10 Greatest Drummers In Rock Music History

Titans behind the skins.

By Tim Coffman /

As far back as rock and roll is concerned, we've always had drummer jokes.

Advertisement

Even in the era when the drummer has actually come up to the front, it's hard to shake off the Spinal Tap cliche of the drummer being either the dumb one or the most undependable member of the group. If all you needed to get by was a decent drummer though, rock wouldn't have survived for nearly as long as it has.

From the British Invasion onward, the best acts in the world have benefited from having an expert behind the skins. From manic tom fills to immediately catchy drum parts, these guys had the capacity to tear a drum kit apart if given the right opportunity.

That's not the point of drumming though, and most of these musicians understood the power of building a classic part, whether it's some crazy fill or hanging back in the groove.

Note the mention in the title. This is going to be just in the rock category, and the world of metal is going to have to be reserved for another day (Sorry Danny Carey....and not sorry Lars Ulrich). If we're sticking just to standard rock and roll though, we have got an absolute treasure trove to look through. Whereas the singer might be the voice of the band, these are the guys who provide the beating heart.

10. Larry Mullen Jr. - U2

The idea of drumming for a mainstream rock group seems more and more like a thankless job.

Advertisement

I mean, since someone like Meg White could find her way into the public eye by just pounding away on a few snares and cymbals, it should be a walk in the park, right? The beauty of being a drummer though is just how much you're able to do with just the little bits of percussion in front of you.

While most people come to U2 for the warped sounds of the Edge and Bono's upper register, they wouldn't have been able to reach half the heights they could without Larry Mullen Jr. in the background.

Outside of his incredible sense of timing, there are a lot of unique tom fills sprinkled throughout their back catalog, like the iconic opening of Bullet the Blue Sky and the pattern for Pride, which involved Larry completely reworking his kit to give the song its heavy sound.

Larry also doesn't get nearly the credit for his willingness to experiment with other kinds of rhythmic approaches. You very rarely hear him play the standard 4/4 rhythm, as he puts in more modern patterns into the mix and also finding time to flirt with the world of electronica on later albums like Achtung Baby and Zooropa. He may have been in the game for a while, but Larry definitely is aware of the changing trends going on around him.

9. Jim Keltner - Various

Very rarely will you find a band where the drummer is the most recognizable guy. Outside of the acts who have the drummer sing, you're always going to focus on the guitarist or singer and leave the guy beating on the skins in the background. It can get demeaning for percussionists, but it also gives you an amazing career if you do your job well enough.

Advertisement

There are probably many people who have no idea who Jim Keltner even is, considering he has never been the main member of any specific band. What will make everyone pay attention though is this man's insane resume, being one of the go to session players in the '70s and having fruitful relationships with music legends.

Before he got his few glances with fame, his start in the '70s saw him working with people like Steely Dan on Aja and even suggesting different drumming ideas for Tom Petty during Damn the Torpedoes.

It's also worth mentioning that he was the go to drummer for one of the greatest supergroups of all time, with the Traveling Wilburys picking him up because of how consistent he was. And that's pretty much what Jim Keltner is in a nutshell. Even though he's not going to go off on some wild drum solo all the time, you don't have to worry about the drums with him at the back.

8. Alex Van Halen - Van Halen

When you have someone like Eddie Van Halen in your band, why the hell would you care about anybody else? Since this is a guy who can practically make a symphony on just one guitar, even David Lee Roth had to be getting a little bit jealous whenever he took to the stage, At the back of the stage though, Alex Van Halen's touch on the drums had the potential to equal what his brother could do on guitar.

Advertisement

The real allure of Alex's sound is just how much muscle he got out of his drums, with his snare drum almost sounding like another tom based on how its tuned. Like his brother though, Alex never just found a gimmick and decided to stick with it. Hell, if you listen to the intro to Everybody Wants Some, the rock drumming goes out the window and is replaced with some weird tribal beat that perfectly sets up the song's mood.

