10 Best Documentaries About Musicians

Cinematic looks behind the music.

By Steve Beres /

Music documentaries are in full form when their focus is limited to a specific artist or band. When the subject is at most four or five people, there is more potential to arrive at bare human emotion than say, a film covering a wide movement of a certain important genre. The most interesting films about music are the ones that put you in the head of the artist in question. Maybe they won't release every factual detail to sum up an artist's life, but they infuse the documentary with a mood that puts you directly in the shoes of an artist either at a specific point in time or throughout their entire life. As we see from the following documentaries, music is not always fun. Whether the conflict of enjoyment is brought about from malicious record companies, family drama, or mental illness, most brilliant musicians become consumed by their environment. The exhausting effects of one's surroundings can both trip up an artist's success and fuel their voice, and the following documentaries display how far a musician can be pushed by their situation for better or worse.

10. I Am Trying To Break Your Heart

This 2002 film by Sam Jones follows rock band Wilco throughout the arduous process of releasing their acclaimed album "Yankee Hotel Foxtrot." A beautifully shot look into the often strained relationship between a band and their record label, "I Am Trying to Break Your Heart" sees a band on the brink of hitting it big but stuck in the procedure of getting the album in question released. Great music documentaries often showcase the internal strife of a band, and the film really represents the disintegration of Jeff Tweedy and guitarist Jay Bennett's relationship, which leads to the latter's ejection from the group. The knowledge that "Yankee Hotel Foxtrot" is arguably the group's best release makes the conflict with their record label all the more frustrating. "I Am Trying to Break Your Heart" perfectly executes the struggle to put out a piece of art while being held in the palm of a corporate gatekeeper.

9. Mistaken For Strangers

This tour documentary following The National as they tour behind "High Violet" stages the dynamic between lead singer Matt Berninger and his brother Tom, the director of the film. Strangely enough, their interpersonal dynamic bears a similarity to that of David Spade and Chris Farley, albeit through a slightly more somber perspective. Tom is the boisterous extrovert in a room full of studious indie musicians. His actions, while well-meaning are often without grace. He often sees himself in the shadow of his more successful older brother, who is constantly trying to improve his sibling. The film, beleaguered with the tone of a song by The National, takes a closer look at a relationship between vastly different brothers and its effect on touring. It becomes an inadvertent behind-the-music documentary as their bond faces increased scrutiny.

8. Beats, Rhymes, And Life: The Travels Of A Tribe Called Quest

Directed by actor Michael Rappaport, this documentary discusses the history of seminal hip hop group A Tribe Called Quest. The film is entrenched in Rappaport's adoration for the group, which characterizes the film in an interesting manner - an exploration of musicians through someone whose attachment to their music drives the movie. When approaching the hostility between Q-Tip and Phife, Rappaport does so with the same interest that any fan may have. His depiction is not sensationalist, but rather out of genuine interest in his heroes. It is a tense look at the popularity of musicians credited with changing the direction of an entire genre along with the problem of conflicting egos that eats away at any continuation as a group. While the film portrays what makes the rappers so influential and important to hip hop, its study of interpersonal dispute puts it among any standard dramatic work illustrating the same trope of competing genius. A captivating portrait of rap pioneers.

7. The Punk Singer

"The Punk Singer" takes an in-depth look at one of the most important figures in punk music - Kathleen Hanna. It charts the progression of her career from the rise of her most well-known act Bikini Kill, to the formation of her electroclash band Le Tigre, and the various incarnations of The Julie Ruin. In between it all is a compelling look into her life behind and between the music as well as the varied responses to her work, from those who were reviled to those completely enamored. Everything is examined with unwavering energy as the young Hanna finds influence in experimental writer Kathy Acker and becomes the wild voice of the Riot Grrrl movement. Fellow musicians such as Carrie Brownstein and Kim Gordon discuss the power of Bikini Kill in the 90s as an energetic paragon of third-wave feminism. In 2005, she inexplicably dropped out of the music world and the documentary addresses the reason for her absence - a diagnosis of late-stage Lyme disease and her battle with the illness. The latter half of the film is spent discussing her struggle in solitude and the staging of a comeback with 2013's "Run Fast." The film is an excellent portrait of an essential figure in music as she continues to fight.

6. A Band Called Death

A particularly prevalent topic in music documentaries are those musicians that should have hit it big; musicians that showcase a particular originality and energy that should have awarded them with a greater amount of respect than they ever received. Very rarely has the case displayed a greater potency than in "A Band Called Death." 1970s rock band Death, despite being early purveyors of punk music, never made it out of Detroit. The film follows the quick period of formation and dissolution among the brothers Hackney as they eventually abandon Death and let their lone demo together vanish into relative obscurity. That is, until record collectors picked up a 45 containing songs off the self-financed record and passed it around among music fans everywhere. The two remaining brothers Bobby and Dannis are rewarded with the regained interest in their music on a wider level, playing the festival circuit and having their original album reissued. The documentary sees important figures in the course of music finally receiving their dues.

