metal that would follow. Unfortunately, most of Zeppelin's followers haven't a fraction of their musical intelligence or raw talent, and this makes the loss all the greater. At least we can console ourselves with their great existing catalogue and a few wild live records. The mythic status of the greatest rock band of all time seems likely to only grow as new generations continue to discover where hard rock really came from.