10 Songs That Led To Massive Lawsuits
The lines are often blurred when it comes to defining music plagiarism.
Have you ever listened to a song and thought that it sounds a bit like another that you've heard before?
Musicians do that too, particularly when the song sounds like their own. A musical ear was one of the strengths that got them to the top and they use it to stay there, keenly listening out for any potential copycat renditions of their biggest hits.
While not every musician is sensitive to this form of flattery - Tom Petty, for example, brushed off a Red Hot Chill Peppers song resembling his own by stating that he didn't suspect negative intent - plenty are. After all, middling songwriters can land a huge payday when they enter a surprising squabble with a singer who sells out arenas.
You would be surprised to hear that your go-to karaoke picks can be themselves one step removed from karaoke. A few of the artists listed here are prolific when it comes to making hits out of songs that already exist in one form or another.
Juggernauts of the music industry are not shy to drag imitators to court either. There has been a boom in lawsuits related to music plagiarism in the last decade with the aggrieved seeking huge sums of money. Songs that usually echo in packed venues are played out in a tense judicial setting.
10. My Humps By Black Eyed Peas
A childish song about a woman using her body to get what she wants, My Humps was slammed by music critics for being immature. However, what had critics tutting packed out dancefloors. The third single from the Black Eyed Peas' fourth studio album Money Business, it was also one of their most successful songs.
The video landed them an MTV award and the song itself created an unexpected cultural domino effect. Blades of Glory, an absurd 2007 sports comedy about figure skating, featured a scene in which Will Ferrell's character Chad Michael Michaels demanded that he only skate to that song. His dialogue would later be sampled by Kanye West and Jay-Z for their 2011 song N*ggas in Paris.
My Humps actually sampled a 1983 song called I Need A Freak by a band called Sexual Harassment. The writer of that song, a DJ named Orrin Lynn Tolliver Jr, recorded the song at James McCant's studio and McCant later registered the song with BMI. The pair appeared to have agreed that Tolliver would get 75% of the song's royalties but then McCant denied this agreement existed and began selling the track for use. Despite Tolliver sending McCant a cease and desist letter, his former friend continued to make the track available for sampling to the likes of BEP.
With My Humps selling over two million copies, it was inevitable that this dispute would end up in court. Once there, McCant proceeded to contradict himself with a number of different stories. He initially denied issuing a licence before claiming that he co-wrote and owned I Need A Freak. Then, he tried to use a musicology expert's report to show that My Humps didn't use a sample at all. This didn't work. Tolliver was awarded $1.2 million in damages.
9. Ice Ice Baby By Vanilla Ice
Ice Ice Baby was the biggest hit of Vanilla Ice's career and it sampled the bassline from Under Pressure, the Queen and David Bowie classic. Ice, whose real name is Robert Van Winkle, disputed the claim that the melodies were identical in a 1990 statement but he later went back on this (saying his comments were made jokingly) when legal action was taken by Bowie and all of the members of Queen. The British artists didn't find the idea of any association with Ice funny.
There was an argument made that this collaboration that Bowie and Queen were forced into had somehow damaged their reputation. They were forever linked with a rapper detested by the community he wished to be accepted most by. Eminem was one prominent rapper who said that Ice's public profile made it hard for him, a fellow white rapper, to be taken seriously. Although his reputation was in tatters, Ice's hit topped the Billboard Charts and Bowie and Queen were happy for that, eventually settling out of court for an undisclosed sum.
The epilogue to this drama is no less fascinating. An associate of infamous record producer Suge Knight, a Californian rapper named Mario "Chocolate" Johnson, claimed that he wrote Ice Ice Baby and had received no credit or royalties. Ice claims that Knight launched an intimidation campaign against him to get him to sign the rights of the song over to Johnson.
It culminated with Knight confronting Ice on a 15th-floor hotel balcony, implying he would throw him over if he didn't do it. Unsurprisingly, Ice signed. Knight is now in prison for other crimes.
