10 Massively Underrated Albums From The 2000s

We let these albums down in the 2000s, it's now time to change that.

By Paris Fawcett /

The 2000s were a great time for music lovers and the last decade in which rock, metal, pop, hip hop and R&B acts were all able to live alongside each other in the charts and popular spaces. We were inundated with brilliant music whether it was the female pop takeover of Britney Spears, Gwen Stefani and Beyonce, the success of R&B artists like Usher, the indie British takeover, the reign of Nu Metal or the sweeping of emo that took over a whole generation.

Advertisement

There were massive movements within music, places where people could belong and so much good stuff going on that it was no wonder we were left with so many underrated gems. These come in the form of records that time forgot, stuff the world wasn’t ready for and albums that we didn’t give enough of a chance to.

However it’s never too late to start appreciating more excellent music from the 00s, and here are some of the records that you should start with...

10. Art Brut - Bang Bang Rock And Roll (2005)

Art Brut released their first album Bang Bang Rock and Roll in 2005 when British indie-rock was coming to the peak of its popularity, however if anything they’re more vital than ever now. Perhaps the band were ahead of their time or perhaps they’ve gone on to influence the boom of modern British indie punk, but regardless Art Brut are sorely underrated.

Advertisement

Bang Bang Rock and Roll saw Art Brut cleverly jab at the music industry and how serious it had all become and with three chords and a whole load of attitude wrote the prototype for what bands like IDLES would come to popularise. Full of clever observations, brilliant one liners (like “We're gonna be the band that writes the song that makes Israel and Palestine get along”) and sweet optimism, the band embodied the best of British attitude.

Art Brut should have been massive and they probably know this however when the album came out in 2005, people wanted their British poetry in the form of Arctic Monkeys and the consequent bloated rock of Radiohead, Franz Ferdinand and The Fratellis. Nothing will take away the brilliance of Bang Bang Rock and Roll though, give it a listen, hear their rants and listen to the sweet simplicity that comes with being that smart.

9. Hundred Reasons - Ideas Above Our Station (2002)

Before the mid-00s indie rock revolution came the British wave of alt rock masterpieces, and Hundred Reasons’ Ideas Above Our Station is one of the very peaks. Channeling emo and post-hardcore music into life affirming alternative rock, Ideas Above Our Station is a British rock masterpiece and a largely left behind gem. It sounds like a product of its time without becoming dated, it’s the sort of music people don’t make anymore and are worse off for it.

Advertisement

Songs like I’ll Find You and Dissolve are massive singalong rock bangers while What Thought Did and Gone Too Far throw catchiness onto post-hardcore heaviness. The record is a perfect combination of big chorus and ballads, full of catchy instrumental lines and featuring the excellent vocals of singer Colin Doran. Hundred Reasons were one of the first bands to remotely break through from early 00s post-hardcore and paved the way for artists like Frank Turner with Million Dead to to the same.

The record is a genre classic and despite catapulting the band to a UK top 10 and onto stages with Sugababes and Sophie Ellis Bextor has remained largely a classic only inside of the genres fanbase. This record may have been missed by many, but Hundred Reasons were one of the most important bands of their scene and both emo and rock are forever better because of Ideas Above Our Station.

8. Jimmy Eat World - Futures (2004)

Jimmy Eat World’s Bleed American is widely considered to be one of the most important, influential and brilliant albums in the history of pop-punk and emo. It’s full of the hits, the festival anthems such as The Middle and Sweetness, as well as ballad Hear You Me (which was most likely in every middle school disco circa 2003). However Futures is Bleed American’s even stronger sibling, the follow up that proved the band could turn the success of a massive record into something vital for their fans.

Advertisement

Futures received a notoriously sniffy review from Pitchfork, a write up that could have never predicted the amount of impact that the record would have on people. The album is just as massive as its predecessor but has this uncanny ability to understand highschoolers and awkward young adults.

Despite the band having formed over ten years before the album’s release, Jimmy Eat World knew exactly who they were singing to and did it with all of their heart. Futures still sounds just as important all these years later, and like all classics it will last forever.

7. Lamb Of God - Ashes Of The Wake (2004)

Ashes of the Wake is notoriously disliked by old school Lamb of God fans despite it being the closest thing the band have to their very own Master of Puppets. The album was released only a year after their first genre classic As The Palaces Burn and features their biggest single Laid To Rest but fans felt like the record saw the band enter autopilot and lose the ferocity of previous releases.

Advertisement

Looking back on Ashes of the Wake now, it’s extremely underrated as it sees the band write some of their best headbanging fun riffs, catchiest choruses and reset the benchmark of what their biggest songs could achieve. It’s one of their biggest albums for the sheer reason that it challenges itself to go big and break through the glass ceiling that stifles most metal bands. It’s no surprise that the record has been challenged and disliked by the band’s hardcore fans as it presented an opportunity for the band to reach new heights and Lamb of God managed to do it all without seeming to simply be searching for popularity.

This is not just a great metal album, but a record that absolutely shouldn’t be dismissed.

6. Mclusky - Mclusky Do Dallas (2002)

Whoever let Mclusky out of their cage deserves a medal: storming through the record with pure visciousness, the post-hardcore trio rampage all over Mclusky Do Dallas. The record is produced by Steve Albini, making it watertight power punk with all the savagery of a bunch of dogs finally running free after ripping off their leads. Above all, this record is fun, you can tell the band had a blast making it and as a result, the album is infectious.

