10 Times Megadeth Did It Better Than Metallica
"It wasn’t enough for Megadeth to do well; I wanted Metallica to fail" - Dave Mustaine.
Back in 1983, four excited, drunken, pimple-faced youths entered a recording studio in Rochester, New York to record their debut album. The name of the band was Metallica, a tight-knit thrash metal band from California, who had laid a solid foundation the year prior.
At this point, the band consisted of James Hetfield, Lars Ulrich, Cliff Burton and Dave Mustaine. Drawn together through a mixture of adverts for starting a band, and scouting from local gigs, this foursome was driven by one purpose: Metal Up Your Ass.
In the early days of recording, guitarist and wild man, Mustaine, had become something of a liability. While his axe work was exemplary, his attitude was too problematic and the other three members predicted disaster if the man continued to run roughshod unchecked.
The band made a decision: Dave Mustaine was out of the band.
While Metallica picked up the super talented Kirk Hammett to take over lead guitar duties, a sobering Mustaine was on a bus back to California. By the time he made it back home, Mustaine made a vow to get revenge on the band that had abandoned him.
In nearly forty-years since that day, Metallica has become one of the best selling bands in history, totalling over three times the number of albums worldwide Megadeth has.
But, numbers aside, are Metallica really better than Megadeth?
10. Duelling Guitars
One of the staples of all Heavy Metal music is the use of duelling solos. Popularised by influential bands such as Diamond Head, no Metal band worth their salt can be without a shred off to show off their axemen’s mettle.
Metallica’s Kirk Hammett and James Hetfield are two solid guitarists and have written some hefty riffs together. Hammett is one of the last students of guitar god, Joe Satriani, and this has excelled Metallica musically almost beyond compare. Together, Hammett and Hetfield have duelled on several tracks, with the most notable taking place towards the end of the seminal anthem, One. Hammett strangles his guitar to help bring the atmosphere up to a violent degree, then Hetfield comes in with a lower tone and a slower pace bringing in a sense of impending doom.
However, as good as this is, the destructive duo that is Dave Mustaine and Megadeth’s best lead guitarist, Marty Friedman, are simply better. Sharing solo duties on numerous songs, the pinnacle of all guitar solos takes place on their 1990 masterpiece, Hangar 18.
Immediately punching through with a throbbing Thrash riff, the pace is kept throughout the five-minute firestorm. Mustaine and Friedman intercept with casual solos between each verse, to then unleash all fury in the song’s latter half. Friedman performs melodic manoeuvres with an Eastern twist, while Mustaine shreds with such precision he started getting rid of the band's old bank statements in the process.
Megadeth performed with more raw power. Simple.
9. Who Did It Better?
After Mustaine’s dismissal, what would become of the riffs he created? Firing the lead guitarist at the beginning of their recording sessions for their debut album, Metallica had no time to bin Mustaine’s work, so carried on using it. Mustaine, quick to form his own band, had equal rights, so he decided to use the riffs too.
In 1983’s Kill ‘Em All, the seven-minute-long track, The Four Horsemen, is a Heavy Metal classic containing a riff replicating a Thrashy gallop mimicking the song’s title. It is a strong entry in Catalogus Metallica, but as Mustaine once quipped in the Rude Awakening Tour, ‘there's two ways you can hear this next song. There’s our way, then there’s their way. For those of you that think this their way, this song is called The Mechanix!’
Noticeably on The Mechanix - which featured on Megadeth’s debut album, Killing Is My Business… - the main riffs are the same, but Megadeth plays the song at a true Thrash speed of 256 bpm, whereas on the album, Metallica chug along at 203 bpm. While that isn’t a massive difference, the preferred style of each band in the early days was fast and energetic, and Megadeth just pulls it off with more skill.
On the album, Metallica inserted several different riffs into the song, including their best riff during the call out section, however, they also included a parody of Sweet Home Alabama, which makes the song comical. Megadeth kept it simple, kept it raw, and kept it theirs.
8. Composition
Over the years, Metallica has diversified its sound. Beginning with Thrash, then comfortably entering Metal, to then becoming simply Rock. While it is understandable for artists to experiment with composition and form, Metallica seems to have done it so much, they’ve strayed too far away, and are unrecognisable as a band.
While 2016’s Hardwired…To Self Destruct was a return to the Thrash genre, the band had been away from it for so long, they no longer appeared comfortable in that realm. Many fans had been clamouring for a return to form for many years, but this effort seems too little too late.
Megadeth on the other hand, have also diversified their sound, with their 1997 album Risk being a wildcard for ‘Deth fans. However, since that experiment, they have solidified themselves well within the genres of Thrash and Heavy Metal.
