20 Greatest Metal Albums Of All Time

Heavy metal doesn't need fancy new technology to kick your ass.

By Henry Dowling /

Heavy metal doesn't need fancy new technology to kick your ass. The raucous wailing of a edgy new B.C. Rich electric axe isn't going to differ much from what we were squeezing out of our Fender Stratocasters in the eighties. It's a genre far less dependant on sci-fi synthesisers or banks of computers that the techno-monkeys use when spitting up their dubstep, funk-house wally-trance and electro-trash bubble pop. Of course over the years there have been elements of fizzy electronica sneaking in here and there - sub-genre affairs with electronic discord and pulsing electro beats like assault rifle fire - but for the most part, metal types tend to weave their heavy magic with the tools of their ancestors. The upshot of this approach is that heavy metal from thirty years ago can be compared on level ground with the shiny new stuff, and still come up looking golden. Which is why, when taking a leather-clad stroll down heavy metal boulevard to pick out the twenty greatest metal albums of all time, a lot of the potential prime candidates will have been out-thrashed not by the bright-eyed fervour of youth, but by the veterans of the genre. Hell, some of these bands don't even exist anymore, but like any great work art they live on through us, the fans. There are modern bands banging their heads right now that will surely prove themselves more than worthy of a place among the greats, but heavy metal is a genre largely entrenched in its past. It's not just lazy nostalgia though; the past has been rife with unforgettable artists whose impact can't be overlooked or simply replaced by the next big thing. Thats not to say that new albums aren't given fair consideration (there will surely be those of you who will shout out your more contemporary favourites in the comments section bellow) and it's purely coincidental that there is only one album on this list that's less than a decade old. But, before we get sucked into a wormhole of prejudicial ageist debating and "My favourite band can beat up your favourite band" banality, lets look back at the stand-out achievements of this loud, often abrasive, most wonderful music we call heavy metal€

20. Mastodon - Leviathan (2004)

Mastodon's epic concept album Leviathan is the youngest entry on this list, its 10th birthday coming up later this year. It's also about as heavy as a to-scale concrete model of a certain whale the album is loosely based on. Taking the story of Moby Dick and turning it into a stomping tooth-grinder of a metal album might sound like an odd move, but these guys made it work. By this point, just two records into their career Mastodon was starting to mould the progressive sound that would become their trademark. Don't let the progressive tag throw you off though - we're not dealing with the kind of prog-metal where they wander off into musical obscurity for half an hour between riffs. Throaty, raw vocals reminiscent of Wolverine Blues-era Entombed or Baroness' heavier work, spliced with occasionally powerful clean sections made for a full-force vocal attack - just the right sound to complement the often intricate, always crunchy guitar work and technical drum constructs. Perhaps not as widely known as many of the legends on this list, Mastodon's second full-length was a masterpiece in 2004 and holds up brilliantly today.

19. Children Of Bodom - Follow The Reaper (2000)

Finnish melodic death experts Children Of Bodom are an acquired taste. If you're not up for dazzling synth shenanigans and guitar vs. keyboard solo face-offs, the Bodom charm will be lost on you. Follow The Reaper brings together the best of this incredibly technical style of metal, based heavily on classical melodies and key structures (and we're talking about proper Mozart-style classical, not Led Zeppelin), powerful choruses and a rasping vocal line carving into each track. It's not warm or terribly inviting to outsiders, but it's not meant to be - Children Of Bodom trades exclusively in frosty Scandinavian metal. As far as melodic death goes, there is an almost clinical precision to these tracks; instruments aren't smashed and defiled, rather plucked and picked like surgical equipment. Guitar solos are insanely quick, the keyboards even more so, twisting around one another at a frightening pace while Alexi Laiho's theatrical snarl cuts in like a knife fight in the dark. Flashy but with the skill to back it up, Follow The Reaper shines like the metal-infused lovechild of power, speed and icy death all in one.

18. Cannibal Corpse - Vile (1996)

Vile broke new ground for death-merchants Cannibal Corpse. The overall feel was still something like having your head forced into an industrial meat grinder, but there was a surprisingly catchy tone here too - with memorable riffs and even a bit of a groove to get stuck into. Neater production and a more refined approach to the classic hammer-blow style moved Cannibal Corpse towards more listenable territory without alienating the fans. We cried blood at the loss of vocalist Chris Barnes, but his replacement George "Corpsegrinder" Fisher's gravel-throated growl added new texture to the consistently repulsive gore which has been a Cannibal Corpse trademark since day one. Horror hymns like Devoured By Vermin and Disfigured served up a happily appalling feast of death metal debauchery as these industry veterans chewed through yet another chunk of bloody death metal.

