10 Best Acoustic Metal Songs
Discarding the distortion.
Metal music is not a genre that tends to downplay a lot of things. From the first time bands like Black Sabbath and Judas Priest roared onto the scene, the dynamic range of most metalheads was set firmly to KILL without a tinge of remorse for the listener.
At the same time, even some of the best riff masters figured out that the pure shock value of metal does get diminishing returns every once and a while.
After slogging it out playing the same type of head-splitting riff for years on end, most acts start to see what other types of music are out there. It could be in electronica or jazz or even pop, but sometimes it's best just to pick up an acoustic and see where it takes you. As opposed to making a song designed to scare you to death, these tracks make you settle into their dark groove in a far more understated way.
While some may use the acoustic as the foundation for the dark tune, others may use it as an added extension to provide a sharp contrast from the bludgeoning you'll receive in the rest of the track. Even if it's only for a few seconds, stripping down these songs to their most bare form made them cross over from good to great.
10. So Far Away - Avenged Sevenfold
Losing a member of a band is like losing a family member. After years of slogging it on the road, in the studio, or just hanging out, how are you supposed to move on once an integral piece of the puzzle isn't there anymore? Though times looked dark for Avenged Sevenfold after losing the Rev in the early 2010's, So Far Away showed them channeling all of their turmoil into the music.
When compiling the tracks for their next album Nightmare, the Rev had already laid down a lot of the songs before his untimely death. Left with half an album to finish, the group came together with an acoustic song in So Far Away, which felt like they were trying to contact their lost brother from the other side of reality.
While the song was originally written by Synyster Gates as an ode to his deceased grandfather, lines about time turning a page and not being able to speak to your loved ones has the Rev's aura all over it.
As the band took the road, they dedicated every performance of this song to the Rev's memory, becoming one of the true power ballads the band has in their catalog. It's said that time heals all wounds, and with songs like So Far Away around for catharsis, metalheads will have a great song for when they have to deal with friends venturing into the great beyond.
9. Orchid - Black Sabbath
No one was really asking Black Sabbath to go for a softer approach. The whole appeal of Sabbath in the early days was a bunch of bludgeoning rock tunes that helped birth what we know today as heavy metal. Even though these demonic riff masters had plenty of classic tunes at their disposal, the real musical chops came out in between the chunky riffs.
While many people point to Planet Caravan off of Paranoid as the group's first downtempo moment, the fractured beauty gets amplified even more on Orchid. Seeing how most of Master of Reality is a pure exercise in stone rock glory, having a little acoustic section to start off the second side of the record is just what the listener needs to prepare themselves for Round 2. Instead of the typical psychedelic musings you would get on Caravan, this song shows Tony Iommi strapping on an acoustic guitar and playing in an almost classical style.
In just over a minute of runtime, those acoustic picking sections cascade over your eardrums, almost like it's trying to bandage you up from the beating you already received from songs like Sweet Leaf and Children of the Grave.
So the next time you discount Black Sabbath as being the lords of doom metal, just throw on something like this to see the mellower side of hard rock.
8. The Messenger - Linkin Park
A Thousand Suns by Linkin Park may be one of the most misunderstood albums of the modern age.
While the blend of electronic noise and nu metal didn't really sit well with the die hard fans, this approach turned into a rallying cry for the modern age, with bands like 21 Pilots adopting more of the artificial style on their later releases. Even if you wanted nothing to do with the beep-boops you heard on this record, the final track leaves nothing to the imagination.
After being thrown right into the anarchy of post-nuclear war on the Catalyst, The Messenger is where everything comes to its world-worn conclusion. Whereas other tracks tended to have fifteen different production styles within the span of a single song, this is just Chester with an acoustic guitar, as he tries to scrape together what remains of his soul after the trauma of the rest of the record.
This track also hits especially close to home after Chester's passing, with lines like "remember you're loved and you always will be" tearing most fans' hearts to pieces when the singer was found dead by suicide in 2017. This might not be the most satisfying conclusion to the group's electronic opus, and yet the frayed sanity from Bennington doesn't seem to fit anywhere except the end.
7. Question! - System of a Down
Many nu metal fans might not want to admit that System of a Down is a bit of a one-trick pony. Even though most of these guys' songs sound the same, no one's really complaining when the quality is still great from top to bottom. However, if System were ever going to bring it down a notch, they were going to do it on their terms.
Throughout the sonic rollercoaster you got on the double album Mezmerize and Hypnotize, Question! is still one of a kind in the group's catalog. Opening with a subtle classical guitar passage, the track almost feels slightly schizophrenic from one section to the next, with one odd timed riff switching to a subtle acoustic ballad on a dime. Just when you think you've settled into the groove, the chorus will come in with an operatic section that will leave you with your mouth on the floor.
In any other band, a song like this would sound cluttered as hell, but since the song is about the separation of two lost lovers, the balance of quiet sadness and overt despair works amazingly well when bouncing off of these different styles. System may have been known for putting you through the ringer more often than not, but Question! is one of those rare moments where all of the sonic experimentation pays off in spades.
6. Patience - Guns N Roses
It would have seemed impossible to hear a band like Guns N Roses going the soft rock direction when they burst onto the Los Angeles club scene. After all, how the hell were you supposed to make a slow-tempo song when you have literally been christened the World's Most Dangerous Band? Despite having the muscle to stomp out the rest of the poodle-haired metalheads, these hard rock troubadours made a little piece of magic when they ventured into the studio for GNR Lies.
While most of the record has a freewheeling energy given the group's turbulent touring life, there was at least one gem to be found in the power ballad Patience. Written by Izzy Stradlin as an ode to his girlfriend, this track quickly became one of their greatest slowburns live, coming as a sort of palette cleanser in between the heavier sides of the show.