Even when these experiments are considered, Megadeth appears more in tune with their fan base. Risk was a commercial failure, so Megadeth returned with The World Needs a Hero, in 2001, and have been on form ever since. Whereas Metallica went middle of the road for Load, and despite fan backlash, they continued for ReLoad, and even further still with the up and down, St Anger. The latter was harder, but it wasn’t Metallica.
7. Bassism
Cliff Burton is the undisputed champion of bass players in Heavy Metal. His prowess and skill on Metallica’s first three albums are unparalleled, and since his early death in 1986, he has become sainted to metalheads across the world.
Since losing Burton, Metallica has had two full-time replacements. One is the fantastic Jason Newsted, who was in Metallica during their peak, the other is the talented Robert Trujillo who has been in the band since 2003. While all three men are skilled bassists, since Cliff’s passing, the band have been less than fair with their new four-string friends.
Notably, during the mixing of Metallica’s first post-Burton album, …And Justice For All, Newsted’s tone was turned to a minimum, making the otherwise stellar album rather flat. For Trujillo, however, while he doesn’t appear to be conned out of appearing on albums, he has gone on record to say that he sees himself as a supporting member, ‘I’m here with my bass every day ready to jam.’
For Megadeth, they know the importance of creative input from all sides, and longtime bassist, David Ellefson, has been instrumental in some of the bands biggest tracks. Perhaps being kicked out of Metallica helped Mustaine realise that there is more than just one or two people driving a band. This appears to be a lesson James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich haven’t learned.
6. Action Movie Songs
Around the time of Metallica’s dark days, they were commissioned by Hollywood Records to make a track for the upcoming Mission: Impossible 2 movie. I Disappear is somewhat of an underrated gem from the band, and it is rarely played as part of their live repertoire. While the song itself isn’t bad, the movie for which it was written is. Mission: Impossible 2 is the lowest rated of the franchise, receiving an audience score of 43%.
For Megadeth however, they contributed their awesome Angry Again to the 1993 action flick, Last Action Hero. While the movie only received marginally better reviews, receiving a 47% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, Last Action Hero has become something of an Arnold Schwarzenegger cult classic.
In terms of the song, both are hidden gems in each respective band’s catalogues, however, in terms of appeal, Arnie surpasses Cruise in the action category. Not only that, but Angry Again is placed within a pivotal moment of Last Action Hero, playing during the opening credits of the fictitious Schwarzenegger film, Jack Slater IV.
It suits the atmosphere, complete with a destructive title sequence. Whereas Metallica’s efforts were used solely for the ending credits of Mission: Impossible 2. Pitiful.
5. David Mustaine > James Hetfield
It is up for debate about which frontman is the better singer. Mustaine’s higher-pitched whine fits a lot of Megadeth songs but would be out of place elsewhere. Whereas Hetfield has one of the most distinctive gruff voices in all music, it is easily parodied and seems to be more of a caricature these days.
However, one area of no contest between the two is the guitar playing ability. Both men are respectable rhythm guitarists who take occasional leads in their tracks. Coincidentally, both men had similar setbacks in their playing and had to relearn their instruments after freak accidents. In 1992, Hetfield caught his arm in a pyrotechnic explosion, receiving severe burns in the process, whereas Mustaine suffered severe nerve damage in his right arm in 2002, which took 17 months for him to recover.
Despite the setbacks, Dave Mustaine still surpasses his Metallica counterpart in the rhythm category. Hetfield’s rhythm is standard, with plenty of downstrokes, and not much technique. However, with Megadeth maintaining their Thrash pace throughout the vast majority of their songs, Mustaine has to be more intricate with his shifts from open barre chords to palm mutes. Both players revolutionised the metal genre, but Mustaine just did it better.
4. Nick Menza > Lars Ulrich
Whereas Metallica had difficulty (whether due to death or resignations) with finding a permanent bass player, Megadeth has had a worse issue keeping a consistent drummer. Current stick man, Dick Verbeuren, is the band’s tenth. However, with the majority of Megadeth’s biggest tracks coming from the years 1989 and 1998, Nick Menza can be considered the quintessential Megadeth drummer.
German-born Nick Menza was the backbone of the rhythm section for the albums Rust In Peace, Countdown to Extinction, Youthanasia and Cryptic Writings, respectively. During Rust’s first track, Holy Wars, Menza is frenetic in his thrashing of the skins. The tone is brighter, the skins are tighter, and he just shines throughout six-minute onslaught.
In Countdown to Extinction, Menza experiments with a swing beat for the chorus of Sweating Bullets and helps establish it as one of Megadeth’s finest tracks. Menza demonstrates exactly how musicians can explore other styles within their signature genre.