8. Uptown Funk By Mark Ronson Ft. Bruno Mars
British record producer Mark Ronson has a reputation as a hitmaker in the music industry. He's penned songs for the likes of Lady Gaga and Amy Winehouse, so any collaboration with pop superstar Bruno Mars was likely to be a winner. To make absolutely sure, Ronson and Mars allegedly combined a number of elements from songs that they already liked when making Uptown Funk, leading to a bombardment of lawsuits from aggrieved artists.
Despite its extremely derivative boogie throwback style, Uptown Funk was a commercial success and broke the worldwide streaming record when it was released in 2014. The hard-done-by artists from the previous paragraph began to look for their cut of the profits. Minneapolis electro-funk band Collage claimed that Uptown Funk “is an obvious, strikingly and/or substantially similar copy” of their 1983 single Young Girls. They could even point to the fact that the pair had gone on the record about the influence of early 1980s Minneapolis electro-funk soul music. The case was settled out of court with no details of a financial settlement disclosed in early 2018.
Later that year, Ronson and Mars settled another dispute out of court with Lastrada Entertainment, the copyright holders of the 1980 song More Bounce to the Ounce by Zapp. Again, the details of the settlement weren't disclosed but Lastrada sought damages, a jury trial, and a permanent injunction to prevent Ronson from performing the song in concert. It would appear as though the injunction was ineffective as Ronson was performing the song live in 2019. It was reported in 2018 that Ronson was still facing a lawsuit from Sequence, the band behind the 1980 song Funk You Up, over similarities between their songs. The result of this lawsuit has not yet been reported.
7. Photograph By Ed Sheeran
Penned in 2012 by Ed Sheeran and Snow Patrol band member Johnny McDaid, Photograph was the fifth single from Sheeran's second studio album, x (pronounced Multiply). It became certified triple platinum in the UK and received widespread praise from critics and fans alike globally. Telling a story of long-distance love, Sheeran's vocals were complemented by acoustic guitar, piano and programmed drums. While many cooed over the accompanying video of Sheeran's cut-together home videos showing his prodigious talents being exhibited from a young age, two songwriters were struck by how closely Photograph resembled their own creation. It was the spitting image.
Martin Harrington and Thomas Leonard were behind the 2011 Matt Cardle single Amazing and later spoke of how flabbergasted they were by the blatant likeness of Sheeran's 2015 release.
They sued Sheeran for damages worth more than $20 million in 2016 with the dispute eventually being settled out of court a year later. Sheeran made no admission of guilt but it's believed that he forked out a considerable chunk to the pair. They said that Sheeran and McDaid had “copied and exploited, without authorisation or credit … on a breathtaking scale”.
This isn't the only time that Sheeran has been accused of ripping off the work of another musician. Structured Asset Sales, the company that owns the rights to Marvin Gaye classic Let's Get It On, sued Sheeran for the way in which his 2014 single Thinking Out Loud allegedly copies “the melody, rhythms, harmonies, drums, bassline, backing chorus, tempo, syncopation and looping” of the Gaye song.
Sheeran has segued into Let's Get It On from Thinking Out Loud in concert before, which doesn't really help his case. It hasn't yet been resolved but SAS want $100 million.
6. Dark Horse By Katy Perry
One of the biggest names in pop music, Katy Perry has consistently brought out hits for more than a decade. One of those hits was 2013 single Dark Horse on which she collaborated with Juicy J. The pair wrote the song with a bunch of producers and it became one of the best-selling songs in digital history. The song shows the perspective of a witch who warns a man not to fall in love with her or that will be his romantic life settled. The magical vibe that the song goes combines elements of pop, trap, hip hop and electropop. However, not everyone was under its spell.