Unlike the other larger than life hair metal ballads, this track is straight and to the point, almost evoking the weary spirit of the cowboy songs of decades before.
Despite the fact that Guns were about to get much more extravagant on Use Your Illusion, this was a nice peak at what the Most Dangerous Band could sound like when they strip all the bombast away. Not exactly dangerous, but from the heart...like all good rock and roll should be.
5. Dee - Ozzy Osbourne
The heavy metal community really didn't deserve a guitar god as legendary as Randy Rhoads. After Ozzy Osbourne was left dead in the water in the aftermath of Black Sabbath's breakup, Rhoads gave him a new lease on life, with some of the most tasteful solo runs to come from metal's golden age. Then again, Randy didn't really need all the flashy extensions to impress us either.
Even though the Prince of Darkness is front and center on his debut Blizzard of Ozz, Dee is Randy's real showcase, where he goes to town on a classical guitar, hammering out one of the most beautiful melodic passages in metal history.
Given that Rhoads' playing style was much more indebted to classical music, it was pretty much expected that something like this would have found its way onto a record sooner or later.
For a musician that was all about the darker side of rock, the message behind the song is almost wholesome, with Randy dedicating the tune to his mother, who first taught him about musical composition when he was a young boy. You probably weren't going to find something like this in the middle of Ozzy's live shows, but Dee will forever be known as that little beauty that only the hardcore fans remember.
4. Suicide Note Pt. 1 - Pantera
The real draw of Pantera always comes down to Dimebag Darrell. While people may love the distinctive growls of Phil Anselmo, the real muscle behind these tunes is when Dime would take his Dean guitar and go off the rails, with some of the scariest sounding lead tones ever put to tape. Even though the Dean felt like an extension of Dime's body, there is one outlier in Pantera's golden age that doesn't feature his signature six-string.
After annihilating the metal community with Far Beyond Driven, the Great Southern Trendkill offered a bit of a different sound on Suicide Note Pt. 1. Instead of the regular stomping rhythms we've gotten accustomed to from this era of the group, most of this song is dominated by 12-string acoustic guitars. While the tempo eventually picks up in the eventual Pt. 2 of this song, it was still weird to see this soft-spoken moment from a band that was used to tearing your head off.
At the same time, it makes sense that Dime would be well-versed in the acoustic, seeing how his dad was familiar with the country music scene, and even Dime himself guesting on Rebel Meets Rebel, which was released shortly after his death. Despite the metal-headed mentality of most of Pantera's material, Suicide Note Pt. 1 proves that the outlaw mentality isn't exclusive to heavy riffs.
3. Vermilion Pt. 2 - Slipknot
It gets a bit contentious talking about Vol. III: the Subliminal Verses amongst Slipknot fans. While many fans see it as a great bridge between different genres of heavy music, some of the original Maggots felt betrayed by the softer direction that happened across the track listing. However, slowing a song down doesn't mean that the band had lost their edge.
Coming towards the middle of the record, the Vermilion songs tap into something much more disturbing for Slipknot, as Corey Taylor takes on the persona of a man who falls in love with someone who isn't even real. This kind of neurotic behavior works great in Pt. 1, and yet it's the slowed down versions that ends up making your blood curdle that much more.
Instead of having this man having his mental state break down before your eyes like on the first entry, Vermilion Pt. 2 is the sound of that same man completely devoid of his sanity, trying to pick up the pieces of his shattered mind.
Though this is definitely not a song to mosh to, what it lacks in punchiness it makes up for with some of the darkest lyrics Taylor has ever put down on record. Yeah, it's not as heavy as some of their other stuff, but sometimes a song doesn't need to sound scary to make you feel uneasy.
2. Nutshell - Alice in Chains
Alice in Chains always seemed to have two different sides of themselves. In addition to having two competent lead vocalists with Layne Staley and Jerry Cantrell, these Seattle rockers were as proficient in acoustic music as metal, with songs like Man in the Box being balanced on the other side by Brother or Got Me Wrong.
Even though the group laid out all of their demons on their album Dirt, Jar of Flies showed that there was much more to unpack on Nutshell.
With Staley at the forefront, this entire track feels like giving up, as the singer sounds tattered and torn at the hands of his addiction. Set to just a few cowboy chords from Cantrell, Staley's performance almost feels like him releasing every single emotion he has left in his body, with subtle hints of beauty appearing just below the surface.
While Cantrell tries to add some life into the track with his final guitar solo, there's no escaping the drug-addled haze you're stuck in.
This song also ended up taking on a new life when Alice played it live on MTV Unplugged, as Layne looked like he was at the end of his rope, completely consumed by his demons. No one should have to die for the sake of their art, but sometimes the most beautiful musical passages can only be born out of tremendous pain.
1. Fade to Black - Metallica
Metallica were never really concerned with commercial success when they first started getting the ball rolling. Emerging out of the Bay Area metal scene, these thrash metal titans made it their mission to become the biggest band in the world without having to cower to the more corporate side of rock and roll. Then again, a good song was a good song at the end of the day.
Despite being labelled sellouts for picking up an acoustic guitar, Fade to Black quickly turned into one of the greatest songs in Metallica's arsenal. After slogging away at the same fast tempo riffs, this emotional tale of a man having suicidal thoughts was much darker than any fast riff ever could be.
Even though James Hetfield really shines on this song, there are traces of Cliff Burton's influence all over it, from the classical harmonies sprinkled in to the melodic counterpoint happening in the outro.
While there might be faster songs in Metallica's catalog, this is the one sweet spot in their discography that was able to speak to the disenfranchised metalheads without having to dumb down their sound at all.
Fade to Black might not be the first song people associate with Metallica, but when you break it down to its raw essentials, this may be one of the best musical pieces this band has ever written.