There are even some songs that you'll wonder if they're even being played on drums, with the intro to Hot For Teacher going by so fast that it sounds closer to a diesel engine being revved up than an actual percussion part. Though there were never questions about sibling rivalry back in the day, you have to wonder what kind of musical genius is in that Van Halen DNA.

7. Phil Collins - Genesis

And now I present to you good people...the man who destroyed Genesis. Or that's what you would be saying back in the '80s. I mean, ever since Peter Gabriel left the band and Phil Collins stepped up from behind the drum kit, these guys stopped being prog legends and became modern pop stars. If you look a little closer though, Collins never lost his massive chops in the drum department.

Advertisement

In fact, you could argue that Genesis never really hit their stride until Phil was behind the kit, bringing with him different methods to percussion that blended in perfectly with the prog rock ambitions of Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford. From the sounds of Dancing with the Moonlit Knight, you can hear the real muscle behind Collins' playing, having been accustomed to more prog outfits before he got there.

Even on the first few records with Phil behind the mic, he was still flexing his chops on the drums as well, sprinkling in different tom fills that would put some of the greatest jazz drummers to shame. Also, you have to give him props for In the Air Tonight, as he toyed around with different recording techniques and walked away with one of the greatest drum fills in rock history.

Whereas you may know him for his soft pop days, you're doing Phil so dirty if you limit him to the hits.

6. Dave Grohl - Nirvana/Foo Fighters/Everything Else

Once the '90s rock movement started to kick in, it was strange that every band was put into the same category. Even though they were all labeled as grunge, Pearl Jam didn't sound that much like Soundgarden, and no one really sounded like Alice in Chains either. If every band had their own thing, then Nirvana had their Swiss Army knife in the madman behind the drum kit.

Advertisement

Outside of being the main man for the Foo Fighters these days, Dave Grohl has always been most at home behind the drum kit, going back to when he practiced on pillows in his bedroom. While most of the praise of Nirvana comes down to Kurt Cobain, Dave always knew how to serve the song and give just the right accents to make everything explode.

Just think about a song like Smells Like Teen Spirit. The riff itself is a monster, but the song doesn't really come alive until you hear Dave's drum fill come screaming in. And the man still finds time to drum when not being up front at a Foo Fighters show, jamming with Queens of the Stone Age, Nine Inch Nails, and the supergroup Them Crooked Vultures to name just a few.

In terms of musical veterans of the rock scene, Dave Grohl feels like the drum student who listened to every lesson he learned from the masters and then applied them.

5. Ringo Starr - The Beatles

For the more cynical viewers of the rock scene, we now arrive at the least important member of the Beatles. Unless you really hate the songwriting of John Lennon or Paul McCartney, the straight ahead rhythm that you'd find in most Beatles songs would peg Ringo Starr as the unnecessary piece of the puzzle. And you'd be right in the songwriting department....if you didn't count his hooks as songwriting.

Advertisement

Outside of the normal guitar riffs and melodies, a lot of Ringo's drum parts serve as rhythmic hooks unto themselves, being a blast to play for anyone aspiring to pick up a pair of sticks. There's no way your average drummer would have thought of the weird accent shifts on Ticket to Ride, or have the endurance to hit all of those looped drum patterns dead on time on songs like Tomorrow Never Knows.

Aside from the technical chops, Ringo is always known as the ultimate server of the song. Whereas most drummers would take the opportunity to grandstand, Ringo's art is always listening to what the song needs and playing appropriately for the song, even if it means just slapping his knees or being demoted to bongos on the Beatles' more laid back material. Granted, anyone who makes a drum part as groovy as Come Together has done more than enough to earn a spot on here.

4. Stewart Copeland - The Police

There aren't too many drummers in rock who have the mantle of virtuoso bestowed upon them. Though there are technical wizards in the world of metal who can play double bass and make it look easy, it gets a bit dicey when you're laying down a simple groove. When the Police arrived on the scene, every modern drummer got an education with Stewart Copeland behind the kit.