Lars, on the other hand, has just been consistently okay throughout his forty-year tenure with Metallica. His skins are looser, giving the rhythm section of the band a sloppier feel. Also, Ulrich has been shown to struggle with keeping tempo in several YouTube videos. It’s become a running joke during their live shows.
Ulrich’s finest hour came about in the song, Battery, maintaining a fast tempo for the Thrash anthem. However, he never evolved his style, and in some songs dominated the overall sound when it came to mixing the album (Nothing Else Matters goes downhill when Lars comes crashing in).
3. Cryptic Writings > ReLoad
With careers spanning over thirty-five years, it is unavoidable that both bands would have lull periods. Metallica’s well-documented transition to radio-friendly Hard Rock songs in the mid-90s being one, whereas Megadeth’s stagnation period at the end of the decade is the other.
With Metallica already meeting fan’s scores by the time of the release of their ReLoad album, Megadeth started to bore some fans with their album, Cryptic Writings. Both were released in 1997.
Comparing the two, ReLoad contains Fuel, The Memory Remains and Carpe Diem Baby, making them the only tracks worth note. Fuel is a great, crunchy track that still gets played at live shows. Hetfield’s vocals begin to border on comical during this track, but it hits more than it misses. The Memory Remains is another popular live song, and it is the best Metallica pop song. Carpe Diem Baby is underrated with its Southern Rock groove.
On Cryptic Writings, however, there is Trust, Almost Honest, Mastermind, The Disintegrators, and Sin. Trust is an epic track which has a great build serving as an introduction to both the song and the album. Almost Honest is a track reminiscent of their early-90s masterpiece, Countdown to Extinction. The Disintegrators is a Thrash track, proving that the band can still go at that pace. Sin is a great Hard Rock song which, in tone, feels similar to Metallica’s Carpe Diem Baby.
Neither album is stellar, but even in the low times, Megadeth is just better.
2. Peace Sells > Master Of Puppets
From their worst efforts to their best, Metallica and Megadeth released their finest albums during the 80s peak of Thrash Metal. Belonging to the ‘Big Four’ (with Slayer and Anthrax) completing the lineup, 1986 was the biggest year in Thrash.
Master of Puppets, containing legendary tracks such as Battery, Master of Puppets, Sanitarium, Leper Messiah, and Orion, scored the band much critical success and was their gateway for global recognition. Battery remains a Thrash favourite to this day and has been favourably covered by Machine Head. Master of Puppets is a complex track, which goes from super fast to super melodic, showing how the band had developed. Sanitarium is a solemn song with an arpeggio verse structure, which seems like a forerunner to the Metallica masterpiece, One.
While Master of Puppets is very good, Megadeth’s Peace Sells is simply phenomenal. Containing classics such as Wake Up Dead, the dark and masterful guitar skills in The Conjuring, and the tempo altering ballad turned Thrash track, Good Mourning / Black Friday, Peace Sells steals the show. Also on the album is Devil’s Island, a musical descent into doom as Mustaine and Friedman battle their guitars almost effortlessly taking listeners on a rollercoaster of speed, power, and precision.
Finally, for everything Master of Puppets has on its album, it doesn’t have the title track from Megadeth’s ’86 release, Peace Sells. The track boasts the skills of all players in what has to be the greatest Megadeth song of all time.
1. Metal
In 1983, when being interviewed, Metallica was asked if they had anything else to say to their fans. A young, soon-to-be-fired Dave Mustaine shouts, ‘Metal up your ass!’ These four words spat with playful venom sum up the appeal of Metal music. It’s fun, it’s cocky, it doesn’t give a sh*t.
Fusing the skills from classic rock bands, with the careless attitude of the Punk era, 80s Metal was supposed to be counterculture. It didn’t want to be accepted by the mainstream, and it just wanted to have fun, play well, and fuel the desire for simple pleasures.
Metallica are now a household brand and far removed from trying to counter culture. While success is not to be scorned, presenting themselves in a way that hearkens back to the time before they had that amount of celebrity comes across as one of the most un-metal things a band could do.
From countless media appearances to several movie releases, the inner turmoil of Metallica has been well documented. This open window approach, as well as their use of a therapist to keep things afloat, has been criticised as ‘weak’ by their former bassist, Jason Newsted.
On the other hand, Megadeth just seems to keep carrying on. There is no doubt the band has had their issues over the years, but it has still managed to continue. Not only that, but it did so in a way which didn’t seem to capitalise on voyeurism. Metallica became mainstream moguls whereas Megadeth just stayed metal.