17. Ozzy Osbourne - Blizzard Of Ozz (1980)

Ozzy had a lot to prove in 1980. When you've just jumped/been pushed from the most important heavy metal band in the multiverse, your next project is going to have to bring the hellfire like the Great Dragon of Hades himself. Blizzard Of Ozz, the first solo outing for the crowned Prince of Darkness, turned out more melodic than we may have expected - not unlike later Black Sabbath efforts but far from the doomy sludge of the early stuff which fans longed for.

Advertisement
Still, it was the eighties, a dreary time for music in general, and Ozzy did well to put together a substantial metal album when a lot of his contemporaries where slipping into a coma of forgettable pop cheese. Blizzard Of Ozz's credibility owed much to guitarist Randy Rhodes who's slithery solos and sense of timing went a long way to keep metal heads interested in what Ozzy was banging on about this time. Timeless classics like the moody Mr. Crowley and almost jovial Crazy Train helped shift this album in the millions, prompting a long and successful career for the old bat-muncher.

16. Cradle Of Filth - Dusk... And Her Embrace (1996)

Although many will suggest that they decayed into a hackneyed metal pantomime later on, Cradle Of Filth's 1996s ripper Dusk€And Her Embrace was a screech-along classic. Vocalist Dani Filth's deafening wails and wolfish growls were worlds away from his hollow efforts on earlier work, the little black Napoleon tore his way through this sprawling album and proved his worth within the genre. Black metal elitists tend to flip out when Cradle Of Filth are mentioned in the same breath as bands like Mayhem and Emperor - these British lads didn't have the Scandinavian roots or the believable air of danger to earn their true black metal stripes from the purists - but Dusk was a brooding, ferocious album which demanded respect. Layers of shrill guitars and piercing screams interwoven with ghostly orchestral pieces and a penchant for ominous melodies delivered a dark atmosphere for what would be Cradle's most memorable album.

15. Strapping Young Lad - City (1997)

The second Strapping Young Lad album fell somewhere between lunacy and creative genius. Which is fitting, since we could use the same description for band-founder Devin Townsend - a vividly expressive artist who's work often borders on full-blast musical insanity. His solo albums tread a more progressive, experimental path, but when he was in Strapping Young Lad mode it was sonic fury. Angrier than a bag full of catnip-deprived alley cats, City was like a blackened dystopian version of Fear Factory's Demanufacture that had the "death machine" knob turned all the way up to 11. Vocally Townsend was - and still is - in a class of his own, surely turning into a candidate for the first larynx replacement surgery had the group not disbanded. This was the scientific opposite of easy listening, an album packed with explosions of gritty jackhammer beats from ex-Death skin-beater Gene Hoglan and industrial distortion which challenged listeners in the kind of in-your-face style that SYL has become famous for. Corrosive chord structures charged through track after track of exhausting firebomb metal, with only the roof-shaking Detox coming anywhere near marketable as a radio unfriendly unit shifter. City was a psychotically delicious slab of aggressive destruction which many say Townsend is yet to top.

14. Immortal - Sons Of Northern Darkness (2002)

Blackened death, thrashy black, call it what you like, Immortal's Sons Of Northern Darkness was a relentless icy blast of an album from this Norwegian trio. These iconic creatures in their corpse paint and spiked gauntlets had a surprisingly listenable style - by the close of the nineties we were pretty tired of cacophonous church-burning black metal, so this was a welcome change of pace when it hit us early in the new millennium. And it hit us hard. Buzzsaw guitars cranked alongside the drum assault in a more thrashy tone than earlier albums which was a far cry from the thrash that was coming out of the States, and also quite different from the elitist black metal we were hearing back then. The sentiment was dark but without the weary satanic mutterings of their contemporaries, with vocalist Abbath Doom Occulta's delivery sounding like a particularly wicked dark elf. Unlike a lot of the other extreme metal coming from the Scandinavian and Germanic regions at the time, Sons Of Northern Darkness sat neatly in between the old "brash and near-intelligible" sound and the "shiny and over-produced" that was on the rise - a stellar album hanging happily on the edge of its genre.

