10 Legendary Songs That Almost Weren't Released
Rock's Last Minute Miracles.
It's a small miracle to get even the simplest songs to the people. No matter how much the music industry relies on being in the right place in the right time, the greatest songs of all time have to have real thought and care put into them before they're even ready for the primetime. Then again, you occasionally get some random chaos happening at the 11th hour.
Regardless of how great the song may seem today, all of these tracks were in danger of even getting released at all. From the massive headache that went into the production of the song to the endless amount of editing, these songs definitely had an uphill battle before even being put onto vinyl.
Even when they were in their final form, songs can often find themselves dead in the water when the label doesn't want to promote it, instead looking to serve the bottom line rather than something new.
On the rarest occasion, you'll even find the artists themselves trying to downplay their own work, not even wanting their songs to get put down as the massive singles.
Despite not being given the time of day, these songs went from a random filler song to some of the most iconic compositions in rock history.
10. Where the Streets Have No Name - U2
Ever since breaking onto the rock scene with Boy back in the early '80s, U2 seemed to be inching closer and closer to the Joshua Tree. Across just one album, every single aspect of the band was firing on all cylinders, from Bono's voice reaching peak form to the Edge dialing in the perfect delay effects to make every song come alive. When it comes to making a first impression though, Where the Streets Have No Name was nearly disregarded entirely.
Working on the project with famed producer Brian Eno, most of the production hit a wall when no one could figure out how to start the opening arpeggio figure. After trying it with different drum accents that never saw the light of day, the Edge found it incredibly hard to keep time in between the massive amount of overlapping notes.
It eventually got to the point where Eno had every single part of the arrangement written on a chalkboard in the studio, which he came very close to erasing entirely out of pure frustration for not getting it right. Once they hit upon the regular 6/4 rhythm of the tune though, everything started to fall into place. Seeing how much love and care was put into this one song alone, it's no wonder that U2 wanted it as the definitive statement to open up their magnum opus.
9. Beth - KISS
Whenever you think of KISS, you tend to think of the larger than life aspects of rock and roll. As far back as the early '70s, these makeup-clad freaks were creating some of the most aggressive rock music known to man, picking up right where heavier acts like Led Zeppelin had left off. When you're that shocking though, it's a bit of a harder sell trying to get you to go the soft rock route.
After gaining their first platinum record with Alive!, the Bob Ezrin produced Destroyer was a lot more fine-tuned, including the pseudo power ballad Beth. While we know it as classic now, Paul Stanley and Gene Simmons were hesitant to even do the song at first, thinking it was a bit too sappy to be taken all that seriously. Once Ezrin took it home though, he turned Peter Criss's country style love song into a lush ballad, complete with strings and horn lines for good measure.
Even then, KISS were still not all that proud of Beth, instead throwing it on the B-side of Detroit Rock City rather than releasing it as a single. As soon as DJs flipped it over though, the world got a taste of what the sensitive side of shock rock could sound like. For as much tonal clashing goes on here, the idea of a man in cat makeup singing about missing his love at home turned out to be just crazy enough to work.
8. Black - Pearl Jam
The origins of Black go back to before Pearl Jam was even a band. Just after Mother Love Bone fell apart after the loss of Andy Wood, the main chord progression for the song was originally on a demo tape that Stone Gossard shopped around the Northwest before eventually finding Eddie Vedder. While the results were amazing in Vedder's hands, things got a bit complicated when it came time to put out the record.
With the release of Ten, songs like Alive and Jeremy became massive hits on the rock charts, bringing far more attention to the band that Vedder had ever expected. When it came time to go with other singles though, Vedder shot down the idea of Black going forward, considering it a far too personal song to be released for mass consumption.
That didn't stop the stations from playing it though, with alternative radio blaring it as an album cut rather than the mass produced single. Ever since, Black has been heralded as one of the greatest Pearl Jam songs, which made Vedder both proud and hollow at the exact same time. Instead of the typical feel good rock song, this is the case where the song might be too raw a nerve to put out in the open.
7. The Pretender - Foo Fighters
The entire makeup of the Foo Fighters' discography can really be nailed down to a science at this point. For as much as Dave Grohl prides himself on taking risks in song construction from one album to the next, you can normally expect some loud guitars, a soaring melody, and mountains of attitude coming from each respective project. When you're actually creating them in the studio though, some come to you a lot quicker than others.
Looking to combine the soft and loud side of the band on Echoes, Silence, Patience, and Grace, the Foos were coming close to the end of the session when Dave started to come up with an idea on the guitar. With their producer on vacation, Grohl laid down a basic demo of the song before realizing that he was onto something much bigger than he originally thought.
As he started to flesh out the soft opening guitar figure, the booming power chords that followed became the cornerstone for what would become the Pretender, which Grohl described as playing drums on the guitar. By the time their producer got back, the song went from just an odd leftover from the session to one of the foundational parts of the record. Even though the studio time might seem grueling, it just goes to show that you should never underestimate the power of a good idea.
6. Paranoid - Black Sabbath
Across every single Black Sabbath album, fans have gotten used to their epic scope of writing songs. For as much doom and gloom comes from something like War Pigs or Iron Man, the 6-8 minute runtime makes you feel like you're being taken on a journey rather than listening to some poppy single. Even when Sabbath managed to make a crossover onto the charts, it almost took place purely by accident.
After having the bulk of their sophomore album already in the can, Sabbath realized that they needed to have one more song on the record to fill up the first side of the album. Not really being ones for short songs, Paranoid was the result of a jam that came at the end of the session, with Tony Iommi coming up with the now iconic guitar riff on the fly.