Advertisement

The main draw behind Copeland's style is just how much crack he got out of his snare, which came from him allegedly standing on the drum head and tuning it as tightly as possible to get the maximum impact when he hit it.

That's just one facet of his drumming though. Being a part of the jazz world and trying his hand at prog rock back in the day, a lot of what Stewart does for these pop songs is a lot more complex to nail down, especially when you take into account all of the swinging hi hat work he does.

This is probably the clearest example in history of the drummer not being the dumb one either, since Copeland is acutely aware of music theory and tries his best to push himself that one step further in every song he does. In a world where rock was still looked at as a bunch of kids playing with instruments, Stewart Copeland was the one adult in the group.

3. Keith Moon - The Who

When you're stuck behind the drum kit, you're going to have to do something a little bit extra to get the attention of everyone else. Sometimes you have to have some sort of outgoing personality or you're going to have to step up your game to be able to compete with the rest of the group. So which one did Keith Moon do? Both...at the exact same time.

Advertisement

Aside from his excellent drumming, Keith Moon was an absolute freak of nature away from the drum kit, being the epitome of a wild man by tossing TVs out of hotels and blowing up his drum kit at the end of the some of the gigs. That same kind of reckless abandon often translated to his drumming too, going on different tangents and very rarely playing just a straight rock beat.

You have to remember this was years before prog rock really sunk its teeth into the rock scene, meaning Moon set the precedent for the endurance test songs for drummers.

Despite playing some of the most complicated drum fills of the time, never once did it feel like it took away from the song, with the drum solo of Won't Get Fooled Again still sounding epic no matter how many times you listen to it. Though he left us way too early, anyone even remotely fascinated with Moon the Loon knows how much he did for the drum community.

2. John Bonham - Led Zeppelin

Being behind the drum kit doesn't really give you that many options to write songs. Even though you have the job of providing the back beat to every single track, there's only so much that you can do when you just have a rhythm as your job. Drumming has always been a primal talent though, and John Bonham showed just what was possible when you released the animal inside.

Advertisement

Complete with the roughish exterior of a bull, Bonzo's drumming style is one of the most chaotic you will ever find in the world of rock and roll. Like a lot of the funk drummers of the time, Bonham always worked best when playing slightly behind the beat, giving the rest of the band a smooth foundation for the riffs to follow. When it was his time to shine though, Bonham didn't take any prisoners.

From the sound of the ending of Moby Dick, it almost feels like you're witnessing Bonham commit drum-icide, playing with relentless force and eventually giving up on sticks entirely and playing the drums entirely with his limbs. Towards the end, you'd swear that the guy has four hands to get that much sound out of a single drum kit.

Though his friends knew him for his more excessive lifestyle, the real mark that Bonzo left on rock is just how much power you need to have as a drummer.

1. Neil Peart - Rush

One of the sad realities of a musician is that you'll never be able to reach perfection in anything you do. Since we're all still human, there's always going to be that one drum fill that's just out of our skill set or a rhythm that never fully sits that well in our brain. At the end of the day, we're all still students, and it's about time that we all pay our due respect to the Professor.

Advertisement

From the minute that Neil Peart stepped behind the drum kit for Rush, he played like he had everything to prove on each album. Across their varied history, Peart never once tried to settle on a pattern that worked, sprinkling in bits and pieces of jazzy fills in their glory years and eventually adopting the new electronic sounds of the '80s as the years went on.

Like all men though, Peart was always looking to improve, going so far as to work with Freddie Gruber and switching around his grip of the stick to make for a more organic sound for Rush. Because as precise as the drum hits feel on every Rush song, you can always hear the human being inside the music.

Although the Professor may not be here to teach us anymore, he has left behind the rulebooks for how to become a true superhuman behind the kit.

Advertisement