13. Judas Priest - Painkiller (1990)

Judas Priest was scaring the hell out of people before they even heard the music. With a name like Judas Priest, you just know it's going to be pure evil€ the sort of demonic sludge that will send you off straight to hell without any dinner. Pop an album like 1990s Painkiller onto your gramophone and things aren't nearly as devilish as we imagined, but rather a masterclass in power metal rife with deadly guitar thrills splashing around Rob Halford's incredible operatic vocal delivery.

Advertisement

Screaming For Vengeance scored hordes of passionate fans for this British metal triumph, but it was Painkiller which best exhibited the bands technical brilliance and infectious power metal songwriting - this wasn't pretentious falsetto glam pop, it was an album loaded with punishing riff-acrobatics and Halford's most consistent performance in years.

The title track alone is enough to have karaoke hopefuls unconscious with sheer effort, while Metal Meltdown is still a face-melting beast of a song - no question, this is an album which put Priest at the forefront of supersonic anthemic metal.

Advertisement

12. Opeth - Blackwater Park (2001)

In the realm of epic progressive death metal, it doesn't get much more epic, more progressive, or more deathly than Opeth. And it was Blackwater Park which proved the greatest showcase of their multifaceted brand of Scandinavian metal. Here the Swedes struck a fine balance between a layered black metal-inspired sound and the intricate constructions more associated with technical death, often wandering off into meandering acoustic progressive sections and back again. It's heady stuff, the kind of metal that may be accused of trying too hard, but Opeth had been chiseling away at their style for years to get to this point, and with Blackwater Park they had it all figured out. Previous albums may have been just as ambitious as they were musically complex, but felt cold and bleak compared to the dense sound achieved here. A stunning melding of classic Opeth heaviness and melancholy.

11. Amon Amarth - Versus The World (2002)

They try to distance themselves from the term Viking Metal, but Swedish heavyweights Amon Amarth have only themselves to blame - more often than not when the bearded behemoth Johan Hegg is roaring over a melodic death twin-guitar onslaught, it's Odin, Asgard and long, pointy swords he's roaring about. This monstrous sound has never been as focused or effective as it was on 2002s Versus The World; a slower, more deliberate album laced with heavy, doom-like undertones. Previous works had carried a more technical sound, but for Versus things their sound took a down-tuned tone, grinding along a deathly groove - this was infectious metal, cementing Amon Amarth's place among the melodic death heavyweights with its the colossal wall of sound. Like the soundtrack to a battle of the gods, Versus The World is a sword-shaking, shield-bashing piece of work from a band impossible to ignore.

10. Dio - Holy Diver (1983)

As one of frontmen for Black Sabbath, Rainbow and his self-titled project, Ronnie James Dio has definitely earned his Top 10 position on this list. A far more refined vocalist than Black Sabbath probably needed, it was when he was running the show for himself that Dio excelled. So when he headed off into solo territory after a couple of years spent playing yes-man to Tony Iommi, he flourished. A charismatic leader and talented writer, he surrounded himself with a solid team to record Holy Diver in 1983, the album widely regarded as Dio's best work across all of his projects. There will be parallels drawn between this and Ozzy's debut, purely because both artists where out to prove that they could make it without the Black Sabbath name backing them up. Dodgy album cover art aside (to be fair, this was eighties metal€ dodgy cover art was par for the course), Holy Diver turned out to be the more accomplished album in the classic metal sense without veering off into eighties synth melodrama as we saw with Blizzard of Ozz. It was also the musical peak of Dio's solo career - a chunk of vintage metal which lives on after the legend's sad passing.

9. Anthrax - Among The Living (1987)

Sure the eighties brought us horridly bouncy pop music, shoulder pads and keytars, but it also brought an onslaught of a new kind of music that had been brewing among the angry youth - thrash metal. Anthrax was in the front of the queue back then, one of the formidable Big Four, shredding their way through four albums before the end of the decade and inspiring a generation to learn the guitar, grow their hair and scrawl pentagrams on their school desks. Four albums of savage thrash intensity, but it was the third, Among The Living, which spawned the band's most memorable moments. Diehard Anthrax fans will go on about the deeper meaning of their mosh pit classics, but we shouldn't overthink things like this - a lot of the themes here are throwaway thriller stuff or loosely bound social commentary, but we can overlook even the most clichéd nonsense when the music itself is a non-stop thrash attack like Among The Living. Joey Belladonna's vocal style may also split judgements, distinctly less aggressive that we got from Slayer and Metallica at the time, but the chest-thumping choruses and testosterone-fuelled chord progressions had us merrily cracking our skulls together regardless.