5. Louie Bluie

Terry Zwigoff divides his debut documentary between a primer on the history of country blues music and a portrait of forgotten member of the scene Howard "Louis Bluie" Armstrong. Armstrong and his fellow musicians are celebrated as well as accurately portrayed as living in their modern, less-than-glamorous lifestyle. The film portrays an outsider in the present world - Armstrong's musical stylings and artistic outlook have been replaced with the various movements of music that have occurred since his performances would have been considered relevant. Armstrong walks around Chicago and balks at concepts of modernity, specifically a Picasso sculpture erected outside of an office building. He calls it nothing but "a whole lotta money, a big bunch of bullsh*t down the drain." Armstrong is a relic and while the film focuses on it, it does not decry it. Though ultimately, the documentary is infused with a particular optimism for those who belong to a movement that society has deemed "irrelevant." It explains that as long as you can belong to a pocket of creators that support you as much as you support them, you can remain at peace with your art and your lifestyle.

4. What Happened, Miss Simone?

Nina Simone is one of those musicians whose storied life makes a perfect fit for a narrative. The film portrays both her massive talent and her divisive political views. The film's introductory scene sets the stage for the energetic documentary with a 1976 performance that shows Simone's fiery stage performance in all of its glory. Although she berates audience members for not applauding, her set is typically incredible. The film is populated with racial alienation, a feeling which followed Simone for all of her life. As she channels her anger into her songwriting, her fans grow more divided than ever. Simone's important activism is not lambasted in the film as it may have been in an older documentary, but rather portrayed as virtuous. Her rebellious nature was important to her character, and being an outspoken black woman in the 1960s deserves to be treated with dignity. No more relevant a time for this film to come out than this year, in which black self-image is something that remains pushed down by the media and often lambasted. Nina Simone was an incredible talent proud of who she was with no apprehension.

3. Montage Of Heck

Kurt Cobain's story is one that has been both analyzed in every which direction and mythologized to a dangerous extent. While "Montage of Heck" incorporates both approaches, it does so in a manner that places the viewer in the lonely and alienated world of its subject. Through archival footage, interviews, and animation filmmaker Brett Morgen paints a bleak portrait of one of rock's most idolized outcasts. The film tries its hardest to become Cobain himself, detailing his entire life from growing up in Aberdeen, Washington to his suicide at the age of 27 and digging deep inside the artist in the process. Conflicting reports of his outlook on success wrap around a depiction that rarely leaves its place of hanging over his shoulder. Dissection feels too on the nose as a description for the documentary, and yet its messy examination is due in part to the life it analyzes. Kurt Cobain appeared to be a musician whose story had been entirely understood by those aware of his music, but "Montage of Heck" proves that our knowledge of the man was surface level at best.

2. The Devil And Daniel Johnston

Daniel Johnston's legacy is divided between a critically exploitative display of his music and a deep kinship from his most ardent followers. The film "The Devil and Daniel Johnston" takes the approach of understanding the outsider artist as much as possible, through the people who are closest to him as well as following him as he exists in the present day. For many, Johnston's songs are those which most deeply understand feelings of depression and mental illness, but being someone who most understands mental illness means that you have the burden of dealing with mental illness. The film examines his series of nervous breakdowns throughout the 1990s as he drifts in and out of psychiatric hospitals and becomes what he calls "the ghost of Daniel Johnston" at the start of the film. And often cinematic approaches of mental disorders tend to sensationalize for some sort of dramatic effect, but "The Devil and Daniel Johnston" hits its exploration of the topic on the nose. The film's importance is equal in navigating the life of an acclaimed outsider musician as well as mental illness in general. There is a celebratory nature at the end that leaves us with images of Johnston still performing - though of course this celebration comes with its footnotes. The footnotes in question being that Johnston's fight with manic depression and flights of grandiosity still remains, albeit to a possibly more muted extent, and they have essentially sucked him dry. It gets what is at the crux of his output - an understanding of our darker sides, but an inability to not be overwhelmed by his own darkness.

1. Anvil: The Story Of Anvil

Sacha Gervasi's 2008 documentary serves as the progenitor for the movement of documentaries depicting artists that "were never as big as they should have been." The particular artists in question are 80s metal band Anvil, who served as a key element in the development of speed metal among artists such as Metallica and Anthrax. Though as opposed to most bands belonging to the aforementioned subgenre of documentary, Anvil have remained together for over thirty years. The film follows them as they embark on a European tour that barely stays together, bludgeoning the band with disappointing encounter after disappointing encounter. At one particular venue, their audience is next to none save for several headbangers and a goat. The film plays on the notion that viewers are hungry for discomfort. There is something relatable in seeing people who are constantly being beaten back by the music industry and yet won't give up. But the cross section of people who watch something such as "This Is Spinal Tap" and find something to laugh at are hit with the depressing reality that these musicians faithfully remain in. The duo work at their respective depressing jobs, trying to gather together money to record their 13th studio album. What follows is an excruciating exercise in rejection. And yet, there is a persistence of hope. As much as "Anvil: The Story of Anvil" is an upsetting comic endeavor, it is also a portrait of those who will never give up which leaves as much optimism as it can.