Knowing the relentless swagger in the riff, the rest of the band quickly scrambled to their respective instruments, with Ozzy Osbourne eventually delivering the trademark howling delivery that he would become known for later down the line. After initially rejecting the first title War Pigs, Sabbath's label eventually took Paranoid to the top of the charts, displacing Simon and Garfunkel in no time.
It may have only taken a few minutes to get going, but this concentrated piece of metal brilliance was rock's first taste of something truly evil.
5. Nothing Else Matters - Metallica
As Metallica reached the '90s, they were looking to make some drastic changes to their sound. After spending the entirety of the '80s going pure thrash on Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning, the complicated stylings of something like And Justice For All led to them making songs that were a lot more to the point. What no one expected was the massive shift into the realm of soft rock.
Though James Hetfield had already written a softer song for the Black Album with the Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters was written as a fluke in between recording sessions. As Hetfield was talking on the phone one night, he started noodling around with the guitar on his lap before eventually stumbling upon the cascading guitar figure that we know today.
While Hetfield had never intended it to be a Metallica song, things started to turn a corner once Bob Rock listened to it. Looking to go even more experimental than before, Nothing Else Matters blossomed into one of the band's most user-friendly songs, with Rock going so far as to add an entire orchestra backing track into the mix. Once it was finally released, the age of thrash was beginning to turn a corner. It was time to move up to the big leagues now.
4. Man in the Box - Alice in Chains
A lot of people tend to forget how important Alice in Chains was to the Seattle grunge scene in the early '90s. Long before Kurt Cobain first sunk his teeth into the rock genre with Smells Like Teen Spirit, Facelift was actually the first grunge album to receive widespread acclaim, thanks to the massive bluesy single Man in the Box. That wasn't really how it was supposed to play out though.
After handing in the masters of Facelift in to the record label, the suits were hesitant to even give Man in the Box a chance, thinking it was much too slow for the rock world to really latch onto. It's not like they didn't have a point either, with a 5 minute song length and a plodding rhythm that would get boring in the wrong circumstances. As soon as fans got a whiff of the Alice energy though, Man in the Box became the defining sound of the darker side of the alternative sphere.
While initially being panned by the metal crowd that they were affiliated with, Alice turned into one of the biggest bands in the world once the grunge wave kicked in, with Man in the Box becoming their calling card. Then again, when you have a song this good, you don't really need to worry about how long it is.
3. Good Riddance - Green Day
It may be hard to understand now, but Green Day were in a bit of an awkward spot after the release of Dookie. Given the pop appeal of songs like Longview and Welcome to Paradise, these three pop punk brats spent their next record Insomniac doing everything they could to reestablish their punk credibility. If Nimrod was any indication of where they were headed though, Good Riddance was the sound of leaving their punk background behind.
For as much of a staple as it has been at every high school graduation for the past 20 years, Good Riddance was originally written during the Dookie sessions before ultimately being discarded for the more straightahead punk songs. By the time that Nimrod rolled around though, the myriad of different sounds on the record made this song fit right in.
Before even settling on recording it though, Billie Joe Armstrong was still hesitant to even go through with it, going so far as to try and make a full band arrangement of the tune before eventually just laying it down with an acoustic guitar. After tucking it away at the back half of the record, Good Riddance became inescapable once it hit radio, being a permanent staple of pop culture to this day.
Since the punk community was already breathing down their necks to return to their old sound, releasing something like this as a single was probably the most punk thing you could have done.
2. The Masterplan - Oasis
Every so often, an artist reaches a point in their songwriting where they just can't go wrong. Instead of finding a few perfect songs on every record, there just comes a point where you've refined your craft so much that everything hits a peak at one time. In the case of Noel Gallagher, even the B-sides for Oasis albums turned into some of the most celebrated rock songs of the modern age.
As work began on What's the Story Morning Glory?, Gallagher was coming to the end of recording before being told that he needed a B-side for the single version of Wonderwall. Going into the studio with an acoustic guitar, The Masterplan turned into one of the most extravagant Oasis songs ever created, complete with a full orchestra and one of the most heartfelt vocal performances Noel had ever given.
In fact, the quality of the song very nearly hurt its potential when eventually being released, with the record label going so far as to argue that it can't be a B-side because it was too good. Though Noel stuck to his guns by releasing it as a B-side, the staying power of the tune was so great that he almost considered releasing it as a single by itself.
Regardless of where it might fall in Oasis' discography, this is still one of the most essential pieces of music to ever comes from these lads from Manchester.
1. Free Fallin - Tom Petty
It's hard to really consider Full Moon Fever as Tom Petty's first proper solo album. I mean, considering that the Heartbreakers have played a pivotal role in every other album he's made, what makes this one any different? While the other members of Petty's band may have been important in the beginning, nothing else can hold a candle to Free Fallin.
Working with ELO frontman Jeff Lynne for the first time, Free Fallin was originally thrown together in a couple of hours before eventually turning into one of the most important pieces of music in Petty's discography. It's a shame that the label didn't think so though, with most of Warner Brothers saying that they didn't want to release it as a single, thinking it wasn't really fitting in with the image that Petty had worked with up until that point. The label weren't the only ones either, with bassist Howie Epstein refusing to play on the song because he didn't like it that much.
Looking to find some support, Petty eventually took it to his former producer Denny Cordell, who then called Petty's label and told them that they should fire their A&R staff if they let this slip through their fingers. For as perfect as a song might seem in the moment, sometimes it takes that little extra push for everyone to see the big picture.