8. Death - Symbolic (1995)

Few bands have gone through as many member shuffles as death metal founding fathers Death. Over the course of the bands' seven studio album career, no less than twenty five musicians featured at some point - either as fully fledged members, touring members or studio implants. Guitarist and vocalist Chuck Schuldiner was the only common denominator from start to unfortunate end. Through all the changes, it was with the 1995 configuration responsible for Symbolic, their penultimate album, which saw Death forged into its most focused form factor. By then the early years of gore-inspired metal had been whittled down and redirected into deeper lyrical themes and vastly improved instrumentation, sharpening their sound from its brutal roots to a cutting edge of technically flawless death metal. Spanning close to an hour of exhausting tempo changes and a guitar assault somehow both scattershot and exquisitely detailed, this was the culmination of years of development - a development possibly taken a little far with the overly ambitious follow-up The Sound Of Perseverance - leaving Symbolic as the pinnacle of Death before Schuldiner's own death a few years later.

7. Megadeth - Rust In Peace (1990)

Megadeth are seen by some as an orphan Metallica offshoot, since band founder Dave Mustaine was famously ejected by the Bay Area legends before they hit the big time. But Megadeth has proven resilient, carving their own path for the past three decades and solidifying their style. When Rust In Peace was released in the early nineties only the most closed-minded critics would still have labeled them as cheap 'Tallica knock-offs - this was the album which reminded us why Megadeth should be part of the Big Four. A sober, focused Megadeth was behind this one, and it showed - Sharp fretwork and extended progressive build-ups and breakdowns made Rust In Peace a more technically-advanced piece, tied around the duelling guitars of Mustaine and newcomer Marty Friedman. Tightly coiled riffs spiral off of one another through some of the more complex tracks, others just grab hold of one killer bass line and run with it. Perhaps Metallica will always outshine them for sheer crowd pull and charisma, but Rust In Peace secured Megadeth their own place in the sun forevermore.

6. Sepultura - Roots (1996)

Roots was a massive album for Sepultura, both musically and personally for the band. A literal return to their roots, this was world music for metalheads. It was untamed tribal war music that made you want to go out and get tattoos on your face and buy a spear. Down-tuned, raw, Roots was a different beast to the fast thrash-death tempo that the band was known for, littered with South American flourishes which slotted effortlessly into the Sepultura style. The Brazillian impact on the album was most obvious through the hammering tribal percussion, a definite theme throughout Roots and a hub for each track to hinge on. Sometimes intricate, mostly wonderfully violent, these mesmerising rhythms were the driving force - Cavalera's vein-popping aggression hanging on for dear life along with the rest of the band. It turned out to be Max's last outing with this hugely influential band, but we'll always remember Roots as the album Sepultura was born to create.

5. Pantera - Vulgar Display Of Power (1992)

Before Pantera became the flag-bearer for beer-swilling pickup truck metal, the band spent years in the misguided leatherette grip of glam metal - falsetto vocals, fiddly guitar solos, big teased hair, the lot. By the time Vulgar Display Of Power showed up and promptly smashed the teeth out of our heads, not a trace of their sparkly but questionable past was to be found. The transformation was complete. Forgoing pretentious complexity for straight forward heaviness, Pantera was effectively reborn with this curb-stomp of an album. Heavier things were still to come, but Vulgar Display Of Power was the juncture where controlled power, form, and jaw-breaking thrashiness collided best for the band. By now Phil Anselmo had completely shed the falsetto glam style that he inherited when joining the band, setting a benchmark for aggressive metal vocals. The groove-laden southern style of 1990s Cowboys From Hell was intact but free of any shadows of glam silliness, instead honouring us with evergreen metal anthems like Walk and F*cking Hostile to bang our heads to for years to come.

4. Slayer - Reign In Blood (1986)

Reign In Blood is the distilled sweat of a million mosh pits - this is fight music, pure and simple. Other than a few moments of rain sounds and some unsettling distorted guitar wails which bookend Raining Blood, this album thunders on unhindered from bloodcurdling start to finish. Crisp and deadly, Slayer's first major label offering was a ruthless screamer of exquisitely executed heavy metal. The musicianship was bloody frightening in its intensity, riddled with remarkable riffs and Tom Araya's raw vocal shout punching each track square in the face, and still had the party wrapped up within half an hour. Back in '86 this was regarded by many as the heaviest thing ever melted onto vinyl, and is still revered as a landmark release. A major influence on the metal scene for years to come, Reign In Blood left us all bloodied in its wake.

