12 Controversial Songs That Were Stolen

#copycats.

By Sean O'Meara /

Star Trak

They say that imitation is the greatest form of flattery. It's also the most annoying. And in some cases, the most lucrative.

Advertisement

Given how protective artists are of their own work - particularly when it comes to things they own the copyright to - it should come as no surprise that unlawful imitation in the creative world tends to lead to an awful mess. And in the cases where justice is done, that means monetary punishment, usually.

In music, it happens all the time. And while things like samples and conscious nods are seemingly acceptable (within reason), there's a more nefarious thread of musical pilferers who have apparently outright stolen songs - sometimes wholesale - from existing works. And you can probably guess how that tends to go for the offending parties...

Advertisement

12. 'Shakermaker' - Oasis

Where It Was Stolen From: 'I'd Like To Teach The World To Sing' - The New Seekers

There's an old saying in music" where there's a hit, there's a writ.

Advertisement

In the majority of copyright infringement cases, the writ comes from the writer of the lesser-known song. This is for two principle reasons; firstly, most people have more sense than to copy a smash and secondly, it's only really worth suing if the rip off turns out to be a big seller and generates sufficient income to make it worthwhile.

Or to quote another old saying, "You can't sue the pants off someone who doesn't have any pants."

Advertisement

But Oasis ignored these facts in 1994 and ripped off an already well known classic. It was a textbook case of a top line melody being lifted wholesale and transplanted, with new lyrics, into a new song. The unauthorised appropriation of the vocal line from 'I'd Like To Teach The World To Sing' cost Oasis $500,000.

11. 'Last Nite' - The Strokes

Where It Was Stolen From: 'American Girl' - Chuck Berry

Advertisement

Things didn't get legal, but according to Tom Petty - the victim of plagiarism more than once - The Strokes freely admit to "borrowing" the riff, strumming pattern and drum beat from his version of Chuck Berry's American Girl.

It's not an exact lift, but the distinctively hollow nature of the octave-based guitar riff, coupled with the ascending bass line and identically accented drum beat of Last Nite, the "feel" is at least as similar as Blurred Lines and Got To Give It Up. It's a good job Petty isn't petty.

Advertisement

10. 'Whole Lotta Love' - Led Zeppelin

Where It Was Stolen From: 'Willie Dixon's You Need Love' - Muddy Waters

Advertisement

At first listen, these songs are quite distinct from one another, but it doesn't take a musicologist to notice the striking similarities between the vocal melodies and lyrics.

The claim here wasn't copyright infringement, but that Led Zep had created a derivative work of Dixon's 'You Need Love'. The court agreed and Willie Dixon has been credited as a co-writer ever since.

Advertisement

9. 'The Ghostbusters Theme' - Ray Parker Jr

Where It Was Stolen From: 'I Want A New Drug' - Huey Lewis And The News

Advertisement

The story goes that Huey was invited to pitch a song for the then in-production film Ghostbusters. He declined because he was too busy writing a song for Back To The Future. The following year, Ghostbusters was released and the theme, written and recorded by Ray Parker Jr, went straight to number 1.

Huey, convinced that the similarities between his recently-released single 'I Want A New Drug' and Parker's theme tune were too strong for it be a coincidence, sued and while he didn't win, the suit was settled out of court in his favour.

Advertisement

It was later revealed that Huey breached a non-disclosure agreement by talking about the whole affair. Bustin' makes him feel good, apparently.

But hang on, if we're getting litigious here Huey, strictly speaking it would be wrong not to acknowledge how much your tune sounds like more of a rip off than Ray Parker's effort.

Advertisement

Just check out the similarities between I Want A New Drug and The Jackson Five's 'Shake Your Body Down To The Ground'. It's a good job the Jackson family aren't litigious.

8. 'Creep' - Radiohead

Where It Was Stolen From: 'The Air That I Breathe' - The Hollies

Advertisement

Look, when a song has the same chords, the same melody, and very similar "feel" it's not always intentional foul-play. In fact, it's easily done.

But Radiohead can't feel too hard done by on this one, at least not in the eyes of the songwriters of 'The Air That I Breathe' - originally sang by The Hollies.

Advertisement

Back in the 1990s, Albert Hammond (dad of The Strokes guitarist Albert Hammond Jr) and Mike Hazlewood, writers of The Air That I Breathe threatened an aggressive lawsuit against Radiohead and ended up with an out of court settlement that meant they are now listed as co-writers on the credits for 'Creep'.

Somewhat coming full-circle, Radiohead themselves later accused Lana Del Rey of ripping off 'Creep' for her song 'Get Free' from her album Lust For Life. She claimed she had done nothing wrong, even though she was familiar with the song.

Advertisement

7. 'Stay With Me' - Sam Smith

Where It Was Stolen From: 'I Won't Back Down' -Tom Petty

Advertisement

In many instances, it's an artist's publishers that forces legal action, rather than the artist.

This was the case when publishers for Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers' song 'I Won't Back Down' contacted the publishers of Sam Smith's Stay with me to point out similarities between the two tracks, notably in the choruses.

Advertisement

The latter acknowledged the similarities and quickly agreed to credit Tom Petty and co-writer Jeff Lynne, plus awarding them a share of the royalties. "These things happen," said the ever-reasonable Tom Petty, before wishing Sam the best of luck with his career. What a nice guy.