Flame, a Christian rapper, claimed that Perry's Dark Horse copied his 2008 song Joyful Noise and filed a lawsuit against her in 2014. Eventually, five years later in 2019, the jury ruled in favour of Flame and his associates, awarding them compensation of $2.78 million in damages. Perry herself would have to pay $550,000. However, it was a short-lived success for Flame as the story did not end there.
Perry appealed the verdict and had it overturned in March 2020. California District Judge Christina A. Snyder decided that Flame and his legal team 'failed to satisfy the extrinsic test'. The extrinsic test is the test that definitively proves copyright infringement, which can be complex to pass.
The extrinsic test must prove that the accused had access to the defendant's copyrighted material and propose a chain of events that would have led to the accused coming across the work before plagiarising it.
5. Bitter Sweet Symphony By The Verve
One of The Verve's biggest hits, Bitter Sweet Symphony is an era-defining song, bringing back memories of Britpop and the 90s. It's hard to define what the song is specifically trying to say but it gets across a general feeling of dissatisfaction with modern life. It rallies against capitalist society, featuring lines like 'you're a slave to money then you die'. With that in mind, it's cruelly poetic that The Verve frontman Richard Ashcroft was denied the profits of his most enduring anthem. A dispute over the use of a Rolling Stones sample resulted in a court case and Stones former manager Allen Klein was awarded all the royalties of the song.
The opening strings of Bitter Sweet Symphony sample the 1965 Andrew Oldham Orchestra recording of the Rolling Stones' song The Last Time, which was arranged and written by David Whitaker. The Verve negotiated with the recording's copyright holders Decca Records to use a six-note sample. However, they didn't receive permission from Klein who owned all the rights to pre-1970 Stones songs.
When Klein won the court case that followed, Ashcroft suffered the indignity of having his songwriting credit taken away, with that being changed to Jagger/Richards.
Cut to 2019, 22 years after Klein's court win. Ashcroft was collecting the Ivor Novello Award for Outstanding Contribution to British Music from the British Academy of Songwriters, Composers, and Authors. Speaking publically, he decided to announce that the dispute was over.
He negotiated with Klein's son, Jody, and the Rolling Stones' manager Joyce Smith, and came to an agreement. Jagger and Richards signed over their publishing for Bitter Sweet Symphony and one of the great injustices of music copyright was corrected.
4. Creep By Radiohead
The song that announced Radiohead as the new band in town for anyone in the middle of a Venn diagram with depressed and good taste on either side, 'Creep' was the band's first single.
It features Thom Yorke wailing about being a loner and professing his love to a girl who doesn't notice when he's around. Two people that did notice the arrival of Yorke and Radiohead were Albert Hammond and Mike Hazelwood. They were the songwriting team behind 'The Air That I Breathe', a 1973 hit for The Hollies, and they noticed that the chord progression and melody of their song was similar to that of 'Creep'. As sure as loners follow Radiohead on tour, a lawsuit followed this discovery.
What transpired sounds pleasant enough, as lawsuits go. Hammond and Hazelwood won but only took a share of the song's royalties because they were so honest about everything. Hammond said: "I only own the writer's end. The publisher of the song, Rondor Music, felt [Creep] was a steal from The Air That I Breathe, and he sued Radiohead and they agreed. Because they were honest, they weren't sued to the point of saying 'we want the whole thing'. So we ended up just getting a little piece of it." What constitutes a 'little piece' in this instance is unknown.
Radiohead got to sit on the other side of the lawsuit table when they sued Lana Del Rey over her song 'Get Free', claiming that it was extremely similar to 'Creep'. Only a die-hard Del Rey fan would say otherwise, it's pretty blatant. Del Rey offered 40 per cent of the royalties but Radiohead allegedly wanted all the royalties. Del Rey told fans that suit was over during a concert in 2018 before performing the song. We wonder who's in line to be sued by Lana.