3. Iron Maiden - The Number Of The Beast (1982)

Maiden could play the title track five times in a row, followed by an encore of Hallowed Be Thy Name, and no one would have complained - a trimmed-down version of their third studio release would be here on this list. But these Brit legends laid it on thick for us, pulling off a behemoth of classic heavy metal - the sort of album that should be sealed in a NASA capsule and shot into space to teach alien lifeforms how to rock out. The Number Of The Beast needs to be remembered for many reasons, but we'll always keep this '82 banger in our hearts as the first time we heard young upstart Bruce Dickinson take his place behind the mic for Iron Maiden. This was the voice that Maiden had been waiting for, the arena-shaking powerhouse that perfectly complimented Steve Harris' rumbling bass and Murray/Smith twin guitar setup. Dickinson ran to the hills years later to pursue a solo career, and the shoddy also-rans who tried to take his place were just a reminder that he was the only man for the job. Iron Maiden had decades of hits pouring out after this splendid album, but this one marked the beginning of their golden age.

2. Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath (1970)

This is it. Genesis chapter 1, verse 1.

Advertisement

In the beginning there were four Birmingham lads who would shape the future of heavy metal forever. Four lads who would take bluesy rock 'n' roll and paint it black.

Black Sabbath - the song, the album, the band - was just about the darkest thing to be churned out of the British music scene, and was met with generally lukewarm reactions. Now, some forty-odd years later, it stands as the gold standard for early heavy metal, the precursor to all of this throbbing, gritty music that we now hold so dear.

Advertisement

Much of Black Sabbath's brooding debut album was still heavily blues-oriented, but there was a new sound here, a sense of foreboding - Ozzy's addled warbling was as tainted as the masterful licks being spun on Tony Iommi's electric battle axe; a smooth, smokey sound that was dark like tar-black honey. The occult imagery of eternal metal standards like N.I.B and title track Black Sabbath - sitting alongside more upbeat jam-sessions The Wizard and Evil Woman - showed a band who could whip up more killer melodies before breakfast than most bands would in their lifetimes.

There's no getting around it, this was the album which would become the foundation for just about everything else on this list. But, while history has it's place here and Black Sabbath needs to be honoured among the greats, we can't quite label it the greatest metal album of all time...

Advertisement

1. Metallica - Master Of Puppets (1986)

Black Sabbath may have birthed heavy metal, but Metallica raised it, fed it, schooled it... perfected it. Moan all you like about their often-chided Load and Reload "cowboy rock" days. You're welcome to take a swing at the endless clangy pounding of St. Anger too, and you can even hop on your high horse to chastise the black album - incredible as it was - for perhaps playing it safe. But there isn't anything of substance that any self-respecting metalhead can hold against Master Of Puppets - by 1986 these guys had this heavy metal gig fully under control. Battery fires things off like a D-Day beach landing, and for the next fifty five minutes we're beaten into happy submission by a thunderous barrage from the four horsemen of metal. 'Tallica touches on a low-slung doom-tainted vibe with The Thing That Should Not Be and then promptly drags us through the halls of insanity with the epic Sanitarium. We're marched through hellish battlefields and we're even given a little impromptu lesson about the hypocrisy of religion along the way - it's an exhausting ride, with brief respite found near the end thanks to the sprawling instrumental Orion, and then we're finished off with one last bullet to the head; the spiked fist and flaming middle finger of Damage Inc. We could complain that eight tracks isn't enough, but could you really handle much more after that tireless onslaught? The timeless double-barrel shotgun blast of Hetfield and Hammett lead the charge here, but just as much praise needs to go to Ulrich and Burton - the twin guitars build their devilish riffs and fingertip-devouring solos on the scaly backs of their monster rhythm section. Ride The Lightning was a thrashy demon, make no mistake, but Master Of Puppets was a more cohesive, more demanding and a more stylish beast, and it's the album we regard as the pinnacle of heavy metal. So which albums would you put at the top of the pile? Agree with what we've got? Any you'd switch out? Let us know in the comments!