6. 'All About That Bass' - Meghan Trainor

Where It Was (Allegedly) Stolen From: 'Happy Mode' - Koyote

Advertisement

The status of the linked court case is unclear right now, so we'd better stick a big fat disclaimer right here; it has yet to be proven that any similarities in Trainor's 2006 tune are the result of deliberate plagiarism. That's despite a claim by songwriter Joo Young Hoon who said back around 2014 that he was "consulting with a specialized lawyer."

Trainor's legal team would no doubt argue that it is unprovable that she had even heard the K-pop ditty, which wasn't much of a hit outside of Korea. This is one of those rare cases where the Internet stitches an artist up more than it helps them; it used to be so much easier to convincingly claim you'd never heard a song before the Internet came along.

Advertisement

5. 'Midnight Memories' - One Direction

Where It Was Stolen From: 'Pour Some Sugar On Me' - Def Leppard

Advertisement

Again, disclaimer needed: Def Leppard quite publicly stated that they have no intention of taking legal action against One Direction. Perhaps because of how odd hearing them and One Direction in the same sentence is?

The Sheffield rockers have all cited the universality of the chords used in their song, going as far as saying that if they sued 1D, then they'd get sued by whomever they "stole the song from."

Advertisement

That said, it's not unheard of for these things to be settled with a nice cheque and a non-disclosure agreement, so it may be that they can't say otherwise, but we should probably take their word for it.

4. 'Surfin' U.S.A' - The Beach Boys

Where It Was Stolen From: Sweet Little Sixteen - Chuck Berry

Advertisement

Back in the old days, when black artists were routinely ripped off by powerful record labels, The Beach Boys put out a song whose only differences with Berry's recording were the words.

Literally everything else was ridiculously similar.

Advertisement

Berry didn't sue, instead he put pressure on Murry Wilson (Brian's father and manager of the band) to just hand over the copyright, which he did. Berry's song was subsequently covered by The Beatles, The Hollies and John Lennon.

3. 'Warning' - Green Day

Where It Was (Allegedly) Stolen From: 'Picture Book' - The Kinks & 'Never Got The Chance' - The Other Garden

Advertisement

Here's a warning for you, if you're going accuse someone of nicking your song, make sure you haven't nicked it yourself. Just wise words all round really.

In 200, Colin Merry from The Other Garden received quite a lot of publicity for claiming that Green Day had stolen the main riff from his song 'Never Got The Chance'. The two songs are very similar and he would have had a case, had it not been for the fact that his song sounded exactly like 'Picture Book' by The Kinks.

Advertisement

2. 'Heartbeat Song' - Kelly Clarkson

Where It Was (Allegedly) Stolen From: 'The Middle' - Jimmy Eat World

Advertisement

If anything, this one seems like a case of plagiarism by osmosis. Accidental theft, if you will.

Back in 2015, American Idol winner Kelly Clarkson was accused - mostly by keen-eared fans - of ripping off Jimmy Eat World's seminal pop punk track 'The Middle'.

Advertisement

The issue was with the lead melody heard in the intro and chorus of Clarkson's song and the chorus of Jimmy Eat World's song are pretty much identical, prompting the accusations. To her credit, Clarkson dodged the accusations entirely telling Rolling Stone magazine, "I didn't write the song, I just sang it. But I didn't catch that. Nobody behind the scenes did. What's funny is that I was a huge fan of that Jimmy Eat World album."

Apparently, Jimmy Eat World weren't over-keen on the idea of pursuing legal action, at least according to Clarkson:

Advertisement
"I thought it was really cool of Jimmy Eat World to say, 'Hey, no harm, no foul.' There are only so many chords."

Seemingly, the writers just did that thing all musicians do from time to time where you come up with a great hook and then realise it already exists. Oops.

1. 'Blurred Lines' - Robin Thicke

Where It Was Stolen From:

Advertisement

Given how notorious this case was, you'd be forgiven for wondering how Robin Thicke and his musical cohorts thought they'd get away with it.

I mean, you listen to 'Blurred Lines' and all you hear is the iconic opening of Marvin Gaye's 'Got To Give It Up'. It's so blatant you'd suspect permission was sought and given. But the fact that it wasn't was the reason Thicke's side were ordered to pay $7.3m (£4.8m) to Gaye’s family by a US Jury following a ruling at the US District Court in Los Angeles.

Advertisement

Somewhat ironically, the ruling came about when collaborators Pharrell Williams and Thicke pre-emptively brought a lawsuit pre-emptively fearing that Gaye's family would be litigious. Their intent was to affirm that ‘Blurred Lines’ is “strikingly different” to ‘Got to Give It Up’. That backfired when Williams' claim that he was just "channelling that late 1970s feel" was thrown out.

Thicke, meanwhile washed his hands of any involvement, saying he was “high on Vicodin and alcohol when [he] showed up at the studio.” He went on:

Advertisement
"I started kind of convincing myself that I was a little more part of it than I was and I – because I didn’t want him – I wanted some credit for this big hit. But the reality is, is that Pharrell had the beat and he wrote almost every single part of the song.”