Advertisement

Mclusky have an onbioxious attitude which makes them sound like Art Brut’s rapid post hardcore second cousins. They’re in and out on Mclusky Do Dallas, using humour to lighten breakdowns and make this album effortless fun to listen to. The band have been likened to the Pixies but without the dynamics levels and variation, but isn’t entirely true, the band know when to slow things down, lighten off the attitude or play with levels, they just never do all three things at once.

The band never compromise, they’re just here to have fun, and if you find Mclusky Do Dallas to be too relentless, they’ve achieved everything they set out to do.

5. Gwen Stefani - The Sweet Escape (2006)

When Gwen Stefani left No Doubt to pursue a solo career, nobody really expected she’d make an album as good as 2004s Love. Angel. Music. Baby. The record fused electronics with bubblegum pop and new wave and spawned singles such as Hollaback Girl, Rich Girl and What You Waiting For - it proved that she was one of the best songwriters in the game and people loved it.

Advertisement

However two years later, when Stefani released The Sweet Escape it did well commercially and its title track was a hit single, however it sold a fraction of what it’s predecessor did.

People simply didn’t get on with The Sweet Escape as well as Love. Angel. Music. Baby. and it’s criminal when considering how good the songs are. Co Written by Pharell WIlliams, the album is often tighter than its predecessor, dizzying and full of great songs full of attitude such as Wind It Up, Orange County Girl and Now That You Got It. It’s potentially a more straight ahead record, but it’s the kind of earworm songwriting you just can’t deny.

4. The Bronx - The Bronx (II) (2006)

The Bronx are one of hardcore’s most reliable bands. They always release brilliant records, play live wire shows and bring a smile to the faces of their fans. Their gigs are utter chaos, with frontman Matt Caughthran getting right into the crowd, big old mosh pits and hardcore songs with massive vocal lines and choruses. They’re just one of the best bands making music right now even though they’re largely unknown outside of hardcore and metal crowds.

Advertisement

They could have all the success in the world but not even that would be enough for what this band deserves. The Bronx (II) is one of the best rock albums of the 00s, full of wall to wall bangers, singalong anthems, so much heart and energy. Whether it’s the rapid circle pit rager of Small Stone, hardcore classics such as History’s Stranglers and Shitty Future or the almost hardcore ballad in White Guilt, the band proved with this album that they were able to take the genre to new heights.

The Bronx (II) is the kind of album that everyone from fans of Foo Fighters to Black Flag should be able to enjoy, they've just gotta listen.

3. Motion City Soundtrack - Commit This To Memory (2005)

You may only know Motion City Soundtrack for their hit song Everything Is Alright but the band are one of the best pop punk acts of the 00s. They come from an era where pop-punk was more Jawbox and Sunny Day Real Estate inspired rather than its current sound, and Commit This To Memory is a collection of tight, catchy, big punk tunes.

Advertisement

Commit This to Memory isn’t a perfect album, the tracklisting could probably benefit from moving opener Attractive Today further down. It also saw the band switch from their quirkier, punkier sound to something much more mainstream; however this just brought an even bigger sense of songwriting to their music.

Commit This To Memory is a rare occasion where a pop-punk band manages to mature their sound while retaining the youthful freedom of the genre. It cemented the band as worthy of living alongside their contemporaries such as Jimmy Eat World, Fall Out Boy and Paramore, even if they don’t have the big success of those artists.

If you want something rougher and quirkier, check out their debut album I Am The Movie, it’s another underrated 00s record.

2. The Hold Steady - Boys And Girls In America (2006)

The Hold Steady’s Boys and Girls in America was not just one of 2006s best albums but of the entire decade. The band combined the ways in which British artists such as Pulp and Arctic Monkeys perfectly summarised young teen life and combined it with Spingsteen’s capacity for heartland rock and succinct capturing of American life.

Advertisement

Up to this point, the band were known for singing about other people and making up characters in conceptual albums but Boys and Girls In America allows listeners to claim the songs as their own and find themselves in the band’s poetry.

Boys and Girls in America takes all the best of The Hold Steady’s raggedness, the fun of their instrumentals and their fist pumping vocal lines. This album is about the joys of having the entire world in front of you, it unites lovers of classic rock and punk and turns it into a universal message of vitality and looking ahead to a bright future. Singer Craig Finn still tells stories here and rasps through bar style rock and roll tunes.

If there was ever an album to bring a smile to your face, it's this.

1. Iron Maiden - Brave New World (2000)

Many classic metal bands struggled through the 90s, few more than Iron Maiden. As their stock fell, lead singer Bruce Dickinson left and the band released a number of universally disliked albums. People began to lose interest in Iron Maiden, they had fallen out of arenas and were becoming a shell of the band they used to be. That was until Bruce Dickinson returned after seven years and the band released Brave New World.

Advertisement

Despite this, people chose to forget the history of Maiden and how Brave New World reignited the band’s presence; namely they chose to snub just how good this record is. Although it features some classic Iron Maiden metal anthems such as Blood Brothers and The Wicker Man, the band rarely play more than one song from the album at any given concert. Furthermore, there are many songs from the album that haven’t been played in well over ten years which is a shame as they definitely deserve dusting off for the live set.

Brave New World is one of Iron Maiden’s best records since 88s Seventh Son of a Seventh Son, the album shows complete excitement from the band to be making music again and is all the better for it. People may decide to only opt for pre-90s Maiden, but we know how much they still had brilliance in them.

Advertisement