3. Erotica By Madonna
Madonna is often called the Queen of Pop due to the longevity of her career and the number of hits that she has under her belt. It could be disputed when making the argument on talent alone, but when it comes to being sued, Madonna is simply pop royalty. She's been sued over at least four songs, including Papa Don't Preach and Vogue - and that's only the lawsuits that artists got around to launching against her. As the old saying goes, good artists copy, great artists steal'. We're focusing on the time Fairuz sued Madonna for said theft back in 1993.
Lebanese singer Fairuz is one of the most admired and influential singers in the Arab world. It's no surprise that an artist like Madonna would want to sample her iconic vocals. However, Madonna didn't ask for Fairuz's permission when she put her voice as the backing vocals for her sexual 1992 single Erotica.
Fairuz's famous Easter chant 'Al Yawm Ulliqa Alal Khashaba' ended up being worked into the chorus while Madonna sang 'put your hands all over my body'. The chant is question is about the crucifixion of Jesus and is played on Good Friday every year. Needless to say, Erotica wasn't Fairuz's cup of tea and she successfully sued Madonna to the tune of $2.5 million.
2. Stairway To Heaven By Led Zeppelin
One of the most famous bands of all time, Led Zeppelin have more than a few recognisable tunes. A riff so popular that it has become forbidden in guitar stores around the globe, 'Stairway To Heaven' may be the most famous of all and it is instantly identifiable by its opening.
This level of fame must have been hard to stomach for the band members of Spirit, who believed their song 'Taurus' was ripped off by Zeppelin. 'Taurus' was released in 1968 and 'Stairway' was released three years later. The bands toured together before the latter song was written, giving the band members of Spirit a reason to believe that Jimmy Page and Robert Plant saw them perform 'Taurus' live.
Interestingly, the lawsuit that was eventually made against Zeppelin for this alleged copyright infringement wasn't made by a member of Spirit. The writer of 'Taurus', Randy Wolfe, Spirit's guitarist, passed away in 1997. The lawsuit was filed by a journalist named Michael Skidmore on behalf of the Randy Craige Wolfe Trust. After becoming a co-trustee in 2006, Skidmore took legal action in 2014. The jury ruled in Zeppelin's favour in 2016 but a re-trial was ordered by a three-judge panel from the ninth circuit in 2018. Skidmore lost again.
It appears as though the decision hinged on the type of copyright act that covered 'Taurus'. Skidmore's legal team wished to play a recording of the song for the jury but this request was denied. 'Taurus' was registered under the 1909 copyright act, which only covers sheet music. The 1976 copyright act later allowed sound recordings to act as musical compositions. It is unfortunate for Skidmore that 'Taurus' only registered a single page of sheet music.
1. Blurred Lines By Robin Thicke Ft. T.I., Pharrell
A controversial hit of 2013, 'Blurred Lines' managed to top charts, win Grammys and provoke the ire of student unions in the United Kingdom. Robin Thicke was catapulted into the spotlight for being front and centre of a song that critics said promoted rape culture. (The blurred lines of the song interpreted as being the subject of consent.) An array of models parade around nakedly in the song's music video while Thicke, Pharrell Williams and T.I. make everyone uncomfortable with their frat boy actions. It wasn't received well then and looks no better now.
While the song itself was a hit, it was noticed at the time that the drumming on the track sounded like that of Marvin Gaye hit 'Got To Give It Up'. The children of Gaye, representing his estate, promptly sued EMI and the song's writers, Thicke and Williams. Estates of artists are more likely to sue than artists themselves as they've no reputation or artistic connections to worry about damaging.
In 2015, a jury found Thicke and Pharrell guilty of copyright infringement and ordered them to pay $7.6 million in damages to the Gaye estate and to add Marvin Gaye as a co-writer of Blurred Lines. Thicke and Williams received sympathy from fellow artists. John Legend and Bill Withers were among those to speak out while critics of the song appeared to bask in the schadenfreude of the legal loss that Thicke and Williams suffered. The courtroom dispute further damaged the legacy of a song with a tainted reputation.